HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jameshilliard

524 karma · joined October 21, 2017

submissionscomments
jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Israel can only exist via ethnic cleansing, apartheid and genocide.

Ethnic cleansing did happen, but it wasn't just in one direction. Apartheid is race based discrimination, Israel mostly just has citizenship based discrimination these days(like most countries). War is also not the same thing as genocide.

> Supporting its "right to exist" is to support all of those things.

Do you think the US has a "right to exist"? You can make an equally if not more plausible claim that the US could only exist via ethnic cleansing, apartheid and genocide due to what happened to the Native Americans.

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Scientologists don't have a nation

It's confusing because "Jewish" has both a religious and ethnic meaning depending on the context, while "Scientologist" would generally only have a religious meaning. This distinction is the source of a lot of confusion.

> they don't have a right to go genocide indigenous people to make one

I don't think anyone here is arguing that any group has the right to genocide any other group of people to create a new state, that is a straw man argument.

The actual arguments would be that war is not a genocide in addition to the fact that Jews are historically indigenous to the region. Israel also already exists so this isn't a matter of making a new state.

jameshilliard··on Tell HN: GitHub refuses to remove cracked copies of my software after a month
> Thank you for submitting a DMCA takedown notice. We've reviewed the information you've provided, and based on the facts presented to us, we're unable to confirm a violation of 17 U.S. Code § 1201.

Did they actually republish you code or were they just creating wrappers that download/cache the code from your website to run locally?

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Are you saying all Jews support Israel?

The vast majority of Jews do support Israel having a right to exist.

> I’m told that’s antisemitism.

You seem to be conflating Jews supporting Israel having a right to exist with Jews supporting some particular actions taken by some Israeli's or Israeli government policies. One can support Israel having a right to exist while still being against specific government policies or specific actions taken by Israeli's.

jameshilliard··on uBlock Origin Lite is back on Firefox add-ons
> The lite version has better performance since it’s effectively just a bunch of MV3 blocklists.

I think in practice ublock origin lite results in worse overall performance than regular ublock origin since it's worse at blocking ads(which cause more performance issues than the ad-blocker itself).

jameshilliard··on uBlock Origin Lite is back on Firefox add-ons
> Yes, it is meant for the manifest v3 browsers.

It was only created as a workaround to Google killing proper adblock related API support for manifest v3, it's definitely worse than regular ublock origin.

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> If you read it again you will see that I did not say that ultra orthodox jews are nazis, but a subset of those (the settlers) behave like nazis. Perpetuating the circle of violence.

You appear to be somewhat implying that the settlers which are engaging in violence are mostly Ultra-Orthodox(Haredi) Jews. Which is weird since only about 30% of settlers are Ultra-Orthodox and they tend to mostly reside in settlements along the Green Line(which are generally the least problematic type of settlement) for mostly economic reasons. The Ultra-Orthodox also generally try and avoid military service and don't typically engage in violent clashes with Palestinians. I don't know why you seem to be blaming a group that is largely trying to avoid IDF service for "the circle of violence", they tend to clash mostly with Israeli police if anything when protesting against mandatory conscription.[0]

The group you're probably thinking of that causes a lot of the problems by deliberately picking fights(i.e those in outpost settlements that are typically illegal even under Israeli law) when you think of settlers are more National-Religious(Dati Leumi).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haredi_conscription_in_Israel

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> This user continues to only engage in Israel related topics and discussions.

That's just not true.

The last post I commented on[0] wasn't Israel related.

> Is this really the place for propaganda ?

How is a question about the source of this report propaganda?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49940809

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Yes, Israel has spied on and stolen nuclear material from many countries

I'm pretty sure most countries spy on many countries.

> answering your own question as to why the world will be better off without them.

That wasn't my question, the question was how would Civil War and Total Collapse of a nuclear armed state like Israel be good for the entire planet as you've suggested?

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Nuclear armed Israel?

Right, I'm curious how would Civil War and Total Collapse of a nuclear armed state like Israel be good for the entire planet as you've suggested?

> They literally stole enriched uranium from the US to make that happen.

I think there's probably more evidence that the Israeli nuclear weapons program initially was developed mostly in cooperation with France. After France stopped supplying fuel in the wake of the 1967 war apparently Israel did steal yellowcake from a Belgian mining company.[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Plumbat

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> The Red Cell, which is the unit responsible for providing “alternative analysis” within the agency, produced the assessment through a combination of open source information and U.S. intelligence.

So is this article describing a war game sort of thing where units create staged scenarios for gaming out future crisis responses?[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Cell

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> Not only would it be good for the Middle East, it would be good for the entire planet.

How would Civil War and Total Collapse of a nuclear armed state be good for the entire planet? Has Civil War with a Total Collapse of the state in general led to good outcomes anywhere?

> Imagine a US without Zionist influence?

What actual difference do you think that would make?

jameshilliard··on CIA Report Warns Israel Could Head Toward Civil War, Total Collapse
> one can only hope

I'm curious, do you actually think Civil War and Total Collapse in Israel could realistically lead to a good outcome for anyone in the region, including Palestinians? Is there even a remotely plausible scenario resembling a good outcome that could result from a Civil War and Total Collapse?

jameshilliard··on NTSB Preliminary Report: Prime Air 767 Runway Overrun [pdf]
> It really sucks that the FO could not intervene further as he clearly identified the problem and articulated the solution.

First officer could have easily intervened, all they needed to do was call for a go-around. If the captain wouldn't initiate a go-around(AFAIU typical airline policy from my understanding is that if either pilot calls for a go-around then they must initiate a go-around) after being called for by the FO they should have initiated one themselves. The events from the CVR show only the captain ever called for a go-around after it was too late.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> I had to go back 79 days and what felt like hundreds of posts to find any exception (something about heat pumps I think!), but then scrolling further back just led through reams more of the same.

I went and checked myself and it's not exactly quite that bad, I quite regularly comment on posts unrelated to Israel/politics, these are comments of mine newer than 79 days that seem entirely unrelated for example:

7 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49846584

19 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49687187

28 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49569325

52 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49252558

59 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49163184

59 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49163014

79 days ago(the supposedly non-political one you found about heat pumps is quite ironically titled "The politics of air conditioning in Switzerland"): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48915330

> To say that you're simply correcting inaccuracies and misinformation doesn't really work because the question of what counts as accurate vs. misinformation is hotly disputed. It is basically the entirety of the battle.

I think it's more complex than that, for example in this thread I was pointing out that one shouldn't use UN aid delivery data to justify that sufficient aid is reaching Gaza, because UN aid data doesn't support that conclusion by itself, I then pointed out what data does support the conclusion that sufficient aid is being delivered. So I think there are cases where it's entirely possible to correct misinformation without even challenging the conclusion.:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49879645#49906915

> On the other hand, your comments have mostly (though not entirely) been avoiding the more degraded forms of guidelines breakage that people resort to in these threads - things like snark, name-calling, and from there into personal attacks, slurs, and so on.

Yeah, I try and avoid that in general.

> That's good, but it's not enough—if you want to keep posting on HN we need you not to use the site primarily for political battle (broadly construed).

I guess the main issue is that I tend to get more replies to my comments in Israel related threads and I get drawn in responding back if I think there's more to be said on the topic, most of my Israel related comments(in terms of absolute numbers) seem be from these super deep back and forth threads and not top level comments.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> What about that jameshilliard guy that has tens of flagged dead comments about Israel ?

I think overall most of my comments are positive. Some people seem to flag comments as a way of disagreeing I guess.

> Since 2024, 99% of his comments are political and about Israel.

I don't think that's really an accurate characterization, it's certainly not 99%, are comments correcting factual inaccuracies/misinformation in threads related to Israel considered political just because the surrounding topic is politically contentious?

Most of my comments on threads involving Israel are me just correcting some of the more obvious misinformation/conspiracy theories and/or trying to provide more factual background context/nuance to the discussions. I try not to push a specific political agenda/ideology for the most part. It's not like I'm trying to start political/ideological discussions either, there just seems to be more factual misinformation around topics involving Israel and that happens to be something where I know a lot of the history.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> No but it is like taking Russia's word for how many troops they lost.

Russia mostly just doesn't publish those figures at all last I checked. OSINT researchers however following the Russia/Ukraine war will typically use data from Russian, Ukrainian and independent sources where available however so it also wouldn't be advisable to completely ignore the Russian data either. Even extremely biased/limited data can sometimes be used to identify trends, at least for cases where the bias factor tends to be consistent.

Israel also isn't a dictatorship and has what most would consider to be a relatively free press that is not afraid to criticize the government(i.e. Haaretz) so it would be rather difficult for Israel to deliberately publish outright fabricated data on a large scale without getting caught doing so.

I'm also not saying you should blindly trust any specific sources, however much of the COGAT data can also be corroborated via independent sources such as satellite imagery.

Keep in mind it's also not the case that the UN data meaningfully contradicts the COGAT data either, it's entirely possible for both to be reasonably accurate. In general I would say both COGAT and UN data are both likely reasonably accurate once factoring in the published limitations on that data.

The reason the numbers are different is simply because they are measuring different things. In the case of COGAT they generally measure total aid going through border crossings while the UN measures aid reaching only a subset of distributions points within Gaza.

So if you want to estimate per capita food aid going into Gaza you would want to use the COGAT figures since that data is collected at all border crossings and can be used to get a rough per capita figure on aid entering Gaza. On the other hand if you want to measure something like aid reaching UN system aid distribution points within Gaza then you would want to use the UN data.

Attempting to use UN data to calculate per capita food aid going into Gaza would clearly be wrong as the UN's own published data collection methodology clearly shows they are not measuring total aid entering Gaza.

The UN often seems to publish reports analyzing their own data while clearly failing factor in their own published data limitations into their calculations which results in inaccurate conclusions in their analysis. Usually these sort of analysis mistakes are very obvious as the UN generally publishes the math behind their calculations.

You shouldn't blindly discard data simply because you think the source might be biased in one direction, rather you should try to understand the limitations of the data and corroborate it against secondary sources where possibly while also trying to factor in bias where feasible.

Essentially it's not the raw data where there is disagreement, it's the various interpretations of what the data actually means.

> How is comparing a state that is conducting a genocide to another group that did so too against the Jewish people ?

A war is not the same thing as a genocide. The Jews did not start a war with the Nazi's. Hamas started a war with Israel with openly genocidal goals, Hamas simply did not have the military capability to accomplish their genocidal goals.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> COGAT is an Israeli military unit.

That doesn't mean the data is unreliable.

> Trusting their statements is like trusting the statements of the Nazis during the previous genocide.

Comparing Israeli's to Nazi's is a common antisemitic trope.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> An Israeli military unit (COGAT) is not a trustworthy source of data for the aid they provide to an area they are actively blockading and starving.

From my understanding no organization other than COGAT even has the ability to track the total aid deliveries, there is no evidence of mass starvation or that COGAT data is unreliable from what I've seen.

jameshilliard··on Pilot of Israel-bound FlyDubai flight tried to crash plane
https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/omani-pilot-who...
jameshilliard··on Flydubai B38M, first officer under investigation for suspected suicide attempt
The Captain that was attacked by the copilot unlocked the door.[0]

[0] https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/wounded-flyduba...

jameshilliard··on Pilot of Israel-bound FlyDubai flight tried to crash plane
> Apparently, Omanis are not allowed to travel to Israel, so an Omani would not be a pilot going to TLV.

AFAIU Omanis would need a visa to travel to Israel but they are allowed.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> 35000 tons of aid, 60% percent of it food. So.. 10kg of food per person, per month.

That's for UN 2720 Mechanism aid AFAIU, for totals I think you need to look at COGAT data which shows much higher numbers for total food aid.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> Israel is currently allowing in thousands of truckloads carrying 35,000 metric tons of aid per month, according to the UN: https://www.un.org/unispal/document/ocha-newsitem-7aug26/

You have to be very careful when looking at this sort of data, from my understanding UN data only tracks UN 2720 Mechanism aid deliveries. I think you need to look at COGAT data to see total aid deliveries as there are non-UN aid deliveries as well that won't show up in the UN data.

jameshilliard··on Pilot of Israel-bound FlyDubai flight tried to crash plane
> Indian-Emirati captain

I think he may have just been Indian, I did see some early reports listing him as an Emerati but the more recent reports appear only seem to list him as Indian.

> South African and Kiwi backup pilots

Was this confirmed? I didn't see a reliable source reporting on the nationality of the backup pilots. A few sources had secondhand reports that both backup pilots were European but those don't seem to be confirmed.

jameshilliard··on Pilot of Israel-bound FlyDubai flight tried to crash plane
> I read it was ukranian/russian pilots

The apparent terrorist was the co-pilot who was Omani, the captain that the terrorist attacked was Indian.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
Are you claiming my statement is factually inaccurate?
jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> No one claimed “unconditional” hostage return. Of course there are conditions

You responded with that article in response to this question of mine "Are you claiming there is a Haaretz article that states that Hamas was willing to unconditionally give up the civilian hostages after the Oct 7th attacks? I would like to see which article you are referring to as I have been unable to find any with a claim remotely along those lines.".

As expected the article fully confirmed my understanding in regards to what Hamas offered. This was not a real offer to return the hostages but rather a demand for Israel to effectively surrender and leave Hamas in place to carry out future attacks.

> Hamas is fighting 80+ years of Zionist ethnic cleansing, that’s the whole point.

Israel ethnically cleansed Gaza of Jews in 2005.

> Israel decided committing genocide was more important than retrieving their settlers. That’s on them.

There were no settlers in Gaza on October 7th when Hamas launched their attack.

> This is Israel’s policy of killing their own settlers. Human shields would be how the IDF is located in nearly every building in Israel.

This is wrong for multiple reasons, first of all Hamas doesn't care if Israeli civilians get killed so such a tactic would be entirely ineffective, second of all Israel puts their military defenses in front of their civilians, not the other way around. Israeli soldiers simply aren't hiding behind Israeli civilians.

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> White genocide? Don't make me laugh. Cultural Marxism? I sure hope so!

There are many beliefs that posit an international Jewish conspiracy, obviously not all of those may by applicable to you.

> I'm an ultra-progressive extreme leftist.

Antisemitism often exists in both left wing and right wing extremists groups, the international Jewish conspiracy beliefs likewise do as well.

> Class analysis can't explain this slavish attitude that nearly every world leader has to Israel.

It seems the opposite is true overall.[0]

> There's no intra-class conflict in Israel, all disagreements vanish into the ether and they close ranks as soon as they smell the opportunity to rid the world of what they view as the filthy, of the sheqetsim, of the abominable.

There are deep divisions within factions in Israel, to claim otherwise is to ignore reality.

[0] https://unwatch.org/2025-unga-resolutions-on-israel-vs-rest-...

jameshilliard··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
> An alternative to levelling entire cities to the ground to find tunnels, would be to stop the expanding of the settlers, stop the apartheid within Israel, stop the blockade and starving on Gaza, and try to actually foster peace instead of constant conflict, pain and misery in order to retain power.

Israel left Gaza back in 2005 after forcibly expelling all Jews and only later on only blockaded Gaza due to weapons being smuggled in, so they tried that and it clearly didn't work. It seems unilateral disengagement is simply not a strategy that can be succesful here.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →