HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimmytidey

939 karma · joined September 18, 2013

submissionscomments
jimmytidey··on Ask HN: Alternatives to The Economist?
One effect you might be experiencing is over-familiarity. I find magazines fascinating for a while, then you understand their house style, the quirks of the recurrent columns, their political stance, and you know what they are going to say even before you read. Even when they say the opposite of what you were expecting the reach their conclusion by travelling through territory you've been through many times before.

Weirdly, I've recently been experiencing this with Twitter. Every opinion unfolds mechanically. Even the curve balls are predictable at a statistical level.

jimmytidey··on Protect me from what I want
This is such a fascinating insight, I have not sufficiently considered how many people might be using the algorithmic feed.

The main problem I experienced with their 'curated' feed was that the news was so old. If I'm watching Twitter its because there is a news event happening.

So many times I'd see a tweet "Minister resigns!" and I'd think - "Another one, this is the end of the government!" only to discover Twitter has surfaced a tweet from 24 hours ago.

jimmytidey··on Protect me from what I want
Am I missing something? I have Twitter set to show the timeline of tweets as they happen, which although I accept it requires a deduplication algorithm is broadly non algorithmic.

I realize there is also another 'curated' timeline setting, but you can always switch it off.

There are all kinds of problems with Twitter, but I'm surprised to see so many people saying 'the algorithm' is one of them.

jimmytidey··on Rice’s Theorem: An interactive tutorial
It really is fantastic :)
jimmytidey··on Twitter users jump to Mastodon, but what is it?
I think there's a fair amount of 'status quo' bias here.

Mastodon isn't going to be a massively federated system that recreates every nuance of the Twitter UX.

It could still be a worthwhile alternative to Twitter. It would be nice if there were thousands of Mastodon servers, but perhaps a handful is ok. Mastodon has a slightly confusing user experience, but so was early Twitter - maybe that's ok too.

Whatever the downsides to Mastodon are they should be weighed against the benefits of moving away from Twitter, which are enormous. Irrespective of whether the Town Square metaphor fits exactly, Twitter hosts a massive amount of influential political discussion. Demonstrating that many users will stop using a venue for political speech if a billionaire gains unfettered control of it is an incredibly important precedent to set.

Mastodon doesn't have to be perfect, it just has to be a bit better than Twitter. I think it probably clears that bar easily.

jimmytidey··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
I think I'd take the opposite lesson from these examples: if an individual gets sufficiently powerful, they will change the constitution irrespective of how much you formally considered it an 'unchangeable bedrock'.
jimmytidey··on How the clipboard works
So essential - how often would I want the formatting in the obviously completely different context? I used to paste things into the URL bar to remove formatting. I've discovered a colleague does the same.
jimmytidey··on Write better error messages
This is a context where people are used to seeing errors that they don't know what to do with.

If a web app pops a well written error it is much more likely to be acted on than an unmotivated dev seeing a some (probably badly formatted) text.

Every time I see an error in terminal with a link to documentation I'm delighted. And surprised.

jimmytidey··on Noise cameras to be trialled in England to tackle ‘boy racers’
I think you might be forgetting what being a teenage boy is like! I think a noisy car is straightforward 'look at me' peacock tail behaviour.
jimmytidey··on Noise cameras to be trialled in England to tackle ‘boy racers’
I'm afraid I can't see this as freedom of expression, what idea are they expressing? If this is about freedom of expression, isn't fly tipping a type of expression that should be protected?

In terms of general freedom, the question is does it disproportionately affect others? The answer couldn't be clearer - where I live a single person cruising around in their modified vehicle can ruin the sleep of thousands of people.

In terms of the law, this is already illegal, all that's happening is the law is being enforced.

I'm responding to this comment because I think a lot of people have a similar, erroneous, reaction - isn't this just another freedom being taken away? In a way yes, but the costs to individual liberty are vastly outweighed by the consequences for those who happen to be near by.

And, of course, you can always modify your car and drive round a private race track, no activity has been totally prohibited.

jimmytidey··on Even after $100B, self-driving cars are going nowhere
You can have humans 'embark' and 'disembark' the freight, the same way we do now...
jimmytidey··on Even after $100B, self-driving cars are going nowhere
I think non-human payloads make more sense for virtually every kind of innovation:

-- Radically reduced safety margins, if the vehicle itself contains no humans.

-- You can often move cargo at any time of day or night, and therefore do a much more sophisticated job of collaboratively load-levelling traffic.

-- Doesn't matter how uncomfortable a non-human payload is with in reason. Acceleration, cornering, waiting, daylight, motion sickness are all constraints that are eased for cargo.

-- It would be nice if you can move freight anywhere, but even if you can only serve a very limited network its still useful - say between fixed points in major cities. By contrast, a car that can't go almost everywhere is very severely limited.

Example: in major cities, all the freight moves in lorries, which are extremely dangerous and polluting. Meanwhile, the humans are packed into trains in underground tunnels. Surely freight should be moving in autonomous underground trains and the humans enjoying lorry free surface travel?

jimmytidey··on Call for Participation to Chaos Computer Club’s 37C3
CCC often reveals new software vulnerabilities. I don't know if it's deliberate, but if they reveal those vulnerabilities at Christmas, they ruin the holiday of whoever is responsible for fixing them - quite likely someone working for a big corporation.
jimmytidey··on The Crimean Bridge Is on Fire
Trent Telenko also has some fairly unconventional opinions about electoral fraud in the US which, for me, cast his opinions in a different light.

He's entertaining but it's always a bit unclear what his specific expertise is.

jimmytidey··on Ask HN: Ads triggered by WhatsApp “end to end encrypted” messages?
How do you know you have picked the topic at random? Maybe you've subconsciously seem adverts for that thing and that is why it is salient to you. Once you write it down, it becomes actually conscious and you start noticing the ads.
jimmytidey··on The Disaster of Superstition in Nutrition
I'm open to being wrong, but it seems highly unlikely a requirement for being healthy is drinking half a litre of milk a day.
jimmytidey··on Things people blamed on bicycles
What is the point of the traffic signals? A big part of it is safety.

I promise you, no matter what cyclists are doing at red lights, cars are orders of magnitude more dangerous than cyclists.

Cyclists should obey the law, but people focusing on cyclist skipping red lights are missing the point: cars kill people, cyclists don't.

Moreover, if a cyclist causes an accident, they will almost certainly be seriously injured even if they hurt others too. Meanwhile, car drivers can expect to walk away from any low speed accident, even if they just plowed through a crowd of pedestrians.

jimmytidey··on Things people blamed on bicycles
The pattern:

-- A car squeezes past you at high speed -- Less than 30 seconds later I pull in front of it as we both stop at a red light.

In fact, a car coming too close and knocking you off your bike is not a common cause of injury. It certainly makes cycling unpleasant though.

40% of non-cyclists in London say the danger of cycling is a significant factor in their decision not to cycle.

jimmytidey··on The Ends of Education
I have a PhD from an arts university.

My impression was that arts eduction is generally an exploitative scam. As someone (Grayson Perry?) said, they teach all of the stuff you can't learn and none of the stuff you can.

You'll spend 100% of your time trying to develop an 'art practice', which is very likely to entail staring into the middle distance for most your course, or perhaps half reading some philosophy books (preferably ones with no agreed interpretation, so no one can tell if you've actually read them or not).

Meanwhile, you'll spend 0% of your time learning the durable skills you'll need to have a career - varies of by context, but project management and the technical skills for whatever your medium is would be useful.

They whole sector is obsessed with constantly reasserting its moral superiority - "artists are the enemy of dictators" etc. - while studious turning a blind eye to the fact that nearly all the students are hopelessly ill equipped to do anything when they graduate.

I could go on - but the culture of UK arts institutions is hopelessly broken in my view.

jimmytidey··on UK's largest tunnel cutting head lowered into its London shaft
HS2?

I understand your vibe though.

jimmytidey··on Cat gap
What are flying squirrels if not an in between state rodents evolving to fly?
jimmytidey··on Eating horsemeat in France
Fantastic title
jimmytidey··on ‘A massive betrayal’: how London’s Olympic legacy was sold out
Lots of (formerly) less affluent people owned houses in the area and now live close to much better facilities than they did before.

Nothing 'yuppie' about a nice park, Westfield shopping centre or a train station?

jimmytidey··on 10 Years of Meteor
I built a project that supported my PhD in Meteor.

My memory of it is that Meteor is fantastic, but Mongo is a nightmare.

I spent hours carefully designing my database so I didn't need joins and adding indexing, but it never ran as fast as unoptimised MySQL, and had vastly less functionality.

Mongo was literally all hype - I find it impossible to imagine the use case. A salutary lesson in how rubbish the latest fashionable thing can be.

jimmytidey··on Bolt has a cool web interface and they really don't want you to use it
How do you know that people use the app because they are already highly committed to the service, rather than the other way around? IE, the whole thing is a selection effect?
jimmytidey··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
Your broader point might be correct but an anti tank grenade would not be likely to knock out a modern tank.
jimmytidey··on EU vote to ban all sales of combustion engine vehicles by 2035
I absolutely understand the appeal of ic cars, and (I assume), everyone will still be able to hear an engine roar at a race track or other private space.

Engines roaring in a city might be nice for some, but for most it's just noise pollution, particularly offensive noise pollution at that. The lack of noise will be a huge benefit to electric cars.

jimmytidey··on The White House’s weirdly hip record collection
I take this back - I'm surprised to see Trump has expressed quite a few opinions about music: https://www.bbc.co.uk/music/articles/e5e4572a-0676-4120-9eb3...
jimmytidey··on The White House’s weirdly hip record collection
I've always thought 'apart from the national anthem, what your favourite song' would be an insightful interview question for Trump - I guess because it's so hard imagine him with a hobby that isn't about power.
jimmytidey··on Parking kills businesses, not bikes or buses
I have a theory: small shop owners are disproportionately likely to be car drivers, and when they say parking is essential for their customers, what they are really worried about is measures that will make it less convenient to drive them selves.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →