HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

janardanyri

263 karma · joined January 24, 2012

submissionscomments
janardanyri··on You’re paying too much to get a little more space on your iPad and iPhone
It's a healthy dash of guilt by association; these iSuppli reports unfortunately lend themselves to sloppy reporting. This article is a typically wonderful specimen, which crosses lines freely with nonsense sentences like these:

"On the high-end Wi-Fi model, which offers you 64GB of space for $699, Apple’s non-manufacturing profit margin shoots up to 48 percent."

As though you get to handwave away non-manufacturing costs and then call it a "non-manufacturing profit margin."

janardanyri··on Lying with pictures: Smartphone manufacturer share by OS
Headline cleverness is a zero sum game. I'd rather have drier titles instead of a psychological hacking competition, and scan for content quality (as loosely indicated by upvotes) and subject relevancy.
janardanyri··on Why Russia Locks Up So Many Entrepreneurs
There's a huge, huge difference between:

a) a system in which paying a third party to spend their life understanding that system aids in better navigation of that system

versus

b) a system in which you must pay representatives of the system in order to engage with the system.

Yes, in both situations, more resources will get you better results, but process matters. System A is a whole lot closer to redemption than System B.

janardanyri··on Jean-Louis Gassée: Nokia should fire Elop and the board should go too
'Whom' is a relic of formal and archaic English. You might as well fight the singular 'they' or ending sentences with prepositions.

As per Skitt's Law, you might want to watch your sentence fragments and run-ons. ;)

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_%28pronoun%29#Demise_of_wh...

janardanyri··on SSDs cost half of what they did in 2011
Apple charges way more than market rate for storage and memory upgrades. A stick of memory that costs $40 on Newegg might cost $200 from Apple.

In the past the sensible option was to buy a Macbook with stock memory / storage and upgrade it yourself, but of course that's no longer possible with the rMBP. Still, that says no more about the actual cost of SSDs than the price of a hotel room says about beds. :)

janardanyri··on If you're not going to become a professor, then why bother pursuing a Ph.D.?
This is very cool. I love to see the general trend of bigger and more expensive science being bucked here.

In general, though, we're still chasing the long tail of knowledge. Nobody's going to build a cutting-edge particle collider, space probe, or Inca ruin in their spare time.

Arguably microbiology is a lot more like computer science than other experimental sciences economically, at least in certain respects; for example, once you've got something interesting, you can probably execute a fairly cheap reproductive process and get a whole bunch more of it. (Well, this is cheap compared to reproducing a particle collider, at least.)

Fun to think about.

janardanyri··on Nexus 7, Made for Google Play
No, the original iPad was 16/32/64GB, just like the current one. That's why there is no gnashing of teeth. (I have a 64GB original iPad and never have hurt for space.)
janardanyri··on Where has all the money in the world gone?
I'm severely distrustful of those stats and the zeal that surrounds them, generally long on ideology and short on rationale.

Let's poke at it a bit. Does "long-term discouraged worker" mean that if someone works for a few years in their 20s, experiences some obstacles in pursing their preferred career, and decides stay-at-home parenting is more to their liking anyway, are they now permanently "unemployed?" How do we recognize the difference between a detached person who's taken up sculpting and a desperate person living at wit's end?

Do you count as a "long-term discouraged academic" if you once made strides toward pursuing an academic career but strayed into industry? Do we have an economic crisis in the professional sports sector because millions of aspirants are being trained but over 90% of them ultimately can't find jobs playing baseball?

There may be some value in exploring how we define employment, but categorically calling those stats "real" and other stats "manipulated" trips my tinfoil detector, especially since I never see actual economists referencing this data.

janardanyri··on Larry Page is 'Speechless' now
Oh, there's a fair bit of meta-information on the current state of Wall Street reporting and analysis. :-)
janardanyri··on How LinkedIn betrayed a 5-man startup
> But what about all of those software businesses that have built on top of the iOS API + App Store? Would you say that they are also taking a massive risk?

Yes. Very yes. Any iOS developer with any sense is brutally aware that we serve at the pleasure of the king, as Jeff Atwood put it. Apple nurtures its developer community because a robust app store is a selling point for Apple hardware. If Apple decides your app runs contrary to Apple's goals, it's gone, and you better have a backup plan. There've been plenty of panicked anecdotes floating around the Internet on that topic. The grandparent's analysis is sound.

(Also: thousands of independent developers are building profitable businesses on iOS, but tens of thousands aren't.)

janardanyri··on Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide'
A group of terrorists lucked into taking down two big buildings and so we have to debate whether we can afford civil liberties? The premise should be self-evidently absurd.

If we'll kill thousands of Arabs to protect freedom, we shouldn't be so eager to walk away from it for the death of a few thousand Americans.

I would also suggest that abandoning principle for expediency can be hobbling in itself. Wars aren't entirely fought by robots just yet. "Power" isn't a column in an Excel spreadsheet.

janardanyri··on Microsoft Introduces Second-Screen Feature, Xbox SmartGlass
Variations on this line of commentary have been passed around for over a decade. 'Commoditization' of Nintendo hardware is almost irrelevant; no hardware innovation has gone uncopied for long. The core selling point for Nintendo hardware has always been Nintendo software.
janardanyri··on Windows 8 tablet PC makers: We can't compete with the iPad's price
"position" "sell" "say"

The trouble isn't the branding, it's the building. The iPad is recognized as a quality product because it delivers quality experiences.

Microsoft has rightly acquired a reputation for brittle products that will slowly break down in ways you don't know how to fix. "Microsoft" means worrying about obscure error messages, malware, backups, defrag, task management, ad nauseam.

They've made solid incremental efforts with Windows releases, and Windows Phone 7 may well have eliminated all of these experience issues. Trouble is, Apple has now all but eliminated these problems across the entire product line, and they've even solved the meta-problem of tackling the remaining problems through their world-class retail and support presence.

A solid product in isolation doesn't cut it at this point. The competition has a solid complete ecosystem. Amateur hour is truly over.

janardanyri··on How to be a Programmer: A Short, Comprehensive, and Personal Summary
This is short by the standard of well-considered material of durable merit warranting serious reflection.

It's not short by the standard of contemporary consumable Internet content, which is to be expected, as most of that content is not designed to enlighten. It's designed to catch your attention long enough to tell you about a brand, whether corporate (advertising) or personal (blogging).

And at any rate, serious writing implicitly asks for an investment of time in contemplation above and beyond line scan time, so its 'reading time' is only loosely coupled to the apparent length of the material. Making that investment increases the payoff, it doesn't dilute it. "You get out of it what you put into it."

If content consumption time is directly linearly related to content length, that's a pretty good flag that you're probably not getting much real value out of it. I've found low value content to be a difficult honeypot to resist even on HN, which is comparatively a pretty high-quality aggregator.

This is one of the best HN submissions I've ever seen. Given its due respect, it could change lives.

janardanyri··on The Future of Science
I did just enough academic research to discover that real progress could be more effectively pursued elsewhere. I would love to explore this; janardan.yri at me.com.
janardanyri··on Zerg Rush Google Easter Egg
Humans are not robots. Squishy human elements like motivation, attitude, camaraderie, and "fun" have material productivity consequences, especially in cognition-driven fields like software.

"Quality dev hours" are not a fungible resource. In fact, they're so un-fungible that we commonly accept that beyond a certain point the value of a dev hour is negative. Maybe time spent on these projects invigorates engineers to do better work in the rest of their work hours? Maybe not. But the issue is more subtle than you're giving it credit for.

Plus... well... THIS particular simple throwaway Easter egg is what bothers you? You know there are several multi-billion-dollar industries that employ smart people in creating "fun" ways for people to unproductively spend their time, right?

janardanyri··on Mac OS X 10.8 restricted to App Store, signed apps by default
The headline is fairly misleading, and the article sloppily mixes actual fact with predictions stated as fact.

The reality: 10.8 by default only runs apps which were either downloaded from the App Store, with the iOS-style sandboxing that will require, or signed with Apple's new GateKeeper service, and otherwise a traditional Mac app.

Those who condemn this as a flagrant loss of freedom are lost in the philosophical weeds. The conventional wisdom before the iPhone was that native apps were all but dead anyway, and the browser was the future. The iPhone's App Store and attendant restrictions singlehandedly revived the concept of consumers installing software. Meanwhile, the Mac is gaining enough market share that it's now clearly a target for malware. Code signing is about as open as you can get while still tamping down nasty code (and let me stress again that GateKeeper is way more freeform than anything on iOS).

If there are alternate solutions to these issues, it would be fascinating to hear them. Otherwise, well, it's easy to criticize from the bleachers.

janardanyri··on Poll: What is your primary operating system
Don't misread me as a visionless hack. I would never discourage dreaming. My point was not that you are thinking too big, but rather exactly the opposite: that the FSF so often gets caught up in trivial distractions.

"Suck it up" does not mean "accept defeat," it means to accept the blows that come with contesting the arena of ideas, and get serious about effectively pursuing your mission. You don't get to just pretend the arena of ideas doesn't exist.

Free software is an ideology, and as an ideology it badly needs a prophet, someone who can inspire reverence for the cause the way that Carl Sagan or Neil deGrasse Tyson can inspire reverence for science.

rms is wasting his influence. Just look at the primary GNU Project About page; it's a disaster of anxious dissembling, fussing over terminology, scolding people who only 95% agree with him, and taking pages and paaaaages to do it. That is not how you lead.

"If you want to build a ship, don't drum up the men to gather wood, divide the work and give orders. Instead, teach them to yearn for the vast and endless sea."

When the FSF has a message other than "the waves are choppy and all the boats are unsound so you better stay close to shore," maybe they'll find that people start listening.

janardanyri··on Poll: What is your primary operating system
This IS clear to everyone; it's simply irrelevant. Life's not fair. We all have to deal with unfair problems. Emphasizing the unfairness of your problems only makes the FSF look less "idealistic as in principled" and more "idealistic as in naive."

Relatedly, your most critical problem is not external, it's that the FSF is now associated more closely with non-issues like "GNU/Linux" nomenclature than solving serious problems.

Suck it up, grit your teeth, and press on. That's what it takes to be successful in just about any field of life. Anything else ends with you sitting on the sidelines, impotently complaining about how unfair it all is and how bad all the successful organizations are.

janardanyri··on Sqrt(x*x+y*y)+3*cos(sqrt(x*x+y*y))+5 from -20 to 20
Word of caution: I left this open in a Safari tab without thinking about it, and soon found that my Mac's UI was hanging for ~20 seconds every minute or two. Took me half an hour to figure out what was going on.
janardanyri··on This American Life Retracting "Mr. Daisey & The Apple Factory"
This response is telling.

Hypothetical Mike Daisey who takes pride in his decisions: "I use a combination of fact, memoir, and dramatic license to tell the story, and I do so with integrity."

Actual Mike Daisey who knows he's full of shit: "It uses a combination of fact, memoir, and dramatic license to tell its story, and I believe it does so with integrity."

janardanyri··on The Unwelcome Mat - How Not to Attract Tourists
So maybe infants should be more scared of plastic bags than firearms. I'm pretty sure that the commenter in question is not an infant, and thus has little to fear from plastic bags. (Does this really need to be stated?)
janardanyri··on Game Theory Explained: Why The Joker and Not Batman is Our Savior
You were downvoted for relatively shallow and reflexive criticism. You're not disagreeing with the article; you didn't read the article. If you genuinely want to know if it's a good article, read it. You're not saving anyone any time by instead initiating a conversation about how you didn't like a sentence in the second paragraph.

There was a great article recently on being a good reader. I can't seem to find it again, but the general point was that you have to assume some level of good faith and try to see through inevitably fuzzy wording to assess the fundamental points that constitute real value and insight. In reading, you win if you learn something, not if you defeat an argument.

(Or maybe there's a broader problem if an article making the front page of HN doesn't count as sufficient endorsement in itself...?)

janardanyri··on SXSW: Meet Clarence, The Homeless Hotspot
A fellow staying in the same house as me ran across these guys and was highly skeptical of their operation. It's good to hear that it's actually a pretty cool story. :)
janardanyri··on Zynga launches new Platform for social games
No, you buy before good news, and sell before bad.

(If you don't understand your market well enough to know which it will be, maybe you shouldn't be investing.)

janardanyri··on AT&T Caps Unlimited Data Plans
And that's the trick: AT&T implemented throttling just after all the dedicated iPhone users upgraded to an iPhone 4S and locked themselves in for another two years.

Disgusting, eh?

janardanyri··on Windows 8 Consumer Preview released.
The rhetoric in this post is ridiculous, especially when you cherry-pick interpretations of his commentary, castigate him for your interpretation, and question his personal affiliations.

If your best interpretation of "innovation" is "web standards," it is clear that we have VERY different perspectives on modern computing.

Please consider the tone of your posting.

janardanyri··on The Internet Made Me Sad Today
As tlogan's response notes, the distinction to draw in judging 100CE-era commentary is not between Europe in 100CE and now, but rather between Europe in 100CE and the ensuing decades and centuries, which demonstrated that the naysayers of 100CE Europe were completely justified.

That things then swung back upward again is cold comfort to the ancient Romans and does not demonstrate that things could not swing downward for our civilization.

janardanyri··on Windows 8 Consumer Preview released.
Another relevant point: antitrust oversight of Microsoft started in 1998 and ended 12 May 2011, and Microsoft clearly doesn't have a monopoly in PCs anymore.

Imagine a world in which Apple was taken to court for including Mobile Safari on the iPhone, with talk of huge fines and company breakups. Consider having to make strategic decisions with those threats hanging over your head. Would we get Siri? Maybe adding Reminders counts as bundling? Maybe Game Center is anticompetitive against OpenFeint? Will the Growl developers sue over Mountain Lion notifications? What do you do when every improvement could become grounds for a lawsuit?

Of course, Apple doesn't have to worry about those things because they don't have any monopolies. Microsoft did. So competition from Apple may have made the difference simply in that Microsoft no longer has to worry about being a monopoly either.

janardanyri··on The Internet Made Me Sad Today
As both your link and the broader scope of European history indicate, Roman society of 100 CE was in fact in the midst of a many-generations-long decline into irrelevance, so this is perhaps an unintentionally apt citation.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →