HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamesrcole

2,419 karma · joined May 19, 2008

Doing a PhD: The Shared Foundations of Information, Computation, Mathematics, and Semantics: A Causal, Relational Account

https://twitter.com/jamesrcole

Brisbane, Australia.

submissionscomments
jamesrcole··on What Is Constructor Theory?
If something seems that way to you, and you want to say to others that it seems that way, you could explain why.

It’s not like it was developed by random nobodies, and it’s not like the default assumption should be that some work is the result of cranks (the default assumption should be agnosticism towards it)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructor_theory

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Deutsch

jamesrcole··on What Is Constructor Theory?
why? You don’t explain.
jamesrcole··on Apple reveals more about AirTag stalking protections
> Bring on the regulation and the public outrage! Just let it be directed at Tile for not doing this sooner.

Public outrage seems to be based on a very low-res view of reality drawn from viral sound-bites, so I doubt that's how any public outrage would work.

jamesrcole··on Dan Kaminsky has died
The tweet says “Please keep speculation to yourself”. Whether you think it’s appropriate or not, asking if anyone knows what happened is not the same as asking for speculation.
jamesrcole··on Book Review: “A Thousand Brains” by Jeff Hawkins
What if they’re sandboxed in some fashion? There’s zoos and jails and they’re reasonably effective at “keeping them in”.
jamesrcole··on Baltimore plant ruins 15M Johnson and Johnson coronavirus vaccines
How easily avoidable was the error? If it was caused by gross negligence then it’d be fair to criticize those at fault.

We don’t know, but you seem to be assuming it wasn’t as the result of negligence.

jamesrcole··on How Politics Tested Ravelry and the Crafting Community
Kathrine Jebsen Moore wrote three excellent, eye-opening articles about the knitting wars:

https://quillette.com/2019/02/17/a-witch-hunt-on-instagram/

https://quillette.com/2019/06/07/instagrams-diversity-wars-r...

https://quillette.com/2019/07/28/knittings-infinity-war-part...

jamesrcole··on Is Philosophy an Art?
Sure. james followed by a full stop, then cole. At Gmail.
jamesrcole··on Attributes and predictors of long Covid
I think they probably mean that, if there’s lots of cases, then there’s (in principle) lots of available information to study, regarding whatever mechanisms are behind the long covid effects we’ve seen so far.
jamesrcole··on Is Philosophy an Art?
> there is no way to refute or evaluate philosophy.

That is not true at all. Much philosophy throughout history has been shown to be incorrect by later science, for example.

jamesrcole··on Write Simply
The other person (at the top of this sub-thread) did say "Both of these points considered, I disagree entirely with the premise. There can be value to dense, even perhaps enigmatic writing. I would say that the greatest works of English literature tend towards that direction (James Joyce, Thomas Pynchon, David Foster Wallace)." I would not consider these edge cases, because I don't think literature is relevant to the essay and its purposes.
jamesrcole··on Write Simply
The essay is titled "Write Simply". It's about why you should try to write simply, rather than being a how-to. I think that's reasonable. It may be very difficult to precisely define what "simple" means, and it may not be that necessary: it's just telling people why (he thinks) they should aim for simplicity. Most people can make a conscious choice about how simple or complex their writing is - and this essay is advice about which direction to go in.
jamesrcole··on Write Simply
I think the essay is clearly about _non-fiction_ writing. It's arguing about how best to communicate ideas (he uses the term 'ideas' several times).

Sure, fiction can be trying to communicate things, and sometimes even ideas, but to me it's pretty obvious that the essay isn't trying to give advice for fiction writing in general.

jamesrcole··on Write Simply
> On the web, where each individual piece of writing is not meant to last as long, the writing style has become more casual. Consider the difference between your average Medium article versus your average academic research paper.

I would argue that academic writing tends to be pretty poor.

jamesrcole··on Write Simply
> I think there are two sources of confirmation bias here:

[...]

2. On the web, where each individual piece of writing is not meant to last as long, the writing style has become more casual. Consider the difference between your average Medium article versus your average academic research paper.

Did you see what he wrote in the essay, regarding this:

> Simple writing also lasts better. People reading your stuff in the future will be in much the same position as people from other countries reading it today. The culture and the language will have changed. It's not vain to care about that, any more than it's vain for a woodworker to build a chair to last.

Indeed, lasting is not merely an accidental quality of chairs, or writing. It's a sign you did a good job.

> I disagree entirely with the premise. There can be value to dense, even perhaps enigmatic writing. I would say that the greatest works of English literature tend towards that direction (James Joyce, Thomas Pynchon, David Foster Wallace).

It seems pretty clear to me that the essay is about non-fiction writing, not fiction. All the arguments in it apply to non-fiction writing.

jamesrcole··on Indonesia bans forced religious attire in schools
"Good news" doesn't have to mean "the overall trends are good". Something good can happen among a trend of bad things, and acknowledging the good thing doesn't mean denying the bad things.
jamesrcole··on Johnson and Johnson single-shot vaccine appears 66% effective in global trial
> Downvotes without replies again.

Looking at that comment it might be because it just asserts “there are far more side-effects w/mRNA than traditional vaccines” without any explanation or sources.

jamesrcole··on The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997)
I think the point is that a greater amount of more-granular and empirical data could provide the basis for learning more about "the human condition".
jamesrcole··on Tell HN: My entire company's Gsuite access has been banned
> You can contact support by...

It sounds like they've already contacted support. They said "Google support is refusing to let us know what happened" and "no one is providing us any answers or providing support".

jamesrcole··on Larry King has died
it's not being scared of that time after you've died, it's being scared of no longer being able to exist.
jamesrcole··on Larry King has died
The person said "who cares?". This is an issue about people who are still alive and their attitude towards death. What you're saying doesn't apply.
jamesrcole··on Aquafaba
> concerns about hormones

are there chickens anywhere that are given hormones?

As far as I have been able to determine, this is a myth, and the reason they grow quickly is selective breeding.

For example, in Australia https://theconversation.com/ten-facts-you-need-to-know-about...

jamesrcole··on PeerTube v3
It doesn’t need to. But obviously there are people who want it to be at least fairly well used.

The value of such a thing has a lot to do with how many people use it and how much content there is. You need users to give incentive for people to upload content. And you need content to incentivize new users.

jamesrcole··on PeerTube v3
> The ecosystem is vibrant, healthy, and will keep growing.

I'm in favour of it, and hope it does well. But at the same time, constant growth itself doesn't mean that much.

There's a big difference between slow constant growth and explosive constant growth. Something can constantly grow yet still remain something most people have never heard of. I think Linux on the desktop is a reasonable example of this.

The alternatives will likely be constantly growing as well.

> in my mind there will eventually be a tipping point

it's going to be difficult to compete against YouTube... there has to be some reason why people use it instead of YouTube.

jamesrcole··on The lesser-known Orwell: are his novels deserving of reappraisal?
You can argue there is a distinction to be made, but you can’t argue that it isn’t a form of censorship.
jamesrcole··on Michael Apted has died
There’s the Before film trilogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Before_trilogy

Before Sunrise (1995), Before Sunset (2004) and Before Midnight (2013)

jamesrcole··on Apple targets car production by 2024, eyes ‘next level’ battery tech: sources
> This is starting to make increasingly more sense even though Apple making a car seemed laughable a few years ago.

Which, for what it's worth, is an illustration of how our intuitions about future likelihoods aren't very good. We tend to see as implausible things that are too different from how they are today, overlooking how much things can change in a few years.

jamesrcole··on How and why I stopped buying new laptops
> The 11" Macbook Air solved the laptop form factor.

That's weirdly-specific. Some people would prefer a larger screen size, for example.

> Could there be some refinements to my 2015 MBA ?

I upgraded from a 2015 (I think) MBA to a 2018 model (both 13" ones), and two actual improvements that I like are: larger trackpad size, and smaller overall dimensions (so there's a smaller bezel around the screen, for example).

jamesrcole··on Zero to Emacs and Org-roam: a step-by-step guide on Windows 10
I switched from Vim to Emacs (specifically, Spacemacs) 1-2 years ago. So much time and effort to configure it and deal with its quirks. (I like Emacs and plan to stick with it longer, but I still think it has a number of issues).
jamesrcole··on Coca-Cola named world’s worst plastic polluter for third straight year
You reply implied I had said things I didn’t.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →