HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgg

937 karma · joined October 1, 2009

submissionscomments
jgg··on I’m graduating with a CS degree but I don’t feel like I know how to program.
It's funny, because the situation we're in right now (at least in the US) does neither really well.

On the one hand, hardcore theoretical courses at the average CS school don't exist as weed-out at all. If you're lucky, you've got a good faculty member teaching a compilers or operating systems course that'll make it challenging, but only sometimes. Teaching things like Haskell, The Lambda Calculus, Prolog, Complexity Theory and C are "impractical" for someone doing a CS degree, because, you know, everyone uses "OO" (whatever that means) nowadays so that's the theory we should teach. Plus, if we teach a hard course about the theory of computation, lots of kids will flunk, and we can't have that, now can we?

On the other hand, any attempt to make the curriculum practical (since most schools border on vocational training anyway) is met with the response of "Well, a CS degree shouldn't prepare you to be an industry programmer!"

So really, most universities are left in a luke-warm middle-ground, where theory is being neglected but no one is willing to be the administrator who "flips the switch" and turns CS students into non-stop code monkeys.

Really, grounding yourself in a lot of CS theory, while occasionally forcing yourself to break out and hack up a project, is probably the best route to becoming a well-rounded programmer. Whether most people are capable of realizing how bad current CS education is and doing so, however, is another matter.

jgg··on [dead]
Something like AbeBooks, combined with an e-mail to the professor asking if an older edition is okay (provided they didn't help write the newest edition of the book (-:) will usually suffice. First semester, I spent ~$600 on a book order at the campus bookstore that was essentially worthless. Second semester, I spent <$100 and got all my school books plus 5 or 6 extra computer and science books, and I finished this semester fine. If the system is screwing you, outsmart it. The only problem I've come across with this method is a) specific readings and exercises out of specific editions and b) activation crap that is required to do online homework (a bullshit tactic deserving of its own separate rant, but whatever). For a), make friends with people in your program. For b), you can often buy a separate activation code for whatever vendor they're using without buying the textbook, but they like to make you think otherwise.

If you really know what you're doing, you can just not buy the book at all, or substitute it for a better, cheaper book. Example - I substituted the crap-tastic Rosen book on "Discrete Mathematics" for a better, $12 Dover Press book and was perfectly fine.

That being said, stuff like this just keeps reminding me of the uncomfortable truth that our so-called "ivory towers" of academia are just as corrupt and run-down as the world around them. They are a business, no more, no less. Yeah, yeah, it's a big "no shit, Sherlock", but it still makes me feel queasy when I think about it.

jgg··on It's Official: Valve Releasing Steam, Source Engine For Linux
It appears that I missed that one.
jgg··on [dead]
>It was a badly played joke.

Ah, apologies then. I vaguely understood what the humor was there, but I wasn't sure if that's what you were going for. (-:

jgg··on It's Official: Valve Releasing Steam, Source Engine For Linux
That is awesome. If it hasn't been posted already, please submit that as a top-level link!
jgg··on [dead]
Are you...joking? Or am I supposed to be taking that explanation as your reasoning behind why that's a lambda?

I'm hoping for the former.

jgg··on Better performance in App Engine with new Lisp language Clojure
If the usocket library suddenly disappeared, along with all the current Lisp implementations, there would be no guarantee that someone making a new CL implementation had to implement the library in a way similar to usocket, or even implement a socket library at all. It's the same as saying "everyone uses Emacs to edit Common Lisp, so it's the standard Common Lisp editor".
jgg··on Better performance in App Engine with new Lisp language Clojure
Common Lisp has no standard way of doing Network I/O. usocket is one of several available socket libraries which don't exist in the ANSI spec.
jgg··on EA Sports Locks Out Multiplayer Modes On Used Sales
>Not going to be a popular move for EA but it's a smart business move.

If I'm misreading your post, I apologize, but how is something that pisses off current and potential customers a 'smart business move'?

jgg··on Think before you code (2007)
This is why I love Haskell. Dealing with the type system and purely functional style forces you to think about the problem at hand before you do anything.
jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
If I had known that, I would have actually tried in highschool.
jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
>I had a 4.7 GPA in high school.

Funny story: my school wouldn't allow you to score over a 4.0 on anything. This meant that if, for example, you blew off a stupid humanities class and got a 'B', you could never have a 4.0. This is great in theory, as most schools should ask for a "GPA out of a 4.0" number, and all would be grand. In practice, they didn't, so my official transcript from the school would always read '3.9', without giving any clue that the GPA's were capped!

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
That's what they told me too.

It depends on the college. I would imagine that Stanford would be a bit better quality than my school.

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
I know it sounds corny, but it does feel good to hear someone say that. (-:
jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
>I might be considered a huge failure because I've devoted myself to raising my son (and learning lots of interesting things along the way) rather than to a technical career.

The system in place would consider you a failure because you haven't lived up to the expectations of what the system wanted you to do. No one can claim that as an absolute, no matter how hard they try. (;

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
Short answer: money.

Long answer: I had an ACT in the 30s and a GPA of 3.9 upon graduation from highschool, and I took a few AP courses (my school only offered 3, and in addition I took AP Physics over the internet (terrible idea)), got a 5 in the AP Calc test, etc. but past that I hadn't taken the SAT subject tests or anything, so I wasn't really competitive. My family and I don't have a lot of excess money just lying around, and basically my options were thus: get admitted to a couple upper-tier-but-not-Ivy-League schools and pay with money I didn't have, or go to a crappy state school with scholarships.

I've had a job since 7th grade (but there are not a lot of tech companies in my area, so they haven't really been 'tech' jobs), but all of that was saved for buying my own vehicle, insurance, 'spare' money for college, etc. I remember getting excited when I received a ~$20K a year scholarship to a "Blah Blah Institute of Technology", only to find that it cost $50K a year to attend.

Overall, I'm burnt on the education system. My goal now is to get out with a stupid degree before I completely crash, but I'm already coming dangerously close...

EDIT: I was also in Duke's TIP program, which got me mail from Columbia and the like, but once again I couldn't really afford to go through with any of that.

EDIT 2: Before this sounds like just a bunch of whining, a huge chunk of this was my fault. I could have had higher scores and grades and whatnot, but I really just didn't give a shit. I hated school, and wanted to do as little as possible. I've always loved learning though.

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
It depends on the classes, actually. They do "clepping out" on a per-professor basis. But trust me, I'm looking into that.

EDIT: I even sat in on an upper-level programming languages course, and the most advanced thing you learned (from what I gathered) was a bit of Common Lisp. I hate to sound like an arrogant ass, but for the entire lecture I was thinking "Is there something wrong with me? I learned this in highschool!"

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
I hate "me too" posts, but when I saw what you wrote I really did want to give you more than one "upvote". I'm a mathematics (and computer science) major at a large, middle of the road university and I can say my experience has been exactly this. I gave my full rant in another comment ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1312043 ). Basically, real mathematics takes a lot of mental resources, so in order to appeal to the masses universities have to make the material mind-numbingly stupid. Remember: it would be unacceptable to large corporations if only 1% of the current engineering graduates were graduating, regardless of how much smarter that smaller group would be.

> Of course most smart people I knew would more or less blow off the homework and just ace the tests, and thus they would often end up getting a B- even though they probably understood the material better than anyone else.

My Calculus II class graded mostly on the stupid homework (from James Stewart's book, no less) and attendance!

Unless you care enough to work hard in highschool and have enough money to go to a school like MIT, "higher" education is a huge joke.

jgg··on Many gifted children fail academically
I hate to say it, but after spending some time at an average college that I got a scholarship to, it became rather apparent that a lot of the regular people who go to college do so because they don't know any better. That's why things like "Undergraduate Studies" and "General Business" degrees exist. The college is ultimately a business, and that business can only sustain itself if is has a sizable source of revenue; telling unmotivated slobs that they should be questioning the value of taking 15 hours a semester of "general education" credits isn't high up on the list of priorities.
jgg··on Android Tablet Crashes during Flash Demo
I do. There are so many of these as of late that it's become unbearable. I've been trying to ignore it, but I can't stand it anymore.
jgg··on Android Tablet Crashes during Flash Demo
I've kept my mouth shut for a while now, but I have to be honest - I can't stand this fucking bullshit anymore. Do you realize how pathetic you look by posting this back-and-forth tech company drivel? I don't have or use an Android, an iPhone, a Palm or whatever other pointless gadget everyone here masturbates to, so I'm not saying this as a fanboy of anything. I'm just tired of seeing all this tech gossip posted to the front page. It's not interesting, it's not new and it makes Hacker News appear no better than Reddit - read some of the comments in this thread to see what I mean.
jgg··on Academia is not Broken. We are.
>but i was lucky enough to have a high school computer and robotics teacher that let me explore things i found interesting for credit.

You were lucky - the only thing that saved me from giving up entirely in high school were a few good books I found by browsing MIT's OpenCourseWare pages and other places. My high school was full of corrupt assholes who spent all the school's funding on elaborate sports complexes for our shitty sports sports teams, so that all the funding to our science, math and tech clubs dissolved and the library only had a few outdated dictionaries and some terrible fiction books.

But I'm not bitter. (;

jgg··on HackerMed - My HN-like Site for Hackers Interested in Bio/Med
I guess the only problem there is that it makes it harder for one community focused on a certain topic to "branch" to another when things get rough, whereas now you can just start "/r/ruby_two" or whatever if /r/ruby makes you mad. It's definitely a trade-off, but I think Hacker News is still high-quality enough that tagging would work.
jgg··on The Big Bang Was an Explosion of Space, Not in Space
I'm resisting the urge to link to an Erik Naggum rant...
jgg··on The Big Bang Was an Explosion of Space, Not in Space
Wrong, God wrote in Lisp: http://www.gnu.org/fun/jokes/eternal-flame.html
jgg··on HackerMed - My HN-like Site for Hackers Interested in Bio/Med
Even just a simple tagging system would suffice. One to two tags attached to the submitted link would be great. One could use Reddit for this, but I prefer the average comment/article on Hacker News to the average comment/article on Reddit. (:
jgg··on HackerMed - My HN-like Site for Hackers Interested in Bio/Med
Someone should do something like this for hackers interested in math...or does such a site already exist?
jgg··on The Little JavaScripter
It's awesome that you're in high school and you're already checking out Scheme. I did the same thing (I'm a freshman in college now). (:

On that note (since I'm derailing the topic of conversation anyway), does anyone have experience with teaching Scheme to younger kids? The Little Schemer seems a little too hard for a child, but I think Scheme would make an awesome introduction to programming (or maybe I'm just a horrible language bigot). For the really little ones, I'd probably use Logo.

jgg··on The Little JavaScripter
The way I read The Little Schemer featured a lot of skimming, punctuated with occasional moments of re-reading. I enjoyed that series, but I think if I had read it line by line I would have gone insane (at least in the first book). The key is to figure out what they're trying to teach in a particular section (for instance, a large chunk of the first book is really just trying to teach you recursion).
jgg··on Features That Give Lisp Its Power
I think that's why Lisp is pleasing in a mathematical sort of way. You start with your basic axioms, which are simple to understand. The real test, however, comes from your ability to build up from those axioms an elegant, abstract framework which gets closer and closer to describing your problem set. This is why smug Lisp weenies say that in other languages, you wrap your problem around the language whereas with Lisp, you wrap your language around the problem.

There's definitely a mindset behind building Lisp programs that makes it worth using, but sadly those benefits require lots of work to arrive at and are often buried in pages of elitist, manic-depressive drivel on certain newsgroups when trying to describe why someone should use Lisp.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →