HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jillyboel

182 karma · joined November 12, 2024

Not a fascist, unlike some of you.

Hey Dang, maybe show the "You're posting too fast. Please slow down. Thanks." message before someone writes their comment? Or just fuck off with that shit?

submissionscomments
jillyboel··on Strings Just Got Faster
java hashcodes are just 4 bytes, there will always be collisions
jillyboel··on Anubis saved our websites from a DDoS attack
The point of a static cache is that your backend isn't impacted at all.
jillyboel··on Don't watermark your legal PDFs with purple dragons in suits
At least it wasn't a bad dragon.
jillyboel··on Anubis saved our websites from a DDoS attack
They'd also work if the bot, or another bot, hits that route before. It's a wiki, the amount of content is finite and each route getting hit once isn't a problem.
jillyboel··on Anubis saved our websites from a DDoS attack
a static cache for anyone not logged in, and only doing this check when you are authenticated which gives access to editing pages?

edit: Because HN is throwing "you're posting too fast" errors again:

> That falls short of the "meets their needs" test. Authenticated users already have a check (i.e., the auth process). Anubis is to stop/limit bots from reading content.

Arch Wiki is a high value target for scraping so they'll just solve the anubis challenge once a week. It's not going to stop them.

jillyboel··on Anubis saved our websites from a DDoS attack
The license explicitly allows you to make such changes. They could have picked a different license, but didn't.

> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the “Software”), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software

jillyboel··on Anubis saved our websites from a DDoS attack
> One thing that I've noticed recently with the Arch Wiki adding Anubis

Is that why it now shows that annoying slow to load prompt before giving me the content I searched for?

jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
Because they're getting paid tens of millions. same reason people join criminal organizations, really. the profit outweighs the potential downsides.
jillyboel··on Google Wallet launches new age and identity verification features (ZK proofs)
gross and blatantly illegal under dutch law. companies don't need a copy of my id. most of them don't even adhere to the law anyway and demand an uncensored copy. every time I follow the instructions from my government to blank out the BSN (SSN) the (usually american) company rejects it and demands an uncensored version they're not even permitted to have.

https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/identiteitsfraude/v...

Last time I checked Google isn't any of the following:

* a government instution

* a bank

* a notary

* a casino

* my life insurer

* my employer

https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/identiteitsfraude/v...

jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
So it's spam in the eyes of everyone who doesn't happen to subscribe to their service of choice? If they want to read an article through their news app they are of course free to do so, but why spam that link?
jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
You're posting on HN and you think regular websites are the "dark web"? Do you think HN is the dark web?
jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
> I never thought Apple would outright defy the courts to the degree they'd risk a prison term for the executives.

He probably got offered a couple mil for a slap on the wrist, he likely won't even be jailed for a day. Why wouldn't they lie? They have the money to get away with it.

jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
Other way around. Too big to fail and individual employees are too isolated from any consequences so they have no reason to give a shit.
jillyboel··on Apple violated antitrust ruling, judge finds
why do we want an apple link that just redirects to the original article? is this just "look at me i'm a mac user" levels of spam?
jillyboel··on Wyze pays $255k of tariffs on $167k of floodlights
It's just a few shell companies doing stuff. Good luck stopping them.
jillyboel··on Retailers will soon have only about 7 weeks of full inventories left
I'm in the EU and used to occasionally order stuff from the UK. Haven't since brexit, way too expensive now.
jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
> the harm is plagiarism

How is plagiarism harmful outside of an academic setting? Is it illegal? Who is hurt by it? In what way? Does this supposed harm outweigh the benefit it brings to the rest of society? And, mostly unrelated, why are you okay with bigtech doing it, but not a mere human?

Just admit you realized that you don't actually have an argument. It's a simple question, and you're not able to answer it.

It's okay to admit you were wrong. It shows growth.

jillyboel··on Retailers will soon have only about 7 weeks of full inventories left
This isn't even about how much of an asshole Trump is. It's about how he literally cannot string a sentence together.
jillyboel··on Retailers will soon have only about 7 weeks of full inventories left
I'm sure there are competent people whispering evil things in his ear, he appears very easy to influence. Just look at how he keeps flip flopping on Ukraine every time he talks 1-on-1 with Zelenskyy versus when he gets back to being surrounded by his cronies.

That doesn't make Trump any less demented.

jillyboel··on Retailers will soon have only about 7 weeks of full inventories left
Have you listened to the guy talk? There isn't a comprehensible thought in there, and there hasn't been for years. He's old, older than Biden was when he started his term, and probably suffering from dementia.

edit: The pro trump voting bloc showed up. Comment went from +2 to -3 in a minute. This chain will probably be flagged to death within the hour.

jillyboel··on Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies
What about literally every other application you download and install?

All your video games could be (and probably are if they include "anticheat") spying on you.

jillyboel··on What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Today's Adversaries
In Article III, Section 3 of the United States Constitution, treason is specifically limited to levying war against the U.S., or adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort.

Under U.S. Code Title 18, the penalty is death, or not less than five years' imprisonment (with a minimum fine of $10,000, if not sentenced to death). Any person convicted of treason against the United States also forfeits the right to hold public office in the United States.

jillyboel··on Sycophancy in GPT-4o
Most keyboards don't have an em-dash key, so what do you expect?
jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
> Right, because if one wrong thing is allowed, we should allow... Other wrong things.

Unless you think LLMs deserve more rights than actual flesh and blood humans, yes. Either that or get bigtech to stop what they're doing, but we both know that's not going to happen.

> Okay. Well I feel sympathy for the poor developers who put time into making a free open source tool that brought many people joy now having their work ripped off without credit because I guess it's okay if LLM training is legal for some reason.

If LLMs get to do it, so do humans. If humans don't get to do it, then LLMs don't either. Society has embraced LLMs and bigtech is not going to give up their new toy, so it has to become okay for humans, even if you think this is unfortunate.

> I mean, honest to God, how much rationalizing are we going to go through here?

The same amount as people go through to excuse legal bullying.

> It's okay because LLMs?

Again, humans deserve more rights than machines, not less. So apparently, yes.

> It's okay because it's free so that means plagiarism is fine?

Yeah. No one was hurt, not even financially. You can think it's distasteful, that's fine.

> Copyright licenses are "made up nonsense"?

Yup, only serves to make the rich richer anyway.

jillyboel··on I use zip bombs to protect my server
Which plugin?
jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
> This falls under the "two wrongs don't make a right" adage, I'd argue. (To clarify... I agree, at least insofar as LLM training is plagiarism.)

The argument is that so far society at large seems to have decided that what bigtech has done with LLMs is not wrong. Everyone is happily using it, pretty much every company is touting their new "AI" features, and lawsuits haven't gained any traction. So if it's not wrong for an LLM, I'd argue it's not wrong for a human, either.

> Personally, I do sometimes get upset about things that don't directly affect me, as the result of empathy, sympathy, and having principles. I think if you really think about you'd agree.

True, in this case I feel sympathy for the poor developers who put time into making a free open source tool that brought many people joy now being harassed over something as insignificant as a license dispute. It's all just made up nonsense designed to protect the big boys who can afford the fancy lawyers anyway.

The rest of the post is mostly about the legal angle where I'm sure you're right, but the main take-away is that these people did not really do anything morally wrong. It's just because of legal bullying that they have to be careful. So my distaste is aimed at those who perform the legal bullying and those who enable it, not at their victims.

jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
Alright, my point is that any harm done here is significantly less than what the bigtech LLMs are doing. If plagiarizing code is bad then so is both building & using LLMs. If building & using LLMs is fine, then so is plagiarizing code.

In this case there's a non-commerical open source project that ignored some other project's licenses. This isn't great, but it doesn't affect me, a third party, in the slightest. I have no reason to be upset about this. It doesn't really affect the other projects either, nor does it negatively affect our society. If anything it adds to our society by giving something people are clearly interested in having.

In the case of RTEMS the only thing they're missing out on is attribution. Nintendo isn't missing out on anything at all, people will still be buying their hardware to run this software.

So my argument is that any harm that may have been done is insignificant at best. Hardly worth getting upset about, especially as a third party.

As for the legal argument, it's hypocritical at best. If someone wants to condemn what happened here they should first go after the big boys who are making billions by doing the same thing on a massive scale.

> If you were able to use this algorithm to produce a representation of learned skills and knowledge, e.g. something lossy enough to be considered legally distinct rather than just a compressed form of the training data, then surely this would not be considered a derivative work of the copyright material used to train it. I think most people would agree with this.

If it's okay for an algorithm to do then it's okay for a human to do. So in that case copyright would be dead since the conclusion is you (or a machine learning algorithm) are allowed to ingest some content, then produce similar content.

A simple example is using an LLM to draw an image of some disney characters. If we say the LLM is allowed to do this because it learned to do so, which we aren't considering to be plagiarism, then why are human artists being sued by disney for doing the same?

Or in this case, let's say the original authors used an advanced LLM to assist their coding. The LLM once happened to ingest Nintendo's binary blobs during training and was advanced enough to learn from them. It uses this knowledge to produce code that can interface with the hardware which just so happens to look like the original code because that's just how you do it. Is it suddenly not plagiarism anymore? Did it become morally okay because the LLM laundered the code? Is this any different from LLMs ingesting all of github and becoming coding assistants? Why are we okay with that, but not when a human does it?

I know that in the end the legal answer is that if you have enough money you can do whatever you want, but this doesn't answer the moral questions.

jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
> Well, now I asked for yours, and I'm also still waiting.

I asked first and I don't want to influence your response. So, go ahead. You first.

If your only answer is that plagiarism is bad then I agree with that (in certain settings, such as education), but it's clearly no longer considered to be illegal (if it ever was?) or immoral. Just look at all the bigtech LLMs doing so while raising billions without getting into legal trouble. So apparently society has recently decided that this is fine.

jillyboel··on How a single line of code could brick your iPhone
As per the DMA if it's available to Apple's own apps it has to be available to third party apps as well. Of course apple will fight this tooth and nail so they can maintain their walled garden, making them billions per year.
jillyboel··on Libogc (Wii homebrew library) discovered to contain code stolen from RTEMS
I'm specifically asking you (and other HNers) what definition of harm you think applies here. I'm still waiting.

As for not condoning plagiarism, grow up. We're not kids in school anymore. You're (hopefully) an adult who graduated already.

If you're so against plagiarism, how do you feel about LLMs plagiarizing the whole internet? Didn't all the techbros collectively decide for us that this is the future we want?

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →