HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jeffmcmahan

388 karma · joined August 1, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jeffmcmahan; my proof: https://keybase.io/jeffmcmahan/sigs/LkRxkjFGiURCcGAZhebTYaCjrrZ6HbydIvnH9FJA2HE ]
submissionscomments
jeffmcmahan··on Microsoft Support advises, “Please use Chrome.”
I agree completely. Switched to FF 3-4 months ago; it's been great, actually.
jeffmcmahan··on Microsoft Support advises, “Please use Chrome.”
The total history of the support issue is displayed. Nothing omitted.
jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
There is no need to jump in as a PhD. Enroll as an undergraduate anywhere that has a good department in the area you're interested in, and then express interest and work as hard as you can -- if you show promise, the faculty and graduate students will notice you and enjoy your conversation. However, if you want a paid career as a researcher, you will absolutely need a PhD.
jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
I hope you're right. Do you have specific policy moves in mind?
jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
Yes, I do recognize that. However, it also benefits the Chinese regime enormously, and I think a future in which that regime has the scientific and technological capacity that we currently have is unlikely to be good for humankind (not that Western governments have been perfect ... or even basically good).
jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
No. I said they're cleverer than we are, at least on average. I said the Chinese government should learn some humanity (which they obviously should -- and given the current state of the US gov't and Western politics broadly, ours should too).
jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
The average Chinese is just as clever, if not more clever, than the average Westerner. They'll absolutely produce good results given good funding. But the tradition of the University is not Chinese; the Areopagitica is alien to mainstream Chinese civic and intellectual values; the inviolability of the right to interrogate the universe as a free, searching, essentially individual being is not part of the mentality driving all this investment. It is essentially like 20th century Soviet enthusiasm for science and mathematics. The government expects the benefits of a world class intelligentsia with the downsides held in check at the point of a rifle.

I think the US and Europe should slam the (academic) doors shut; no more collaboration until the Chinese government learns some basic humanity. The strategy of influencing the Chinese by educating their elite has not worked. Clearly.

jeffmcmahan··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
Right, so never ever. :/
jeffmcmahan··on FrontPage 98: Elegant and Exquisite (1997)
"Here's an Automotive theme that is quite unique and pleasing to the eye: ... <BARF>"
jeffmcmahan··on J. L. Austin: A return to common sense
I've long been an Austin fan -- "How To Do Things With Words" is dazzling.
jeffmcmahan··on Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intolerant’ Liberal Culture
"Would [De Morgan's theorem] benefit some group more than the other?"

Your actual publicly adopted opinion reads like a joke.

jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Why is MacOS so popular among developers?
Why Mac? Like many, many devs: (1) acceptable font rendering, unlike Windows, (2) compatible with Adobe CS unlike Linux, and (3) it's a *nix, allowing me to develop stuff that will run on linux cloud instances.
jeffmcmahan··on Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intolerant’ Liberal Culture
How is it cynical to demonstrate that a specific claim -- put across with unreasonable certitude -- is in fact flatly false?

Let me ask you: is De Morgan's theorem political? Directly? Indirectly?

jeffmcmahan··on Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intolerant’ Liberal Culture
"[E]verything is inherently political."

My preference for the scent of lavender over cinnamon -- political. I'm against the designated hitter rule. Political too. I think my dog should not get into the trash. It's all politics.

jeffmcmahan··on There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought
Nautilus is built on this kind of psycholo-garbage. The conclusions go way too far, but the title gets clicks.
jeffmcmahan··on The function that gives AI value is the ability to make predictions
Humans are not predicting what a photo depicts when they look at it. They more or less immediately come to a definite conclusion.
jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Your favorite syntactic sugar from any language?
Same in JS
jeffmcmahan··on Firefox dropped below the 10% share value on Netmarketshare
This is important, but Safari has a stable market position too (macOS + iOS), so the worst case scenario will not be as lousy as the early 2000s situation w/IE.

I tried to switch to FF completely - for dev work and all - late last year. The dev tools were just not as good as Chrome/Chromium. I use FF for browsing. I'll try to make the dev switch again, starting today.

jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: How did you transition from Mac to Linux?
I tried to switch to Ubuntu in mid-2015, using a VM for Adobe CS, but it was awkward, particularly with the CS working files not being easily shareable btw the VM and linux. Gave up after about 3 weeks and went back to my Mac. It will stay this way until CS or something similarly capable comes to linux (and if you're about to say "GIMP!", let me just stop you right there).
jeffmcmahan··on Bitpress: An Open Protocol for Tracking the Credibility of News
How do we avoid the problem of 40% of people shouting "liberal bias!" when they see the Times, the Post, and CNN dominating the graph?
jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Which books have made you introspect?
The Gospel According to St. Luke and the Acts of the Apostles (also by St. Luke).
jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
"Chomsky contributed to linguistics and it was an interesting theory but it turned out he was mostly wrong..."

You've made a very strong claim about linguistic theory while knowing very little about it. The vast majority of those working on phonology do so within the mold set by Chomsky & Morris Halle in 1970, and there are roughly zero syntacticians doing serious work on natural language syntax outside the Chomskyan tradition (whether in GB or Minimalism).

"The religion built around Chomsky is a bit crazy."

You're hardly in a position to judge, with no more than a passing acquaintance with psych 101 summaries of his work.

"Just because you defined something doesn't mean it's impressive."

The Chomsky hierarchy was not "defined" in the deflationary sense that you're pushing. Chomsky discovered that generative mechanisms partake of a special set of related properties relating the range of their output to specific constraints on the formalisms that can exactly describe their grammars. It so happens that this discovery made possible much that happened in CS during the 60s and into the 70s.

I'll leave aside your bizarre comments as to the unimpressiveness of Peano arithmetic.

jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Why are so many coding challenges about math?
I figure the math-heavy tests probably represent an unconscious attempt by elite educated CS guys to homogenize the talent they hire, to build teams of people more or less like those doing the hiring - very smart and well-trained in a particular tradition. Smart matters of course, but a CS background, while worthy, is one among many ways of becoming a competent, creative, productive developer.
jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Why are so many coding challenges about math?
Many excellent developers earned degrees in areas other than CS, or are self-taught and have demonstrably first-rate minds, well worth the salaries on offer.
jeffmcmahan··on Ask HN: Why are so many coding challenges about math?
That's precisely it -- one does not build modern applications using the kind of knowledge OP is being tested for.
jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
Yes, as I said above, politics (re American policy) may have some role, but mostly, he has argued forcefully against a whole range of approaches to studying language. And many people (most prominently those in the Barbara Partee/Montague tradition) don't like that.

Oh, and at last look he was not just the most cited linguist. He was the most cited living human being.

(And FWIW, I came to linguistics from philosophy via formal semantics; I once held negative opinions of Chomsky myself. It took time to see that he was right.)

jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
As the article you linked says of Chomsky's view (correctly), "Statistical language models have had engineering success, but that is irrelevant to science." Chomsky wants to know how your brain does things, and not how best to make a computer do something to approximate that. He reiterated to me and a few others in 2009, during a seminar, that right from the start he always said that the only way to do machine translation is brute force statistics -- but back in the 50s he took the funding for translation research, and then just did whatever he wanted with it.
jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
Haha, yes, perhaps.

"I found the mathematical approach to grammar immediately appealing---so much so, in fact, that I must admit to taking a copy of Noam Chomsky's Syntactic Structures along with me on my honeymoon in 1961." - Knuth

jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
"Not really, only the basis of the entire business."
jeffmcmahan··on Parsing: a timeline
Noam is on the short list of the most intellectually impactful human beings of the period since Descartes: Newton, Darwin, Smith, maybe Ricardo, Marx, maybe Frege or Russell, Einstein, Turing, Keynes, Chomsky, and a scant few more.

His politics may motivate people to disregard him, but mostly he's just come to the devastating conclusion (for solid reasons) that people working on language outside the Chomskyan tradition are not doing science; semantics, linguistic anthropology, and some areas of psychology are just wind. People who do such work will not understand his criticism because their academic standing depends on their not understanding it. There is thus a supply of motivated PhDs ready to dismiss and de-emphasize his contributions. Some of the same applies to philosophers who work on language.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →