HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jampekka

5,131 karma · joined August 1, 2016

hn@jampekka.org
submissionscomments
jampekka··on How do we prevent mathemathics from devolving into the Medieval Era of secrecy?
Or if you are afraid of scooping, just don't use public LLMs? At universities, apart from admin stuff, nobody will tell you what you must or musn't use.

And I really doubt university ITs would be able to run these, at least in an up to date and stable manner. High performance computing is typically run totally separately from everyday user systems, and tend to be extremely painful to use (hello slurm!).

jampekka··on Xiaomi Mimo 2.6 live post-training dashboard
That China's official policy is now to prefer open models and open model development may be a part of it.
jampekka··on Xiaomi Mimo 2.6 live post-training dashboard
Kinda yes. The benchmarks become part of the validation set, which means the models get slightly overfit to them if they are used as criteria for stopping the training. But a lot less compared to using them in the training data.

I'd guess everybody uses at least some benchmarks as stopping criteria, which is kinda sensible, but it also does induce some benchmaxxing, and explains partly why the newest models always tend to eke out in benchmarks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Training,_validation,_and_test...

jampekka··on Claude Cowork and chat are now one Claude
> It's barely coherent nonsense. Lots of irrelevant details, buzz words, wrong charts or confusing phrasing. Obviously LLM output.

Plenty of that even before LLMs too though.

jampekka··on Doing Everyone Else's Job
Easier said than done. Saying no is not so easy. There's a bit of a weird dynamic that if you could do something that others need help with, saying no can be considered rude, but saying (even if lying) that you don't know how to do it is generally accepted. Usually a boss (or even a colleague) backing in saying no helps a lot.

Also the helping can cause escalation of "demand". First you help with something quick and easy for you, but soon you find "owning" more and more of the task.

It's not dissimilar from the entitled people in open source project bug trackers.

jampekka··on Don't be the out of touch Kung Fu master
Djikstra seemed to manage?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edsger_W._Dijkstra#Use_of_tech...

jampekka··on Anthropic researcher believes more than 10% chance AI 'could kill all humans'
Sad that there's the obvious regulatory capture angle encouraging motivated reasoning about AI risks and how they should be tackled. Maybe it's not the best idea that potentially civilization destroying technology is developed to maximize shareholder value?

It's not unlike if nuclear weapons was a profit and deployment maximizing enterprise, at least if one takes Anthropic et al cautions seriously.

jampekka··on On the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem
Thousands of some of the brightest minds have worked on this problem for over a century. The million bucks is not the big deal here.
jampekka··on On the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem
> WOW

This.

I do dislike the AI oligarchs as much as the next person, but I do find the thread full of complaining a bit depressing still.

If the result holds (and it looks it does), this may be one of the, if not the, biggest things to happen in computing to date. A lot bigger than e.g. Deep Blue beating Kasparov in chess or AlphaGo beating Sedol in Go.

jampekka··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
Not in the past I guess?
jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
I'm not much of an artist, but I'd guess trying to paint a painting of how quicksort works, in a way someone else can grasp it too, can need a lot more reconceptualization than writing a description about it. Doing plots or diagrams, or even implementing an algorithm, for sure often need more thinking than writing a description.
jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
With the last line I tried to condense (and oversimplify) about these ideas:

Not all writing is thinking: That all, even a lot, of writing, or parts of writing, is such that it will develop one's thinking much. For example most stuff I have to write, the dozen emails a day, the funding application boilerplates, the reports are stuff that don't really need (or deserve) much thinking but they have to get written. And even in the writing that deserves attention, there is stuff like grammar and spelling and surface style that usually take quite a bit of time after the ideas have been written down already.

Not all thinking is writing: for many cases writing is not a particularly efficient way to develop one's thinking, and e.g. visualizations, math, coding, discussions etc can be a lot better.

jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
This is an example of the problem. I did choose to write it in the way that although I knew it can be interpreted trivially, if the reader assumes I'm an imbecile. It was a "punchy" recap of the relatively long explanation for a HN comment and hopefully decently argued point.
jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open (2025)
I did think about this while writing, and I made the compromise to accept that someone will nitpick about it to hopefully drive the point better for those willing to read it charitably.

QED?

jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
Sure, but doing an interpretative dance or an abstract painting can make you reconceptualize the whole concept too. But we're not really pushing those tools as much as writing.

Take for example a non-native writer of the language. I'm sure having to check up words from a dictionary may help to reconceptualize things, but I'm sure also that it's not often very efficient. And I think similar is going on for natives too for many types of writing.

jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
> LLMs write better than most journalists.

I used to think this, but now that I've been trying to use them to help with writing, it turns out they are not necessarily that great on the deeper level. The grammar and the surface style are impeccable, but they often struggle with continuity and carrying on a point or an argument.

jampekka··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
> Writing is thinking. Thinking and deciding. There have been many times when I start out writing something substantial - could be an email, a blog post, a software design document, anything - when my own views substantially changed during the writing process. Writing forces you to serialize your thoughts - and you can't always trust the gestalt.

I don't disagree, but I think it's often not appreciated how much there's other work to writing too.

The biggest one is that you have to communicate non-interactively to an unknown audience. Having to (literally) put it in someone else's assumed terms does help giving different perspectives into the matter, but doesn't necessarily help one's own thinking that much. Instead you have to do some of the reader's thinking for them.

You also have to spend time on textual matters like grammar and style and a lot of "unspoken rules", which aren't really about linearizing your thinking about the contents.

Not all writing is thinking and not all thinking is writing.

jampekka··on Watch the 'Eclipse of the Century' Next Year When Spain, Egypt and More Go Dark
Some ISPs in Finland have blocked it from resolving for copyright issues, but even if you get it to resolve by changing DNS servers, it goes into a Cloudlare CAPTCHA loop. I assume it's still about the spat with a Finnish blogger.
jampekka··on GPT-6 Astra on robot arms
Plenty of delivery robots in Finland at least, with apparently not much problems with them getting stolen or destroyed.

Starship alone seems to have running operations also in UK, Sweden, Estonia and Czhecia.

jampekka··on Watch the 'Eclipse of the Century' Next Year When Spain, Egypt and More Go Dark
For us banned by archive.is: https://unwall.app/www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/travel/solar-e...
jampekka··on How Fairphone built the Fairphone Gen 6+
Seems you have to compromise on HW openness and ethics vs paranoia.
jampekka··on How an MIT research project became the Julia programming language
Also the module/import system is still quite painful/hacky. Which is partly due to the long compile times.

https://docs.julialang.org/en/v1.13-dev/manual/workflow-tips...

jampekka··on Claude Fable 5.1 and Claude Mythos 5.1
It manipulates the PRNG seed in a systematic way, keeping the same token sampling distribution.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-08025-4

jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
1) is not a problem. This is actually already defined technology neutrally in GDPR: "the data subject may exercise his or her right to object by automated means using technical specifications". For specific implementations the law can defer to e.g. standards, as is also very common in legislation.

In general defining laws technology neutrally is bread and butter of legislation, there are just a lot of misconceptions that laws are about specific techniques.

2) you can easily make a non-intrusive UI for that.

jampekka··on Corporate profits hit highest share since WWII, as worker payouts wilt
They banned all of Finland, presumably due to a spat with a Finnish blogger, although the story seems a bit murky.

https://lobste.rs/s/z0mdor/archive_today_is_directing_ddos_a...

jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
Lack of do-not-track header is not a consent to track of course. It's just signaling non-consent.
jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
I don't understand why this was downvoted. It's informative and factual.
jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
The law is not about cookies specifically, it's technology neutral. The law doesn't even include the word cookie anywhere.

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A...

jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
The ePrivacy directive did/does not require the nag for "necessary cookies", i.e. most of the cookies that are serving the user's interests.
jampekka··on You Know GDPR Is Good Based on Who Hates It
GDPR itself is quite a good law. It's implementation and enforcement are not.

E.g. the nag problem would have been solved simply and effectively with something like do-not-track header (probably as OS setting, as apps are often even worse than websites with tracking). Also enforcement of obvious violations taking years and years, especially against large corporations, means it's just violated all the time.

EU also failed to give good interpretation guidelines early on, causing massive piles of overjealous lawyer CYA red tape and just silly stuff like removing names from apartment buzzers.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →