HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jijijijij

1,281 karma · joined February 7, 2023

submissionscomments
jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
That's what I thought, but I happens to coincide with the actual leakage, so....

What is bad UX is the fact there are two reply buttons in the iOS client. One "in" the mail and one for the thread. The mail one pretends to reply from HME alias, the thread one does not. This alone could expose you by accident, since anyone would expect to reply with HME in any case, but you get exposed either way.

jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
I am starting to think all these "privacy" features merely exist as excuse for getting people to hand off their mails to Apple. Clearly the all do not deliver on the intended functionality, but the proxy/relay routing happens to some extent anyway. How convenient. If you were a company promising its users all the privacy, but secretly not giving a fuck beyond collecting user traffic and meta data, wouldn't you expect the state of things to look exactly like that? I mean, how could you explain this any other way, considering the size of Apple and the relative ease of developing such features reliably? Apple is hardly breaking ground here.
jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
Can you comment on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48752294 ?

To me it seems, at least in this instance there is not even an exploit needed and the feature apparently is just broken beyond belief.

jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
> then the real mail gets disclosed in the mail source.

It's not just in the source, I totally overlooked the fact the real email address is shown as sender. Lol.

> Does the initial sender matter? Like if it’s the HME address that sends first and receives the reply? I have around 180 of these addresses.

Appears so. Here is exactly what I did:

1. Created the HME through mail, sending to other email service address (OMA). (This disclosed the information in my original comment.)

2. Did some reply ping pong. (No additional disclosure.)

3. Send a new email from OMA to above HME.

4. Replied from iOS mail client (UI showing usage of HME alias. Yes, I verified this multiple times not to make a fool of myself.)

5. Received at OMA, the real address is disclosed.

6. On the iOS client side, the mail shows up as sent from the real mail address, too.

Not sure if 1. for HME creation is required, you can likely skip straight to 3. for any HME address.

Funny enough, I observed 6. in the wild before, but was kinda hoping that's an artifact of forwarding a copy of the mail to the thread. I tested this some, but not this particular ping-pong. So yeah... I now gonna check where I evidently leaked my real mail address already...

jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
I think they are hinting at the ad hoc "use hidemyemail" feature within e.g. the mail client.

I don't know what I am doing, but from a quick test, the mail header is at least disclosing the internal recipient (mail@host.com) "translation address" (as mail_at_host_com_12345abc_12345abc@icloud.com) and an alias creation date. But the latter seems to be a unix timestamp related to the real address alias creation time and is identical between an hidemyemail mail and a normal one, so there may be already a possible information leak for correlation. Side note, it also seems like the sending hidemyemail server contains the unsuspicious name "junk_forwarder". Lol.

Disclosing an address as alias and particularly as throwaway alias (through the translation address and server) already seems kinda counterproductive to begin with, but I would bet you can use this information somehow to get the sender "translation address". Either by some API interaction, or by messing with the mail header scrubbing of the translation service somehow. A server named "junk_forwarder" may be a little more lenient about what to accept or not.

Edit: Can confirm the Reddit comment linked. You simply send an email to the HME address, reply from Apple mail client, and then the real mail address gets disclosed. Mind you not even hidden. It's shown as sending from the HME alias in mail, but I received the mail with the real address as sender......... Jesus fucking christ, Apple. Did you even test this a little?

jijijijij··on Apple 'Hide My Email' vulnerability reveals peoples' real email addresses
I think "real email" address is underselling it, since that's commonly the apple-ID, which is the gateway to some people's whole digital existence. Not to mention the fact, you tend to use hidemyemail in particular for services you don't want any identity leaked to. The "real email" may contain your legal name already.
jijijijij··on Founding a company in Germany: €9600, 152 days and I still can't send an invoice
> I was arguing that the cost of running a “cheap” UG is closer to the cost of running GmbH than running a LLC.

Then maybe you should have said that instead of talking about start capital... The mere difference between UG and GmbH is the start capital, so what's your expectation?

jijijijij··on Instagram is incorporating users' photos in ads for Meta Glasses
Yeah, and then the charging businesses start selling your stuff anyway. So really, it's the comic creator, who is naive.
jijijijij··on Instagram is incorporating users' photos in ads for Meta Glasses
Doubt. xcancel.com does not even seem to have any advertisements at all, when I disable ublock. Site seems remarkable clean, no thirdparty connections apart from a cdn. Sure you didn't type cancelx.com? Cause there something shady is going on. Otherwise, I would strongly suggest checking your extensions or system for malware.
jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
> Any advance could be dismissed as "case-specific", couldn't it?

and

> If by "counting" you mean the "counting r's" issue, that's a tokenisation artifact (the models are blind to individual characters): ask it to count in Python and it's fine (ie. reasoning is not the problem).

The problem is a lack of transparency. That's on the AI companies, not me. Everybody can attach a mathematics engine to an LLM and say "Look, it does math now!". The intelligence part hasn't changed though, the model didn't figure out mathematics, didn't get any closer to AGI.

I am also not saying, testing is impossible (making claims unfalsifiable), but you have to acknowledge it's inherently becoming harder to argue either way. Now, if I asked to count to 100 the LLMs deliver. I can even ask to count to 100 in base16. But it falls apart in less common bases like base33. The problem clearly isn't solved fundamentally. For counting in arbitrary bases you need a knowledge transfer and creative adjustment since you may exceed the symbol space. I think, this is also a good indicator because for the same reason there is no training material. Again, this can be addressed algorithmically, so this test is not futureproof.

Regarding character counting, the excuse about tokenisation is a bit questionable in this context, I think, because inherent limitations to the current approach is exactly the matter debated. Do we know, the extent of this particular problem space in the real world?

>What's something concrete that you would judge as a fundamental step forward?

I want reproducibility and transparency how a feature happened. If you threw a bazillion dollars onto Wolfram Alpha 15 years ago, you would also have a very useful tool for most questions. Spending a lot of money to implement edge case solution is not technological progress. That's always been possible. I mean, in the beginning there were thousands of humans curating chatgpt answers. That's not intelligence, just reckless spending, exploitation and borderline fraud. And it shows exactly how much "customer experience" can be delivered just by throwing money around.

> "Is progress efficiency per dollar decreasing" is a different claim to the earlier "is progress slowing?", though.

Well, I guess it is a matter of opinion. In my opinion, a "thermodynamic" perspective is useful. If you hire 100000 more workers to harvest a small field, you get it done quicker, but is it a breakthrough in farming? That is, trivially, if we spent more energy, resources, money we can expect to get more anything. However, those investments are not spent elsewhere, the progress of technological/scientific advancement is slowing down elsewhere. So, going by relative contributions to overall progress things are slowing down when progress is disproportionally low in an resource intense field. After all resources on Earth are limited and there is only so much sunlight refueling our energy supply. If the AI hype isn't panning out, the damage by hardware prices alone will be enormous. You need compute for more than AI and a lot of that is unaffordable right now. AI has to be 10X for every field, or it's gonna be a net global set back. Look at the volatility and social disruption in the US. It's a gamble, not covered by growth, but debt. Putting progression into relation to effort is required IMO.

> Measured hallucination rates have gone down, and don't seem to be an issue for achieving things, as per METR and other results. I don't see hallucination issues in practice as all real work I know about includes the ability to validate.

Are you in tech? Because I think there is a bias related to the above, since agentic AI can compile/run code to validate answers and most problems are documented ad nauseam. In my experience, if you search for very specific information in other sciences, you still frequently get confident non-sense. Outside of IT, you can't really have a "fact checking" co-routine, you need actual cognition. Of course, if you "chain AIs" things get a little better, but I claim again that's multiplying effort, not fundamentally making anything smarter. If we compare to biological intelligence, we absolutely do not see the same relationship. You may think this argument is moving the goal post, but if I ask you this: If we double the AI workload (eg. agentic AI) to get 10% better results, doesn't this sound like approaching a plateau to you? We are literally putting the fabric of civilization and humanity's future at risk for this (by social disruption, increasing energy/resource expenditure and not spending the money elsewhere in most critical times). Expectations must be high.

Anyway, thank you for expanding the argument, nice discussion.

jijijijij··on Why does kinetic energy increase quadratically, not linearly, with speed? (2011)
> The previous answers all restate the problem as "Work is force dot/times distance". But this is not really satisfying, because you could then ask "Why is work force dot distance?" and the mystery is the same.

...

> But now look at this in a train which is moving along with one of the balls before the collision. In this frame of reference, the first ball starts out stopped, the second ball hits it at 2v, and the two-ball stuck system ends up moving with velocity v.

That's still just pushing the problem elsewhere. Intuitively, why does the two-ball system end up with a velocity of 1v?

jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
It doesn't matter where we draw the line, or what someone else said at some point. I merely pointed out your argument wasn't a sound rebuttal. Criticizing subjective experiences to assess the situation is, but that cuts both ways.

> HN commenters have been saying that LLMs plateaued ever since the first ChatGPT release.

Your earliest example was 2 years after release, when LLMs were already widely used and there is literally a source to support the claim. Now, you need to show research efforts, time and resource investments, ... are producing proportional results, disproving diminishing returns. If there are diminishing returns, LLMs are plateauing.

Also, manual capability extensions, or use/edge case adaptations, which may improve subjective usability are not exactly advances in AI as technology. LLMs still hallucinate. LLms still fundamentally struggle with certain classes of problems (e.g. counting), but you increasingly need to come up with different problem dress-ups because of targeted interventions to manufacture hype and a limited supply of test cases. Can you make the case AI got actually more intelligent, fundamentally? That is, not an increase in case specific usability, but a decrease in fundamental limitations. And is this proportional to improvement efforts?

jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
"Otherwise". If the craftsman revenue isn't enough to recover the investment expenses, the business is operating at loss. But that's beside the point, because research investments are not the issue at hand.

As said before: Interference costs are not the only operational costs. Same as electricity costs for the craftsman. Running a power drill is not the the whole expense to consider. The craftsman has to eat, AI company's employees have to eat. The craftsman has to learn about new building standards, the AI company has to train their models because no one wants to use a product stuck in time (that's not "research", just maintenance). If not even interference was recovered in revenue, nobody would even start to argue about sustainability.

I can't debate this further, because HN is rate limiting my account for dissenting opinions in the past.

jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
Sorry, I don't understand what you are trying to say.
jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
> Just because there's time between big releases doesn't mean progress stopped.

No, but progress not stopping doesn't mean it's not plateauing. I believe 'plateauing' is understood as the process of approaching a plateau, not being stuck on a plateau already. So, the question is about the rate of progress, not its existence.

jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
Well, then you also have to assume higher expectations put on commercial offers raising operational costs. So, your objection really is a moot point.
jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
Great, but that's only a part of operational costs. A craftsman's revenue may exceed the electricity bill for the power drill, doesn't mean the business is sustainable.
jijijijij··on Why current LLM costs are not sustainable
Is this supposed to be some sort of gotcha? Apart from research and marketing, that's operational costs. I mean, every product could be cheaper, if you didn't have to pay for employees and means of production.
jijijijij··on Founding a company in Germany: €9600, 152 days and I still can't send an invoice
> UG forces you to pay 3-4.000€ per year on tax compliance.

Even in if that was true, the 25k€ difference remains (since the tax overhead is identical). Hardly what people would consider "a bit". Let's say the start capital is 3k€ for the UG and respectively 28k€ for the GmbH. That's almost a magnitude difference. And usually taxes become a challenge only when there is anything to tax or book. Are you "forced" to have a Steuerberater without revenue?

I am not even defending the situation. Just calling out your characterization.

jijijijij··on Founding a company in Germany: €9600, 152 days and I still can't send an invoice
> which a bit less start capital.

You may consider a capital stock of "at least 1€" even significantly less than 25k€. Not sure you are arguing in good faith.

jijijijij··on Did my old job only exist because of fraud?
German here, can confirm. Although, I don't think it's honest incompetence, but intentional corruption. Eg. public calls for bids tend to be a little too specific and politicians tend to get jobs where they funneled public money.

However, things are changing... As of this current government, nobody is scheming anymore. The corruption and wealth extraction happens openly. They are really testing the waters in what they can get away with. It's almost US level audacity, tho not yet as undignified. The sad part is, although people here are universally frustrated about it, they flock to the one party evidently more corrupt and incompetent than the CDU: The AfD.

Honestly, despite political disagreement, all my life I considered myself lucky to live here, but for the first time it makes me sick thinking about Germany's future, working here and paying taxes. And the base motives showing as reactionary malice by my fellow citizens disgust me. It's shameful to admit, but this country is truly ill and deeply corrupt.

jijijijij··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
Also dumplings, tortellini, Maultaschen, pierogi, ... Local pride across the globe, kinda boring around the world.
jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
Except when the technical capabilities prevent access??? Are you a troll?
jijijijij··on German ruling declares Google liable for false answers in AI Overviews
Quite frankly, in this very instance, Europe's slow tech adaptation and comparatively little investments are a blessing.

At this point, there is nothing to gain but volatility. Let the US figure out the economic and social disruption, and then adopt whatever sticks. There is no rush. The useful parts got little moat. It's not like there is a magnitude of difference to justify the expenses and risks of frontier operations, in comparison to open models, or smaller players. Chances are, all of this AI business will settle on local models for most use cases. The US may get their first trillionaire, but let's be real, that's not because of innovation but corruption, exploitation and raging wealth inequality. If the AI economy is not panning out as "projected", there is no recovery. That money got converted to heat and single-use hardware trash. Not worth risking pensions and the social fabric over "the tech edge".

jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
It's not about what I believe or not, it's about technical capabilities of the ID card.
jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
So, then why exactly do we need an alternative?
jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
Neither does the normal web. It became this way. The ability to run decentralized is not what is preventing enshittification.

I would argue eg. a LoRa based Reticulum network is enshittification resistant, because of physical bandwidth and range limitations. It enforces decentralization and abuse/advertisement/... inherently doesn't scale, is not worth the effort. It favors authentic, low reach human2human information sharing.

jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
The age verification with the EU ID card can be implemented without leaking any identifying information. If it's gonna be like that is questionable, but it's technically possible.
jijijijij··on Age verification for social media, the beginning of the end for a free internet?
But is it resistant to enshittification?
jijijijij··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
Putting the AI in cocaine, eh?
← PreviousPage 5 of 30Next →