HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamesliudotcc

356 karma · joined May 31, 2020

submissionscomments
jamesliudotcc··on Why they're smearing Lina Khan
More Brandeisian. Hence the name, Neo-Brandeisian. But those precedents were overturned by the Supreme Court.

Only the Supreme Court can overturn the precedents. But since it is interpretation of statutes, Congress can change the statutes.

jamesliudotcc··on Why they're smearing Lina Khan
Khan and the "Neo-Brandeisians" have a legal theory, which to oversimplify, holds that the true meaning of the antitrust statutes is "big business is antithetical to democracy, and so the federal government is empowered to stop businesses getting bigger." The current precedent in antitrust holds that antitrust means that the government is only empowered to act when bigness results in consumer harm, mostly in the form of higher prices.

Note, legal theories are not like scientific theories! Courts can be influenced by legal theories. And in fact, the current mainstream in antitrust, which focuses on consumer harm, started as a legal theory propounded by the likes of Bork (yes, that Bork) and Posner. Because it has been adopted by the courts, especially by the Supreme Court, it is the precedent.

Trial courts are bound to follow the precedent! So, of course the legal strategy was bound to lead to losses in court. You can win under this strategy, but only in the Supreme Court, which isn't bound to follow the precedent, but mostly prefers to follow its own precedent. Getting to the Supreme court typically takes years, and it requires the Supreme Court wanting to take the case.

We'll see in the next stage if this was the strategy. If I were pursuing this strategy, I would say so. Then the losses wouldn't hurt morale!

jamesliudotcc··on What is “the right way” to install Python on a new M2 MacBook?
Use a Python.org universal install binary. Install as many versions as you want. You will always be able to get a particular version by typing, e.g., `python3.10`. Then use that version to create your virtual environment: `python3.10 -m venv env`. You can start your virtual environment with `source env/bin/activate`.

Here is 3.8: https://www.python.org/downloads/release/python-3810/ Here is 3.9: https://www.python.org/downloads/release/python-3913/ Here is 3.10: https://www.python.org/downloads/release/python-3108/ Here is 3.11: https://www.python.org/downloads/release/python-3114/

Whatever you do, do not use Homebrew, which has a habit of breaking your python environment when it updates patch versions. https://justinmayer.com/posts/homebrew-python-is-not-for-you....

Pyenv is usually ok, but sometimes you need to be a shell scripting wizard. And I am not that.

Conda is probably ok too. If you are in a data science ecosystem, go with Conda and you will be fine.

And building your own has always been fine.

jamesliudotcc··on Ask HN: What is the most timeless font?
Times New Roman is less than 150 years old, Helvetica less than 100. Despite their ubiquity due to being the default fonts on personal computers, they aren't super common in publishing or signage. They're actually kind of special purpose typefaces. Times is specifically designed packing narrow columns, like newspapers, and Helvetica is for ... I dunno what, documentary filmmakers? (The documentary was great).

As another commenter has said, Garamond has been around for many more centuries.

jamesliudotcc··on Wall Street scooped up a third of Texas single family homes sold last year (2022)
It should really be called small-parcel-of-land-plus-a-residential-structure borrowership-with-eventual-ownership.

And it is not all upside. Changing from one "owned" "home" to another has high transaction costs compared to renting. This has all kind bad consequences: people wind up living in the wrong shape/size of house for their family size. It makes it expensive to move to follow economic opportunity.

And then there is all the downside from having such a large portion of your savings tied up in a single, often highly leveraged, asset. Nobody would let you lever up your retirement portfolio 20:1 on any other kind of asset. And home ownership turns otherwise reasonable adults into NIMBYs.

As for the demise of home ownership, the last few decades have seen it fluctuate in a relatively narrow band. See these charts: https://dqydj.com/historical-homeownership-rate-united-state... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home-ownership_in_the_United_S...

jamesliudotcc··on Lawyers blame ChatGPT for tricking them into citing bogus case law
Hilariously, the explanation of the notarization typo (actually, I find that believable) is a 1746 "declaration." It's an old federal law which provides that as long as you say you are signing under oath, it is as good as an affidavit in federal court.

Why didn't he just make a declaration in the first place? Also, why would he have the lawyer who is in trouble notarize the document? Now that he has made the typo, he may now need Schwartz's testimony that actually, it was April 25, not January.

In my legal career, I worked for a judge once. He told me to never get a notary stamp. It only creates problems. There's never a good reason for a lawyer to notarize something. You ask your staff to do it instead.

jamesliudotcc··on Lawyers blame ChatGPT for tricking them into citing bogus case law
I used to be a lawyer. While I never got in trouble with the disciplinary commission, I did keep up with what they were up to. And once, I was involved in a bankruptcy case where they were a party (the disbarred lawyer filed bankruptcy, and it was a whole mess).

My sense is that these are serious people who do not put up with BS. BS will only make it worse.

jamesliudotcc··on Federal judge: No AI in my courtroom unless a human verifies its accuracy
A lawyer who files any document in federal court vouches for the factual and legal soundness of the document under penalty of sanctions, up to and including losing the case and being reported to the state bar's disciplinary board.

Lawyers often delegate tasks, including research and writing, to others. It has never been an excuse that their associate, paralegal, or cat did it.

The order doesn't create any new requirement about AI tools. It just reiterates that human lawyers are responsible for their filings.

jamesliudotcc··on Mandatory Certification Regarding Generative Artificial Intelligence
In federal courts, when you file something under your account (often, attorneys have staff do the clicking to file), it is the equivalent of signing. And what you sign, you vouch for.

This standing order reiterates what any practitioner _should_ know. It a rule which states that you should follow the rules! But as we learned from the Air Avianca filing, at least one lawyer is missing something very basic about what it means to sign a filing in federal court.

jamesliudotcc··on Why do recipe writers lie about how long it takes to caramelize onions? (2012)
Thomas Keller does not lie about this. It takes 6 hours on the stove.
jamesliudotcc··on I’m a student – you have no idea how much we are using ChatGPT
In law school, one professor asked if we preferred a take home exam or a proctored exam. To his surprise, we nearly unanimously chose proctored.

A take home exam or an essay is not less stress. It just expands the time boundaries of the stressor. The intensity of the stress doesn't ever get as high as an in-class exam perhaps. But the total stress was, in our lived experience, much greater.

jamesliudotcc··on Starbucks CEO will work a shift at the company’s cafes once a month
It is a good way to get exposed to the baristas once a month. When I was a barista there, I saw my manager's manager a few times. I think I knew the name of that person's manager? I think there's at least 2 more layers before the executive in charge of all of the stores.

This is the most direct way of accomplishing that.

jamesliudotcc··on Starbucks CEO will work a shift at the company’s cafes once a month
Yes. About the least-skilled position in retail is working the POS. Even with a touch screen, it takes practice. It makes a big difference if the operator knows where all the buttons are as opposed to having to hunt and peck. Yes, the machine tells you how much change to make, but picking up the right number of coins by touch instead of by picking up a bunch of them and counting them out into the other hand, that makes a difference. Picking up single bills out of the cash tray without fumbling takes some touch. Knowing all the sizes (short, tall, grande, venti, trenta?) and all the drinks. If you are at a store where they don't print drink labels, you have to know the order in which to announce a drink (size, modifiers, drink-type, but make sure the modifiers are in the right order) and the shorthand for the sharpie markup of the cups.

There's skills you need. None of it is that hard. But it is not easy to do it at speed without practice.

jamesliudotcc··on Starbucks CEO will work a shift at the company’s cafes once a month
Better not be during the rush. Someone who works half a day once a month is going to be worthless in a rush, and it isn't worth the trouble to train them because they aren't coming back soon enough to remember any skills.

During the less busy times, he might learn something, though. Especially if he talks with his partners. They still call the workers at Starbucks "partners," right?

jamesliudotcc··on Amazon to lay off 9,000 more workers after earlier cuts
Former barista who did a 90-day bootcamp here.

I never got any FAANG interviews until I'd had a developer job for a couple years. I got to a final round at Facebook, but didn't get hired there.

Still doing ok at that first job, though.

And yes, I agree, I am happy that I am not hitting the job market out of a bootcamp today.

jamesliudotcc··on Ask HN: Forcing Apple to use USB-C is wrong. They must open up Lightning. Agree?
Disagree. Even with the flaws.

Like it or not, USB-C is the new de facto standard. Even if Lightning were opened up, who else would use it? Current generation electronics of all sorts (laptops, phones, headphones, cameras, bike lights) are designed for usb-c charging. Old ones still have micro because they are amortizing down the equipment for making the port, and because everyone knows everyone has micro cables lying around. Even Apple households surely have USB-C lying around, so given the choice, why would any manufacturer choose Lightning for a net new product?

jamesliudotcc··on Ask HN: Has anyone successfully started their career over in their 30s?
Yes. Started as a lawyer at 31. Got laid off. Did a coding bootcamp at 37. Manage a team at 40. Very doable.
jamesliudotcc··on Times New Roman is being phased out at the State Department, replaced by Calibri
Skeuomorphism is a strong impulse.
jamesliudotcc··on Times New Roman is being phased out at the State Department, replaced by Calibri
What I want to know is what they were doing before 2004 when they adopted Times New Roman. Courier? Gothic?

Calibri is a nice screen-reading typeface. It is likely that "upstairs" reads on a screen, but I wouldn't bet that much on it.

Times New Roman was designed to shove as many letters into a multi-column newspaper page as possible. It's atrocious for anything else, and should be confined to whence it came, print newspapers. It's only the default because it is the default. Good riddance.

jamesliudotcc··on Ask HN: Could Tesla produce an e-bike without cannibalizing its car/truck sales?
No. Musk thinks cars are the thing. So Tesla can't, at all, regardless of cannibalizing sales or not.
jamesliudotcc··on Can GPT pass the bar exam?
The disruption will be from within the legal profession. Some lawyers will gain a great deal. Others will lose a great deal.

There is a lot of differentiation in terms of the level of skill and effort legal work takes. Some firms will specialize in automating away routine legal work, and have just enough lawyers to comply with unauthorized-practice-of-law laws.

High value legal work still contains a lot of grunt work, which will also become more automated. Already partners at big firms review the work of a pyramid of lawyers and non-lawyers. Many of those tasks can be done by an LLM instead. As long as the partner signs the result, it is the same. As these partners learn to trust the LLMs more than the humans, a lot of human jobs will fall by the wayside.

A lot of legal work is already copy-paste from form books or other prior art, with a lot of filling in the blanks, search-replace, and so on. What is the difference between that and using an LLM to draft the document? Was that integration clause from the form book carefully reviewed by a human lawyer to make sure it fit the situation? No.

Many law firms have a deep library of forms that are battle tested, and lawyers of long experience know what provisions are good and which may not survive a court challenge. That kind of contextual know-how is what you are paying for. Why not use the adversarial techniques from deep learning to analyze how various provisions have actually performed over time? Then generate the document based on that statistical knowledge, with highlighting to show what is risky in a document? Why pay for an expensive lawyer when a cheap one will do that work for you and can give you that explanation, plus alternative legal provisions?

I am out of the profession because I did not want to be on the automated-out side. If there is automating to be done, why not do the automating?

jamesliudotcc··on Can GPT pass the bar exam?
I took the bar exam. I passed, but it was Illinois, which has low standards and high passage rates. Take that for what it is.

On the essay portion, the scoring is about 1/3 focused on knowing the legal doctrine that is being tested, and 2/3 on the structure, clarity, and style of the response. (State the law, analyze how the law applies to the facts presented, assess the strength of the counterargument, come to the conclusion, go back and state the conclusion at the beginning.). In Illinois, the passing score is about 65%, so in theory you could pass the essay part while knowing no law at all.

Of course, you will not do so well on the multiple choice. I believe a skilled test taker with no law knowledge could triangulate answers to get to around ... 33%?

Of course, with statistical learning, and enough data, you could train an LLM to pass the bar.

Honestly, given how robotic studying for the bar exam was, I am only surprised it took until 2022-3

jamesliudotcc··on Twitter Sued for Nonpayment of Rent on San Francisco Office
It does, but only temporarily. Think of bankruptcy as fundamentally that the debt holders take over, and so a short time is given for everything to be sorted out. Creditors are paid by priority based on lien rights and some policy preferences encoded into the bankruptcy code. Nobody gets to jump ahead in line.

That is what the automatic stay does--it provides the pause to make sure nobody gets to jump ahead in line. As long as the stay remains in place, the landlord (or any other creditor) is forbidden from taking steps to evict a debtor. But it is possible to get relief from the stay if you can demonstrate that you would not be jumping ahead in line, and often relief from stay motions can be heard quickly. If the debtor needs the stay in order to reorganize (the theory being that it is better to have a bigger pie) then the debtor can apply for an extension, but only if it provides "adequate protection," which generally means paying according to the terms of the contract, or supplying additional collateral, or some such.

Timing is important. Once you file, all legal actions against you cease, and that is a very powerful tool. Unfortunately, you can only use that tool once. (Well, if you are a human individual, you get another chance years later.)

That is a very brief sketch. I haven't been a lawyer for years. You can ask a real bankruptcy lawyer for details.

jamesliudotcc··on The 5% Rule
I used to work in food service. I didn't keep track, but I don't think it was 3-5%. More like a tenth that. Maybe it's just coffee, and so even a great majority of the really terrible people could manage to pay and leave without exposing their terribleness.
jamesliudotcc··on Federal judge overrules NIH veterinarians about lab chimp retirement
The NIH, like most federal agencies, is used to this legal doctrine known as "deference," which comes in many flavors, usually you will hear of "Chevron deference." The general idea is, (step 1) when Congress does not specify what should be done, (step 2) the agency's decision need only be "reasonable." In this context, "reasonable" means "a lawyer spent words writing it," which given how the government operates, is almost always the case. So here, Congress _did_ specify what was to be done. Oh. So no deference for you.

It's really hard to figure out what to write in legislation. It is also somewhat hard to update the legislation to accord with new but subtle understandings, especially considering how much attention Congress members can possibly have as compared to how much law is in the books (go to a law library, look at a copy of the United States Code without the annotations, and consider how long it would take to read it, and that is only the beginning). But it is better when courts apply the law as written than making stuff up to suit their preferences, constrained by their prior precedents (assuming you are still at a law library, look at a copy of the United States Reports -- all the Supreme Court opinions ever -- and consider how long it would take to read that, and that is only the beginning).

jamesliudotcc··on Waymo expands its rider-only territories
GCP loses money.
jamesliudotcc··on Apollo Layoffs
They are paying the COBRA. So this goes toward copays and hitting deductible. Assuming their health coverage is good (why wouldn't it be, it's a San Fran tech company?), this gets you pretty far.
jamesliudotcc··on Smartphones wiped out 97% of the compact camera market
The astonishing thing is, compact cameras have 3% market share remaining.
jamesliudotcc··on Mercedes-Benz to introduce acceleration subscription fee
I wonder how many people buy these things outright. Every time I see an ad for a luxury car, they tell you about the monthly payment. If you stop making the monthly payment, guess what? They take the whole car away.

There are already GPS interlock systems where the dealer can shut down your car and locate it for collection, just in case of such a thing.

jamesliudotcc··on Mercedes-Benz to introduce acceleration subscription fee
This is an SUV that can do 0 to 60 in 6.2. Those used to be sports car numbers not too long ago. 5.2 is ludicrous for anything without an electric motor. It is not as if this is a 90s Yugo.

Some car magazine a while back did a side-by-side comparison of two Mercedes sedans, one with a V6 and the other with a V8. They were happier with the V6, because nobody can use the extra power given speed enforcement on highways. So do yourself a favor and just don't pay for it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →