25,176 karma · joined October 16, 2012
"You have said exactly 0 things of substance."
"What a complete waste of time it is discussing anything on HN that you touch."
username@g
This seems like one sort of thing, in which money that used to be in a depositor's pocket is now in the bank and available for lending.
...and in fact they generally lend out money they borrow from a central bank...
This seems like another sort of thing, in which money that previously did not exist has been created by the Fed changing a number in a spreadsheet so it's now available for lending.
You might point out that in our system, these different-seeming things are essentially the same. If so, you're really agreeing with GP.
The real reason interest rates are rising is to kill the infant unionization trend in its crib. SVB is just collateral damage.
China discouraged Kim from invading RoK, and didn't come in on DPRK side until dumb-ass insubordinate MacArthur told them he was going to keep rolling across the Yalu. Well that went over about as well as NATO missiles in Donbass! Or Soviet missiles in Cuba! Belt and Road is simply a less abusive foreign investment regime than IMF/World Bank. Little wonder that it appeals more than what USA has on offer.
If you actually agree that American Indians have been robbed and genocided, why be so quick to designate a convenient time before which we shouldn't worry about robbery and genocide? If you don't actually agree about the American Indians, on which side of the line does our strikingly similar subjugation of Philippines fall? Maybe we shouldn't care about that either, even though it was in the 20th century? Maybe you want to move the cutoff line? That seems a common maneuver when discussing the conflict in Ukraine. We're definitely not supposed to remember e.g. 2019 discussions of Ukrainian Nazis. [1]
Recall we started talking about Pentagon's abysmal record of losing every war, then we moved to supporting sovereignty, then we moved to opposing authoritarianism, while you stipulated 'no one is talking about "winning wars"'. There was something about China empowering Pol Pot, which seems rather beside the point when it was USA that bankrolled him for years. [2] I forgot about him in my long lists upthread!
There is some bad news about your final goalpost relocation. The bitter end must be the idea that our current participation in the Ukraine theater of WWIII is in opposition to "authoritarianism". Unfortunately, our puppet in that region is every bit the authoritarian as previous ones in other regions. He is banning political parties, closing down TV channels, disappearing residents [3], and feeding battalion after poorly trained battalion into the meat grinder of Bakhmut. For current Ukraine leadership, it's more important to pretend that Russia even cares about holding this minor town than it is to attempt to preserve military strength. When politics trumps security and respect for life, that is authoritarian.
The late Barry Crimmins was occasionally asked the same cretinous question you pose: “Why don’t you go live somewhere else then?” Barry would reply, “Because I don’t want to be a victim of US foreign policy.”
I support your material analysis, even while rejecting its rude implication. Most opinions about war are motivated by money. Unfortunately, in USA popular media, war is very profitable.
[0] https://nationalinterest.org/feature/the-us-military-proud-o...
[1] https://fair.org/home/action-alert-nyt-celebrates-neo-nazi-a...
[2] https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~furrg/pol/polpotmontclarion049...
[3] https://jacobin.com/2023/02/ukraine-censorship-authoritarian...
The Quaternary Megafauna Extinction (QME) was the well documented, extremely rapid crash in available calories, beginning around 50,000 BC, and accelerating into the Neolithic around 11,000 BC.
We don't need to wade through the literally contradictory citations noted for this proposition; it's ridiculous enough to reject on sight. 39,000 years is "extremely rapid" on a cosmic scale but not on a human one. It's not as though big game hunters were flying airplanes around the globe to collect trophies. People in e.g. northern Europe didn't share anything cultural with people in e.g. southeast Asia. Humans responded to ecological reality, but it most likely did not take the form that you claim.
It's easy to convince yourself of this. In our time, modern agriculture and modern chemical manufacturing provide food for most of us, but not all. In remote locations throughout the world, right now but more significantly within the last millennium, indigenous neolithic populations support and have supported themselves in "the old ways". That is, even though no giant ground sloths exist (although large mammals such as buffalo, elk, moose, elephant, hippopotamus, rhinoceros, giraffe, etc. do) and even though modern humans have been consuming most global resources, these isolated tribes have successfully fed themselves. They have been visited by anthropologists who have recorded their lifestyles of e.g. monkey hunting, clam digging, or swidden agriculture. They don't starve and they don't hoard. In most locations, meat makes up less than half of the diet. Foraging plants and consuming small game isn't strange and isn't inefficient. That is what hominids have done throughout our existence.
As we know from ecology, the particular species that make up a trophic level do not change the fact that energy flows up the food chain. Perhaps koalas might die out if eucalyptus disappears, but humans are highly creative and adaptable to various food baskets. Your speculative, ecologically unlikely argument needs more support than an "imagine you're a nomad" just-so story. For one thing, we "evolved" to eat fruit not mastodons. Some of us have eaten mastodon when it has been available, but it has only ever been available on a small portion of earth's landmass. When mastodons disappeared that probably caused some people to starve but starvation is a common cause of death for any predator. That's why humans in the state of nature typically eat plants that they forage: to avoid starvation.
I mostly agree with the "against the grain" hypothesis, but it has been covered better elsewhere. I haven't spent enough time thinking about your later propositions to judge them. This paper may be recoverable with some editing.
[0] http://pacificecologist.org/archive/18/pe18-hunter-gatherers...
Alternatively, if we knew a particular asteroid would threaten us in one decade, that one decade might be enough to do something about it. Many asteroids won't give us that sort of notice, since orbits can have century-long periods.
We still occupy Hawai'i, as well as the entirety of continental USA. We still occupy the eastern third of Syria, as Trump said and Biden hasn't contradicted "to steal their oil". The various nations we occupy in Africa invite similar explanation. We occupied Philippines for decades, as colonial masters, until Japan kicked us out, after which we reoccupied it. As observed above, that wasn't a different thing from the colonization of North America, because it was done in the same racist way by the exact same racist army officers. We maintain military bases all over, every one a direct threat to the host nation should they stray from our political line. For example, how successful can Korean reunification efforts be while our sword hangs above their heads? This isn't winning wars. This is terrorizing populations.
Over the decades we spent in Philippines we pioneered the sort of financial colonialism we codified at Bretton Woods. This has been extensively documented by economist Michael Hudson. After we trick a nation (i.e. pay off whichever corrupt locals we can maneuver into power) into signing up for this program, we oppress working people, extract resources, privatize public assets, and financialize the whole mess. Most of the surplus in the economy is exported to e.g. NYC and London. This is the real explanation for USA capitalism's "century of success". Our system can no more support itself without victimizing other nations than the Roman Empire could have thrived without slavery. As developing nations throw off our yoke (witness the "Россия" t-shirts worn in every nation in Africa), we'll have to organize very differently, or else the American 99% will suffer the same predations from the American 1% that were previously focused overseas.
In four thousand years, China has never fought a war on the other side of the world with a nation (or with a ragtag bunch of goat enthusiasts) that could never threaten the territory of China.
TFA claims explicitly, in the title, to be about "winning". I observe that the Pentagon doesn't have a recent track record of doing that. ITT that observation has been answered by novel definitions, references to WWII, appeals to sovereignty, and now you have appealed to anti-authoritarianism. Hold on to your history book, because our record in USA doesn't look too good on that either.
Here is a short list of authoritarian dictators whom USA supported for years: Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, Saddam Hussein, Mohammed bin Salman, Ibn Saud and the half-dozen other Saudi "kings", Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, Hosni Mubarak, Syngman Rhee, Park Chung-hee, Chun Doo-hwan, Mobutu Sese Seko, Sarit Thanarat, Suharto, Augusto Pinochet, Juan José Estrada, Manuel Noriega, Anastasio Somoza García, Luis Somoza Debayle, Anastasio Somoza Debayle, Carlos Castillo Armas, Fulgencio Batista, Phoumi Nosavan, Hugo Banzer, Jorge Rafael Videla, Hissène Habré, Ferdinand Marcos, etc, etc, etc. As before, I have left out many. Tens of millions of innocent people died due to USA support for these authoritarian dictators, not to mention the hundreds of millions more who lived in fear and penury.
There is not a chance in hell that support for any of those awful men contributed in the least to USA not being shelled over any period of history. That has been guaranteed by our two giant oceans and two fairly large vassal neighbors. The more straws you attempt to grasp, the clearer the picture of USA militarism becomes.
I stipulate that USA navy defends shipping, except of course in those fairly frequent events in which battleships mistakenly run into shipping vessels while tooling around in the dark.
This is the point in the discussion at which we usually suffer tired invocations of "Ukrainians had agency!" Sure they did, but if we had polled even the most violent of the protesters as to whether they wanted to import enough NATO weapons to cause a war with Russia, very few of them would have agreed. (Probably more would have agreed that it was good to start killing Russian-speakers in Donbas? Well if the poll was taken in Kiev.) Ukraine was a weak polity, without the sort of solidarity required to resist American (and Russian) exploitation of civic divisions. Maybe they imagined that they would escape the fates of similar polities in Hungary, Georgia, Afghanistan, etc. They have not.
We're still not supposed to criticize whatever happened in Wuhan. Fauci certainly seems multi-generational...
Sure call WWII an "allied victory": Stalin did. I'm not talking about "credit". TFA pretends to be a practical analysis, so I criticize it on that basis. The Soviets learned more about war than we did, and we've forgotten most of what we learned. TFA, in turn, crouches about the shins of hobbits.
A better way for USA to support that principle would have been not to invade the sovereign nations of Cuba, Philippines, Hawai'i, Haiti, Dominican Republic, Panama, North Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Grenada, Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya, Yemen, Serbia, etc. Those are just a selection of the invasions our leaders admit. There have been far more unacknowledged actions in various parts of Africa, Asia, and Latin America, as well as violent actions that didn't include uniformed USA troops like when we paid Saddam Hussein to have a horrible war with Iran. Also there have been violent actions for which some local support could have been argued, such as when Suharto and his CIA handlers killed millions of people in Indonesia. Also we genocided American Indians for centuries. As soon as there weren't any more of them to kill, the exact same USA army officers were doing the exact same racist violence in Philippines. USA's existence is one continuous rejection of sovereignty.
Crackpot realists ITT will gleefully point to my list of USA military victims and crow about "victories" in "war". Many of these were "police actions" in which there wasn't even an opposing force, just civilian victims. That's not war. Also, although every one of these actions served the someone's interests, not one accomplished a military objective that benefited the average American. That's not winning.
Since much of our own industrial base is in China, our military will prosper while the rest of us will lack most human comforts. Some portion of our military will be diverted from the battlefield to curtail the resulting unrest. We will lose, much more painfully than we lost in Korea or Syria or any of the intervening wars. Alaska, Hawaii, and all Pacific territories will be gone. We'll lose most of our foreign bases. The dollar will be worthless. American-owned intellectual property will disappear. Australia will be (re-)colonized. Germany will re-militarize, and Europe will remember why that's bad. (One might expect that also of Japan, but they are probably too geriatric now.) The portion of Ukraine that Russia doesn't take will be taken by Poland. Israel will abandon us in favor of the Saudi/UAE axis, but that group will decide to coexist with regional rivals rather than follow us down the drain. USA itself might split into several pieces, none of which would be capable of the sort of excessive militarism we've inflicted on the world for the last 120 years. So, not totally bad.
A war that was fought for no reason, that didn't end before causing the most disastrous attack on USA soil since 1814, I would call "dumb".
We should avoid wars in general, but we should especially avoid a world war with China, Russia, India, and the rest of their many allies. We got beaten by the Taliban, but if we fight 3 billion people we'll get curb-stomped.
You might follow with an obvious question about Indonesia. Since that nation is a vassal of USA, the answer is equally obvious. Let's not stop thinking just yet. This is why context is important. The certification scams you cite serve to move wealth from the poor to the wealthy. That is bad. Requirements that imports to poor nations not be mostly trash serve to protect the wealth of the poor from that sort of extraction. That is good. More familiarity with Indonesia, or with any similar developing nation, would have provided you with this knowledge already.
Vehicles that get absolutely trashed are a loss, but that's why the lenders want every repo to be a surprise to the creditor.