HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jameshart

22,635 karma · joined March 31, 2011

submissionscomments
jameshart··on The newest ESP32 can run Linux and it's getting close to a Raspberry Pi
Pete Townshend knows what he did.
jameshart··on UK military jamming other nations' satellites to defend itself, BBC told
What does this have to do with the claim at hand which is ‘we need to keep our comms infrastructure secure because critical things like the primary way our population conducts economic transactions depend upon it’?

That you find the population’s choice to use such mechanisms questionable, or that you think it is foolhardy to do so, does nothing to disobligate the government from trying to keep that infrastructure up and running.

jameshart··on UK military jamming other nations' satellites to defend itself, BBC told
Certainly not spelt (or spelled) like that.
jameshart··on UK military jamming other nations' satellites to defend itself, BBC told
All of which (except the cheque, which we can ignore - nobody in the UK has a chequebook any more) depend on the same communication infrastructure that the app does.
jameshart··on 28% of job postings on company career sites have been open over 90 days
> In a case like this always open job listings are a warning to others

‘Warning this company has management practices oriented around remaining solvent for the long term, rather than providing a sinecure for workers’?

jameshart··on UK military jamming other nations' satellites to defend itself, BBC told
In a largely cashless society like the UK, ‘banking apps’ are effectively people’s wallets. Knowing you got paid, being able to pay your rent, being able to pay for goods and services… seem like pretty everyday concerns.
jameshart··on The GitHub wiki is an anti-pattern
Corrections and improvements to docs are just a bugfix though?
jameshart··on I don't want the details
Organizations don’t choose whether or not to ask questions. People do. The behavior of an organization is the sum of the actions of the people in it. If you are a member of an organization, and you ask ‘how do we prevent this from happening again?’ Guess what? The organization just learned how to ask that question.

Now it just needs to learn how to answer it, and act on the answer.. but step one seems solvable.

jameshart··on I don't want the details
The SVP doesn’t plan on making any decisions here.
jameshart··on I don't want the details
They trust your ability to do a root cause analysis. They don’t trust that you feel empowered to do anything about it, so they are verifying that you actually do.
jameshart··on GPT-6 Sol and Luna
This is how the price cut is portrayed on OpenAI’s site. They are trying to say the prices have moved from the higher ones to the lower ones.
jameshart··on English: A vs. An
Yep. Languages would be much better if they followed an RFC process.
jameshart··on English: A vs. An
Great way to frame it. But it does rely on just chance that the nouns you’re talking about will slot into different categories. Would be much more useful if pronouns let us refer to ‘the previously mentioned subject’ or ‘the previously mentioned object’ rather than ‘the previously mentioned masculine person’.

Like in “John met David. He was delighted to meet him.” We have a conflict over the ‘masculine object’ register, so ‘he’ and ‘him’ are ambiguous.

But if we had a pronoun like ‘de/dim’ for ‘previous subject’ and ‘ne/nim’ for ‘previous object’ you could unabiguously say “John met David. De was delighted to make nis acquaintance, but ne wasn’t so keen”

jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
There's also a vast gulf between 'startup culture' and 'Enterprise engineering'. But the general sense of "this voice is for a specific context, and it is not 'weekend ZX Spectrum hacking project'", is correct.
jameshart··on If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate the rest of it
This is, as always from Grant Sanderson, thought provoking and opens new insights.

It occurs to me on reading this that there’s a connection to other computerized mathematical activities.

Occasionally some computer lab in the past would announce that they have computed pi to more digits than ever before; or a new Mersenne prime will be found.

These count as ‘math news’ but they’re of little interest to mathematicians. These computational efforts demonstrate the great power of computers but they do nothing to advance mathematical understanding. Finding a larger Mersenne prime is not surprising to anyone; we’re pretty sure there’s an infinite number of them. Finding the largest Mersenne prime would be the surprise.

So it is with proofs. An LLM might prove some conjecture - Riemann, say or P≠NP. But in general we know that things can be proven and we think those things are probably true, so the existence of a proof doesn’t do much more than producing a new Mersenne prime does.

It’s only if in proving the thing we learned something that there’s actual value in the proof.

jameshart··on I think you should almost never use AI to write
* do nearly as well
jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
What’s interesting about the project might no longer be ‘wow, someone figured out how to do that, I guess they must have a MASSIVE BRAIN’, but we can still wonder at the fact that the hardware can be made to do such a thing.

If someone finds an interesting shiny pebble and shows it to you, is your reaction to say ‘what do you want, a round of applause? You didn’t make that rock’

Can’t you just appreciate the shiny pebble someone went out of their way to find?

jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
> If the author didn't do this for themselves - to learn, to show off their skills - then why bring it to life?

Isn’t wanting a thing to exist reason enough?

It’s a bit like seeing someone post an instagram photo of them eating a cake they made, and saying ‘why? Why did you make this cake? Are you trying to learn, or show off your skills?’

Maybe they.. just wanted to eat a cake?

I swear the instagram ‘look at me’ culture has broken people’s ability to just do a thing because they can.

jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
I think some people prefer their labours of love to involve the expenditure of actual labour.
jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
Sure. If I ask my roommate to go make me a ham sandwich without mayo, I expect them to observe basic hygiene practices, too, but I am comfortable with them just handing me the sandwich and saying ‘there on you go - sandwich’ rather than “Here is an edible sandwich: No mayo, no lettuce – just bread and ham. And the load-bearing insight that makes it work: it doesn’t use the open ham from the fridge that was past its use-by date. That one decision changed everything.”
jameshart··on I think you should almost never use AI to write
Use AI to write things for you to read that you wish someone else had written. ‘Give me a summary of the research on this topic’; ‘Write a report on this data to help me make a decision’. ‘Take this transcript of a meeting and write me the email it could have been’.

Don’t use AI to write things that you are producing for someone else to consume.

jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
If you’re familiar with the way in which documentation artifacts like this fall out of a Claude project, you will recognize that every place where Claude says ‘this changes everything’ or ‘this is the load bearing insight’ most likely resulted from a human looking at what Claude had done, and redirecting it towards a more fruitful line of inquiry. When Claude gets ‘excited’ about a thing like ‘we figured out which clock measurement approach helps us actually optimize performance’ - excited enough to explain it in this level of detail - it usually results from the user pulling Claude out of a rabbit hole where it was going about things the wrong way.
jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
You can do a lot with custom agent prompts. Just telling Claude ‘this is only a personal project, we’re messing around here’ changes its tone somewhat already. It’s still Business Claude, but more Casual Friday Claude, less Monday Morning Standup Meeting Claude.
jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
Claude’s written voice is so distinctive, anyone who has spent time working with Claude instantly recognizes it.

Which, if you think about it too hard, says something slightly profound and a little disturbing about identity…

jameshart··on A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum
It’s Claude’s earnestness that’s so disingenuous in this kind of write up. This voice Claude has where it believes the work is important and deserves to be taken seriously, and where it takes ever part of the process where it has to adjust its approach because of a thing it figured out as a great insight which is incredibly valuable and that people should be made aware of…

I feel like vibecoded projects need Claude to pick up on a sense of ‘this is just me messing around’, and a project like this where there does appear to be genuine digging into the art of performance tuning Z80 assembly needs Claude to understand ‘this is impractical hacking for hacking’s sake not groundbreaking research’

I don’t have a problem with projects which are, essentially ‘Claude and I burned a lot of tokens for giggles to see just how far you can push something’. But the write up needs to reflect that spirit.

jameshart··on How to Write with an LLM
If you’re familiar with tptacek’s writing you would be confident this is deliberate and recognize it as an ‘I see what he did there’ moment.

If not, it does risk planting the seed of doubt - have I been duped once again into reading tokenslop again?

Risky move. Surprised the LLM copy editor didn’t flag it.

jameshart··on AWS says it can't restore some data from mideast facilities struck by Iran
The footnote which says that is the design durability against equipment failure literally begins:

> In the unlikely case of the loss or damage to all or part of an AWS Availability Zone, data in a One Zone storage class may be lost. For example, events like fire and water damage could result in data loss

jameshart··on Claude Cowork and chat are now one Claude
Because nobody actually knows what anybody else’s job consists of. But everyone is familiar with how jobs work in the ‘romcom job universe’ where workplace stakes are generally driven by ‘I have this really important make-or-break presentation due Friday!’

I suspect it’s because writers don’t normally have jobs and the only time they are ever in offices it’s to deliver a pitch for a project.

jameshart··on Most people prefer traditional architecture
A lot of the sample images shown of ‘traditional’ architecture in this piece are not what you’re talking about - they aren’t ’traditional materials’ or ‘traditional techniques’, they just use choices of exterior cladding and window layouts that are evocative of traditional choices - but they are just as much a soulless product of low cost materials and construction efficiency.

Not the case for all of them (the brick-built viaduct proposal for example looks like it would be a nightmare to build and maintain), but most of the buildings shown, the ‘traditional’ variant just uses less visible steel and glass, in favor of ‘layer cake’ designs with stone cladding panels on the lowest level.

jameshart··on IKEA made a mod for Skyrim [video]
You can only defend your trademark with respect to product categories that you actually market. Unless IKEA were in the business of selling parody video games, their trademark doesn't apply.

Wait... is that why IKEA just put out a parody video game?

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →