211 karma · joined November 10, 2012
This is entirely true, and there are absolutely areas of natural science where the "right models" are pretty unclear, such as theoretical physics, as you mention. In this sense my distinction is somewhat fuzzy.
I am likely biased to perceive a large gulf because I work in molecular genetics, a field in which the there is a lot we are certain about; much of what we do is filling in holes and fleshing out the details of overarching models that are known to be largely correct.
>Like any academic community, the work within NLP had become largely an internal dialogue about approaches to problems the community had itself reified into importance.
I would argue that this is an issue of goals. If you're motivated by the application of research results to solve practical problems (as the author is), then this is a valid criticism. But for me science is also self evidently valuable — understanding the principles that govern the universe is a noble goal irrespective of finding opportunities to apply them.
Perhaps the field plays a role as well. In all sciences one's goal is to discover the rules and facts that govern a particular system. In the natural sciences, this system happens to be the world in which we live, whereas in the formal sciences (math / CS), the system is often an artificial one of human construction. In the natural sciences, the importance of the rules you discover is self evident (they govern our own lives and capabilities!), whereas in the formal sciences, its more necessary to justify the importance of your discoveries (with, say, practical applications) because the importance of the system you're studying isn't as self-evident.
This isn't to say that the natural sciences are in some way superior; just a speculation about the attitudes/motivations of academics in different fields.
EDIT: I realized this sounds very discouraging to laymen trying to learn more about science. This was not my intention! By all means, go forth and learn! :) My point was simply that press releases / news often make it seem like science advances at a breakneck pace all the time, whereas reality is that it's fits and starts and often we haven't the slightest clue what we're doing.
"Solving problems with computers" is too broad for any one person to master all aspects of it. There are so many different kinds of problems! Many of them also involve domain specific knowledge that has nothing to do with computers or computation (my airplanes and scientific computing examples above).