HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamesrcole

2,419 karma · joined May 19, 2008

Doing a PhD: The Shared Foundations of Information, Computation, Mathematics, and Semantics: A Causal, Relational Account

https://twitter.com/jamesrcole

Brisbane, Australia.

submissionscomments
jamesrcole··on 50% – 75% of cases of Covid-19 are asymptomatic
CFR, whatever it is, isn’t the most significant detail. What is “terrifying” is its high contagiousness combined with its high hospitalisation and ICU rates.
jamesrcole··on U.S. Government official: Coronavirus vaccine trial starts Monday
Complacency and panic aren’t the only two options.

Complacency is a massive problem right now. So many people are not taking social distancing seriously, and it’s going to have disastrous consequences, al la how things are currently playing out in Italy, in many countries.

And compared to that, the temporary exhausting of supplies is a trifling matter. (Wait until the real panic sets in when hospitals can’t keep up). But like I said, it’s not like we have to chose between complacency OR panic. We can take it seriously and take appropriate actions.

jamesrcole··on U.S. Government official: Coronavirus vaccine trial starts Monday
I worry that headlines like this will lead to complacency amongst certain parts of the population.

They'll think a vaccine will be here soon.

I imagine their thought processes would be like: what's the big deal with this virus, why do we need to mess up the economy by social distancing, if we're going to have a vaccine quite soon?

jamesrcole··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
> Any half-decent plot aimed at non-specialists will have "log scale" written in the title or surrounding description

I have to wonder how many non-specialists would even know what “log scale” means.

jamesrcole··on Open letter from Italy to the international scientific community
In part, because they think they already understand the situation, and the nature of that understanding precludes taking things like that seriously.

“It’s just the flu”

“It only kills 2% of people”

“The flu, cancer, car accidents, malnutrition, etc have killed far more people”

“People were worried about SARS, Swine Flu, and H1N1, and they turned out to be hardly kill anyone.”

“There number of cases here is small. Why are you panicking over nothing?”

“People need to stop panicking. People are going hysterical. The media is trying to make people panic. Just look at them hoarding toilet paper”.

“People are trying to ruin the economy over nothing”

“The experts — epidemiologists — say there’s nothing to worry about” (I’ve had this said to me and I was given a link to a news article that spun statements from some epidemiologists to make it sound that way. They were saying that they didn’t know how the situation would pan out, and this was presented as if it meant they didn’t think there was any issue).

I imagine that most people aren’t aware of the graphs. I imagine most people would be dismissive of them for reasons like the following:

They simply believe the apparent normalcy in front of them more than some abstract maths. They don’t grasp the notion of exponential growth, so it seems fanciful. They also don’t understand how it’s possible to project into the future like that. Maybe they think it’s just fear-mongering speculation. What concrete evidence do they actually have for the situation in Italy? And why should they believe what’s going on in a different country will apply to their country. Maybe their country has a good health care system, and they assume that Italy doesn't.

jamesrcole··on Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid-19 threat
We’re in a real situation where choices (or the lack thereof) will have major consequences. If the best estimate we can make is a rough one, it’s still sensible to use it as a guide for our actions.
jamesrcole··on What we can learn from the 1918 flu pandemic
> so I’ll be fine

I hope so, but

- it will kill some number of younger people, even healthy ones.

- it’s also worth considering that we don’t (AFAIK) have a clear picture about potential long-term complications (eg lung damage). We should not simply assume there won’t be these.

I’m saying this to emphasize the seriousness of the situation.

jamesrcole··on Google recommends all North America employees work from home
> Whereas the rest of us are trying not to let those thoughts surface.

If people in positions of power are trying to not let such thoughts surface, they’re being highly irresponsible.

jamesrcole··on Why the central problem in neuroscience is mirrored in physics
How do you know it is unrelated to neuroscience?

If you were to ask me whether I think neuroscience currently has any understanding of the hard problem of consciousness, I would say that I don't think they do.

But it's still related to neuroscience.

jamesrcole··on CDC: Possible ‘community spread’ coronavirus case in Bay Area
You are making a flawed assumption that we have good enough data from which to conclude such definitive statements.

It is obvious that we still have a lot to learn about how bad it is actually going to be, and it is obvious that a lot of the figures we've received so far are untrustworthy.

jamesrcole··on CDC: Possible ‘community spread’ coronavirus case in Bay Area
> I know I'll probably get it eventually and be fine

unfortunately, you don't know you'll be fine or even probably fine (which applies for everyone else, too), and it's unhelpful to be propagating such misinformation.

jamesrcole··on San Francisco's mayor declared state of emergency as the coronavirus spread
> I think it's a wise move because of both outcomes: 1. There is no pandemic ... 2. There is a moderate pandemic

Given the information that we currently do and don't have, there's clearly more possibilities than just those two. (I am not making any claim about how likely any particular possibility is)

jamesrcole··on Clinical characteristics of 50k patients with 2019-nCoV infection
> a small percentage of the population is going a little crazy

What are they doing?

jamesrcole··on Iran lawmaker says 50 dead from coronavirus in city of Qom
Regarding your second paragraph, I never said that I’d never heard the terms. I said that they weren’t covered in high school history for me.

There’s so many topics that can be covered in high-school history classes, and so little actual aggregate time for those classes - why would you expect those topics be amongst them?

Also, why do you think that criticising such history classes, and the country they're in, somehow negates the point i made?

jamesrcole··on Iran lawmaker says 50 dead from coronavirus in city of Qom
> Everyone who had history in high school has historical information about this

I don't recall any such information.

There's people on this site of all different ages, who grew up in all sorts of different places. How do you know what their high-school history covered?

In my school, history was mandatory in the first year of high-school, and I think it might have been in the second year as well. Hardly anyone did it as a subject for the remainder of their high-school years.

Needless to say, the content taught in those first 1-2 years barely even scratched the surface of historical topics.

jamesrcole··on Programmer's critique of missing structure of operating systems
The important question here is, why? Was it because of those features? Or something else?

I don't know, but one major factor in OS adoption is network effects. "The rich get richer", and it's very hard to introduce a new and different system, no matter how good it is.

jamesrcole··on Programmer's critique of missing structure of operating systems
> the fact that most of those items were shipped in a extraordinarily well-supported, mass market OS literally decades ago and still didn't catch on maybe says something about the value of the design ideas.

that statement seems heavily draw on the idea that success is the result of a meritocracy. But 'how good something is' often plays a small part in the selection of winners and losers.

jamesrcole··on Why we need a book about naming
> Why does it matter what things are called if the name of the thing might be a lie anyway? I'm going to have to check what it does anyway!

Imagine a program where all the keywords and identifiers have been replaced with randomly generated strings.

jamesrcole··on Cotton Candy (2010)
> The value of cotton candy was never the chance to eat something sugary. It was the chance to eat something magical that belonged in faerie tales ... Tasting it was such a minor element of the whole thing.

I don't agree that this is true in general. It doesn't have to be one or the other, it can be both. Kids love sugary things, and it also has an appealing "melt in your mouth" texture.

jamesrcole··on Reasons not to become famous
The article covers that, near the start.
jamesrcole··on Philosophy as Math-Like Thinking
I've read a fair bit of philosophy, and I think the approach this post describes is often problematic.

They try to treat concepts as if they were like mathematical symbols that they can reason precisely with. The problem is when they don't understand the concepts involved well-enough to be able to treat them in this way. This is often the case, given that the subject-matter is in philosophy.

So you end up with a situation where it looks like they're drawing conclusions in a rigorous fashion, but where it's actually a kind of garbage-in-garbage-out situation.

Precision is really important. But you have to acknowledge the level of precision that your level of understanding affords. Trying to be more precise than that makes things worse.

jamesrcole··on Artificial Mountains
Though it's hill-sized not mountain-sized, there is Silbury Hill in England

"The largest artificial mound in Europe, mysterious Silbury Hill compares in height and volume to the roughly contemporary Egyptian pyramids. Probably completed in around 2400 BC, it apparently contains no burial. Though clearly important in itself, its purpose and significance remain unknown."

https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/visit/places/silbury-hil...

jamesrcole··on Andrei Tarkovsky’s Message to the Young: “Learn to Be Alone” (2015)
> I don't like the idea of "understanding" a film. I don't believe that rational understanding is an essential element in the reception of any work of art.

I think it depends on the work. Take the tv show The Wire. There is a lot to understand and learn from it. I found doing so really worthwhile (for multiple reasons).

jamesrcole··on Andrei Tarkovsky’s Message to the Young: “Learn to Be Alone” (2015)
I spent a fair bit of time alone, and bored, while growing up (I was born in the late 70s, so this was primarily in the 80s). I felt it helped me to get comfortable with my own thoughts and to be able to think for myself.

It is of course difficult, on the basis of memory and introspection, to tell how much it helped in that regard.

I'm not saying that being alone will help someone get comfortable with their thoughts and be able to think for themselves. It just seems like it can be conducive to that.

jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
"If one of the worst members wasn't scared off, that's a good piece of evidence." Yes, I think that him being one of the worst has zero bearing. You made the claim - why do you think it's good evidence?
jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
No, I did not see any evidence there at all, and I wrote my comment on the basis of that.

Having seen the subsequent replies, I can now see how other people have taken it as a form of evidence.

While I can now see why other people might consider it evidence for the claim, I do not consider it to be such myself (in the sense of 'evidence' being something that supports a claim).

jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
That one person wasn't scared off provides no evidence about how many other people were or weren't scared off.

That he might be the worst has zero bearing on this.

jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
That is not true.

What I did was not simply asking a person to back up a claim they made. If that was the case you could call me out for inconsistency.

I was responding to a person who had claimed to have provided some evidence that they had not actually given.

I responded to a sentence that was presenting a claim, and also implying that the evidence for their claim was given earlier in their comment, which I did not believe was the case.

That sentence was: "So no, OP, academics who didn't support trans politics weren't scared off by the community".

That 'So no' implies that the evidence for the claim has been given earlier in their comment. I did not see any evidence in their comment, so I asked if they could provide some.

jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
> If that abomination of a researcher wasn't scared off, it's pretty strong evidence that there wasn't any significant harassment that had a chilling effect on discussion.

Just because one person wasn't scared off doesn't mean they didn't get a lot of harassment. I don't know whether they did or didn't, but the fact that they weren't scared off is not evidence they didn't get lots of harassment.

And that doesn't mean other people weren't scared off. Different people have different tolerances for harassment, and differing degrees to which they want to be involved in a particular matter.

> You can apply all the "autogynephilia" testing and logic to most cis women and they'll come out with a strong diagnosis. Whatever you think about the nature of transgenderism, applying that particular theory leads to nothing but pain and abuse.

This has absolutely nothing to do with the content of any of my comments.

jamesrcole··on David Rosenhan’s fraudulent Thud experiment set back psychiatry for decades
> The claim wasn't that there was or wasn't harassment, but that harassment was the cause of the change in policy.

hsyqiwgx wrote "The trans community lobbied and bothered academics ... until the academics threw up their hands and decided their funding wasn't good enough to justify having a spine".

sterlind replied "So no, OP, academics who didn't support trans politics weren't scared off by the community."

The claim that both of these people were talking about, concerned academics being harassed and as a result being scared off.

And just because that one person was involved, doesn't mean that other people weren't scared off.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →