HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamestnz

583 karma · joined September 14, 2012

submissionscomments
jamestnz··on 10yr+ PHP Dev Wondering: Python vs. PHP for Web Applications?
I've developed for the web (ranging from small one-script hacks, up to large commercial applications) for about 15 years. Much of this work has been in PHP, often using the CodeIgniter framework [1]. As far as PHP goes, I do like CI; it provides some semblance of an MVC environment, a predictable URL/parameter routing scheme, view templates, and so on. I have a CI custom controller I inherit from to publish my REST endpoints. Generally CI projects will tend toward a somewhat common/predictable structure, enhancing maintainability and team development.

But over the years I've also inherited some absolutely abhorrent PHP nightmare projects, whose design/coding decisions truly boggle the imagination. Often based on no framework at all, and apparently motivated largely by the developer's desire to use as many PHP and SQL features as possible in the same project.

Latterly I've been using python for some web projects. I played briefly with django, but I've found myself settling on Flask [2], a very nice "microframework" which is super easy to get running with, and which gives a great balance between power and stay-out-of-my-way-ness. It has a simple URL routing system based on function decorators and regex, the ability to factor your apps into reusable components based around your python modules, jinja2 templates, etc. I use sqlalchemy for db access.

Honestly I find it much more of a pleasure to be coding python/flask vs PHP/codeigniter, but due to team and project constraints it isn't always possible to go that way.

[1] https://ellislab.com/codeigniter/

[2] http://flask.pocoo.org/

jamestnz··on Samsung Unveils SSD Delivering Speeds of Over 2 GB/s
I can assure you that the iPhone as originally announced was never going to allow third-party native apps; it was to be web-apps only forever, and this was not intended to be a temporary position. Even though their language was often cagey, it is my clear recollection that Apple's general attitude around/beyond the release of iPhone OS 1.0 was that web-apps were essentially "as good as" any native app could be, and were therefore everything developers would ever need. As I recall it was some 13 months before they finally relented and began to talk native third-party API access.

I was at WWDC 2007, here's what Jobs said at the time -

"The full Safari engine is inside of iPhone. And so, you can write amazing Web 2.0 and Ajax apps that look exactly and behave exactly like apps on the iPhone. And these apps can integrate perfectly with iPhone services. They can make a call, they can send an email, they can look up a location on Google Maps. And guess what? There’s no SDK that you need! You’ve got everything you need if you know how to write apps using the most modern web standards to write amazing apps for the iPhone today. So developers, we think we’ve got a very sweet story for you. You can begin building your iPhone apps today."

Additionally -

Apple board member Art Levinson told Isaacson that he phoned Jobs “half a dozen times to lobby for the potential of the apps,” but, according to Isaacson, “Jobs at first quashed the discussion, partly because he felt his team did not have the bandwidth to figure out all the complexities that would be involved in policing third-party app developers.”

The following article discussed this http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/21/jobs-original-vision-for-the-i...

jamestnz··on How Colonel Sanders Became Father Christmas in Japan
The coca-cola company sure does like to claim this! Snopes has an interesting analysis http://www.snopes.com/holidays/christmas/santa/cocacola.asp
jamestnz··on Jailed criminals think they are more kind, trustworthy and honest than average
It's not necessary that most other drivers have had an accident for most people to have had below the average number of accidents.

Consider a population of 100 drivers, none of whom have ever had a traffic accident. The average number of accidents per driver is therefore zero.

Suddenly, two of them collide. Now, 2/100 drivers have had an accident, and 98/100 drivers have still never had an accident. The average number of accidents per driver is now therefore 0.02.

Since 98/100 drivers have had 0 accidents, but the average number of accidents per driver is 0.02, then 98% of drivers have had below the average number of accidents.

jamestnz··on The Truth We Won't Admit: Drinking Is Healthy
Here is one, http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/content/155/8/732.full

A reduced risk for Parkinson's disease (PD) among cigarette smokers has been observed consistently during the past 30 years. Recent evidence suggests that caffeine may also be protective. Findings are presented regarding associations of PD with smoking, caffeine intake, and alcohol consumption from a case-control study conducted in western Washington State in 1992–2000.

jamestnz··on DigitalOcean or Linode? What Do You Guys Recommend?
>How to migrate from DigitalOcean to Linode?

Did you try this article? It is a tutorial for moving a wordpress blog from a Linode VPS to a DO VPS (the opposite of what you're asking), but contains many steps and general tips that you will find useful. https://www.digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/migrate-you...

In general terms, you'll be looking at something like this: boot a fresh VM at Linode, apply updates, and install all your needed packages. Stop services on both hosts. Copy the necessary data/config files to the destination host, using a tool such as scp or rsync. Set permissions/ownership on destination files if needed. Start services on the destination host, test everything, reconfigure dns, and you're all set.

FWIW, I've been a happy linode user for 5+ years. I have nothing against DO, I've just never had cause to use them yet.

Incidentally, you mentioned in your blog that you tried a range of shared-hosting providers (HostGator, Bluehost, iPage...) finding them all unsatisfactory, before deciding to move to a dedicated VPS. You may or may not be aware that all three of those providers (and many more) are actually owned by one parent company, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endurance_International_Group (i.e.: by trying a set of commonly-owned companies you may not have ended up surveying a particularly diverse cross-section of the market).

jamestnz··on ITerm2 2.0
There is a tool named TotalTerminal (formerly "Visor") for the Mac which extends Terminal.app and does exactly this. I even have control-~ mapped to the behaviour. It seems pretty configurable, and hooks nicely into the prefs window of Terminal itself. You can hit cmd-opt-F to temporarily switch the current Terminal into full-screen mode, in case you need to delve into a particular task.

Screenshot: http://imgur.com/LiYdTu2 Prefs: http://imgur.com/YCDROa3

jamestnz··on 4chan demands 4chan.com domain name
Another interesting example is the fact that Burger King is known ubiquitously as "Hungry Jack's" within Australia (but here in New Zealand we get the real BK branding).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungry_Jack's#History_of_.22Bur...

"When Burger King moved to expand its operations into Australia, it found that its business name was already trademarked by a takeaway food shop in Adelaide. As a result, Burger King provided the Australian franchisee, Jack Cowin, with a list of possible alternative names derived from pre-existing trademarks already registered by Burger King and its then corporate parent Pillsbury that could be used to name the Australian restaurants. Cowin selected the "Hungry Jack" brand name, one of Pillsbury's U.S. pancake mixture products..."

jamestnz··on How not to write an API
Well saddle-up, my friend ;-)

In seriousness, recall the weev/AT&T case[1]. As I understand it, the attack was roughly of the sophistication of making a totally unauthenticated request to:

get_user_email_address.php?id=N

(where N was from a series of sequential integers)... and apparently the feds had a colorable argument that N constituted an "access control system", and therefore the act of iterating the entire series of possible N values (and downloading the resulting data) constituted "unauthorized access to a protected system".

Not quite in the same realm as coughing up plain-text passwords, I'll admit. But clearly some relevant authorities would set the bar for "access control system" fairly low. And apparently rank incompetence on the part of the site developer/owner appears not to come into things.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4808676

jamestnz··on Why am I here?
It’s better. We have things like fibre and VDSL2 with unlimited caps now. Like properly unlimited ones (not just "unlimited"). You can get a gigabit internet connection -- or even dark fibre between private premises -- in many cases.

For example, one residential ISP just released a statement apparently clarifying their policy regarding "unlimited" plans [1]:

“Customers are free to go crazy and use as much data as they want. We have some customers using nine terabytes per month on our residential unlimited plans which shows just how unlimited they really are."

9TB at home?!

Personally I use a different ISP at my house: I have ADSL2+ and get a quota of 260 GB per month for about $50. This is a "naked" service so I receive it via a copper line whose regular landline dial-tone service has been disconnected.

[1] https://www.orcon.net.nz/about/article/orcons_unlimited_broa...

jamestnz··on Sent $10,701.03 to Coinbase. Still missing bitcoins.
"I'm not sure how that guy got the CEO of the company to intercede on his behalf"

Well, he did so by raising a public fuss about it, that much seems obvious. The OP of this thread seems (quite reasonably) to be attempting to achieve the same outcome by the same method.

Taking this OP’s claims at face value, it seems like the support person quoted was trying to be helpful (or at least empathetic). Unfortunately, on a basic customer-service level, the response fails spectacularly.

I fail to believe that a company such as coinbase would neglect to have some mechanism where staffers can escalate support tickets (as is apparently being claimed). Jeez, it doesn’t even have to go directly to the CEO skipping all intermediate steps: just bump it up the chain!

That CEO intervention should be necessary to achieve basic customer satisfaction is crazy to begin with. Either empower the hierarchy to solve problems, or give them access to someone who can.

OP did you try emailing brian@coinbase.com directly? (I’m not revealing any information here that a quick googling doesn’t).

jamestnz··on Would you take smart drugs to perform better at work?
@greenfieldprod: You seem to have made multiple high-quality replies in this thread, but nobody is seeing them (and nobody can reply to them) because your account seems to be 'hellbanned'. Some people (like me) will see your posts, because they surf HN with 'showdead' turned on in the prefs, but most people won't even be knowing that you exist right now.

Normally this is only applied to spammers and trolls etc, but I thought it might be nice to let you know since you seem to be legitimately attempting to participate here.

I'm not sure how to appeal this, aside from contacting pg or making a new account.

No need to reply to this, not trying to derail the thread. Cheers.

jamestnz··on Bitcoin and the Byzantine Generals Problem
In fact, storage-area density apparently increases more rapidly than does transistor density (i.e. Moore's law).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Kryder#Kryder.27s_Law

A PhysOrg.com article reports on a 2009 study by Mark Kryder. According to the report, if hard drives continue to progress at their current pace, then in 2020 a two-platter, 2.5-inch disk drive will be capable of storing more than 14 terabytes (TB) and will cost about $40.

jamestnz··on Inside the Saudi 9/11 Coverup
> What's Bush's interest in protecting the Saudis?

Perhaps not so much protecting the Saudis, as protecting the established pretext for the administration's response?

For instance, it has been reported that within mere hours of the first plane hitting, high-level officials were specifically seeking ways to blame it on Iraq, without regard to whether that was a relevant course of action [1].

Additionally, senior officials have stated that they believe Bush intended on invading Iraq at the time he took office, or at least well ahead of 9/11 [2][3].

And it's clear that protecting the public story was important: The Bush administration outrageously persecuted those who attempted to move the public discourse in directions that contradicted the official line, for instance [4] which was nothing but retribution for pointing out that the administration lied (i.e.: already knew their claims about uranium and Niger had been specifically investigated and debunked).

[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/plans-for-iraq-attack-began-on-9... Rumsfeld was "telling his aides to start thinking about striking Iraq, even though there was no evidence linking Saddam Hussein to the attacks" five hours after an American Airlines jet slammed into the Pentagon. ... [N]otes that had been taken at the time by a Rumsfeld aide ... quote the defense chief asking for the "best info fast" to "judge whether good enough to hit SH (Saddam Hussein) at the same time, not only UBL" (Usama bin Laden). The administration should "go massive...sweep it all up, things related and not".

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq Former chief counter-terrorism adviser on the National Security Council Richard A. Clarke believes Bush took office with a predetermined plan to invade Iraq.

[3] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/bush-sought-way-to-invade-iraq/ And what happened at President Bush's very first National Security Council meeting is one of O'Neill's most startling revelations. "From the very beginning, there was a conviction, that Saddam Hussein was a bad person and that he needed to go," says O'Neill, who adds that going after Saddam was topic "A" 10 days after the inauguration - eight months before Sept. 11.

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plame_affair

jamestnz··on Sequence of Events in the Cockpit on Asiana Flight 214
Yes. Each new airplane type that you're going to pilot requires you to first attain a Type Rating[1] in it.

For instance, I picked a random link to a flight school that offers a B777 type rating course[2] - which takes 14 days of ground-work and 9 days of flight training (36 hours in the simulator in this case; often for big airliners it's going to be too expensive or impractical to perform a type-rating in a real aircraft).

Additionally, having attained the type rating, you're required to maintain "currency" in that type by flying it frequently; if you let type currency lapse by going too long without flying it, you need to undergo a kind of mini "refresher" training/assessment to regain currency again. This is the case for Private/GA Pilots in NZ at least, I'm not so familiar with other jurisdictions or license categories.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_rating

[2] http://www.balticaa.com/en/aviation-training-courses-/type-r...

jamestnz··on The microhydro plant
Indeed, the Wikipedia page on the Vortex Tube mentions it has been successfully used with water when input at high pressure.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vortex_tube

In 1988 R.T.Balmer applied liquid water as the working medium. It was found that when the inlet pressure is high, for instance 20-50 bar, the heat energy separation process exists in incompressible (liquids) vortex flow as well.

I hadn't heard of this before, interesting stuff!

jamestnz··on Internet horror stories: How ISPs screwed over users
Interesting article for me, being that I have no experience with the ISP industry in America at all.

"The best solution, I think, is to lay fiber in all the municipalities and have consumers choose their ISP, with service delivered on the municipal fiber lines..."

This is exactly what has been happening where I live - Christchurch, New Zealand. A number of years ago, a city-owned LLC called Christchurch City Networks Limited (now known as Enable Networks[1]) began rolling out an extensive fibre network in the downtown/city-centre area. Initially, for about $700 (NZD) per month, you could lease a dark pair between your premises and your ISP of choice (or even directly between two arbitrary premises, plugging directly into your own equipment at each end, with no ISP involved).

You'd then negotiate arbitrary speed/bandwidth/caps with your chosen ISP. We were paying something like $3000 per month for a 1000 mbit/sec internet connection with (IIRC) a 2TB cap. This was probably 8 years ago or something, it doesn't cost anything like this now.

Latterly, they've been rolling out a GPON-based (passive) fibre network. If you are connected to this part of the network, there are highly standardised plans available from multiple ISPs. You can choose one of two speeds: 30 mbit/sec symmetric, or 100 mbit/sec symmetric. Different ISPs have different usage plans available. Any public (government-funded) school can sign up for a 30 mbit/sec plan, with unlimited traffic, for something like $200/month.

Amongst home users, ADSL2+ and VDSL2 are both still popular choices (and our pricing there seems similar enough to the US, with stupidly low caps and high prices), but fibre continues to gain traction.

[1] http://www.enable.net.nz

jamestnz··on Google Made My Daughter Cry Today
This got me thinking, as I have many primary-school clients ("K-6" schools) making extensive use of Google Apps for Education to give the students access to various services like gmail, drive, sites, blogger.

So I just did a search, and found the following question and answer on productforums.google.com[1] from 2009...

Question:

We currently have Google Apps Education in our school. Our teachers in the elementary and middle school have expressed a great interest in using Google Docs in the classroom. I read on the web that there is a age restriction of 13. Is there anything in the terms of service that indicates this and what is Google's position on using Google docs in k-5 classrooms.

Answer:

If you are using Google Docs within Google Apps Education Edition for your school domain, your school assumes the responsibility for complying with COPPA and the information that students submit. When offering online services to children under 13, schools must be cognizant of Child Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). COPPA is a regulation that requires parental consent for the online collection of information about users under 13. Per the Google Apps Education Edition Agreement, any school administering Google Apps Education Edition acknowledges and agrees that it is solely responsible for compliance with COPPA, including, but not limited to, obtaining parental consent concerning collection of students' personal information used in connection with the provisioning and use of the Services by the Customer and End Users.

Parental consent and notification could take place in form of a permission slip granting use of Google Apps and/or other technology services at the school. For more information on complying with COPPA see the FTC's website at www.ftc.gov/coppa.

EDIT:

From [2], google have also said:

Asking for age information helps us provide features like age-appropriate settings to our users, who are interacting more every day with the people they know. Under our policies, Google doesn’t allow users who are under the age of 13 to have Google Accounts, unless they are using Google Apps for Education accounts through their school. This is similar to a lot of online services, as it's very complicated for many providers to offer better solutions for children that meet the relevant regulations.

[1] http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/google-educati...

[2] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/blogpost/post/hey-google...

jamestnz··on A Prediction: Bitcoin Is Doomed to Fail
Something that might be considered an "intrinsic" value of bitcoin is its ability to instantly and securely transfer wealth across large distances at zero or near-zero cost. This is an feature not present in some of the incumbent currencies and store-of-value assets.

For example, physically shipping hundreds of kilograms of gold (or physical, folding USD) is a costly exercise fraught with security risks, and the risk profile varies depending on many factors, for instance the political situations in the sending and receiving countries.

Transferring large amounts of electronic USD across international borders via the traditional banking system is going to invoke all kinds of reporting requirements, and possibly higher transaction costs (though you can do large wire transfers for like $25 I think).

Transferring arbitrary amounts via bitcoin is easy, secure and the transaction itself is cost-effective (notwithstanding the current relative difficulty/expense of moving large amounts of fiat currency into and out of bitcoin in the first place, which problem I'd expect to ease as the btc economy matures).

jamestnz··on Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transaction
The numbers for this, sadly (or gladly, for holders of bitcoin), don't work out. Even if you had the most powerful supercomputer in the world and could try trillions upon trillions of keys per second, you'd need, on average, more than the current age of the universe to brute-force the key.

From: http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/22/is-it-possible...

In order to spend money sent to a Bitcoin address, you just need to find a ECDSA public key that hashes to the same 160 bit value. That will take, on average, 2 ^ 160 key generations.

Supposing you could generate a billion (2 ^ 30) per second, you need 2 ^ 130 seconds.

Doing this in parallel using a billion machines requires only 2 ^ 100 seconds.

Getting a billion of your richest friends to join you gets it down to only 2 ^ 70 seconds.

There are about 2 ^ 25 seconds per year, so you need 2 ^ 45 years.

The age of the Universe is about 2 ^ 34 years so far—better get cracking!

jamestnz··on How to Sell a Blog for $36,200
I think this is good advice. I researched this very subject some months ago, and came across an interesting article by an Aussie guy named Yaro Starak, where he discusses his ideas about selling blog ad-space directly, and his pricing model for it.

http://www.entrepreneurs-journey.com/10201/how-much-should-y...

(Not spam, I'm not affiliated with this guy, I was just reminded of it so I pulled the URL from my history to share it, I promise!)

jamestnz··on Why It's So Hard to Get From Brooklyn to Queens
Not really related, but your comment reminds me of a fantastic exchange from a Seinfeld ep, with Kramer advising Jerry on how to get to Coney Island.

Kramer: Ok, you can take the B or the F and switch for the N at Broadway Lafayette, or you can go over the bridge to DeKalb and catch the Q to Atlantic Avenue, then switch to the IRT 2, 3, 4 or 5.

But don't get on the G. See, that's very tempting, but you'll wind up on Smith and 9th, then you've got to get on the R.

Elaine: ... Couldn't he just take the D straight to Coney Island?

Kramer: Well. Yeah.

jamestnz··on Announcing The Dark Mail Alliance – Founded by Silent Circle and Lavabit
>Without searching I have no idea what that is supposed to mean. I guess it is something related to free speech in the USA?

He was a British philosopher from the 1600s, an important Enlightenment thinker.

jamestnz··on Using the world's first Bitcoin ATM
You were probably kidding :-) But: from the screenshot in TFA, they require you to provide biometric identification and then they appear to apply a $1001 per day usage limit to this identity, and this is specifically in place to comply with AML regulations.
jamestnz··on Uber CEO responds to concern that Uber's SF service is decreasing in quality
> and that it was illegal for him to pick anyone up from the airport and that Uber had specifically given him guidance not to pick anyone up from the airport

This potentially has some truth to it. Many times, to operate a passenger service to/from the airport requires the operator to purchase a (costly) license from the airport authority. Depending on bylaws etc, unlicensed operators who provide passenger service to/from the airport will be subject to fines. In other words, providing access to ground-transport operators seems to be a revenue stream for the airport, but also likely serves to protect the air passengers from cowboy/dodgy transport operators outside the terminal.

Anecdotally, I once struck up a conversation with a taxi driver in Sydney, Australia. We'd passed a pedestrian who (for some reason) was standing on airport land, some distance from the terminals, trying to hail the passing taxis. The driver remarked to me that they'd be waiting for a while, as no taxi would ever stop there: Apparently it is stipulated in the contract that the taxi company has with the airport, that they can only collect and drop fares in the designated areas outside of the terminals. If they pick up a fare at any other location on airport land, they are subject to large fines (he said $10k, but perhaps this was hyperbole). I found this an interesting insight into the level of regulation apparently applied to airport ground-transport operators.

jamestnz··on Bitcoin breaks $200
I experienced similar frustration when trying to buy bitcoins. I ended up using localbitcoins.com, and had an excellent experience.

The site matches up private users (by geographic location by default) wishing to buy bitcoins with those wishing to sell. It offers "feedback" ratings for traders, and an escrow system where the site confirms your coins have been sent to it and placed in reserve, and these get released to you once the seller confirms receipt of your funds, either by texting a code from their phone or by using the website. There were no onerous fees, and my entire trade was completed within hours. Typical trading methods would include internet bank transfer (which is what I did), or even meeting in person with cash (riskier but more anonymous I guess).

>Also someone explain to me how that is anonymous when they have all my information if I had uploaded my driver's license and my bank account information.

Nobody claimed it was anonymous. And companies acting as "money transmitters" (or who the feds decide to consider as such) have a bunch of AML/KYC regulations they are required to follow, hence the whole ID thing. You can enhance the anonymity of your coins in various ways, typically by services which chop them up and shuffle them between many addresses to obfuscate their trail in the blockchain (so-called "mixers").

>And this fluctuating price isn't very impressive either

What concerns you about it? For many people I guess the short-term fluctuations aren't such an issue (e.g. those playing the long game with their bitcoin investment; or those only holding coins for a short time to make a specific purchase, particularly where the sales platform offers a hedging feature like Silk Road apparently did).

jamestnz··on Mozilla's New Fira Typeface
>is there a typographic standard for labeling typefaces italics and oblique

As I recall it, oblique type uses the regular glyphs just slanted, whereas a 'true' italic typeface employs modified glyph versions having additional calligraphy- or cursive-like flourishes.

In the following picture I've just made using Arial and Times, both fonts are claiming an 'italic' version. The Times one really is italic by the above definition, while the Arial one is 'oblique'.

http://imgur.com/UVUZb5F

jamestnz··on Big buttons are great, but they'd better make sense
>UI's _need_ discoverability and plane cockpits do not

Interestingly enough, Boeing has a world-class ergonomics research/implementation department focusing on solving problems just like this within the cockpit.

You see, it turns out that pilots were occasionally activating the switch for Undercarriage when they meant to activate the Flaps switch, because the switches were near each other on the console and they looked identical. This despite the switches being clearly labeled, and despite the intensive training that pilots undergo. Apparently this was enough of a problem that a habit developed amongst some pilots, of sticking a tiny paper cup over the Undercarrige switch shortly after each takeoff (the kind of tiny paper cup that they serve you your tiny cup of water in).

The Boeing folks were tasked with this issue, researched likely causes and tested potential solutions, and (IIRC) came up with the idea of physically/visually distinguishing the switches, and furthermore to actually design each switch to be visually reminiscent of the feature it controls.

(Hopefully I related this story correctly, it comes from a textbook-level source I read ages ago).

jamestnz··on Big buttons are great, but they'd better make sense
That's a fair point. And just to clarify (since you mentioned "instructions"), my references to MC above were referring just to the colored circular non-buttons discussed in the OP, and not to the "A quick primer" and "Need help with your first campaign?" instructions (which I'm assuming are always there, and are unrelated to the non-buttons… I guess it would be nice if users could dismiss these newbie instructions once they've become experienced with the site).

But if these large circular non-buttons are to remain a permanent fixture on the MC Dashboard (rather than just a temporary "look, here are our new features" exercise), I still wonder why I'd want it to jiggle the blue pointer as if to say "Oh there's the place you SHOULD have clicked just now", when it could actually just take me to my obviously-desired destination immediately. That destination page would then become active on the navbar, presumably with some kind of visual indication that it is now the active one ("presumably" because I'm just speaking extemporaneously here, I haven't used MC in ages)... so the attentive user will have learned a second way to reach their desired feature (as in, "I clicked the big round button and it took me straight to the place I was expecting, and the 'Lists' item on the navbar has become active").

Then you've provided two different ways to get to the desired feature in a single click (each method reasonable in and of itself), rather than providing one direct method (the navbar), plus an indirect method that attempts to retrain the user to click somewhere else instead.

jamestnz··on Big buttons are great, but they'd better make sense
Such 'instruction buttons' and other notices/signs sprinkled through the UI can be an indicator of bad design, an insufficient consideration of 'affordances'[1].

Which is to say, a good user interface (and not just software, but anyplace human/device interaction occurs) should probably be as intuitive/discoverable as possible, featuring behaviours which can be inferred/suspected from an element's inherent properties (e.g.: in an aircraft cockpit, make the "flaps" switch resemble a flap), from the user's general experience in other contexts (an on-screen control that looks like a "button" should act like a "button"), or which preclude incorrect actions entirely (on a door which only swings open in one direction, install a flat plate on the "push" side and a pullable handle on the "pull" side, so the incorrect choice becomes impossible, and no signs are even needed). Putting actual instructional labels onto interface elements, whether in software (e.g. using words "Click here to..." in the text of a hyperlink) or in real life with the push/pull signs, is oftentimes a cop-out in lieu of a more thoughtful/obvious design.

In computer software interfaces (particularly web apps), I would suggest that a large, prominent, colored circle with a gloss effect and an action written/iconized on it, has the affordance of carrying out that action immediately when clicked (for some value of "immediately") -- i.e. being a button.

If substantial UI changes have taken place within an app that already has a customer base, I agree it may be valuable to bring these to the attention of the users. But a highlighted notification box appearing at the top of the app's regular UI screens, which persists until the user reads and dismisses it, is widely used -- rather than sprinkling "push" and "pull" signs around a wrongly-conceived interface[2].

Even the venerable "tool-tip" (aka HTML "title" attribute) seems often overused, becoming a crutch to support a mystery-meat navigation[3] philosophy which requires users to hover and wait to figure out what the hell _anything_ does.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordance

[2] I'm not suggesting that the MC UI itself is wrongly-conceived or even particularly bad, just continuing with my general point.

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mystery_meat_navigation

[n] The examples about cockpit design and push/pull doors come from actual published studies in ergonomics. I do not have the resources available at the moment to cite them further.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →