291 karma · joined March 18, 2019
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jimzhou; my proof: https://keybase.io/jimzhou/sigs/5542hVA_DUqiel7JlfbKdp9gWCY9XNaLMiMgRaQf0ZQ ] wonderfuldev_jn85tk9qvounx4pq2bpjmixw
I think there are probably some very talented solo operators who did their homework and have contingency plans and have OPSEC down who are able to pull off some long running schemes that may never be uncovered, just knowing the points of failure in th processes I've seen, but the amount of specialized knowledge and discipline required is going to be comparable to what's required to succeed in almost any field. Except for the very few at the top of the chain that nobody knows about, most people are better off getting a real job instead.A lot of those people who engage in fraud do it and get caught because ths isn't what they wanted to do butout of necessity, greed, or shortsighted assumptions they opportunistically engaged in the scheme. The internet does enable, I believe, single individuals to commit long term fraud operations as effectively lone-wolf actors whose necessity to employ a service offered elsewhere can be effectively done anonymously, and these are the dedicated, professional, and sometimes sometimes ideologically engaged types whose choice to engage is a long-term project and the sheer amount of knowledge in divergent fields of expertise required makes me wonder that if it wouldn't be better served to actually run amnesty programs to get these people into the legitimate sector even as consultants if not corporate jobs because our retributive criminal justice system renders that basically impossible. A bug bounty for fraud, perhaps? Just a thought.
There's a lot of fraud, waste,a abuse, or other chicanery in the courts and luckily in my experience they're never simply kept hidden without anyone noticing. The problem is always redressability. So much of the system requires discretionary rulings but the laws that dictate how we handle misconduct is heavily skewed in favor of the state if they ar a party and fails to take into account the urgency in resolving these cases that very often it becomes obvious that there's fraud, yes, but there's no redressability, and therefore there's no real punishment.
A particularly egregious case of falsifying evidence and using prtextual reasons to elicit false testimony and racially-based jury selections is the US v. Flowers case in the Supreme Court last term. There's a podcast on it, but the decision itself is... excoriating to say the least as to how far and how egregious the conduct was to try to execute an innocent man. It's discovered all right, but there's no punishment. So courts can and do definitely figure out fraud pretty readily, but when it comes to doing anything about it, victims not on the side of the state frequently find it cold comfort.
However, the very scenario is covered generally by statute already. Regulations, even copyrighted ones adopted by an agency, must be publicly accessible to have the force of law. Freely accessible in most cases relate to having physical access to the text in some free way. This seems like something that can be solved very simply on the state level: just redefine publicly accessible to publicly accessible on the internet.
"Guest workers" was effectively the de facto system of how ostensibly undocumented immigrant workers operated in America prior to the militarization of the border from the 70s to the 80s that effectively removed the option of having laborers who would work in America but reside in Mexico with their families during the winter, which is a major cause of why this whole "illegal immigrants moving to America crisis" even exists. So under this current regime, part of that idea is restored, because, frankly, the old model was fairly effective.
However, this kills one of the most necessary elements of, well, capitalism, which is that the workers would need some measure of bargaining power in terms of wages. The current scheme takes away that by tying one's ability to reside and work in a country to a particular employer, which turns into a somewhat more charitable version of indentured servitude. Why are these workers paid less than American workers? Because they can't negotiate for higher wages without getting booted. So it's fixing a problem that's self-inflicted except effectively turning it into quasi-indentured-servitude, as the H2 program comes with a long history of reported abuses, which surely only represents a minority of actual abuses.
And you can't adjust status to anything permanent in the end, so it may even be worse than indentured servitude.
Coming from Trump, as well, I wouldn't believe a single thing he says regardless so this could all just be a mirage anyway, but ultimately the reforms needed needs to actually work on a level that liberalizes a lot of the restrictions that have no benefits and are in fact holdovers from far more explicitly racist policies of old (there's still a chapter in the US Code specifically titled "Exclusion of the Chinese" for crissakes). Without that, all these stopgaps are just putting bandaids on gunshot wounds.
This is really poorly thought out and in practice, impossible to enforce. This is clearly shoehorning a civil case framework into the criminal justice system.
"Negligently permit or fail to prevent" is the sort of clause that would almost inevitably end up hitting founders engaged in any sort of company that deals with personal data. Larger companies can simply fall back to delegating the security issue to a non-executive. At that point proving negligence becomes incredibly difficult.
"A violation of law that affects data" is also ridiculously broad. Currently, CFAA is already overbroad and assigns criminal liabilities to far too many potential acts that simply couldnn't have been imagined in the early 1980s. Any unauthorized access that sees records falling into the many categories stated and amounts to 1% of a state's population, which could be a few thousand rows, would somehow subject two people to imprisonment potentially.
And of course, how would this even be enforced? A company can simply change its terms and conditions to allow for information disclosure, and selling or giving away things certainly isn't illegal. This would immediately shift the onus back onto the one accessing the data, who also has no reason to report or cooperate.
If anyone actaully suffers a quantifiable injury, just sue. Warren clearly haven't been practicing criminal defense or having been a prosecutor for quite some time because this sort of statute is the sort that both sides get headaches for.