HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jeremy_arnold

80 karma · joined June 8, 2021

submissionscomments
jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
Grilling is cool. TLDR is I'm a copywriter turned comms consultant. I work mostly with tech companies. My interest in journalism review came just from years of diving into stories on topics I knew and finding them grotesquely misrepresented. This then kicked up a gear when I wrote about Elon Musk and the Thai cave rescue in 2018 and had a bunch of newspapers/journalists shit on my work. I wrote an exhaustive rebuttal to all their points (and offered them money for any mistakes they could find) and they just didn't read it. I came to realize that they have the privilege of just never having to engage with criticism no matter how rendered. So I started my substack to effectively pre-publish chapters of a book I'm writing with a list of examples of really bad journalism from top outlets. Then going to segue from that to my own journalism-esque platform to put my money where my mouth is a far as building a news org with better incentives and more accountability.
jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
OP here. Can you explain to me how calling bullshit by its name is trolling?
jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
OP here. A few readers mentioned versions of this. Am correcting. (IRS would likely try to stagger in some way. But there's basically no good system for doing this, and you're going to cause roughly the same selling pressure no matter how you go about it. But agree that my framing was rushed/bad here for this bullet.)
jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
OP here. Happy to answer direct questions as you have them.

It's a self-funded project. As for trust, I pay bounties for corrections for a reason. And I keep a public list of all past bounties paid. Readers can review and decide how much to trust accordingly.

jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
OP here. Just replied to this elsewhere. Step-up is just to avoid double taxation. Estate taxes are at a 2x rate (vs. LTCG) for assets above the baseline ($1m + exemptions etc).
jeremy_arnold··on ProPublica's tax story
OP here. ProPublica made the same argument. Maybe I should have covered it.

Here's why that step-up doesn't really matter. For round numbers, let's imagine Bezos acquires shares of Amazon at $1 each. Fast forward a few decades and they're now worth $100 each. He's accrued $99 in taxable gains. But he blows up in space, so it's all left for heirs. At transfer, the cap gains part is thrown away. But this is only to avoid double taxation, as the heirs now pay 40% on current market value for assets > $1m. Making them pay 20% CG on $99 and 40% would be far too high. So the gov lets them only pay 40% on ~$100, which is roughly 2x the total receipts.

(If the assets are left in trust, you can avoid the estate taxes. But then you're back to paying cap gains when the money is withdrawn.)

EDIT: Technically it's assets over $1m + other exemptions and deductions. In practice it kicks in more like $10-12m depending on particulars. But the amounts in question here are way, way above that baseline.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2