HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jijijijij

1,284 karma · joined February 7, 2023

submissionscomments
jijijijij··on Are Tesla Gigafactory Berlin's days numbered?
We here are all guilty of this. Nobody is really aware of or grateful for all the things that enabled us to make a living.

Even if you are unloved, digging for gold with your bare hands, you were spared by people stronger, had people grow your food, teach you, build the streets, make your meds, literally deal with your shit all your life. And let's not forget the people who endured cruelty, suffered and died for your jeans and coffee...

(There are some great scenes in Pluribus, which illustrate this ignorance very well.)

jijijijij··on Are Tesla Gigafactory Berlin's days numbered?
You can't be a billionaire without pathology. The power, unlimited access to every resource, the inherent isolation, security implications, factual immunity to most consequences, morbidly twisted self-efficacy, the ethical dissonance of having it all while others starve... the human brain evolved adapted to scarcity and existential group boundaries to check on social pathology. These guys are holistically unchecked, inherently dysregulated on every axis. Their brain is constantly in an extraordinary, extreme state, trying to reach homeostasis for a life that couldn't be more distant, trying to find a model of reality which explains the abnormal signals it is getting.
jijijijij··on Are Tesla Gigafactory Berlin's days numbered?
I think this view is limited. Right now, we can clearly see ideological motivations beyond money in these billionaires. They are going for the crown, they want to reign.

Thiel, Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, they want to rule the world. I think Musk is just the least competent, most impulsive of them. Thiel is probably the most dangerous, who, besides being completely insane, is able to pull off the long con and can moderate his ego best.

jijijijij··on Are Tesla Gigafactory Berlin's days numbered?
Walmart learned 20 years ago, not everyone wants the American way of life. Guess, US hubris entails the inability to learn from such mistakes. Thanks for the factory.
jijijijij··on Are Tesla Gigafactory Berlin's days numbered?
> 1. Why Musk made such a hard-right turn politically, alienating most of his customers. People on the left were always far more likely to buy an EV than those on the right.

Additionally, I think, social-darwinistic libertarianism is not exactly the best ideological foundation for a Mars colony :D

jijijijij··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
I understand your use case and the benefit experienced, but quite frankly, I don't think that's easy to generalize or extrapolate to common problems justifying the expenses of this technology.

Having a compiler or any kind of easy, fast formalized "sanity" check is a huge privilege of coding work when it comes to AI usage, something missing in almost every other industry. But even in tech the full extent of such capabilities is rather limited to a few programming languages etc.. Outside of those, confidence in understanding, vouching for the output is limited without actually RTFM. I mean, move fast and break things, but I don't think the quality of knowledge gain is comparable to doing it the hard way.

Side note: I also think, prospectively, it's really bad, if pressure for efficiency on the tech stack used is reduced by making any mess seemingly manageable by AI interfacing (which is insanely inefficient and wasteful in someone else's backyard). Dev "pain" and productivity pressure are needed to improve ergonomics and performance, driving innovation. Why would nix improve, if it can be managed through a chat interface? Similarly, the whole human communication quirk of writing prose with each other becomes utterly meaningless, if expansion and compression of information is expected to happen through AI interface intermediaries anyway. A prose letter is formality and subtext of respectful human interaction, which becomes worthless/offensive, if done by a mindless machine. And if the need for prose vanishes, the AI overhead is fantastical, ridiculous compared to effectively sending the prompt information bits directly to the recipient (without expansion and compression in-between). Nothing makes me wanna scream more than LLMs talking with each other, no matter the language. That's just insanely stupid. If there is not value in formality and indirect communication, we can just cut that and use a trivially simple and amazingly efficient protocol for information exchange.

> _I_ feel like this goes into the overthinking territory. I think software and systems will still die by their merits. Same applies to training data. If bugs regularly make it to end users and a competing solution has less defects, I don't think the buggy solution will stay any more afloat thanks to AI.

But where is the training data coming from? I also think this is fallaciously extrapolating from prior tech innovation and questionable market narratives (considering the tech oligopoly). These models are not like lego, can't be tuned or adjusted like that, there is nothing linear about them. And if you spend all that investment money on manually fine-tuning answers, the tech itself does not warrant the cash, to begin with. That's not AI, that's just a lot of effort. The pyramids are also evidence of laborious human hubris and great expense, a sight to behold, but hardly a technological revolution with great ROI.

I don't think refeeding model degradation is comparable to bad human input as with autopilot (besides, as if that's actually working/solved :D). Thing is, frequency of faulty human information is probably rather constant, while AI slop is exploding, drowning available total human crafted content (again, the scenario is AI wide adoption). And that's not even considering unique feedback mechanism, not fully understood. Who is gonna put out handcrafted, thoroughly thought out training content anymore, when the skill of learning itself atrophied widely? And who is gonna do it for free? Or who is gonna pay for it, when you also have to pay for the absurd energy and resource expenses at some point? Keep in mind, AI, in contrast to human intelligence, does not gain functional understanding and relies statistical tricks from crunching stupid amounts of data. One thought-out piece of code sufficient for you to get cooking, means nothing to the machine. To train these things, you need massive input. Again, where is all that clean data coming from? How much are you willing to pay for an AI service to help you a little with nix?

If there was no refeeding degradation, we would have escape velocity and AGI. In that case, all bets are off and money becomes meaningless anyway. The expenses, the investments don't make sense. Nothing of this shit makes sense :D

jijijijij··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
> and can pick up unfamiliar ones quicker

Do you tho? Does "picking up" a skill mean the same thing it used to? Do you fact check all the stuff AI tells you? How certain are you, you are learning correct information? Struggling through unfamiliar topics, making mistakes and figuring out solutions by testing internal hypotheses is a big part of how deep, explanatory knowledge is acquired for human brains. Or maybe, it's been always 10,000 kilowatt-hours, after all.

Even, if you would actually learn different tech stacks faster with AI telling you what to do, it's still a momentary thing, since these systems are fundamentally poisoned by their own talk, so shit's basically frozen in time, still limited to pre-AI-slop information, or requires insane amounts of manual sanitation. And who's gonna write the content for clean new training data anyway?

Mind you, I am talking about the possible prospect of this technology and a cost-value evaluation. Maybe I am grossly ignorant/uninformed, but to me all of it just doesn't add up, if you project inherent limitations onto wider adoption and draw the obvious logical conclusions. That is, if humanity isn't stagnating and new knowledge is created.

jijijijij··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
For the life of me, I don't get the productivity argument. At least from a worker perspective.

I mean, it's at best a very momentary thing. Expectations will adapt and the time gained will soon be filled with more work. The free time net gain will ultimately be zero, optimistically, but I strongly suspect general life satisfaction will be much lower, since you inherently lose confidence in creation, agency, and the experience in self-efficacy is therefore lessened, too. Even if external pressure isn't increased, the brain will adapt to what's considered a new normal for lazy. Everybody hates clearing the dish washer, aversion threshold is the same as washing dishes by hand.

And yeah, in the process you atrophy your problem solving skills and endurance of frustration. I think we will collectively learn how important some of these "inefficiencies" are for gaining knowledge and wisdom. It's reminiscent of Goodhart's Law, again, and again. "Output" is an insufficient metric to measure performance and value creation.

Costs for using AI services does not at all reflect actual costs to sustainably run them. So, these questionable "productivity gains" should be contrasted with actual costs, in any case. Compare AI to (cheap, plastic) 3D printing, which is factually transformative, revolutionary tech in almost every (real) industry, I don't see how trillions of investments, the absurd energy and resource wasting could ever justify what's offered, or even imaginable for AI (considering inherent limitations).

jijijijij··on Hacktivist deletes white supremacist websites live onstage during conference
Certain views on human "races" are incompatible with intelligence. A highly intelligent individual may instrumentalize useful idiots through emotional and conspiratorial agitation, but they wouldn't be honestly convinced by these narratives themself. Not these days, there is too much scientific evidence to the contrary. The far right mob is easy to rule, if you can free yourself of empathy, dignity and honor. The people in power are not true believers, they are psychopathic opportunists.
jijijijij··on Hacktivist deletes white supremacist websites live onstage during conference
These power fantasies seem to be all you got going in your life. How often have you written/said "given the Maduro treatment" in the last 48h? Still feeling it?

Pro-tip from Germany: Don't make enemies in South America.

jijijijij··on Hacktivist deletes white supremacist websites live onstage during conference
Don't make up stuff, watch the talk: https://media.ccc.de/v/39c3-the-heartbreak-machine-nazis-in-...

(English translation available.)

jijijijij··on Hacktivist deletes white supremacist websites live onstage during conference
Illegal? Maybe. Wrong? Lol, no.

The site, and the extended media presence are full of hardcore racist statements not protected under the German constitution, not considered legal expressions of free speech here. If you have seen the talk, you'd know the site/owner has been investigated by the German inland intelligence agency (Verfassungsschutz), but due to incompetence they only got the wrong person fired... In fact, the "Q&A" intro to the deletion bit, references the executive's inaction.

Some information disclosure is also evidently in the public interest. For example the AfD representatives found are additional evidence for anti-constitutional sentiments within the AfD. This is highly relevant for a possible party prohibition process (which has an extremely high legal threshold).

After all, the website security was hilariously bad. (I suspect the members' IQ scores may have been largely self-diagnosed...) From what I've gathered the publicized data has been somewhat anonymized. The victims of this hack should be rather happy the original data got nuked.

Also good luck extraditing the activist. It's pretty clear the pink power ranger on stage is a borrowed body, and/or, I presume, the voice heard is AI or borrowed recording, as well. OpSec seems alright. But you know, these days, the president of the United States may personally order the NSA and navy seals to snatch the Martha Root off the streets to uphold the holy rule of law and freedom of speech/expression...

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
Get off your high horse. In this instance it's been a kid, and it does not concern some highly arcane flaw in a crypto library or chained kernel exploit, which may have passed even a pro. I already implied this bug should have been found by in-house security, so obviously it's within the domain of professionals and teenagers alike.

> The submission doesn't say they've even contacted Xitter.

This one doesn't. This one does: https://heartbreak.ing/. Or at least, I presume they meant Twitter when they wrote "one company valued 44 billion".

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
In an ideal world, these bugs, especially low-hanging fruits, shouldn't be discoverable by some random kids. These billion dollar companies should have their own security researchers constantly monitoring their stack. But those costs are cut, because the law de facto doesn't hold them liable for getting hacked. It's a very good deal for companies to pay bug bounties, but they mostly cheap out on that, too.

It's like a finders reward elsewhere in life. If you lost your wallet, your immaterial and material loss is quite high, but apart from cash the contents are of way less value for a finder/thief. These type of rewards are meant to manipulate emotions and motivation. Twitter paid these kids each between $1 and $20. That's insulting. As I said elsewhere, bug bounties are PR. And it's bad PR in this case. Black market pricing is the absolute low end for valuation (it's basically the cash value in the wallet example).

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
https://security.apple.com/bounty/categories/

The lowest tier is $5k. XSS up to $40k. I think we're talking exfiltration of dev credentials...

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
I wasn't aware they are gone. It's not my game, replace with whatever shady exploit trader/market out there.
jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
> That's not how any of this works.

Yes, evidently not.

Just because on average the intelligence agencies or ransom ware distributors wouldn't pay big bucks for XSS on Zerodium etc. doesn't mean that's setting the fair, or wise price for disclosure. Every bug bounty program is mostly PR mitigation. It's bad PR if you underpay for a disclosed vulnerability, which may have ended your business, considering the price of security audits/practices you cheaped out on. I mean, most bug bounty programs are actually paid by scope, not market price for technically comparable exploits. If you found an XSS vulnerability in an Apple service with this scope, I bet you would have been paid more than 4k.

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
That's a limited view. The damage this could cause should be accounted for. People don't have to sell shit, they could fuck things up just for the fun of it. That's something to consider, especially with a bunch of teenagers. Now, these big corpos didn't take the chance to sponsor and encourage these kids early careers and make this fuck-up good PR, at least.
jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
> Unfortunately a competitive rate agreed to in advance with a company before we do any pentesting is the only way we have ever been able to get paid fairly for this sort of work.

So, rough estimate, how much would you have made for this?

jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
$11k for the three of them in total! That's just bad PR.
jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
There are laws governing these scenarios. It's different everywhere. Portugal just updated theirs in favor of security researchers: https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/portugal-upda...
jijijijij··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
If a $500 drone is coming for your $100M factory, the price limit for defense considerations isn't $500.

In the end, you are trying to encourage people not to fuck with your shit, instead of playing economic games. Especially with a bunch of teenagers who wouldn't even be fully criminally liable for doing something funny. $4K isn't much today, even for a teenager. Thanks to stupid AI shit like Mintlify, that's like worth 2GB of RAM or something.

It's not just compensation, it's a gesture. And really bad PR.

jijijijij··on Valve is running Apple's playbook in reverse
> because Apple has been so thoroughly not-invested in gaming

Is Apple invested in anything at all right now? Seems like they are only ever iterating over the same products in their idiotically domain separated legacy zoo of devices. Lately even fucking that up with UI "innovation" literally everyone hates. I mean, who's talking about Apple VR anymore? Apple AI is a meme. What are they cooking with all that cash?

I don't think Valve has to even consider Apple.

jijijijij··on 'Ghost jobs' are on the rise – and so are calls to ban them
I am sure, you hold the employer to the same standards. For example disclosing salary range information beforehand, or writing rejection letters afterwards, so applicants going through the trouble of doing their part aren't wasting their time and energy.

Right?

jijijijij··on Gut bacteria from amphibians and reptiles achieve tumor elimination in mice
Cool story, bro.
jijijijij··on Gut bacteria from amphibians and reptiles achieve tumor elimination in mice
> But I was curious if there is working happening on L1 defence — fixing the enzyme that fixes the wrong copy paste mechanism. Or making the enzyme get more efficient and powerful. Is that line of thought even valid?

Mutations in general are not the defining quality of cancer. It's mutations in these very L1 safeguards. There are several such safeguards and a cell needs several mutations in those to become malignant. Eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P53

Correcting genes only works in certain conditions (e.g. limited single strand breaks), in a narrow time frame during cell division, safeguards rather trigger cell suicide, or if that fails they mark the cell for destruction by immune cells. A cell can't fix DNA which made it through cell division once, because it got nothing to proof-read against.

After the safeguards are gone, everything goes and genetic diversity increases quickly within each tumor. This diversity is what's making cancer treatment hard. At some point there won't be a shared vulnerability in all malignant cells. The repair mechanisms are working in favor of the cancer now. For example, with radiation therapy you preferably want to induce DNA double strand breaks, because cancer cells can't repair those. Otherwise you need to increase the radical burden enough to overwhelm repair, but migrating radicals may damage distant cells, too.

I presume you could hypothetically inject mRNA of a working safeguard gene (eg. P53) into all cells (at some point cancer cells can't be selected exclusively, since they lost identifying marks and present as stem cells), so the functional enzyme or transcription factor is forced to be built inside. I am sure people are trying this right now. However, the inner workings of cells on a molecular level are insanely complex and our understanding is only scratching the surface. As with P53, you have a transcription factor, which means it's modifying gene expressions elsewhere. It's only a small part of a complex regulatory cascade. I doubt there is a safeguard target, which can easily be injected without considering the precise timing and environment within that safeguard cascade in the cell. Of course, the rest of the safeguard system needs to be present in the cell to begin with. Mind you, you don't want to cause cell suicide in healthy cells, so you want to restore the function of whole selective complex.

Then there is the question of delivery. Can you deliver eg. the mRNA to every cell without raising suspicion of the immune system? With the COVID vaccine, the enabling breakthrough was the delivery vehicle, not as much the mRNA part. Can you even reach the cancer cells at all? Cancer cells are frequently cloaked, shadowed or cut of by senescent, or necrotic cells, or acquired unique ways of metabolic adaptations. A bit similar to bacterial persistence, like M. tuberculosis, which can evade bodily and chemical defenses for decades.

The take-away: Life is complex beyond comprehension! Despite simplifications taught in schools and reductionist zeitgeist, we actually know very, very little about what's going on in genetics and molecular biology, most medical knowledge is empiric guessing instead of explanatory understanding.

jijijijij··on AI will make formal verification go mainstream
> At the most basic level this means making sure they can run commands to execute the code

Yeah, it's gonna be fun waiting for compilation cycles when those models "reason" with themselves about a semicolon. I guess we just need more compute...

jijijijij··on SHARP, an approach to photorealistic view synthesis from a single image
I don't see any examples of a 3D scene information usable for simulation. If you want to simulate something hitting a table, you need the whole table (surface) in space, not just some spatial illusion effect extrapolated from an image of a table. I also think modelling the 3D objects for simulation is the least expensive part of an simulation... the simulation is the expensive thing.

I doubt this will be useful for robotics or industrial automation, where you need an actual spatial, or functional understanding of the object/environment.

jijijijij··on “Super secure” messaging app leaks everyone's phone number
No degree, just a kid with a Macbook Air.
jijijijij··on Roomba maker goes bankrupt, Chinese owner emerges
I was making a point about trust, not what to do about it. If you are American, you should worry about Americans spying on you, as that actually could have consequences for your life and there is well know evidence and a legal foundation to justify such worries.

As non-car owner, I also dislike the Tesla cameras around me. Maybe one solution would be to not have fucking cameras everywhere, if the owner's exclusive access can't be guaranteed, abuse can't be prevented and legal consequences are not enforced. Maybe there should be standards and certification.

← PreviousPage 10 of 30Next →