HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimbo808

724 karma · joined July 24, 2025

submissionscomments
jimbo808··on The American Missile Crisis
America isn't Ukraine, we are a *massive country with a nuclear deterrent,* wedged between two massive oceans and two friendly countries.

Nobody is going to attack us unless we go out into the world creating enemies.

jimbo808··on The American Missile Crisis
We could also just not start wars and we wouldn't need to worry about missile production
jimbo808··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
No, I'm implying that people who maintain their own cars do it more efficiently. The simple stuff like cleaning has to be done by someone. It's not about doing a "worse job," it's about doing a more expensive job.

Waymo is replacing human drivers with a capital-intensive fleet business, a substantially more expensive vehicle, and still a large number of remote assistance staff, fleet operators, safety engineers, incident response, operations staff, etc.

But I'm not saying they can't beat a human driver, I'm just saying it hasn't been proven that they will. It may only be that the highest demand markets will provide a sufficient enough utilization to make it economically viable.

jimbo808··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
I'm implying that drivers are more efficient at cleaning and maintaining, refueling, storing, repairing, and replacing their cars they own than the complex systems of personnel maintaining a much more expensive fleet of cars they don't own or give a shit about.
jimbo808··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
Not a valid analogy. At all.
jimbo808··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
Not comparable at all. Autonomous driving isn't obviously a viable business. It's not because computer programs can't drive well, it's because the and workforce infrastructure required to maintain and operate the expensive fleet may be less efficient than a human maintaining their own vehicle.
jimbo808··on Waymo pauses Atlanta service as its robotaxis keep driving into floods
The huge disadvantage they have over people is that their cars cost $250k, require a workforce of people to retrieve and repair them, maintain them, clean them, monitor them, etc. They are more expensive to operate than a normal car with a human driver, so far. The break-even point requires a lot of problems to be solved, and even then, the upside is not looking to be astronomical in the best case.
jimbo808··on Palantir employees are starting to wonder if they're the bad guys
As far as businesses go, I'd say Palantir finds itself somewhere between "extremely ethically dubious" and "overtly, transparently evil."
jimbo808··on Palantir employees are starting to wonder if they're the bad guys
It's a U.S. domestic surveillance operation, disguised as a defense contractor.

Or really, it's not disguised at all. The company is named after Tolkein's palantíri, so they weren't being shy about it.

It's a company that exists solely to exploit a loophole that shouldn't have been upheld, effectively eliminating the fourth amendment.

jimbo808··on Investigation uncovers two sophisticated telecom surveillance campaigns
Ha. That's what everyone thinks before they've needed the police.
jimbo808··on We found a stable Firefox identifier linking all your private Tor identities
Could be accurate but governments can be profoundly incompetent even with great capability at their disposal
jimbo808··on AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It
AI is massively asymmetric in its benefits, which are overwhelmingly concentrated among those with extreme capital, and the authoritarians they're aligned with.

The benefits for them include:

- replacing workers with lower quality (but good enough) AI solutions, which degrade the quality of nearly every product or service for the consumer, but not by enough to offset the labor cost savings

- mass surveillance at low cost, a way to take the absurd amounts of data humanity now produces, and use to subjugate them

- propaganda/deception/misinformation, a new vector for propaganda which people are naively inclined to trust. bonus points for the "flooding the zone" strategy which AI makes easier

Benefits to the worker:

- lower cost of goods and services (but not for you, silly - they'll still be taxing you via inflation to fund their wars of conquest)

- you won't have to work anymore

- you won't have to eat anymore

jimbo808··on Hollywood Enters Oscars Weekend in Existential Crisis
It's your point of view.
jimbo808··on Hollywood Enters Oscars Weekend in Existential Crisis
Maybe I'm insane or it's my age, but I can't watch new movies/shows without just seeing propaganda agendas at every turn. Really kills it for me.
jimbo808··on Yann LeCun raises $1B to build AI that understands the physical world
You're right that world models are the bottleneck, but people underestimate the staggering complexity gap between modeling the physical world and modeling a one-dimensional stream of text. Not only is the real world high-dimensional, continuous, noisy, and vastly more information dense, it's also not something for which there is an abundance of training data.
jimbo808··on Israel Strikes Oil Facilities in Iran
They can't really not talk about it, it's a world war unfolding. It's going to affect every person alive. But as much as it can be, it is absolutely being mitigated in traditional media.
jimbo808··on Homeland Security Wants Social Media Sites to Expose Anti-ICE Accounts
> until it's too late.

I'm afraid it's far too late.

jimbo808··on Sam Altman responds to Anthropic's "Ads are coming to AI. But not to Claude" ads
They already got a clear signal when they fired him. It's baffling that they did an about face when the red flags were all there.
jimbo808··on X offices raided in France as UK opens fresh investigation into Grok
It sounds better in the news when you do a raid. These things are generally not done for any purpose other than to communicate a message and score political points.
jimbo808··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
It's a pretty easy category to identify, some warning signs:

- You rarely write loops at work

- Every performance issue is either too many trips to the database or to some server

- You can write O(n^n) functions and nobody will ever notice

- The hardest technical problem anyone can remember was an N+1 query and it stuck around for like a year before enough people complained and you added an index

- You don't really ever have to make difficult engineering decisions, but if you do, you can make the wrong one most of the time and it'll be fine

- Nobody in the shop could explain: lock convoying, GC pauses, noisy neighbors, cache eviction cascades, one hot shard, correlating traces with scheduler behavior, connection pool saturation, thread starvation, backpressure propagation across multiple services, etc

I spent a few years in shops like this, if this is you, you must fight the urge to get comfortable because the vibe coders are coming for you.

jimbo808··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
Also, the assumption that you can do ___ thing (tests, some dumb agent framework, some prompting trick), and suddenly magically all of the problems with LLMs vanish, is very wrong and very common.
jimbo808··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
Internal tools do suck as far as usability, but you can bet your ass they work if they're doing things that matter to the business, which is most of them. Almost every enterprise system hooks into the finance/accounting pipeline to varying degrees. If these systems do not work at your company I'd like to know which company you work at and whether they're publicly traded.
jimbo808··on AI’s impact on engineering jobs may be different than expected
I have read this same comment so many times in various forms. I know many of them are shill accounts/bots, but many are real. I think there are a few things at play that make people feel this way. Even if you're in a CRUD shop with low standards for reliability/scale/performance/efficiency, a person who isn't an experienced engineer could not make the LLM do your job. LLMs have a perfect combination of traits that cause people to overestimate their utility. The biggest one I think is that their utility is super front-loaded.

If a task before would take you ten hours to think through the thing, translate that into an implementation approach, implement it, and test it, and at the end of the ten hours you're 100% there and you've got a good implementation which you understand and can explain to colleagues in detail later if needed. Your code was written by a human expert with intention, and you reviewed it as you wrote it and as you planned the work out.

With an LLM, you spend the same amount of time figuring out what you're going to do, plus more time writing detailed prompts and making the requisite files and context available for the LLM, then you press a button and tada, five minutes later you have a whole bunch of code. And it sorta seems to work. This gives you a big burst of dopamine due to the randomness of the result. So now, with your dopamine levels high and your work seemingly basically done, your brain registers that work as having been done in those five minutes.

But you now (if you're doing work people are willing to pay you for), you probably have to actually verify that it didn't break things or cause huge security holes, and clean up the redundant code and other exceedingly verbose garbage it generated. This is not the same process as verifying your own code. First, LLM output is meant to look as correct as possible, and it will do some REALLY incorrect things that no sane person would do that are not easy to spot in the same way you'd spot them if it were human-written. You also don't really know what all of this shit is - it almost always has a ton of redundant code, or just exceedingly verbose nonsense that ends up being technical debt and more tokens in the context for the next session. So now you have to carefully review it. You have to test things you wouldn't have had to test, with much more care, and you have to look for things that are hard to spot, like redundant code or regressions with other features it shouldn't have touched. And you have to actually make sure it did what you told it to, because sometimes it says it did, and it just didn't. This is a whole process. You're far from done here, and this (to me at least) can only be done by a professional. It's not hard - it's tedious and boring, but it does require your learned expertise.

jimbo808··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Forced? It's been a delight. I'd say if anything, I've only ever felt forced to use MacOS or Windows, never forced to use Linux.
jimbo808··on Adoption of EVs tied to real-world reductions in air pollution: study
Who could have possibly anticipated this?
jimbo808··on Nonviolence
As long as you pretend these didn't happen:

Iran (1953) - overthrow of the Shah by the CIA

Guatemala (1954) - overthrow of an elected government on behalf of US corporate interests

Cuba (1961) - invaded Cuba via proxy forces, attempted to assassinate Castro (Bay of Pigs)

Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia (1955–1975)

Chile (1973) – overthrow of Salvador Allende

Nicaragua (1980s) - overthrow the Sandinista government (Contra war) without international authorization

Panama (1989) - invaded and overthrew the government without international without international authorizationauthorization

Iraq (2003) - invaded and overthrew the government without international authorization

Serbia (1999) - airstrikes without international authorization

Libya (2011) - exceeded authorization by UN to effect regime change

Syria (2014–present) - US military occupation and oil seizure is ongoing

There are many more, these are the more notable ones

jimbo808··on Gaussian Splatting – A$AP Rocky "Helicopter" music video
A$ap Rocky's music videos have some really good examples of how AI can be used creatively and not just to generate slop. My favorite is Taylor Swif, it's a super fun video to watch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5URefVYaJrA

jimbo808··on The recurring dream of replacing developers
I think we massively downplay the experience and expertise required to ask the right question.
jimbo808··on The Influentists: AI hype without proof
Yep - no doubt that LLMs are useful. I use them every day, for lots of stuff. It's a lot better than Google search was in its prime. Will it translate to massively increased output for the typical engineer esp. senior/staff+)? I don't think it will without a radical change to the architecture. But that is an opinion.
jimbo808··on The Influentists: AI hype without proof
Humans are unreliable in predictable ways. This makes review relatively painless since you know what to look for, and you can skim through the boilerplate and be pretty confident that it's right and isn't redundant/insecure, etc.

LLMs can use linters and type checkers, but getting past them often times leads it down a path of mayhem and destruction, doing pretty dumb things to get them to pass.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →