HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jdvolz

279 karma · joined February 22, 2007

submissionscomments
jdvolz··on Ask YC: What is your preferable development environment?
Windows: VS 2005.NET, ActiveState (Python and Ruby), notepad++ Ubuntu: Gnome, gedit, RoR, Spidermonkey
jdvolz··on Ah-Ha Moment: I wrote my first program with eval and lambda!
I feel the same way about Ruby and Javascript. I can't imagine what I was doing where I could have been using "eval" in C#. I was having to write my own interpreters inside the program and then pass around strings, which is crappy.
jdvolz··on A hypothetical counterexample to "succinctness is power"
Wouldn't it be pretty easy to write an Arc (or even Arc') program to do this for you automatically?

My first macro in Arc' would be "arcp" a macro which took Arc code and translated it to Arc' code. Then you just wrap every file in:

(arcp ;;file contents )

So, based on that, Arc' has an extra macro compared to Arc and extra entries in each file, and thus isn't as succinct as Arc and thus isn't as powerful as Arc -- if we're going to be philosophical about it.

jdvolz··on Windows Vista: Past Its Due Date Already (dBASE IV and Vista comparison)
I just built a new computer. I make Windows programs for consulting and sale. I didn't want to buy another copy of XP (already have 2 for other computers) and Vista is a bloated mess that offers nothing to the end user (even if the kernel and memory management are better, you can't see that). I also didn't want to fork out the ~$180+ for Vista Ultimate.

I had just one day earlier spent an hour on the phone with a customer because a program I wrote actually uses the correct ProgramData location, but the program hadn't been added to the User Account Control (UAC) yet so Vista was preventing it from writing some files. Once added, it worked perfectly. Who wants to deal with that crap?

Long story short: Ubuntu costs me $0, it works with my dual monitors, it was easy to install, the second hard drive got mounted easily, and I'm switching to web programming. I'd also like to say I am in love with Ubuntu. It's like rekindling a flame with a previous lover (Linux).

jdvolz··on Ask YC: Are there any promising non-web startups?
Coming from the consulting angle, it is much easier to get work doing web related stuff, and that work pays better I am finding. Even the desktop stuff I am doing either has a web component, communicates with the web or a website in some way or has a version that is a website. Learn your Javascript and have a decent working knowledge of HTML and CSS.

I do think that you should know probably PHP (for consulting most web projects are in this or are extensions of projects written in it) and one of either Ruby or Python.

There are opportunities out there, just not nearly as many. Also keep in mind as a recent graduate you are competing with all the people who never made the web transition because they already had 3-5 years experience on the desktop that now have 10-12 years experience there.

jdvolz··on Stress impairs cognitive functions - The loss of those functions can explain why programming is hard
hmmm... apparently some of stars got removed. Point was that the star goes with the type, not with the variable name, except for dereferencing
jdvolz··on Stress impairs cognitive functions - The loss of those functions can explain why programming is hard
I agree this is an issue with the C syntax. I always used to write my pointer declarations as:

char* p

instead of

char p

That way there was no clash with when you are dereferencing p -

p

Admittedly this approach may not help entirely with more complex examples, like a pointer to a function that returns a point to a function that takes two pointers to void...or something. Indeed having languages that create less accidental complexity is a huge win.

jdvolz··on How good were you at college?
My reason is that my mom wants me to. I figure she did take care of me all those years, I might have to go back and get a degree once I'm well off.
jdvolz··on The people formerly known as informed
His conclusions are off.

First, for his evidence he is using a study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism. Do you think the study might be biased? The crowd mentality threatens the entire profession of Journalism (I'm not saying it's going away, but they are less and less in control of what people read hear and see).

Second, he argument assumes the dividing line is "hard news" vs. "soft news" when it is really "I care" or "I don't." The problem is that nobody cares what's on the news. If we are to believe the study, the news is more consistent in what it shows. That means they are showing us the same thing over and over again. People care about things that are relevant to them or that provide some form of entertainment. Surprisingly, the mainstream news is just picking up on the fact that their product at the very best under-serves the needs of their market.

Third, the article paints the mainstream media as "informed" and everyone else as "uninformed." No bias there. Even if we assume they are right, it just points out that they aren't providing their customers with the information they want. If Google can target ads to me based on search, how come news can't be tailored to my desires.

Finally, the crowd based sites know the mainstream news exists. They don't have to cover the Iraq war for the 10,000,000,000th time. That's what the news is for. If you wanted to see information about Iraq you'd go to a mainstream news distribution channel. Haven't they considered that maybe there is no reason to rehash those stories already beaten to death in the mainstream media?

jdvolz··on Would you sell your startup to Microsoft? Why? Why not? (I am not sure).
Yes I would. Y = for money.
jdvolz··on They Write The Right Stuff. Old, but still very interesting article.
Okay, so the 4 steps to "perfect" software break down to:

1. Big-Design-Up-Front

2. Have a testing department

3. Use Source Control and Bug Tracking

4. Fix all instances of systematic errors and fix the process by which those errors were injected into the program.

Most of those sound familiar:

http://joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000043.html

I admit that this article isn't written as a technical instruction sheet for writing perfect software, but they could at least come up with something we haven't heard of before. You mean NASA actually has the funds to do a full BDUF and to have a testing department? No kidding.

jdvolz··on Is Enterprise Software Failing The Innovation Test?
I liked this part the best:

"Some of my banking customers have infrastructures that are bigger than the public Internet in terms of the storage they consume, given all the data and equipment they have to support."

Somehow, I doubt that anyone has a system larger than the public internet particularly as measured by storage. Can you imagine trying to sell that much hard drive space to someone? Yeah, you need more space than the Internet! I bet they aren't even using as much space as YouTube. I tuned out after reading this comment in the article.

Ever since I read PG's article about PR I've been leery of articles that stink of PR. This article reeks of it and then he goes and makes an incredible claim with no backup. There are hundreds of other articles I could be reading, I'm done with yours.

jdvolz··on Why Ubuntu Sucks
This guy is basically saying that Ubuntu sucks because it does exactly what it is intended to do, namely help convert Windows users to Linux and to make the transition as easy as possible. While it may be true that more hardcore Linux users don't like Ubuntu, it's hard to say something sucks when it does exactly what it is intended to do.
jdvolz··on What programming language should I start with?
I'm surprised that people disagreed with my C recommendation (although, note that I did say Python or Ruby if you want to get something done quickly). Learning C isn't really about learning C, it's about learning how the computer actually does things (aka pointers, memory management, etc.). Knowing C lets you understand concepts in higher level languages easier. For example, "pass by reference" is easy to understand once you have passed around some pointers. It helps you understand what the garbage collector is doing, and why it's doing it. It helps explain why even in managed languages sometimes you need to "free()" something (an example is bitmaps in C#).

Would you rather start programming on the surface (not knowing what is happening underneath) or would you rather start by learning the hard stuff underneath? I, personally, would rather know what is happening underneath. Is there an argument for learning the more surface stuff first? Maybe I'm off nuts and have a slanted view because I learned Java, Scheme and then C.

jdvolz··on What system do you use for bug tracking?
I use //TODO: in my Visual Studio stuff. VS will find them for you automatically, I don't even have to grep for them.

I also try to write code so small and simple that it approaches the complexity of "Hello World." That way, it's easy to find the bugs.

jdvolz··on What programming language should I start with?
If you want to learn to program then C. That's right learn C. C is the language that the operating system you're using is written in, not to mention several of these other programming languages (the main implementation of Python or Ruby, for example). Is this language easy? No. Is it right for newbies? Maybe, maybe not. If you want the least amount of abstraction and don't want a bunch of stuff in your way, learn C. It's a hair's breath from learning assembly, and you can get a free compiler for it on any operating system.

If you want to get stuff done quickly, learn Python or Ruby.

jdvolz··on What can you do with money?
Figure out what you want to have, do and be. The have part is easy, most people can work that out on their own. What do you want to do? Do you want to learn something new (foreign language, to tango, a new programming language, etc)? Do you want to do something physical (run a marathon, achieve weight lifting goals, swim the English channel,etc). Do you want to be a philanthropist? Do you want to run a non-profit organization? Figure out 3-5 things you want to do.

Be is harder IMO. Do you want to be a husband? father? grand father (you need help on this one obvious)? Do you want to a champion whatever? These are the questions I would ask myself. With the answers, you can start taking concrete steps.

jdvolz··on A Thousand Lines of Code Per Week
As I'm sure everyone will say, this heavily depends on what you are writing. If you are writing Windows Forms in C# using Visual Studio you could easily write 1,000 lines of code in an hour (because the IDE makes them for you). Similarly, if you are merely typing up what should be done by an ORM product, then you can easily write 1,000 lines of code in a day. I've had 3-4kloc days doing the combination of these two. It's possible because the coding is easy, and you have tools to help you do it.

Also, are we counting things like macros in this estimation? I mean, a single line macro could yield hundreds of lines of code once through the compiler.

jdvolz··on If you run your web services alone, like me, are you using "I" or "we" pronoun on website and in touch with customers?
I like to use the name of the company in place of "I" or "We" because it reminds the customer who you are. Also, it's good for search engine positioning.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3