179 karma · joined September 16, 2009
dispatch.io
I've just noticed that clients of all ages have trouble bringing themselves to get the right help they need when they need it. Coming into your own in business and in your career is not a linear progression, so people learn different things at different stages. You're lucky to have learned this early. :)
It's useful to ask who your business is going to be because it's a concrete acknowledgement that you are not your business. Once you do that you can decide which parts of who you are should be applied to solving the problem you're going to solve, and what contributions you'll need from others to complete who you want your business to be, whether they're contractors, co-founders, employees, advisors, or whomever.
Your business will also have a personality, but that's only small piece of the picture, just as a person's personality is only a piece of who they are. A person has skills, abilities, a point of view, values, etc., just like your business. And the way your customers will relate and interact with you as the provider of a product or service, is more similar to how they would relate to a person than anything else. So I think the lens is useful.
Thanks for the comment! :)
A Founder's Job.
Your Business is a Person. Make her Awesome.
Who is your Business?
Is there one you like better? Any tips for picking titles?
Thanks!
I also thought about suggesting sailing for a couple weeks, but I was worried about what liability there'd be if some startup team got lost at sea. :)
To be clear, registering a mark with the USPTO does give a business tons of advantages. Most obviously, it gives notice to others that the business considers the mark part of their identity, and it makes enforcing the their exclusivity to the mark easier. But registration isn't a slam dunk, and in this case I would wager a case of nice Scotch that the mark "SEO," even if registered, would basically be unenforceable. Here's why.
Without getting bogged down in too much detail, above all else, trademarks must be DISTINCTIVE. There's a whole framework setup the creates four categories of distinctiveness (from least to most): Generic, Descriptive, Suggestive, and Arbitrary/Fanciful. The framework comes from this case: http://bit.ly/bNw3pp
Generic marks are never valid as marks because they aren't distinctive enough to ever serve as part of a business's identity. If they were valid, we'd eventually cede the exclusive use of our entire language to mark owners. "Piano" is the textbook example of a generic term.
Descriptive marks are only valid once they've acquired an association with a particular company in the marketplace. "Red Piano" would be a descriptive term as applied to red pianos, and if a company came to be known at THE supplier of red pianos in the marketplace, the mark would probably be valid.
Suggestive marks are immediately valid assuming no one else has already established a confusingly similar mark. "Lovely Ivory" would be a suggestive term as applied to Pianos. Suggestive marks require some flight of the imagination to relate them to the goods they are fixed to.
Arbitrary/Fanciful marks are also immediately valid subject to the same limitations as suggestive terms. "Crap Sandwich" would be an arbitrary term as applied to Pianos. There is no connection between the mark and the goods.
[I've laid out a more in depth description of this framework here: http://bit.ly/bVxbv1 ]
Applying the framework to the acronym "SEO" and the phrase "SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION" as it applies to the SEO services, both are generic terms because they are the label for an entire genre of services. Without some modifier that makes the term descriptive, SEO could never carry the distinctiveness necessary to describe an SEO firm. If the mark holder ever tried to enforce the mark "SEO", it would be at their own peril because it would never pass this test.
I will say that the $17K spent now probably saved the SEO industry some nuisance cease and desist letters and probably saved some cash for the first person that Jason Gambert opted to sue over use of the mark (it would have also been the last). In that regard Drysdale kinda fell on her sword for the greater good, however certain a favorable outcome may have been.
Either way, glad it's settled. :)
-a non-practicing attorney, soon-to-be entrepreneur