9,140 karma · joined February 2, 2015
Treatments for medical conditions should be (and may be legally required to be) evaluated through professionally-conducted randomized clinical trials to prove that they are efficacious.
That would seem to be important for a product that tries to help people treat a medical condition.
It's easy for those with the loudest microphone to promote the work of the researchers they like or are connected to, or research that confirms their preexisting beliefs. This risks making the field insular by excluding new voices with new perspectives and without such preexisting interpersonal ties.
I think that you need criticism to be able to overcome this issue: to allow disinterested parties to push back on praise given by biased sources, and to ensure that current researchers aren't always elevated above newer ones.
This story is pretty much a nothingburger; there's no evidence that his "skeleton crew" has changed anything yet.
In practice, to adopt crypto you usually also need to rely on intermediaries to handle parts of the process for you. Fortunately, in the crypto space, you can use trusted, non-capricious, democratic intermediaries like FTX.
But will those institutions be democratic or respect human rights? Proof-of-work blockchains are effectively plutocracies, controlled by those with the most computing power.
In a country with a stable, effective government, you don't need a blockchain for this: you can just have a centralized database.
In a country without such a government, a blockchain wouldn't help: the government will care more about the large landholders than about the blockchain records, and will have little incentive to enforce the latter.
(Also: I won't look forward to the day when some hacker figures out how to get into a bunch of farmers' crypto wallets and takes all their land. If the government doesn't respect the hackers' claims, then the blockchain isn't really the source of truth; if it does, then a bunch of people's lives are destroyed.)
That seems like the sticking point. Most likely, someone "fulfilling" the contract would try to fool the (publicly available) verification code, rather than actually providing a PostgreSQL instance. It would be hard to create a bulletproof, automated way of verifying that something is a fully functioning PostgreSQL instance with working backups. If verification code was shared across many contracts, any bug discovered in that code could allow someone to wipe out the entire market.
Since those batteries aren't 100% efficient, a fair amount of this power is probably being lost to the batteries themselves.
Regardless: this whole attitude strikes me as an overly utilitarian outlook. Yes, if someone else handled the development, the consequences might well have been worse. But it is still wrong to participate in an injustice when you have the opportunity not to do so. "I was just following orders" is a pretty weak excuse.
Again, if the commenter had no other options because they couldn't risk the loss of income, that would be a good reason, but it isn't clear that that was the case.
I think it's pretty naive to assume that this project wouldn't have been used against the Uighur population, given how China has used extensive surveillance against them.
You couldn't have stopped someone from building it. But you could have refused to work on it on principle, or even have become a whistleblower.
Yes, doing so might have been infeasible for you, particularly if you couldn't risk a temporary loss of income. But your involvement was, nevertheless, a choice, and it's important to acknowledge that.
edit: If it was exactly 5 years ago, you may recall that, when you were working on this, China was starting to round up Uighurs to send them to concentration camps. Nobody should take working on this sort of thing lightly.
But I do think that a good parent would grant their kids a certain level of privacy and autonomy, depending on the child's age and the risks involved.
In this case, the risks of a kid eating meat are fairly low; one kid's chicken tenders aren't going to build a factory farm, and they can always change back to a vegetarian diet later.
(Of course, some vegetarians will have stomach issues if they suddenly start eating meat. The kid should know about that risk, but the reactions in question are usually very mild.)
Somewhat irrelevant, but: do parents actually have a right to enforce a no-meat diet on their kids?
I understand (say) having a "no meat in the house" rule, telling your kids not to buy meat products with your money, and/or only cooking vegetarian food.
But requiring your kid to adopt a vegetarian diet at all times--even when they're away from home--seems excessive.
Maybe it's OK at age 5, but once the kid is old enough to understand the distinction it should be entirely their choice.
I think that Musk has realized that his free speech absolutism conflicts with his goal of increasing profits. So now he's trying very hard to find a compromise.
It seems like this sentence (like many others in our judicial system) is based more on retribution than anything else.
I think these two cases are sort of parallels: people assumed that someone was a genius to such an extent that they disregarded any signs of fraud and sought little proof of the assertions being made.