HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jballanc

9,437 karma · joined November 23, 2008

I'm just a guy with some ideas...programming lets me do something with them.

Get in touch! jballanc@gmail.com https://github.com/jballanc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jballanc; my proof: https://keybase.io/jballanc/sigs/pxb6FPsVF9hoQMyb2ap0euWoNG3YxwN2g4VY94RRxX8 ]

submissionscomments
jballanc··on Cloudflare Global Network experiencing issues
More like it's time for the pendulum to swing back...

We had very decentralized "internet" with BBSes, AOL, Prodigy, etc.

Then we centralized on AOL (ask anyone over 40 if they remember "AOL Keyword: ACME" plastered all over roadside billboards).

Then we revolted and decentralized across MySpace, Digg, Facebook, Reddit, etc.

Then we centralized on Facebook.

We are in the midst of a second decentralization...

...from an information consumer's perspective. From an internet infrastructure perspective, the trend has been consistently toward more decentralization. Initially, even after everyone moved away from AOL as their sole information source online, they were still accessing all the other sites over their AOL dial-up connection. Eventually, competitors arrived and, since AOL no longer had a monopoly on content, they lost their grip on the infrastructure monopoly.

Later, moving up the stack, the re-centralization around Facebook (and Google) allowed those sources to centralize power in identity management. Today, though, people increasingly only authenticate to Facebook or Google in order to authenticate to some 3rd party site. Eventually, competitors for auth will arrive (or already have ahem passkeys coughcough) and, as no one goes to Facebook anymore anyway, they'll lose grip on identity management.

It's an ebb and flow, but the fundamental capability for decentralization has existed in the technology behind the internet from the beginning. Adoption and acclimatization, however, is a much slower process.

jballanc··on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi
Yeah, "foolish" maybe wasn't the right word. All metaphors fall short in some way (hence why they're metaphors). I just, knowing something of the history of that part of the world, like to use the opportunity to share the knowledge that, despite the appearances of a chaotic, random aggregation of humans, Bazaars often had a significant structure under the surface (perhaps another lesson about open source to be had there).
jballanc··on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi
Shoot, you're absolutely right! It's been a long while since I last re-read the article, and I had forgotten how "targeted" (for lack of a better term) it was at certain specific individuals.
jballanc··on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi
It's a reference to Eric S. Raymond's famous article "The Cathedral and the Bazaar", where he compares the rather top-down, leader driven culture of Unix development to the free-for-all style of Linux.

Of course, I always like to point out the foolishness of this metaphor: Bazaars in the Near East were usually run in a fairly regimented fashion by merchant guilds and their elected or appointed leaders.

jballanc··on Ask HN: PhDs/students, how do you come up with viable problems/solutions?
I can tell you the same thing I was told when I started my program: no thesis represents more than 1 year's worth of work. The reason it takes most Ph.D.s 5-10 years (8 in my case) to graduate is that you have to fail, and fail, and fail again for 4-9 years before you find your thesis project.

In my case, I started on two exploratory gene knockout "fishing expeditions", both of which didn't turn up anything interesting after a year. Then I crystalized a protein and submitted it to X-ray diffraction, but the results were not good enough for a "high quality" structure, and besides the structure we did find was not particularly interesting. Then I switched to working on NMR structures, but ended up switching universities (politics...there's going to be lots of politics) before that went anywhere.

At my new university I switched to structure modeling and worked on a project my advisor suggested for about a year to optimize a modeling routine, but even the optimized version didn't turn up anything interesting. Finally, I landed on a very intriguing problem that could have had far reaching implications. I worked hard at it for almost a year, only to realize that even state-of-the-art modeling was at least a decade away from being able to begin to address the problem I needed to solve. Finally, I returned to a question that a professor had asked me in my first year of graduate school, half jokingly, assuming there was no way to answer the question. For about a year I worked hard at it, finally arrived at a very interesting answer, and graduated.

jballanc··on Is the world really running out of sand?
And concrete dates back to (at least) Roman times
jballanc··on Was the Internet created to survive a nuclear strike? (2022)
I'm no expert on Tor, but IIRC the story is precisely that spies operating from hostile territory would have a red target painted on them from using encrypted communications...unless a whole lot of people in that hostile territory were also using encrypted communications. This is why Tor was released open source and wide adoption was encouraged.
jballanc··on The evolution of Ruby's Range class
Nice write-up, but no discussion of Ruby's Range class is complete without at least a mention of the venerable flip-flop!

Can you predict the output of the following?

    (1..20).each do |i|
      puts i if i.odd?..i.prime?
    end
jballanc··on The irrational hungry judge effect revisited (2023)
Without having read in-depth either original paper, it seems like the issue here is much simpler than reproduction (though reproduction is the gold standard as is totally under-appreciated these days).

Rather, it seems the authors made a much simpler mistake: hypotheses can only be refuted by evidence, not confirmed. So, in this case, if the hypothesis is "judges act more harshly when hungry", what they should have been doing is looking for evidence disproving that statement. Instead, they seem to have presented a correlation and a suggestion, which is not the same thing as a scientific finding.

jballanc··on Car dealerships revert to pens and paper after cyberattacks on software provider
It is extremely hard!

Dealerships don't make most of their money (or any money, really) selling cars. They make their money from service, and selling info to 3rd parties (ever notice when you buy a new car, you will receive mail from SirusXM for a year after). In order for this to work, their systems are all tightly integrated. When you buy a new car, the dealer will know when you're due for service. When you have your current car serviced more than a certain amount, the dealer will know you're in the market for a new car.

So, it's not possible to swap out only the service management piece of CDK or only the sales piece, or only the CRM piece. They all have to work together. The reason I know is I happened to contract with the IT department of a very large dealer network at the time they were undergoing a migration from Reynolds to CDK. A year into the migration process...they pulled the plug. Moving even from one large incumbent to another was too much work.

Good luck breaking in on that as a brand new baby startup! I think you'd probably have better luck completely disrupting the car sales process from the ground up.

jballanc··on Ask HN: Has anyone else found it harder to review code recently?
I agree, and in fact I would consider working with junior developers a highlight of my day because there is an inherent virtue in the "beginners mind". And you're not wrong that juniors writing things that seem more complicated than they have any right to be producing is not a new thing. It's more that the patterns have skewed. Over a nearly 20 year career, I've developed pattern matching skills that can catch this kind of code...when produced by humans. It seems that I'll have to adjust my priors now. That's all.
jballanc··on Ask HN: Has anyone else found it harder to review code recently?
In principal I agree, and it's not like I'm losing entire days to this sort of thing (well, once I did, but only once), but there's a tricky interplay of experience + lingering imposter syndrome. I do a fair bit of jumping around between languages and frameworks, so when I, say, come back to JS after being away for 6-9 months and I see something unfamiliar, there's usually a 60/40 split that it's a bug vs something the JS community has decided is a new "industry best practice". Before immediately going to the author asking for an explanation, I attempt to do my due diligence and be sure that I'm on the 60% side of that split.

It's just that lately the split has been more like 60/30/10 between bug, some new thing, and garbage AI spew.

jballanc··on A new RISC-V Mainboard from DeepComputing
We're getting a factory seconds one for my son (he loves to tinker, so the fact that it'll need various upgrades is a feature, not a bug). If I were to get one for work, I'd likely start with Ubuntu, but I've really been looking for an excuse to run Nix for my main dev machine.
jballanc··on A new RISC-V Mainboard from DeepComputing
Yes! I don't currently have a Framework 13, but this is making it reeeallly hard to hold out any longer. Yes, upgrading parts instead of buying a whole new laptop is more economical, and more environmentally friendly, but I think the real killer feature is that it has the potential to democratize new ideas around computer architecture.

It sort of reminds me when you actually had a choice of whether you would set up a Token Ring or Ethernet network, before the option was taken away by the overwhelming ossification of existing hardware.

jballanc··on The Functional Programming Hiring Problem
This is why one of my favorite series of questions to pull out during an interview are:

What is your favorite programming language/library/technology?

What do you hate about it?

Anyone that jumps to answer the first but struggles to answer the second is likely not someone you want to hire.

jballanc··on Ask HN: Freelancer? Seeking freelancer? (March 2024)
SEEKING WORK | REMOTE | US/Europe/Asia | Clojure/JS/DevOps

We are a small, close-knit team of software craftspeople, spanning the range from mid-level to very senior (some of us have been writing code for 20+ years). We have worked with a range of clients in a variety of industries including Retail Sales, In-Person and Remote Conference Production, Accounting, Manufacturing, and more.

If you are a larger organization, we can help you increase your efficiency, and leverage the open source community (we're also the team behind the Lambda Island open source project) to get to the next level. If you are a startup still looking to make your first hire, we excel at advising new companies on how to choose the right technology, grow the right culture, and build the best team.

But you don't have to take our word for it! Check out our website for testimonials from Nextjournal (who we helped get off the ground) and more: https://gaiwan.co

Get in touch, we'd love to chat! contact@gaiwan.co

jballanc··on Ask HN: Freelancer? Seeking freelancer? (February 2024)
SEEKING WORK | REMOTE | US/Europe/Asia | Clojure/JS/DevOps

We are a small, close-knit team of software craftspeople, spanning the range from mid-level to very senior (some of us have been writing code for 20+ years). We have worked with a range of clients in a variety of industries including Retail Sales, In-Person and Remote Conference Production, Accounting, Manufacturing, and more.

If you are a larger organization, we can help you increase your efficiency, and leverage the open source community (we're also the team behind the Lambda Island open source project) to get to the next level. If you are a startup still looking to make your first hire, we excel at advising new companies on how to choose the right technology, grow the right culture, and build the best team.

But you don't have to take our word for it! Check out our website for testimonials from Nextjournal (who we helped get off the ground) and more: https://gaiwan.co

Get in touch, we'd love to chat! contact@gaiwan.co

jballanc··on Petalisp: Elegant High Performance Computing
Getting Julia to statically compile is not even that hard anymore. I think people are merely turned off by the lack of a (consistent, well supported) story around distributing Julia apps as single, statically-compiled binaries.
jballanc··on Monster gravitational waves spotted for first time
>None of those people noticed before the instruments registered a detection.

IIRC, the reason no one noticed is that even the strongest gravitational waves are only going to "stretch" space by something less than the diameter of a hydrogen atom.

jballanc··on NYC Congestion Toll Could Cost Drivers $23 per Trip Starting Next Spring
Based on the fee being below 60th only, you can easily cross the GWB into Bronx without getting anywhere near the toll.
jballanc··on NYC Congestion Toll Could Cost Drivers $23 per Trip Starting Next Spring
About time!

NYC is easily the city most connected by public transit in the US. Manhattan doubly so. In fact, you can find relatively nice, reasonably discounted hotels in the Hell's Kitchen neighborhood because it is a relative public transit desert: you have to walk a whole 3 avenues to the nearest subway station!

jballanc··on First Moon landing was nearly a US–Soviet mission
I believe the idea was for this capability to go along with the ISS as a life-boat contingency. That is: shuttle is damaged on launch such that a safe return is no longer a sure thing, so the crew links up with the ISS, shuttle attempts an automated return (or ditching), and the crew hang out while another shuttle is prepared to fetch them.

This is also why all but one post-Columbia mission either went to or was within range of the ISS. The only mission for which this wasn't true was the final repair of the Hubble, and for that they had a second shuttle on stand-by for a potential rescue launch on short notice.

jballanc··on Ask HN: Stuck with an unpronounceable product name
Everyone's missing the more obvious (recent) massive rebranding: Comcast to Xfinity.
jballanc··on New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
So, two quick points in response:

1. Yeah, I probably overstated the case. It's not as if it's impossible to move a gene somewhere else on a chromosome and have it function completely normally. As you point out, we do this all the time. That said...

2. Genetics is hard, and I'm of the school of thought that one reason it is so hard is because systems are more fragile in meaningful ways than we assume. That is to say, if you attempt a gene translocation 100 times and get 3 successes, most geneticists would be happy with that result and not question the 97 failures. And, indeed, it is entirely possible that the quality of the reagents, the stringency of the protocols, or any of an infinite number of other variables that have little or nothing to do with genetics could be the cause of those 97 failures...or, it could be that 97 times the translocation worked but the product wasn't viable. I know from experience that it is very hard to distinguish between these possibilities, and furthermore that in the publish-or-perish world of academia today there's not any motivation for navel gazing into the reason most genetic protocols are not more efficient. That said, I've seen hints in my past work that make me think location, gene dose, DNA secondary and tertiary structure, etc. are more consequential than the common wisdom would have you believe.

(Oh, and for anyone still reading, I'll share the brain teaser that was my light-bulb moment for the extent of gene dose effect in prokarya: it takes 40 min to replicate the E. coli genome, but during exponential growth E. coli can double in number every 20 min. How?)

jballanc··on New Causes of Autism Found in Noncoding DNA
Gene location is extremely consequential, especially in Eukaryotes (everything that's not bacteria or bugs living near hydrothemal vents). A couple of things that are influenced by position:

* First, and most immediate, are promoter/suppressor sequences. These are the bits of non-coding DNA that regulate when a gene is turned on or off. If you move a gene away from its promoter, it will not turn on and off at the right times. These sequences are so closely tied to the proper functioning of a "gene" (typically a term that refers to the introns and exons of a coding sequence), that the operating definition of "gene" should probably be expanded to include them.

* Copy number. Chromosomes take a long time to copy, and if you had to copy the whole length of a chromosome from one end to the other you'd never get a chance to divide. So chromosomes contain multiple ORIs (origin of replication). Even so, it takes long enough to copy DNA that genes located near an ORI will have an effective gene dose higher than those located further away (i.e. it will be almost as if you have two copies of the genes close to an ORI and only one copy for those further away). Granted this effect is more pronounced in bacteria with circular chromosomes and a single ORI, where gene dose can differ by a factor of 4 (or even 8) depending on location, but the effect is still there.

* Sub-nuclear localization. This is an area that is still under active study (last I cared to look...which is a number of years ago now), but there does seem to be some order to the location of chromosomes within the nucleus during interphase (i.e. when the cell is not compacting chromosomes and lining them up to split the cell). It's likely that this localization is related to the distribution of various signaling pathways so that, if a gene is expecting to be "turned on" by a specific pathway, but it happens to become dislocated in the nucleus from where the elements of that pathway are doing the work of activating genes, then it may not respond the same way to extrinsic signaling.

* Finally, and most importantly: heterochromatin/epigenetics. In addition to regulation that occurs on a gene-by-gene basis, eukaryotes are also capable of large-scale regional regulation of their chromosomes. Essentially, a signal causes modification of the histones associated with a region of DNA and the entire region becomes "condensed" into heterochromatin. A gene in a heterochromatin region will not become activated even if all of the signals that would normally kick it into gear are going full blast. In other words, if you accidentally move a gene that should be active into a region of heterochromatin, you may as well have removed it from the cell entirely!

jballanc··on A 25-Inch Plot of Land in Greenwich Village Embodied ‘a Resistance’
It would vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but generally you can't just carve up a lot willy-nilly. In order to transfer ownership of a lot, a deed must be recorded with the relevant government agency (city, county, etc.). These agencies generally have plat books recording the location and coordinates of lots so that this transfer can take place without having to send a surveyor out each time there's a transfer, and there are rules and procedures regarding how lots are recorded, modified, and updated.
jballanc··on uLisp: Lisp for microcontrollers
Or, if you have an installation of Julia, just run `julia --lisp` to get the same thing ;-)
jballanc··on Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results
What's volume? After-hours trading tends to be extremely light (and heavily restricted as to who may participate), so prices have a tendency to deviate from reality by quite a bit. Watch the futures if you want to know where AAPL will land in the morning.
jballanc··on Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results
"Buy on the rumor, sell on the news" is a tradition for Apple's Quarterly reports going back to at least 2004 (by my own memory).
jballanc··on Saudi Backlash Threatens U.S. Startups
Agreed, but I don't think that negates my point: taken to an extreme, libertarianism is extremely inefficient with respect to morals. Instead of making clear choices once (or once per election), I am now tasked with making an ethical choice with every purchasing decision.

One may argue whether or not it is ever possible to avoid at least some component of ethics in purchase decision making as every company must make many decisions on how to source labor and materials. One may also argue whether or not it is ever possible to completely avoid paying for a social safety net (or lack thereof) as crime increases when poverty is rampant.

I merely wanted to point out that (IMHO) the only reason we're even having to read articles like this is because of a glaring lack of moral authority at the head of the current administration.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →