HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jamiecurle

357 karma · joined March 19, 2011

submissionscomments
jamiecurle··on The Beauty of Bonsai Styles
As well as a software person I'm an arborist as a side hustle. I love bonsai and I have started a few off myself in my garden (technically this makes them 'niwaki' - in garden, rather than 'bonsai' - in a pot. I went with scots pine (Pinus sylvestris, Wych Elm - Ulnus glabra and Quercus robur - english oak) as they're all native to where I live.

But I am somewhat conflicted because as awesome as they look, all that aesthetic comes from doing the exact opposite of what a tree needs. Deliberate wounding at non-meristematic sites to create deadwood, binding roots into and using wires to manipulate the structure and keeping the tree at a juvenile isolated state. Basically it would make Alex Shigo shudder in his grave.

That being said, if anyone is in their twenties and looking for a nice future hustle pension, then start off some bonsais today. In forty years, if you can keep them going, with a hundred or so you could be sitting on 300K plus of stock. The trees will teach you a lot (notwithstanding the above sentiment on treating them brutally) in terms of patience, planning and delight in aesthetic.

jamiecurle··on Apple Business
MacOS used to be excellent for a short period of time when Fleetsmith existed. Then Apple purchased Fleetsmith around 2020 and killed the product not long after.

Fortunately around the same time, JamF ended the practice of the mandatory Jamf JumpStart (£5K fee), which finally made Jamf a feasible option for the company I was in at the time.

jamiecurle··on Apple Business
yes, that's exactly how it happens.
jamiecurle··on Ask HN: What breaks first when your team grows from 10 to 50 people?
Not everyone is great at the level above and even if they are, sometimes it is not always a good fit for them. I've had more a good few engineers ask to go backwards when they've been promoted - each for their own reasons but nearly always around the theme of being in a position of leadership / seniority.
jamiecurle··on I'm reluctant to verify my identity or age for any online services
technically, it's the ePrivacy directive. GDPR requires the consent to process personal data and governs the data but the ePrivacy directive is the instrument that requires that god-damn-please-make-it-stop-banner.
jamiecurle··on GitHub is down again
I waited 2.5 hours for a webhook from the registry_packages endpoint today.

I'm grateful it arrived, but two and half hours feels less than ideal.

jamiecurle··on How to carry more than your own bodyweight (2025)
I wasn't in construction but I did spend three years working as an arborist / forester between 2022 and 2025 whilst taking a little break from tech after a long 20-year stint. I've been in good shape since I was 30 with strength training, cardio and even a little stint as a masters level competitive olympic weightlifter. A long way of saying, I know my body fairly well.

Two years into climbing trees in domestic settings and hand cutting in timber plantations, even three days a week and my body was hammered. Now maybe that's because I was in the 46–50 year old range, but it was clear it wasn't a viable long-term strategy for me. Speaking about the people I now know in that industry, it's commonplace for "climbers" to be done by their mid-thirties. Shoulders all mashed up from climbing and carrying heavy loads. It's not pretty.

On the positive side and injuries notwithstanding (I did get a shoulder issue just like everyone else) my bodyweight dropped 10kg and I did look (and feel) much nimbler. The core of the problem in this kind of work is that when the rubber hits the road "getting the job done" always comes before "correct techniques for doing X". And there's no liability claim to be had as at the start of each job you sign the risk assessment which states that you will get it done in a health-and-safety-compliant way. If you don't sign, you're not on the crew the next day and you're walking home from site. This is basically how it is in the UK for these kinds of jobs where salaries are between £24–34K annually.

jamiecurle··on Sinclair C5
That cane was no fun. It was around for one year when I was in juniors before it got banned. I can remember as clear as the day at the start of September us new boys were taken into the toilet by the headmaster (lovely guy actually) and given a demonstration of what waited for us should we mis-behave. Pink Floyd's "The Wall" was in the charts and it was a perfect experience of 1980s english schooling.
jamiecurle··on How wolves became dogs
They do it a lot. My garden backs onto a public woodland and I can confirm it happens. Last summer when I tidied up out the back of my house, I found at least five years worth of buried dog turds in bags. Cleaning it up was not fun. I used a backpack blower to blow it all into line of "turd shame" away from the houses.

It looks a lot nicer out there now and I gave the trees a little prune (I'm a qualified arborist) so people know this is a "tidy area" and so far no more turds in bags.

jamiecurle··on Privacy doesn't mean anything anymore, anonymity does
Specific to the UK, there's a list of enforcement actions that the Information Commissioners Office (ICO) have taken:

https://ico.org.uk/action-weve-taken/enforcement/

Some went to prison, some were fined £14M and it's a mixture of small fry and big fry.

jamiecurle··on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws
If you're under UK law the ICO guidance on "pay to reject" can be found here: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-re...
jamiecurle··on You will own nothing and be (un)happy
Copyright and performance rights are two separate things. It's completely fine for me to go and perform (not record - that does need a license) the latest hit song until my heart is content.
jamiecurle··on Eating stinging nettles
yes by "shop" I did mean the place in Blagdon, Northumberland. I live right next to it two small towns down.
jamiecurle··on Eating stinging nettles
I live about five minutes by car from that shop. Weird when that happens on HN.
jamiecurle··on Amazon’s Ring to partner with Flock
Same here, only I used Hikvision PoE cameras.

If I had of had a webcam on my front door a few weeks ago I would have been able to identify the thieves that broke into my car and stole a bunch of stuff whilst I was asleep.

Since then I have "cammed" up, but I use my own hard wired network and connected to a Pi5 with a Hailo8 chip running frigate.

No third party apps, just the fun of more stuff on the network. I do run a Cloudflare tunnel on the PI so that I can connect to Frigate from anywhere when I get alerts.

But basically, it's me and only me accessing the content of those cameras. However I do plan to configure Frigate to upload the alerts and detections into S3 with a three month lifecycle.

jamiecurle··on Why I Chose Elixir Phoenix over Rails, Laravel, and Next.js
I think what the blog post is getting is OTP and the mystical/but not mystical GenServer / Supervisor/ distributed pattern. It's baked right in there as a core part of the Erlang VM. I think the post glances over the fact that in rails land solid queue may be right there to use (I've not really used rails in over 10 years).

Thing is with Elixir though, yes the tools are right there, but you do have to take time to understand them. I've been on and off with Elixir since 2016 and I'm currently wrapping up on a fairly complex elixir project with zero UI. (connecting Shopify GraphQL to a series of 3rd party fulfilment providers who use SFTP (gross). So yes, GenServer, Supervisor etc are all right there as first class citizens, but whilst they are relatively simple to start using, you can end up with some horrifically structured code that would have been much better written without the distributed stuff.

Personally, I prefer Django. Been using it since 2006 and as a person who started off in design but ended up as an engineer, nothing beats Django's template engine (braces for incoming). Django isn't perfect but nothing is. When I have to get something done quick and there's UI work for me to do, I go to Django. When performance or no UI, I go elixir. If someone else is doing the UI, I go phoenix.

jamiecurle··on California enacts law enabling people to universally opt out of data sharing
I don't get this. Many years ago there was "Do not track", a header that was sent based on browser configuration. As a data subject, I loved it. As an engineer I also loved it - it was easy. If the header was present don't render any tracking code. If all services acted in good faith, it could have been epic. But there was pushback, and it went away. Sadface.

For what it's worth I think the browser is the right place for tools like this. If the same thing could have been applied to cookies, we'd not be experience cookie-preference-popupageddon.

The article suggests browser vendors are somehow on the hook for implementing "do not sell". Is the idea the same as do not track?

jamiecurle··on The least amount of CSS for a decent looking site (2023)
> Could you recommend any good books

The Elements Of Typographic Style by Robert Bringhurst

"Five minutes to learn, a lifetime to master" kind of thing.

jamiecurle··on The Mondrian introduction to functional optics
Man I'd like to hang out. No one I know is a Mondrian nerd. I love all his work and have a few replicas hanging around my home.
jamiecurle··on The Mondrian introduction to functional optics
Authenticity nitpick: during this period where Mondrian produced geometrical works, he was emerging from theosophy as a primary influence towards universal truths. A key part of this was never using green. It's my pet peeve when people cite Mondrian based on geometry and then use green.

This is why I don't get invited to many places.

jamiecurle··on Zürich voters ban noisy leaf blowers
Maybe if you're just doing your own back garden and it's just leaf matter. But for professional arborists / municipal arboricultural teams, a leaf blower - specifically a backpack blower (battery / alkalyte | petrol) speeds up clean up by orders of magnitude.

I could understand the ban for residential use, fine - I agree just using a rake if it is just leaves, but for tree work / hedge work where the owner expects "tidy" as one of the things they see at the end of the job they're essential. Without then It'd mean an extra couple of hours on every job, which means less jobs, which means higher costs. The fine chips, the hedge cuttings and the tiny snapped twigs they take ages to clear up. Especially on gravel or grass. Fast moving air is the perfect tool for cleaning up this stuff on all surfaces.

All that being said, it is actually better to leave material for habitat and detritivores. It's really valuable, so in that regard it may force peoples hands in "accepting the mess" or as I like to say "the reconfigured habitat".

It'll boil down to "the cost", "the mess" or "the noise".

context: I'm an arborist as well as a software engineer.

jamiecurle··on Sora 2
Fun.
jamiecurle··on My game's server is blocked in Spain whenever there's a football match on
The escape hatch with all personal data processing is "legitimate interest". Consent is a big part of it, but an industry with sufficiently deep legal pockets would likely go down the route of "legitimate interest" if cornered.

I'm not a legal professional. I just work next to this stuff.

jamiecurle··on How to Lead in a Room Full of Experts
I love the phrase "It's because that's why". For anyone interested in this kind of subject I've benefited a lot from Vanessa Van Edwards books which essentially boil down to signalling warmth and competence in the right ways for a given context. Of course, it's a giant field and no one person has all the answers, but for me it's yielded some wins.
jamiecurle··on Rights groups urge UK PM Starmer to abandon plans for mandatory digital ID
I don’t want this, but I don’t really see a future where it isn’t a thing. One group of people are right to point out the scope for abuse and control of a population, and another are correct that we already have multiple forms of digital ID in the shape of driving licenses, national insurance numbers, and passports. At this point, I view it as a thing we have to navigate as a society and get to the other side of. If I have any energy at all to fight anything related to this, I’m saving it for after the implementation because, as I said at the start of this post, I view it as inevitable. Luckily for us, though, through total coincidence, we’re now going to have massive AI data centres to help us with this brave new digital identity.
jamiecurle··on American Prairie unlocks another 70k acres in Montana
Same in the UK - it is called the Occupiers Liability Act. It's not black and white but the liability is on the Occupier. I know this because I own an area of ancient semi-natural woodland which I'm restoring back to the natural NVC type (basically, oak standards and hazel coppice). As part of my duty I have to go and survey all the boundary trees once every "reasonable period" and after storms or significant weather events. There's some nuance to in the liability I've got when considering the harm to trespassers, but staying on top of duties and having your auditing ducks in a row helps.
jamiecurle··on Excalidraw+ Is Now SoC 2 Certified
Organisations need to ensure that doing business with you isn't over their risk threshold. One of the areas they focus on is security (cyber, info and physical and perhaps soon AI). In order to determine this they ask you a bunch of questions in which you insert answers and evidence into a spreadsheet, sometimes an online app. These are "the questionnaires". They're also pretty expensive[0]

Having a SOC 2 attestation or certified IS027001 compliance of your Information Security Management System allows you to do business with "less friction" because you can often shortcut some / all portions of those questionnaires.

But you can never get rid of them.

[0]: https://sharedassessments.org/sig/

jamiecurle··on Estimates of plant CO2 uptake rise by nearly one third
It depends. For forestry stock there's no real way to avoid monoculture if you need a lot and you need it soon (40-60 years). There's much more to this answer though because Phytopthora is hammering larch, Ips is hammering spruce and red band needle blight is hammering pines. That's another topic on itself. Broadly though, there's nothing wrong with a monoculture per-se ([Pando][1], Boreal woodland) it just depends on how it is managed and how well the ecology does in response to it.

That being said, personally, I favour the continuous cover approach of mixing up natives broadleaves with non-native conifers as long as the site isn't ancient or semi-ancient natural woodland (ASNW) or plantation on ancient woodland site (PAWS). For those sites, they're too important for use as a commercial forestry site and arguably the ecology needs to be restored, maintained and managed. Those sites are precious and should be managed properly in-line with their identified [NVC identifier][2]. The one exception to this is coppicing. Having a coppice on ancient sites where coppicing was practised is one of the few woodland management techniques that adds to ecology over all four woodland layers over all time frames.

I never thought I'd answer that question on HN. I appreciate you asking. What's your take on forestry monocultures?

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pando_(tree) [2]: https://jncc.gov.uk/our-work/nvc/

jamiecurle··on Estimates of plant CO2 uptake rise by nearly one third
At least in the UK woodland cover is increasing. It was 3% back in 1900~ and today it stands at about [13%][0]. The aim in the UK is to be at 15% woodland and tree coverage by 2050 – quite achievable.

I currently teach woodland management and arboriculture (I also run a weird hybrid business doing software and arboriculture) in the UK and the idea that we cut down more than we plant is a common misconception that I spend a lot of time (and I mean a lot of time) correcting with the public and general layperson. Felling trees for forestry purposes requires a felling license[1], which always comes with a re-stocking clause.

As for urban green infrastructure (basically private and municipal trees and hedges), that comes with it's own issues, and there's a lot of wins to be had there but there are also lots of challenges. I know the Arboricultural Association in the UK are doing some great work here to advocate for finding ways to retain private and municipal trees whilst managing risk to the public (the main reason trees are normally removed second only to "aesthetic").

Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) is also a thing in the UK which broadly translates to ensuring that any private building works or developments must now have a demonstrable positive effect on local biodiversity and where that's not possible, then developers can "offset" by commissioning biodiversity projects elsewhere. For example, I've just taken delivery of 1200 trees (oak, hazel) today, which will be planted into semi-ancient woodland that I manage.

So basically the idea that we're cutting down forest ahead of what can restock isn't accurate, in fact in the UK at least, it is quite the opposite.

A good news story for you.

[0]: https://www.forestresearch.gov.uk/tools-and-resources/statis....

[1]: unless it is a) less than five cubic metres in a twelve week period (basically "thinning" woodland so that other trees have room to grow / habitat improvement for priority habitats). b) a private tree without a preservation order/ fruit tree, c) diseased or dying or d) a suitably high risk to public safety.

jamiecurle··on UK's Online Safety Act comes into force
Yes.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →