If you're new to web archival, expect a learning curve.
137 karma · joined November 24, 2016
If you're new to web archival, expect a learning curve.
Parent comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23124327
I'll explain why it sounds preposterous to me, and why the idea that google could change the fate of cancer research or missions to mars if not for its profit motives is patently unrealistic to the point of being insulting to everyone involved in this counterfactual.
1. Why cancer?
Number one cause of death is heart disease. Why not that? Surely the #1 problem is good enough for people currently working on adtech if the #2 problem is.
You said curing cancer, not "applying the numerical optimization expertise of a tiny fraction of google's workforce to the occasional omics problem in collaboration with a research lab" or "headhunting the PI of a lifesci research program to build an initiative at Google" or "throwing google infra at something other than Stadia". Even something far more obvious like "applying deep learning to diagnostics / early detection / etc."
These are the things Google can actually do, and they are the things Google already does. Examples: DeepMind for breast cancer screenings, Public Datasets program support for selected research. Still no cancer cure. So if you'd said that, well, they're doing it, to whatever extent they deem worth the prestige bump.
Unless they decide to become Microsoft and buy out entire sectors of applied biotech, they're not going to radically improve their hands-on involvement in lifesci relative to what they're already doing.
More, just ballpark the numbers. Google has 100k employees — "98771" in 2018-12 as per their SERP infobox. "A lot" of those employees absolutely do not by any stretch of the imagination possess the skillsets required to assist in meaningful ways on high-end cancer research, unless that work is conducted like some kind of wartime effort and the assistance is largely of a clerical nature.
And in the event that Google employees were being unilaterally drafted into this effort as grunts, the very first thing they'd do would be to crowdsource/outsource the bulk of the menial work to cheaper labor sources beyond Google. So their main contribution would undoubtedly be in building the scaffolding required to pass the buck.
2. Why Mars?
This constitutes a complete diversion of Google's autonomous driving and robotics people to an out of the blue project that they're out of position to handle. It would merely sabotage a division where Google is a market leader for the sake of starting up an incoherent, laggard mess in an area defined by maddening bottlenecks and complexity. Google has no substantial preexisting expertise in this area, afaik.
At one point they put up 30M USD in sponsorship prize money for a lunar lander competition, but that's about all that comes to mind. It also went pretty dismally. They had to repeatedly extend the deadline. Eventually the comp ran 11 years and ended in one launch -> one crash on the lunar surface. They threw a mil at the team as a consolation prize.
That project was more of an exercise in reifying the moonshot metaphor than anything else.
One far more recent indicator of how hard it is to make strides in this area is the DARPA Launch Challenge, intended to accelerate radical improvements to launch pipelines. It just closed without a winner. One team barely made it to the launchpad then scrubbed.
In terms of both social good that Google can do with its nearest preexisting R&D and profitability, it's clear that redirection would be disastrous. Autonomous vehicles are the play for them. This has nothing to do with the adtech people either way.
All in all, the relevance of Google to either of these problem areas is about what would be expected, cet par: not a lot. Modern work with any technical bent is hyper-specialized. There's no jump from literal cancer like adtech to actual cancer.
On top of that, adtech is largely a house of cards. You can't ever assume that 'data science' coupled to business requirements and marketing is in any way rigorous or indicative of the current state of the art in independent research. A lot of this work is pure smoke and mirrors operating on greater fool theory. To specialize in that sector is to specialize in window-dressing falsity. So it's not like you'd want adtech data jockeys touching subject matter that actually matters.
Your typical software engineer slept through the minimum amount of biology coursework required of them and has no special interest in chemistry beyond maybe like, a broscience-level grasp of pharmacology related to research compounds commonly viewed as smart drugs.
If bay area futurism woo is indicative of broader trends among software engineers, this person also has a vague, half-ironic commitment either to superintelligent AI immanentizing the eschaton or brain uploading becoming a hot-swappable replacement for the mortal coil within 20 years. Or both.
A belief that Google's workforce constitutes an addressable vat of brainpower of such raw g that, were it not for the idle concerns of developing adtech, it could turn to curing cancer is a very strange belief.
that's still a CoC. you've just added entitlement.
Everyone who replied about html6 not being a real thing took the bait.
This is a mangled neologism for epistemic vigilance. We have many terms for epistemological outlooks that describe them without conflating commitments and information at large.
> Suppose that all published information followed a normal distribution [wrt quality of information]:
Or don't, because that's not remotely close to true or useful for modeling what to do about it.
This criticism is worth making because assuming a normal distribution of information quality makes the world already flat, and your problem reduces to news media bias.
This type of simplification reflects tech-culture naïveté. It is not the case that all problems are simply waiting to be properly understood as simple by someone familiar with tech.
> This is not to say that the Internet means that everything is going to be ok, either in the world generally or the coronavirus crisis specifically. But once we get through this crisis, it will be worth keeping in mind the story of Twitter and the heroic Seattle Flu Study team: what stopped them from doing critical research was too much centralization of authority and bureaucratic decision-making; what ultimately made their research materially accelerate the response of individuals and companies all over the country was first their bravery and sense of duty, and secondly the fact that on the Internet anyone can publish anything.
This is not true. A push/pull of many factors plays into how modern science gets done. Some of those factors include centralization, bureaucracy, piracy, and individual judgment.
It is neither useful nor accurate to claim that "centralization of authority and bureaucratic decision-making" prevented a group of researchers from exploring research predicated on genome sequences whose coordination, publication, and syndication all rely heavily on centralized infrastructure projects and public health institutions.
Scientific and public health bureaucracies are complicated. Lifesci loves preprints and dodging publishers, but it also loves centralized bioinformatics and genomics infra.
I am comfortable generalizing "lifesci" here, because it's damn near universal.
Every [reasonable] educated person resents or at least distrusts medical regulators, especially those who work for them. So it's not saying much that yes, of course, scientists do too.
Within lifesci, you would be hard-pressed to find scientists who aren't simultaneously saying "open access good", "publish your data at <centralized repository>", and "I can't believe that <govt agency> is <regulating something incredibly poorly>."
This differs from attitudes of general populations, whose stances on health + safety + environment bureaucracies seem to be well-predicted by factors entirely unrelated to the efficacy of the tooling and services provided by those bureaucracies. Often that means keystone issues that reflect information diet, like views on GMOs and climate change.
If the first word out of your mouth when discussing the needs of modern science is "centralization", you're engaging in wrongheaded techthink. It's worth doing something about, of course, but it truly is immaterial to the everyday workflows of most lab science.
I see this error a lot in tech infrastructure projects. It's frustrating to see very cool, valuable things get built by scientist-coder teams who fail to appreciate that "decentralized x" is not a selling point for the vast majority of prospective users.
These projects often fail to achieve good market fit because they treat problems of scientific research as if they're problems of consumer data privacy. Nobody BLASTs a sequence because they just love the bureaucratic directives of NCBI so much, nor do they contribute new GenBank sequence data for the clout. They do so because it helps make their work feasible.
Don't underestimate the impact of that separation of concerns on scientific attitudes toward centralization. It matters a hell of a lot that researchers don't have to know how GenBank is built or what BLAST actually does as an algorithm.
Getting people talking about your stuff because they're motivated enough to have a pineapple-on-pizza type of argument over the demo is canny and bigtechs do this deliberately.
"Did anyone notice <demo>? LOL and WTF" is why we're communicating now.
It's also wrong in principle: memorable demos remain the most culturally-significant standalone things associated with tech since the 1960s.
1. Pictures.
> What we aren't as humble about is the potential we think this application has.
So you're not humble? Ditch the marketing goofiness. You think it has major potential. Be humble or don't. It's inessential to conveying what HiddenVM is.
> Like Tor, Tails, or Whonix, HiddenVM can be used for bad purposes
Unnecessary. You're already on the back foot.
> - You're a spy
This isn't a normatively 'good' reason.
> Activists, dissidents, political asylum seekers, and journalists (like Laura Poitras)
Don't cite a specific person unless that person is endorsing the product.
> Using Tails should never be reason to suspect you are a criminal or a spy. It protects basic data privacy and democracy.
Don't lead with a user story that exactly matches the stereotype, then. You're walking right into it.
…
Noting disappointment in people being miserable about something interesting, which in itself totally disinvites on-topic conversation, isn't bile. I can't ask people to read the article per the site rules, even though it's painfully apparent that half the problem is lack of nudging to read the article. So of course dissent is going to be colder than it could otherwise be.
The short-form summary that provides this requires the same number of clicks to reach from HN as your comment.
The other half: people who didn't read the link providing baseless conjecture.
Good stuff. Curiosity bad. 200-comment threads about minor releases of enterprise middleware only.
You're describing a reviewer, brainiac.
>you posting a comment here talking about a product/service you like
The only difference between unsolicited, antisocially consumerist behavior and what you do is that you're pay to play. Sure, this is factual.
>As for dishonest influencers who shill for products they don't like... well, probably half the people on this forum work for an advertising company.
Imagine the frailty of a life propped up by shit like transparent tu quoques and $38 in revenue plus like sephora samples and mushroom brand watches with busted dials. Imagine the intense shame and suicidal ideation over the worthlessness of such a life
>Me telling my Instagram followers to buy a product isn't any different from Google showing you an AdWords ad for the same thing.
Google's game is to be large enough that this process can almost be tolerable, while remaining bureaucratically impersonal yet targeted to the ad recipient's consumer profile. It's also eminently avoidable.
Your game is to get access to "exclusive social events" in Area City at the expense of anyone who might've followed you thinking you were an actual person, while failing to get compensated more meaningfully because you just ain't that pretty.
>Being a sellout is only a pejorative to hippies and artists. To anyone else, it's called having a job.
Sellouts are people without professional integrity. That's what the term means.
Italics doesn't make your comment any less circular or beside the point for people looking to move away from github.
>No, it's a matter of reality matching expectations.
What an agent tells me is what they choose to tell me. You're describing some sort of luck-based updating via that third party's choice.
I don't live in a tinseltown universe full of model trains and animatronic NPCs. None of us do. All reasoning about real-world agents is subject to incomplete information and uncertainty.
That much is trivial. More, it's mutually understood to be the case.
Also mutually understood: basic world knowledge stemming from the same. These are principles simple enough to be patronizing in written description, yet persistently ignored or misused at implementation-level. Like:
1. Actors are variably susceptible to errors in reasoning under uncertainty
2. Actors are variably skilled at exploiting 1 to modulate 3rd party behavior
3. Actors are variably motivated to make use of 1-2
It follows from the above that allowing an actor to subtly shift your expectations as if you ever held a platonic model of their behavior is simply a cognitive error. There's no way around it.
Take the "99.995% SLA" example.
In the absence of that figure, would you have assumed a God-Mode level of performance? Clearly not. You can cross all the factors like whether you care about the figure, whether it's above or below average, whether disclosure is standard in this context, … to just enumerate all the cases and see clearly that there's no time when this information is surprising.
I mean, just look at a top google hit for SLA⁽¹⁾. You really think a CIO reader is in any way surprised to hear that some metric they negotiated into a contract indeed holds? Or that it doesn't?
Continuing: A figure like 99.995% is well within reasonable bounds for any number of business processes, so it's not necessarily false precision here. What it almost definitely is, however, is precision in pursuit of persuasion.
There are plenty of industries for which exacting figures at the high end of some performance criterion — manufacturing quality, service availability, measurement accuracy, etc — are essential to informed consumer behavior. Those industries almost universally have norms or regulations setting out certain expectations about what will be found on a specsheet, how units will be tested, how this information will be reported. If not, the spiel is just spiel.
Facts and figures as token gestures of fallibility, however, are confidence tricks.
I already know you're fallible. You cannot sway this comprehension by reframing around some very likely sort of figure: charm pricing⁽²⁾ and related uses of odd figures are marketing weaselry targeting plebs. To point these things in the direction of clientele is to tell them how much you think of their ability to resist bullshit-fatigue.
My feels about whether I'd wanna have a beer with <The Guy>, modulated by his current demeanor toward me or whatever audience he imagines me to be a member of, do not determine his fitness for any high-stakes job.
The same is true here.
Cloudflare is in the MITM business. Absolutely trusted at no point in time, independent of whatever cost/benefit has gone into the decision to use a MITM. This isn't even defeated by being too big a client to lose: if you were big enough to be a lifeline for cloudflare, you'd have no need for cloudflare.
____________________
¹ https://www.cio.com/article/2438284/outsourcing/outsourcing-...
It's plainly wrong.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exception_that_proves_the_rule
>NOTE: THIS SITE IS A PARTICIPANT IN THE AMAZON SERVICES LLC ASSOCIATES PROGRAM, AN AFFILIATE ADVERTISING PROGRAM DESIGNED TO PROVIDE A MEANS FOR SITES TO EARN ADVERTISING FEES BY ADVERTISING AND LINKING TO AMAZON.COM.
I do not revel in the glorious autonomy of, say, permanent academics whose self-help blogger reflexes have become so internalized that it's no longer clear whether they recognize that a post is opportunist piggybacking on trending slacktivist topics. If I can't tell from the general tenor of your blog whether you can tell that you're baldly shilling your books, your self-perception in the matter has ceased to hold relevance.
My first thought upon seeing affiliate marketing links on a self-serious blog is usually something more along the lines of: why does this creature believe they should be paid to have tastes in others' works?
For the most part, I'm not going to visit at all. But when I do, I am going — 100% of the time — to strip tracking parameters, affiliate codes, and all the other bullshit off any link prior to visiting.
Knowing that a platform's design serves to background any given individual user's capitalism of-the-soul in the service of a more homogeneous, impersonal assault from the proprietors is an extremely valuable thing. De-emphasizing personal schemes allows platform-centric economies of scale to double as behavioral peacekeeping. If I only have to circumnavigate a user's terrible ideology, vainglorious twitter feuds, etc. to accrue value from the subset of their posts I find worthwhile, I'm doing better, curatorially-speaking, than if I had to concern myself with that user's schemes to monetize their mere existence in my vicinity.
Constraints on affordances limit a small proportion of content-creating elites. You know you're one of those when your whining about the platform becomes action in leaving the platform, self-publishing in parallel, or otherwise upregulating personal agency.
For everyone else, though, those same constraints make the world go round.
The average internet user has no business whatsoever running their own services, per every single survey of digital skills ever conducted. And a CS prof writing otherwise is either (a) grossly incompetent in his stated area of expertise or (b) allowing himself to shoehorn flights of fancy into his writing in the service of pushing schlock.
A profile you lose because you didn't pay $4 last month, or didn't get security updates for, or […] is simply not a plausible centerpiece of alternative social media under any demographically-literate view of the world.
Homestead the noosphere all you want. Tenements will still need building too.
[ed: you almost certainly will not achieve a net benefit from paying a subscription to an orthographic linter.]
____________________