HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jfkebwjsbx

1,123 karma · joined February 12, 2020

submissionscomments
jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
> a pretty large number of even paid apps are happily vacuuming up data and sending them to the developer and often third parties

Please name some examples. I certainly do not have not use nor know about any paid software that "vacuums" my actual data or tries to track me.

> analytics/debugging platforms

You cannot compare anonymous, aggregate details about overall usage of an app or crash stacktraces (which is what most paid/OSS apps do) to the kind of identification webs do for ads.

Again: native apps do not care about showing personalized ads to you nor their business depends on it.

> I tend to think of an app for most things as a loss of privacy

Mobile apps from vendors like Facebook definitely. Normal paid/OSS desktop software, no.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
I would seriously consider any alternative vendor or simply living without the app. No serious health device will show you ads of any kind in their software.

There is a modern overreliance on apps for everything these days.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
I talked about paid or open source productive software, usually desktop based, nor ad-riddled mobile apps with the Facebook SDK which by definition are not trusted.

Mobile apps are increasingly sandboxed too, like websites, precisely because of that.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
> ... web pages that talk to ... health devices ... there is no way to block ads in an app

Wait, what?? Why on earth would you use an app with ads for health devices?!?

Moreover, why on earth are you using apps with ads for anything?

Please, please, please, pay for your apps and games. Stop making everything an ad service. The race to the bottom in the web and mobile world is disturbing.

Would you want to pay for your house plumbing by being forced to watch an ad every time you shower? Think about how dystopian that sounds. There are even Black Mirror episodes on that.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
Why would you ever want a PWA when a native version exists?

And "heavy client" is a fallacy. Operating systems come with runtimes too. Very complex native app can be very small in size if it uses the native controls and APIs. They can be KB in size. Any asset is going to be bigger than the binary itself.

The web-as-native apps are the ones that are huge, because they embed a behemoth (a browser) which is akin to an entire operating system.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
Well, because native apps are intended to be trusted. They do not have a motivation to invade your privacy: proprietary apps are usually paid upfront and risk their future clients, open source can be inspected.

Instead, the overwhelming web business model is "free to use" (akin to f2p in games). That means ads and other monetization side channels become the priority of the app, not the app itself.

And that is for trusted web apps. Let's not even talk about the fact that you are executing random code every time you visit any webpage. That just does not happen with native apps.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
I agree overall, but:

> That's why you pay $1000 for a phone, so the manufacturer protects you from these risks.

is wishful thinking. You pay 1000$ because that is what people is willing to pay.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
Average users won't do it.
jfkebwjsbx··on Cryengine Source Code
> when writing high-performance manually vectorized code

The point was not about manually vectorized loops in particular. Why is that a problem if you are manually doing it, though?

> Security and compatibility has higher priority.

In commercial games, not really.

As for "compatibility", I am not sure what you mean.

> gcc and clang don't deliver their C runtime libraries with windows updates.

AFAIK you can use Windows libraries just fine. No need for using a different libc.

> Also, debugging and crash diagnostic is much easier with MSVC.

AFAIK, Clang can produce debugging info that you can use with VS.

I don't work on the environment, but it is what I have read here.

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
Epic does not want to be a major store. They want to be the only store.

That is why they have been forcing exclusivity. That is the point: they are anticompetitive.

jfkebwjsbx··on Life is 90% of my use cases for org-mode
GFM, Gitlab and others you list are CommonMark plus extensions, which is what I said.

What is the problem? It is like saying JSON is useless because YAML exists, or that ISO C, C++, Fortran, IEEE 754, etc. are all useless because compilers and chip companies implement extensions.

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
> How is obscene amounts of money forcing anything?

Indie game studios have a very hard time surviving.

Giving them instantaneous access to a huge pile of money that allows them to declare success even before releasing a project is something most people cannot reject.

> Anti competitive would be buying up competing battle royale franchises to reduce consumer choice.

That is what they are doing but with game stores. They are effectively buying everything to dry the rest of the stores, reducing other stores choice of customers.

> This sounds good for developers all around

Not really. Devs get money, but they lose the product. Indie devs are not independent anymore. Etc.

If Epic had success building the monopoly, everyone would have suffered, not just devs.

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
Epic paid obscene amounts of money to studios to force them come to their store and force exclusivity on them.

They basically exploited their Fortnite money-making machine to try to become a monopoly on PC.

How is that not anti-competitive?

For reference, Steam has never forced exclusivity on partners to distribute their games.

As for cheaper, Epic didn't become they couldn't charge the same. As simple as that.

jfkebwjsbx··on Life is 90% of my use cases for org-mode
> Markdown is not consistent across the platforms that support it.

That is not true anymore. CommonMark is the formal spec everyone follows now, including most major sites out there.

> If I wake you up at 3AM would you remember the format of links? is it parentheses first or brackets?

Well, yes. Markdown is super easy to remember.

> LaTeX support. I can write some complex math formulas.

On top of CommonMark you can add extensions to render LaTeX just fine (like MathExchange does, for instance).

jfkebwjsbx··on Cryengine Source Code
False, most standard libraries out there allow you to configure whether you want extra checks or not.
jfkebwjsbx··on Cryengine Source Code
> Having to jump to another function definition which is inline is a bigger mental block than following a goto.

Local lambdas are ideal for this.

> Are you suggesting that the code should have done something like this?

Yes, but you can manage the array inside too.

> I mean, sure, it's a very minor cleanup. It changes like, two lines though

The point is that TempArray can be reused everywhere. This is a typical class that many projects use (stack if small, heap is bigger than threshold).

> Here's modern MSVC. Let's play "spot the difference"

The optimizer has been asked to leave everything as it is, so that is the expected result.

BTW, MSVC is not what you should be using if you want performance.

> Don't just say "should be"... test it yourself!

I always test codegen for all abstractions I use! So I agree.

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
An engine like UE which has decades and decades of work does not care about what a small engine like Godot does.

The grant is more about avoiding monopoly claims, getting good PR and attacking Unity.

jfkebwjsbx··on Xi-Editor Retrospective
I didn't know about Xi, but JSON, RPC, multiprocess, microservices, Async... are all red flags.
jfkebwjsbx··on Cryengine Source Code
> C has no pattern for breaking out of multiple for loops at the same time.

True, but it is cleaner to reorganize the code into several functions and use the return value to propagate across layers if needed. Performance should be the same.

> it's not applicable here

Why? If there is a new/delete pair anywhere, it should have been an object.

> Game developers have a long-seated distrust of std::vector, and for good reasons.

Which reasons? std::vector (and std::unique_ptr) is universally useful (unlike many other std data structures) and codegen should be on par as a new/delete pair.

If the std is completely broken in some of the console platforms they need to support (likely from what I hear here) then it can also be done with a custom heap array wrapper.

So I don’t see the reason why that shouldn’t have been an object.

jfkebwjsbx··on Astronomers detect regular rhythm of radio waves, with origins unknown
It is not perfectly explainable by us, though.

And it may not actually perfectly explainable ever. Nothing guarantees we can get a perfect understanding of physics.

jfkebwjsbx··on Show HN: A Reddit reader that looks like the frontpage of a print newspaper
Hanging or crashing without feedback is pretty much "not handling errors".
jfkebwjsbx··on Examining ARM vs. x86 Memory Models with Rust
> cheaper cloud bills

That remains to be seen.

jfkebwjsbx··on Xbox Architecture
> Those who "pirate" will never convert to paid customers

That's not true. Many people won’t pay for something if they can get it for free reasonably easy.

jfkebwjsbx··on Examining ARM vs. x86 Memory Models with Rust
A pointer does not contain what it points to, it just points to it.

The content (the value) of a pointer is an address.

jfkebwjsbx··on Fix Your Timestep
I guess most games cap velocities for most objects if not all, so I doubt that is an issue.
jfkebwjsbx··on Symbian Won
RAII can be used without constructors and without exceptions. The acronym is misleading.
jfkebwjsbx··on Apple: Advancements in Game Controllers
It is spot on. Macs are less than 5% of the Steam audience, software now needs notarization, developer tools cost money in the form of hardware, GPU drivers are buggy (unless you use Metal and buy into Apple ecosystem), modern OpenGL was abandoned years ago, etc. So developers only target macOS if the game gets big enough.

From the point of view of gamers, it is annoying. The recent 32-bit support drop killed a huge amount of macOS games. Now I have to bootcamp to play some of my favorite games. The GPU performance is also quite bad due their fight with NVIDIA.

jfkebwjsbx··on Perl 7 is going to be Perl 5.32, mostly
> it is not the notorious "write only" language that many troll it to be

I dispute that.

I have worked with many languages, and Perl has always been one of the hardest to remember due to non-standard symbol abuse and a few strange semantics.

There is a reason it has that reputation.

Even writing it isn’t easy. I can describe the Python syntax after years of not using it. Perl? No way I remember it.

jfkebwjsbx··on PEP 622 – Structural Pattern Matching
The point of GP is that the match assumes an equality test and it does it against a single object too.

There is no way in many languages to write an if using a match.

jfkebwjsbx··on The Problem with Git Flow
Releases are created off the master. Only if something is supported for long a branch is created where only fixes are backported, no development happens there.

What the GP suggested I assume is one master-like branch for every deployed version. Otherwise it makes no sense.

← PreviousPage 7 of 29Next →