HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jason_oster

219 karma · joined May 9, 2013

Just passionate about games, art, and technology.

https://www.blipjoy.com https://github.com/parasyte

submissionscomments
jason_oster··on Building an HTML-first site doubled our users overnight
Plain old HTML with vanilla JS is not exactly a pit of success but React is much closer to a pit of despair. The former tends to be clunky but effective, while the latter requires a PhD in complexity avoidance to stand a chance.

JavaScript: The Good Parts by Douglas Crockford is a comically short book. React: The Good Parts would be shorter still.

jason_oster··on GPT-2: Too Dangerous To Release (2019)
I don't particularly doubt your experience. But if you have struggled to maintain an app that is effectively complete upon inception, it means that changes in your environment are so common that it's a surprise you get anything at all done.
jason_oster··on Rich Sutton on AI creativity and discovery
And then there's France, which gets about 70% of its electricity from nuclear energy.
jason_oster··on Rich Sutton on AI creativity and discovery
Can't tell if you are spending time in the wrong circles or just shitposting. Here's one: https://youtu.be/l6DKRf-fAAM?si=6u54mry0TLgS868a
jason_oster··on Rich Sutton on AI creativity and discovery
I agree in general. But making this claim with a narrowed definition of generative AI that doesn't match what is being used in practice is setting up a strawman.
jason_oster··on Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post
Are you sure about that? Most of the mid-2000's jQuery components bundled their HTML and CSS in bespoke template strings within JS. If you remember, jQuery's `.css()` method accepted JSON to set CSS properties, and `.html()` accepted a string to set the inner-HTML.

And if you needed to manipulate strings to generate HTML, you'd be doing so with some kind of template mechanism, like string concatenation or substring substitutions. John Resig, author of jQuery, wrote Secrets of the JavaScript Ninja in 2008 [1], offering a small templating engine that does exactly that. The first commit in the Underscore library credits this book for their `template` method [2].

I think your chronology is skewed or confused. "SPAs" have been brewing in some form since the mid-2000's, when people stopped writing plain old HTML and CSS. Everything was jQuery UI widgets and AJAX, Prototype and Underscore templates. HTML died a very long time ago.

[1]: https://blog.codinghorror.com/secrets-of-the-javascript-ninj...

[2]: https://github.com/jashkenas/underscore/commit/02ede85b539a8...

jason_oster··on GPT-2: Too Dangerous To Release (2019)
Good times! Iraq acquiring 4000 PS2 for military purposes was a hoax [1], but the fear was palpable at the time. I was an obnoxious teenager, ridiculing the idea of a PS2 supercomputer. It would have been approximately impossible to achieve in early 2000 due to Sony's anti-piracy measures in the console. PS2 Linux appeared around 2 years later in 2002.

[1]: https://www.eurogamer.net/article-29913

jason_oster··on GPT-2: Too Dangerous To Release (2019)
There is almost no maintenance work for bespoke apps apart from infrequent updates to keep OS and hardware compatibility as the environment slowly changes.

Keep in mind, these are not products in the endless feature treadmill promoted by scrum.

jason_oster··on GPT-2: Too Dangerous To Release (2019)
My non-programmer friends have created:

- A mod manager for Vintage Story in Swift.

- A GameShark Pro adapter using an ESP32 that hosts a web app for dumping N64 ROMs and searching for cheat codes.

jason_oster··on Where is the AI jobs crisis?
I don't follow. Aren't you arguing something more like "no one is a programmer now"?
jason_oster··on Where is the AI jobs crisis?
This.

I have been out of the tech startup labor market for many years. But when I was doing hiring in a startup around 2017, we had to put specific, conscious effort into accepting inexperienced candidates. The default mode for hiring is finding like-minded individuals whose experience overlaps with the existing team.

Using AI as a scapegoat for hiring freezes or layoffs is just more FUD. Like all propaganda campaigns, the purpose of fatigue is to induce an amnesia effect.

jason_oster··on Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post
I agree, I wouldn't classify PHP as "not writing HTML by hand". But that's not what I'm talking about. Most websites in the last 20 years have heavily leaned into client-side rendering, picking up with jQuery circa 2006. It's only recently with htmx that the pendulum has started swinging back toward server-side rendering.
jason_oster··on Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post
Do you normally listen to quacks? You clearly don't believe them. Why are you even paying any attention to it?
jason_oster··on Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post
They were replaced by other WYSIWYG website editors like Wix and Squarespace. These replacements are evidence in favor of the original claim. The specific products are irrelevant.
jason_oster··on Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post
> people would have stopped learning how to write html and CSS around 2005.

They did. Now it's all JSX or htmx or some other favored template or DSL monstrosity. Most people do not write HTML or CSS, and haven't in decades. You're spot on.

This says nothing about quality, however. Quality of HTML/CSS is purely subjective. A website's presentation layer cannot meet any technical standard metric for quality in engineering or manufacturing such as durability, reliability, efficiency, or safety.

jason_oster··on The architecture of the internet creates risks for democracy
That’s not the root. The root is the human drive for survival.

We can stop any time, now. Money was already a satisfactory root cause.

jason_oster··on We Need VAT and UBI
> And hopefully it can then steer people towards better choices.

As a counterexample, tobacco taxation is less effective for reducing smoking than alternative policies [1]. So, yes, we can hope that higher taxes help people make better choices. Or we can implement better policies that are known to be more effective.

[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20250323131704/https://tobacco.u...

jason_oster··on The architecture of the internet creates risks for democracy
If we are going to be pedantic, let's do it correctly. The specific, direct problem is advertising, where the money flows. Algorithmic feeds are designed to capture attention, and the reason for attention capture is eyes on advertisements.

Having identified the true root of the problem, I would recommend directing resources towards dismantling advertising. Focusing on anything else is wasted effort.

jason_oster··on LLMs are eroding my software engineering career and I don't know what to do
Progress happens in a series of S-curves. While your observation is correct that advances occur initially rapidly then taper off, the next step tends to arrive sooner than the previous, and with greater magnitude [1]. Tim Urban's article from 2015 has a great explanation of this phenomenon [2].

[1]: https://ourworldindata.org/technology-long-run

[2]: https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/artificial-intelligence-revol...

jason_oster··on Programmers will document for Claude, but not for each other
"Collaboration" is bullshit. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47484519
jason_oster··on C++: The Documentary
Screw this game! I lost all of my progress because it crashed and the last auto-save is 10 minutes old. Uninstalled. 0 stars. Getting a refund.
jason_oster··on Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software
I'll take that as a threat of violence.
jason_oster··on Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
> Artificial intelligence is not conscious

I don't care.

jason_oster··on Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software
You best start believing in piss-soup stories. You're in one!
jason_oster··on Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software
> this one thing that is being used as an excuse to lay people off en masse, you have tech ceos near daily saying they're gonna come for everyone else's job too, and you have the hyperscalers taking up every bit of oxygen in the room.

I hear these complaints multiple times per day. Not just "nearly daily". The backlash has long since drowned out the original source. The ad nauseam anguish has been steadily increasing for months.

I almost prefer to listen to asshole CEOs at this point. At least they have more to say than just repeating these same points.

Being dismissive of AI panic is healthy. What you're engaging in is not.

jason_oster··on What Is a Dickover?
You don't need tracking cookies to log RED metrics.
jason_oster··on Erin Brockovich made a map to track data centers around the country
Reference Cipolla's basic laws of human stupidity. The commenters are genuinely unaware of how they are harming others and themselves.
jason_oster··on Don't Roll Your Own
> Making assumptions about strangers on the internet tends to be embarrassing, and this is no exception.

I was going to say the same of you.

> https://xkcd.com/610/

Touché.

jason_oster··on Don't Roll Your Own
The definition of extortion is the coercion of money in "exchange for protection", where the threat to be protected against is typically perpetrated by the coercer. I'm not using the term in the literal sense, as if an antivirus software firm is producing computer viruses. Thus, this case "feels like extortion", not "we are being extorted". (It may as well be advertising firms selling ad blocking software because the net effect to the end user is the same, but I digress.)

FWIW, I don't consider surgeons to be extortionists. That's an absurdity that you are using as illustrative of why I'm wrong to call software developers extortionists when they charge for a privilege that should be a right. There are two issues with the comparison: 1) I did not call software engineers extortionists (but sure, I can see how you drew that conclusion), and 2) people absolutely should have a right to life-saving surgery and should not be denied on the basis of payment.

There is a huge preexisting problem: health care is not a human right [1]. There are other issues with health care that isn't just money. Many life-saving transplant patents are stuck in a wait list, for instance, and many die waiting. I do what I can. I'm a registered organ donor and try not to destroy my liver. I just haven't died yet, and I still need it. But this line of reasoning is off in the weeds, and I won't pursue it further.

Perhaps what it comes down to is that you have a pro-capitalist outlook, and I have They Live sunglasses.

[1]: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1126951/

jason_oster··on Don't Roll Your Own
That depends entirely on how much needs to be downloaded for each round trip.

A lean website can work just fine on complete trash connections like GPRS or Comcast without incremental loading. Web developers are not incentivized to make lean websites.

SPAs add unnecessary complexity -> increasing page weight -> making finer grained incremental loading more important -> requiring even more code. It's a self-induced problem.

As a corollary, McMaster Carr is often used as an example of a website that didn't fall into the SPA trap, and customers greatly benefit from that [1]. The front page weighs about 14 MB with all of the images, but the loading experience is great even with network throttling simulating a poor connection. There is a good reason the site has this reputation.

Overengineering is the true root of all evil. Web developers cannot learn that fast enough.

[1]: https://hn.algolia.com/?q=mcmaster+carr

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →