HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimmyvanhalen

25 karma · joined April 8, 2012

submissionscomments
jimmyvanhalen··on Apple responds to NYT: "We're among top payers of U.S. income tax"
How about China and India.
jimmyvanhalen··on Apple responds to NYT: "We're among top payers of U.S. income tax"
what is immoral or unethical in paying less taxes? The corporate and personal tax rates in Germany and Belgium are higher than the US. Are Germans or Belgians more moral or ethical than Americans?

Apple pays billions in taxes, will pay billions in dividends to shareholders (which goes to retirement/pension funds, universities, charities, etc.), employs thousands (the employees pay taxes), donates to charity, etc. They created an Apple ecosystem that spurred thousands of developers and start-ups to build apps, etc. which in turn created more jobs, taxes, etc.

Are those not ethical or moral to you?

jimmyvanhalen··on Apple responds to NYT: "We're among top payers of U.S. income tax"
what they're doing is legal so what's you're problem?

Apple pays billions in taxes, pays dividends to shareholders, employs thousands, etc. if you're not happy with that, maybe you should move to countries with higher corporate tax rates, i'm sure they have a better/bigger economy than the US (they don't, take a good guess why.).

jimmyvanhalen··on Apple responds to NYT: "We're among top payers of U.S. income tax"
if you're the CEO/CFO and you're not looking for every legal way to maximize shareholder value, then you're not doing your job.
jimmyvanhalen··on Jonathan Schwartz says Google's Android didn't need license for Java APIs
..and yet when Oracle's lawyers noted that Schwartz "wasn't talking about Sun's legal position, but rather its business agenda." Schwartz said he was not a lawyer and therefore not an expert in copyright, patents and license agreements. Schwartz also said "I'm there to define our business strategy -- not to write our contracts."

Here's the main thing about his testimony: Schwartz "endorsement" is not a license agreement or a permission to break copyright/patent laws.

Edit:

and if you look at Jonathan's blog post it clearly says in the header "JONATHAN'S BLOG".

jimmyvanhalen··on Google (Potentially) Blows the Door Off Oracle's Copyright Claims
Judge Alsup: "It is my job to decide whether or not the copyrights on the computer programs do or do not extend to protect the structure, sequence and organization of the code of the programs. I will not be able to decide this question until after your verdict. For purposes of your deliberations, you must assume that the copyrights do cover the structure, sequence and organization of the code."

http://www.fosspatents.com/2012/04/oracle-and-google-comment...

jimmyvanhalen··on A $20 Trillion Rock That Could Turn a Startup Into Earth’s Richest Company
this is easy. someone call Bruce Willis.
jimmyvanhalen··on Google (Potentially) Blows the Door Off Oracle's Copyright Claims
New development: The judge plans to inform the jury that structure, sequence and organization of Java APIs are copyrightable.
jimmyvanhalen··on Jonathan Schwartz says Google's Android didn't need license for Java APIs
Here's news to you: The Judge plans to inform jury that structure, sequence and organization of Java APIs are copyrightable.
jimmyvanhalen··on Jonathan Schwartz says Google's Android didn't need license for Java APIs
Schwartz also said 30 min. prior.

Schwartz said his blog post was like a press release, an official Sun statement, but there was a lot left unsaid.

"We didn't like [what Google was doing with Android], but we weren't going to stop it by complaining about it," Schwartz said, explaining that Google could have chosen to work with Microsoft, a major competitor for Sun, or an open-source Java implementation. "At least with Java they could be part of the Java community," he said. Without the Java community, Google would have to "reinvent a whole community," Schwartz said.

And a few months ago the Judge said this...

Sun offered Google a three-year, "all-in" royalty license for Java for $100 million, which Google rejected, Van Nest said. The offer was made when Google was just starting Android's development.

But if Google tried to negotiate a license for Java, Alsup asked, doesn't that show Google knew it was going to infringe Sun's patents all along?

"Tell me why there's not wilful infringement here?" The Judge asked.

http://www.networkworld.com/news/2011/072211-google-sun-offe...

jimmyvanhalen··on Jonathan Schwartz says Google's Android didn't need license for Java APIs
1. all versions of BSD prior to 4.3 BSD(?) incorporated proprietary AT&T Unix code and were, therefore, subject to an AT&T software license.

2. Google's chief Java architect: it's 'likely' I copied Sun code found in Android, 'I'm sorry' if I did

http://www.theverge.com/2012/4/19/2961128/google-chief-java-...

If Oracle can prove that Google willfully broke Sun/Java copyright and license, Google needs to pay up.

jimmyvanhalen··on Jonathan Schwartz says Google's Android didn't need license for Java APIs
testimony of Sun co-founder Scott McNealy essentially nullified everything said by former CEO Jonathan Schwartz less than 30 minutes prior.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1001_3-57422366-92/oracle-turns-to...

1. McNealy affirmed to Oracle counsel David Boies that Java was "extremely valuable" to Sun and that it involved "lots of intellectual property."

2. Going over the restrictions that Sun had in place through licensing, McNealy explained that the "most important one, with respect to Java, is to maintain compatibility because that was one of the most important value propositions that we offered."

3. In an effort to null the testimony the jury heard from Schwartz less than 30 minutes prior, Boies asked if it was ever Sun's policy to allow any company to implement an incompatible version of Java so long as they didn't call it Java. "I don't recall that was ever a strategy that we pursued nor allowed in the marketplace," replied McNealy.

4.When asked if he saw Schwartz's November 2007 blog post (now a notable piece of evidence bounced around by both sides to their own -- but different -- advantages in this case) praising Google's announcement of Android.... McNealy asserted that it was company policy that those kinds of blogs were not corporate, but rather personal.

5.Boies asked about if allowing an incompatible version of Java to exist on the market would adversely affect Sun's economics. After a long explanation, McNealy finally said it would have a "negative" effect. "It was a very clear corporate strategy for the Java platform to stay compatible," McNealy said.

jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
the "random punk" is probably a swimming coach ;)
jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
>It's that the venture business is a business that scales mostly with people.

I agree which is why I brought up the topic of management fees and carry. You need them both to pay for additional people in order to scale your business. (which you addressed in your other comment).

jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
Thanks for the clarification.
jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
Having capital to invest in more start-ups reduces risks and increases the chances of the VC earning bigger returns. In order to invest in more start-ups, the firm needs top-notch people (partners, associates, etc.).

1. The best people are not going to join a firm that's giving away 50% of their management fees and carried interest income.

2. Not enough people & capital means

-Less investments, therefore more risks and less return.

-Less due diligence and monitoring of portfolio companies (again more risks)

-investors hate risk and low returns

jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
the money they make for their LPs goes to pension funds, universities, businesses, etc. which in turn creates more jobs, start-ups, investments, donations to charities, etc.

If you're going to donate to charity, do it personally and without all the media hype.

jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
it's not foolish. it's just not the most efficient way to spend capital. look at it from the point of view of the LPs. A VCs job is to deploy capital and maximize return to it's investors. they should reduce their management fee and carried interest income, and give them back to the LP, or re-invest them and fund more start-ups/create more jobs.

My opinion on this would've been different if they said "I am personally giving 50% of my money to charity in perpetuity..."

jimmyvanhalen··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
clearly a PR ploy. it's a waste of capital imo. Reduce your management fee and carried interest income and return them to your LP. or re-invest that capital in start-ups to create even more jobs.

edit: it's their money and what they do with it is their business. but they're in the venture capital business, not in the charity business. their job is to deploy capital and maximize returns to their investors (they create jobs and companies in the process).

Horowitz shakes off the potential for such troubles at Andreessen Horowitz, saying that half of firm earnings will be more than enough to satisfy its partners' lifestyles. "We don't play polo," he says. "And our skills are better suited for doing this than working full-time at a non-profit... I think this works out better for both us and the nonprofits."

Again: If they think they're earning too much. reduce their management fee and carried interest income and return the money to their LPs.

jimmyvanhalen··on Apple Q2 2012: 35.1M iPhones, 11.8M iPads, 4M Macs, and 7.7M iPods
> This qarter only includes two weeks of the sale of the new iPad.

good point.

jimmyvanhalen··on Apple Q2 2012: 35.1M iPhones, 11.8M iPads, 4M Macs, and 7.7M iPods
comparisons are always yoy. comparing the current quarter with the previous quarter doesn't make sense due to seasonality (holiday season, summer, etc.).
jimmyvanhalen··on Microsoft comes to Facebook's aid with 550 patents
it's a pre-emptive strike to anyone who's thinking about suing Facebook.
jimmyvanhalen··on Instagram
Elon Musk's first start up was called Zip2. Only after selling Zip2 was he able to co-found Paypal, Tesla, SpaceX, etc. if it werent for Zip2, a online publishing company (which could've been used posting cat pictures), there wouldn't be a Paypal, Tesla or SpaceX.
jimmyvanhalen··on Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrightable, not the jury
According to Joshua Block, Google's Chief Java Architect. (slide 62 and 63)

“I find it very rewarding to design great APIs and have people come to me years later and say, wow, you know, the collections framework changed my life.”

"API design is a noble and rewarding craft"

"API design is tough"

jimmyvanhalen··on Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrightable, not the jury
According to Joshua Block, Google's Chief Java Architect. (slide 62 and 63)

“I find it very rewarding to design great APIs and have people come to me years later and say, wow, you know, the collections framework changed my life.”

"API design is a noble and rewarding craft"

"API design is tough"

Also, according to Andy Rubin (slide 73)

“Ha, wish them luck. Java.lang api’s are copyrighted. And Sun gets to say who they license the tck to, and forces you to take the ‘shared part’ which taints any clean room implementation.”

According to Google employee Bob Lee (Slide 72)

Q. Did you consult the Java docs when doing your work on the API implementations for Android?

A. Yes.

Q. Okay. And where did you obtain those Java docs?

A. They’re posted for free on Sun’s website...

Q. Did you observe any copyright notices on the specifications?

A. Yes.

jimmyvanhalen··on Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrightable, not the jury
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2403292,00.asp

Under questioning from Oracle lawyer Michael Jacobs, Reinhold contended that "each page of the [Java] language specification includes a copyright notice,"

"Page, 39, testified over the course of two days, claiming that Google only used elements of the Java programming language that are freely available in the public domain. But after being admonished from the bench for evasive responses to Oracle questioning, the Google CEO finally admitted that his company never obtained a license to use Java code in its own software."

jimmyvanhalen··on Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrightable, not the jury
In related news:

Google-Sun court docs reveal long Java licensing dance

For more than five years, Google sought to license Java or acquire rights to the language before Sun got into the hands of Oracle or IBM.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-57417898-94/google-sun-cour...

jimmyvanhalen··on Google's opening slides in the trial v. Oracle
>Their contention is that they don't need one. Besides, they don't use Java- They use Dalvik and a JVM bytecode-to-Dalvik translator.

Google's lawyers are going to have a hard time convincing the jury.

Check out Oracle's slides.

http://www.oracle.com/us/corporate/features/opening-slides-1...

slide 90:

What Google Said Before Lawsuit

Jul 26, 2005: “Must take license from Sun”

Oct 11, 2005: “We’ll pay Sun for the license and the TCK” “We are making Java central to our solution”

Feb 10, 2006: “helping negotiate with my old team at Sun for a critical license”

Mar 24, 2006: “Java.lang api’s are copyrighted”

Sept 28, 2006: “Leverage Java for its existing base of developers”

Nov 6, 2007: “Is Android Java compatible?...No.”

Nov 17, 2007: “Scrub out a few more J’s”

Mar 24, 2008: “Please don’t demonstrate to any sun employees or lawyers”

Aug 5, 2009: “How aggressive do we scrub the J word?”

Aug 6, 2010: “technical alternatives…to Java for Android…suck” “we need to negotiate a license for Java under the terms we need”

Oct 13, 2011: “Android is hugely profitable”

jimmyvanhalen··on Google's opening slides in the trial v. Oracle
how about slide 52.

Dick Wall: Can we demonstrate the tooling, emulator, dev environment, etc.?

Andy Rubin: Yes, one-on-one only please, where you know exactly who you are talking to. Please don’t demonstrate to any sun employees or lawyers.

yikes.

jimmyvanhalen··on Google's opening slides in the trial v. Oracle
-Google has to prove and convince the jury that they obtained a license or a legally binding agreement to use Java. So they need to present evidence that they have those. Any statement from an employee, even from the CEO, is useless if there are no legally binding contract or license.

-Oracle only has to prove and convince the jury that Google willfully and knowingly ignored required licensing agreements. So they can present emails and quotes from employees and executives and the emails alone can do a lot of damage.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →