HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jhatemyjob

62 karma · joined May 6, 2019

submissionscomments
jhatemyjob··on GTA 6 Developers Unionize
Ok so now you're lying. I never said that.
jhatemyjob··on GTA 6 Developers Unionize
I never said they are low skill. They just don't have their priorities straight.

Those QA teams, automation people, production, level designers, vfx artists, tech artists, character artists, 2d artists, prop artists, gameplay scripters, etc are doing all that work just to put some pretty pixels on a 14 year old's screen. There's very little value there.

jhatemyjob··on GTA 6 Developers Unionize
That is precisely my point, thank you. Yeah there's a few good ones like Undertale or (early 2010s era) Minecraft or Roblox or Garry's Mod but those are rare. Most of the games out there are the types like Pokemon which are more like a drug addiction.

So bringing this back to the "why don't game devs make boatloads of money like FAANG" it's because the vast majority of roles are being a scripter at Game Freak or Rockstar or whatever. I'm sure the engineers at Valve or Roblox or Epic Games are being treated very well because those companies actually provide value to people's lives.

Roblox to a lesser extent, but you get my point. I'd rather have my kid play Roblox where he might learn Lua scripting, than Pokemon which is just a complete dead end. Just look at what happened to Byuu and Hax. Or hell, even endrift with that weird unnecessary drama with Analogue. Many such cases. Not sure if you get those references. But the stories surrounding those people are why I stay far away from Nintendo stuff. And gaming in general.

jhatemyjob··on GTA 6 Developers Unionize
Funny you mention Pokemon. Have you been to a Pokemon regional championships recently? Take a good look at the average Pokemon player. You really think that hobby is adding value to their life?
jhatemyjob··on GTA 6 Developers Unionize
This, and also, if you just take a step back and think of the bigger picture, the work isn't valuable. There's a lot more value in pushing ads, a CRM, an email app, etc than keeping a 14 year old kid entertained.

I don't really buy the supply/demand argument everyone else is saying here. The end product just doesn't provide value to people's lives. The amount of effort you'd need to put in to provide value to someone's life through a video game is way higher than the effort you'd need to put into a productivity tool.

In fact, more often than not, video games provide negative value to people's lives. They're usually a waste of time at best. And at worst, addictive and carpal tunnel inducing.

jhatemyjob··on Claude Opus 4.8
I agree with your sentiment but I think a fairer comparison would be:

> Who is more valuable as individual, the owner of a watch factory in Vietnam or the guy who makes one watch a month in Switzerland?

With that framing, I'm not sure what the answer is. I suppose it depends on your priorities

jhatemyjob··on Elon Musk has lost his lawsuit against Sam Altman and OpenAI
True
jhatemyjob··on Elon Musk has lost his lawsuit against Sam Altman and OpenAI
Yep. Headline is clickbait. Never bet against Elon.
jhatemyjob··on New Nginx Exploit
Yes.
jhatemyjob··on New Nginx Exploit
Why not 302 instead?
jhatemyjob··on New Nginx Exploit
tl;dr If you don't use ngx_http_rewrite_module, you're fine

Honestly it's such a weird feature, if you're doing complicated redirects like this in nginx where PCRE is necessary, you should do it in your application code. And if you need speed use ngx_http_lua_module.

jhatemyjob··on Ti-84 Evo
Same. But I agree with the parent, I always got the vibe it was a giant racket between public schools and TI. Writing code for it was probably cool back in the 80s-90s but it's so dated now.
jhatemyjob··on Another Day Has Come
[flagged]
jhatemyjob··on Cal.com is going closed source
I mean it's not complete nonsense, but yeah, doing it for security reasons sounds like BS. I actually thought this was going to be about how AI makes it super easy for someone to steal all their code and fold it into their own competing project. I've seen a few open source projects get sideswiped by this, AI is pretty good at copying code (and obfuscating the fact that it was copied). I suspect that's the real reason but it doesn't sound as good. So they went with this half-truth.
jhatemyjob··on FBI used iPhone notification data to retrieve deleted Signal messages
I'm sorry but I'm having a really hard time understanding what you're saying. The first sentence I cannot understand at all. As for the second sentence, I think you might be confused about my usage of the term "Alphabet boys", which is slang for the intelligence agencies: https://youtu.be/lLf84LPzlVc?t=61 it seems like you thought I was referring to Google's parent company.
jhatemyjob··on FBI used iPhone notification data to retrieve deleted Signal messages
So in that case, the system has access to the plaintext, therefore the Alphabet boys have access to it as well. Unless, of course, you believe Apple isn't cooperating with them.

Am I missing something here? Maybe I'm missing a subtle detail.

jhatemyjob··on FBI used iPhone notification data to retrieve deleted Signal messages
I'm confused. You mean the iOS system notification would display the decrypted message in plaintext? Or do you mean the iOS system notification would display the encrypted message (i.e. it would be unreadable)?
jhatemyjob··on Cocoa-Way – Native macOS Wayland compositor for running Linux apps seamlessly
Good eye.
jhatemyjob··on Cocoa-Way – Native macOS Wayland compositor for running Linux apps seamlessly
You are correct. I jumped the gun there, a little bit.
jhatemyjob··on Cocoa-Way – Native macOS Wayland compositor for running Linux apps seamlessly
Gotcha thanks for that info. Yeah that's insane. You have to read the description of a YouTube video to understand what a project on Github is doing. There is no architecture here.
jhatemyjob··on Cocoa-Way – Native macOS Wayland compositor for running Linux apps seamlessly
This is definitely not worth using. It doesn't even say what hypervisor its using. Is it using QEMU? Docker? Podman? Lima? Colima?

And also this chart is super weird:

    Solution  Latency  HiDPI    Native Integration  Setup Complexity
    Cocoa-Way Low      Yes      Native windows      Easy
    XQuartz   High     Partial  X11 quirks          Medium
    VNC       High     No       Full screen         Medium
    VM GUI    High     Partial  Separate window     Complex
A standard VM will always be the easiest to set up by far. And latency should be the same across all 4. I mean after all it's a VM running on your local machine. Honestly I don't even know what it means when it says "Latency".

I also looked at some of the code and it's using OpenGL 3.3 Core which is... super old. But it makes sense in the context of this being LLM-generated since most of its training data is probably OpenGL 3.3 Core code....

Overall this project is very strange. It makes me feel more confident in my skills, AI isn't all that great. It's all hype. You can get to the frontpage of HN. And if you're Peter Steinberger you can get acquired by OpenAI for a billion dollars. But that's about it. The code isn't getting any better.

This reminds me of that C-compiler-in-Rust publicity stunt by Anthropic. There's no substance. It's just a headline.

jhatemyjob··on So where are all the AI apps?
And with the R&D that went into the Steam Frame, the difference between x64 and arm64 is becoming negligible. You can target x64 Windows and can reasonably expect it to run on Android via Winlator.
jhatemyjob··on So where are all the AI apps?
If it wasn't for NeXT and Valve we would still be in the dark ages. Linux sucked for gaming until Valve poured all that money into Wine.

I started with Windows 98. Didn't experience OSX until 2010. 9 years wasted.

jhatemyjob··on So where are all the AI apps?
Windows was so bad that it made the web bad. Imagine the world we'd be in today if Internet Explorer never existed.
jhatemyjob··on 1M context is now generally available for Opus 4.6 and Sonnet 4.6
Yep that's from the same comment I quoted. Decent chance it's not even a real person.
jhatemyjob··on 1M context is now generally available for Opus 4.6 and Sonnet 4.6
The people glazing these tools can't design systems. I have this founder friend who I've known for decades, he knows how to code but he isn't really interested in it; he's more interested in the business side and mostly sees programming as a way to make money. Before ChatGPT he would raise money and hire engineers ASAP. When not a founder he would try to get into management roles etc etc. About a year ago he told me he doesn't really write code anymore, and he showed me part of his codebase for this new company he's building. To my horror I saw a 500-line bash script that he claimed he did not understand and just used prompts to edit it.

It didn't need to be a bash script. It could have been written in any scripting language. I presume it started off as a bash script because that's probably what it started out as when he was exploring the idea. And since it was already bash I guess he decided to just keep going with it. But it was just one of those things where I was like, these autocomplete services would never stop and tell you "maybe this 500-line script should be rewritten in python", it will just continue to affirm you, and pile onto the tech debt.

I used to freak out and think my days were numbered when people claimed they stopped writing code. But now I realize that they don't like writing code, don't care about getting better at it, don't know what good code looks like, and would hire an engineer if they could. With that framing, whenever I see someone say "Opus 4.6 is nuts. Everything I throw at it works. Frontend, backend, algorithms—it does not matter." I know for a fact that "everything" in that persons mind is very limited in scope.

Also, I just realized that there was an em-dash in that comment. So there's that. Wasn't even written by a person.

jhatemyjob··on 1M context is now generally available for Opus 4.6 and Sonnet 4.6
Similar experience. I use these AI tools on a daily basis. I have tons of examples like yours. In one recent instance I explicitly told it in the prompt to not use memcpy, and it used memcpy anyway, and generated a 30-line diff after thinking for 20 minutes. In that amount of time I created a 10-line diff that didn't use memcpy.

I think it's the big investors' extremely powerful incentives manifesting in the form of internet comments. The pace of improvement peaked at GPT-4. There is value in autocomplete-as-a-service, and the "harnesses" like Codex take it a lot farther. But the people who are blown away by these new releases either don't spend a lot of time writing code, or are being paid to be blown away. This is not a hockey stick curve. It's a log curve.

Bigger context windows are a welcome addition. And stuff like JSON inputs is nice too. But these things aren't gonna like, take your SWE job, if you're any good. It's just like, a nice substitute for the Google -> Stack Overflow -> Copy/Paste workflow.

jhatemyjob··on John Carmack about open source and anti-AI activists
that's more or less what carmack said in the tweet in the OP, no?
jhatemyjob··on John Carmack about open source and anti-AI activists
> those were to allay fears of my partners to allow me to make the gift

I respect Carmack so much more now. I always scratched my head why he made Quake GPL. It was such a waste. Now it doesn't matter anymore. I so thankful copyleft is finally losing its teeth. It served its purpose 30 years ago, we don't need it anymore.

jhatemyjob··on Type resolution redesign, with language changes to taste
Yea, it's better to not feed the troll. I'm kind of shocked AndyKelley took the bait.
← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →