HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jannotti

695 karma · joined February 11, 2011

Verifying my Blockstack ID is secured with the address 1914xedLWW7ENJjNf899eXeip4yeNNCbN5 https://explorer.blockstack.org/address/1914xedLWW7ENJjNf899eXeip4yeNNCbN5
submissionscomments
jannotti··on The estate tax is a bad tax say economists (2001)
Well, I'm not sure there's any definition that's going to come straight from first principles, but I see a wealth tax as something closer to the way we tax corporations, which is to tax "profit" not "revenue". A personal income tax is more of a revenue tax - even if someone has to spend every dollar they make on kids, health care, rent, etc - we still tax it. We try to fix this a little, by offering deductions that we think make sense. But a wealth tax seems like a more direct way to get at this idea. Levy a tax on the money that people are able to accumulate, not on the money that flows through them.
jannotti··on Brittleness comes from “One Thing”
Did this blog post just try to coin the phrase "one thing" in place of the clearer and well-known "single point of failure"?
jannotti··on The estate tax is a bad tax say economists (2001)
Counter argument. https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21731626-case-taxing-...

In my opinion, a wealth tax (of which estate tax is one example) is much fairer than an income tax. It is somewhat difficult to levy, but I don't think it's inherently more difficult than measuring income for income tax. It's just that we've spent a century working on income monitoring laws and regulation.

jannotti··on Environmental impacts of food consumption by dogs and cats
The article says 30% of what humans consume, so I think that means 30/130 = 23% of "all" meat products. (Where "all" is human plus pets.)
jannotti··on Explaining React's license
No, if such a startup sued FB, then would end up being a legal user of React under the BSD license, which does not terminate.
jannotti··on Explaining React's license
That may be what was said in a discussion, but it is incorrect. If your company sues Facebook for a patent, then you lose the extra patent grant, which means you would have only the original BSD license. Which is what ASF seems to want the software license under anyway.

The patent grant from FB grants you strictly more rights than BSD alone (though admittedly, you could lose those extra rights).

jannotti··on My son died in 1994 but his heart only stopped beating this year
That's the power of defaults. Italy changed to an opt-out program for donation, rather than opt-in.
jannotti··on Fidget spinner craze inventor struggles to make ends meet
Sure, I'm no lawyer, but I think I can state fairly confidently that this patent, http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=H..., does NOT cover the popular spinners of today.
jannotti··on Fidget spinner craze inventor struggles to make ends meet
Thanks for pointing this out. I didn't even notice that weird frisbee looking thing on first read. Those are not, or at least should not, be covered by the same patent.
jannotti··on A response to “An experienced JavaScript dev’s account of learning React”
Impressive job replying to what seems like a hatchet job, without losing his cool.

But my favorite part: The next React will allow returning an array of components without a div wrapper. Small change, but it annoyed me to no end that it wasn't already possible.

jannotti··on Vanguard Is Growing Faster Than Everybody Else Combined
Is it really worth saying that Lotto winners "Identified the correct lottery numbers"? It's true, I guess. But it doesn't really have any value, if that's all you mean.

(And yes, I understand that you agree with the conclusion there. But I'm saying what's the point of the verbal gymnastics in the first place?)

jannotti··on Living a Lie: We Deceive Ourselves to Better Deceive Others
This seems like a junk experiment. They asked people to perform a task that would be easier if you had some information. Then they started showing them videos. The subjects stopped watching when they had enough inspiration for their story. That's it.

It's as if the authors of the study think the subjects have ESP and know that evidence contrary to their goal is coming up, and therefore decide to stop watching.

jannotti··on Deep Learning enables hearing aid wearers to pick out a voice in a crowded room
That last part seems to really put a damper on things, since the problem the author describes is that a person with a hearing aid requires speakers to take turns. Apparently, when people speak together, the multiple voices clash. Even if the hearing aid amplifies voices only, that problem remains.

Still, cooler than a lot of things Deep Learning is being applied to these days.

jannotti··on Time to Take a Stand
That's not what Trump says. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/trump...
jannotti··on Time to Take a Stand
He was reporting a deed. You are accepting Paula Jones comments as fact of a deed, but you are not accepting Trump's own self-report of his behavior as a deed. Remember that the tape also contained him saying things like, "I can't resist beautiful, I just kiss", and "They let you get away with it". These are not abstract tasteless comments, like saying something tasteless about a woman's body. These are self-reported "nasty deeds".
jannotti··on Show HN: Target almost all platforms at once with react native
Excellent, yes, that's exactly what I want.
jannotti··on Show HN: Target almost all platforms at once with react native
React Native has been moving to give common modules common names across iOS and Android. That seems great, because it's easier to share code. I wonder why there isn't a simple set of wrappers for HTML widgets, using the React Native names, so you can also share code with web. Does this project do that?
jannotti··on $718K penalty against M.C. Dean for blocking Wi-Fi devices (2015)
Why is electromagnetic spectrum special? A convention center couldn't put poison in their air, couldn't stab people, couldn't libel anyone, couldn't cook meth, and couldn't produce patented pharmaceuticals in their own private property either.
jannotti··on How Does Your Kindergarten Classroom Affect Your Earnings?
Right, I'd really like to know about the "random" process that assigned students to classrooms. I know that when I was in elementary school the assignments were theoretically random, but if parents really wanted to influence them, they could. Since this study gets a lot of its results from clustering, they might just be finding that certain classes were perceived to be better (right or wrong) and so involved parents influenced the school to get their kids in it. Now it really is going to be "better" by the metric of those kids' later success.
jannotti··on The World of Fake Vacation Destinations
Oddly, the article addresses Disney, but does so by saying that the photographer says there a difference. Except the difference is something about being indoors? Surprise twist, there's actually no difference, but the man has to sell books, or he won't be able to keep taking international vacations!
jannotti··on Tim Cook assures employees that Apple is committed to the Mac
I was just struck at how Trumpian this sounds: "If there’s any doubt about that with our teams, let me be very clear: we have great desktops in our roadmap. Nobody should worry about that."

Though I also notice the Obamian "let me be very clear". Tim Cook for President?!

jannotti··on How Bad Are Zillow “Zestimates”?
I don't have an opinion on whether zestimates are accurate. But this blog post has 9 samples from only 3 cities. And the author seems to be making claims based on that. This is a lame "thought leadership" post as a subtle ad for his company.

At least give me 10-20 homes in each of 10-20 cities if you are trying to convince me of something systematic.

jannotti··on Bye Bye Emojis: Emacs Hates MacOS
Yeah, kind of true. But Apple not letting others implement iMessage is pretty similar. (I'm sure I could come up with examples for almost every other tech company as well.)

I admit it feels weird that GNU is doing it, since the others can be explained by them wanting to make more money, and this can't. But I guess we should be as understanding of them trying to "win" the thing they want (software freedom, defined as they choose) as we are are of companies trying to "win" (money).

jannotti··on Introducing Custom Elements
This seems almost exactly like all of React. These components do have state, just like a React component. If you're talking about how the state is changed, then now you're not talking about React. You're talking about redux, flex, etc. You may very well want something like that here too, but that's not because this isn't like React, it's because it is like React.
jannotti··on Introducing Custom Elements
I don't see how this could possibly work even a little bit without Javascript. What would you fall back to? A static hunk of HTML? That could only work in the very specific case of a custom control that happens to have exactly the same utility on the page as an existing HTML element. And even then, you'd need to add a templating language, so you could express how to render that HTML chunk with a certain value or text. This templating language would not be Javascript, since you're trying to avoid that. So we add a new templating language to HTML for the benefit of rendering content for people who turn off Javascript?
jannotti··on React 15.4
Does it remove it and redirect? If not, you're fine. I think that's why something like this is chosen. Your (server) app will rightly ignore that query parameter, but you'll probably still serve up the page. React is client-side, so it will still see it in the url. Everyone should be happy.
jannotti··on Vancouver plans to tax empty properties 1% of their assessed value
Which still qualifies as "misleading"
jannotti··on An Update to Our Supercharging Program
Then maybe it works the other way. Can Tesla charge business owners? It would be surprising if the correct pricing is zero, not positive or negative.
jannotti··on How I vetted and dumped a startup idea in ~20 hours and for under $1000
What's interesting is that he did two things. 1) Spent about $1000 on light meters, domains, logo, upwork. and 2) Talked to a couple people, for free, that made him realize the idea can't work. (This conversation did not use any of the knowledge gained from the $1000 spend.)

There is certainly a lesson here.

jannotti··on Headphones Everywhere
It still wouldn't have been worth reading though. If an article uses a click-baity question, but acknowledges that its premise is a dumb one that people have used for years, that doesn't forgive it and suddenly make it a worthwhile article.

(Yes, I did read it, and wish I had closed it sooner.)

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →