2,419 karma · joined May 19, 2008
https://twitter.com/jamesrcole
Brisbane, Australia.
Don't put strawman words into my mouth. You know I said "There's plenty of evidence that "common sense" is often wrong."
There is plenty of evidence that "common sense" is often wrong. You can pretty much say that the whole history of scientific advancements has been about challenging "common sense". I think you need to read a lot more about science and history.
If "common sense" is correct, it should be easy to provide a solid argument, backed up with data, that shows the "common sense" view is correct.
And I've repeatedly shown the details of poor waste management seeming to be the actual issue that needs to be addressed: https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution
If they’re not actually the problem, then why reduce them? Lots of things would be bad if sufficient quantities got into the environment, but we manage them well to avoid that, so don't consider them problems.
But say they are somewhat of a problem, we have to ask how much, and how this compares to alternatives. People talk of things like glass. But they tend to just imply that glass is better. Is it? For example, I think it requires much more energy to produce (and possibly to recycle). It’s heavier, so that means more energy used to transport it. I don’t know myself what the exact tradefoffs are. Again, I’d like to see rigorous arguments/evidence.
(emphasis added)
That's exactly the kind of thing I'm looking for - rigorous evidence and arguments. But not abstract claims that they exist, the actual specific evidence/arguments themselves.
That might be a serious issue, but simply mentioning it isn’t a serious argument against plastics themselves. See https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution
> * We don't really know what the long tail of plastic in the environment looks like.
See my response to another reply - the problem with plastic in the environment seems primarily to do with poor waste management practices. They seem to be a better thing to address to address this issue.
Could there be long tail impacts? I don’t know, but “we don’t know” is not a terribly strong argument. Surely that could also be said for lots of things other than plastic.
> * Plastic is a petrochemical product. Like all petrochemical products its extraction and production steps are environmentally devastating
That seems a plausible concern. We’d have to see the specific evidence about just how damaging that is, and how damaging it is relative to the alternatives.
> * Current policies for managing plastic waste fall into two categories: we either put it in a hole and forget about it (see the long tail point above)
I’ve hear that this isn’t actually a bad thing. For one thing, it’s localized (as in concentrated in specific areas). And surely there are ways of ensuring minimal leaching of ‘bad things’ in surrounds (potential eg: choosing a spot with appropriate groundwater).
> or we externalize it to a significantly poorer country for "recycling" (read: dumping into waterways, burning as trash, putting in their own holes in the ground). The former is an unknown, the later is bad and unsustainable
But then why aren’t these specific issues being targeted rather than plastics per se?
What I’ve heard is that plastics don’t pollute, per se, its poor waste management practices. When those practices are sufficient the plastic isn’t an issue (or is much less of an issue).
https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution#where-does-our-...
The summary of those details from that document:
“However, it is the management of plastic waste that determines the risk of plastic entering the ocean. High-income countries have very effect waste management systems; mismanaged waste – and plastic that ends up in the oceans – is therefore very rare. Poor waste management across many middle- and low-income countries means that these are the main sources of global ocean plastic pollution This makes the improvement of waste management systems across the world critical to reducing plastic pollution. An estimated 20 percent of all plastic waste in the oceans comes from marine sources. In some regions, marine sources dominate: More than half of plastics in the Great Pacific Garbage Patch (GPGP) come from fishing nets, ropes and lines”.
If this is true, then the best way to address the pollution would be to address those poor practices.
"Disposable plastic is bad" is one of those things "everybody knows", that tends to be just accepted as true.
Are there rigorous arguments for it being bad? The common arguments against them tend to be fairly shallow, IMO.
I've heard that the actual issue is mostly poor waste management and recycling practices in certain countries and on ships, and that landfill isn't really a bad thing.
I'm willing to hear arguments against disposable plastic.
We might find one compelling, but what matters is which is more accurate (or maybe neither of them are).
That is completely untrue and completely misrepresenting the game. It's basically the opposite of the truth.
On the gameplay - which has been mostly fairly highly praised https://www.ign.com/articles/2016/12/15/super-mario-run-revi...
On its monetization model - which has been praised for being consumer friendly (and harming profitability for Nintendo). You can play some of it for free and there’s a one-off $10 payment to unlock the rest. https://venturebeat.com/2016/12/23/how-super-mario-run-screw...
> Are all experts in agreement on virtual particles? If not, which are we meant to 'follow'?
?
the person I was responding to picked out one particular expert's view
"you can just tell them that Arkani-Hamed disagrees with you and that he is also smarter than you."
aside from the silly "he is also smarter than you", just because one expert holds a view doesn't make it right.
If all the experts were unanimous, and the particular point had been well tested, then a point like yours would hold.
Also, the comment I was responding to was assuming that no-one on HN has a relevant background for having a solid opinion on virtual particles. I certainly don't, but I would not make that assumption about everyone on this forum. I don't agree with the notion that just because someone has a high status in a field that this automatically makes their opinions superior to other people in that field.
So, argument from authority then?
Are all experts in agreement on virtual particles? If not, which are we meant to 'follow'?
And BTW, I have no position on virtual particles.
What is the intuition that this runs counter to?
I don't see it as counterintuitive. It seems to me a reflection of human nature. I imagine people have always been that way.
It’s not a matter of whether one way is too difficult or not. It’s a matter of whether an alternative has some improvements or not.
I unsubscribe and/or report spam where I can, but on a typical day, I still get around 3 emails intended for someone else.