HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jiriknesl

165 karma · joined August 21, 2019

Software Craftsman, Clojure dev, lifelong learner

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jiriknesl; my proof: https://keybase.io/jiriknesl/sigs/kXz6VllLsHtiK2kkueTrWEtaOV0x_eJvj52b54r-90Q ]

submissionscomments
jiriknesl··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
> We can't solve collective issues

Unless practically everything (food, transport, education)... becomes a collective issue and no space for individual liberty is left.

Honestly, I'd rather live on 1 degree warmer Earth with 1/100 of regulations/subsidies than the opposite. And this is my vote, yours is yours.

> If the food you eat has global externalities

Everything has externalities. Pesticides have externalities. Mining base materials to do just anything (a tractor to farm land, materials to build a house) decrease amount of nonrenewable materials, which is externality. Many meat substitutes are packaged in plastic materials made from oil.

There just must be acceptable level of negative externalities.

jiriknesl··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
I doubt it is healthier diet. Researches showing vegetarians are healthier have a problem that puts vegetarians to one group and omnivores to the second group putting people eating at fast foods altogether with people eating for example Paleo or mediterranean diet.

Greek diet is healthy, still they eat fish, seafood and meatballs.

Japanese cuisine is healthy, still they eat fish and seafood.

Korean cuisine is healthy, still they eat pork, fish.

Mediterrean diet is healthy, still they eat all types of meat.

Speaking of sustainability, there are regions where animal product is better (Mongolia, nordic regions). Besides that, sustainability is one of measures in the equation. People want sustainable diet, but not by all costs.

jiriknesl··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
> Going back to a mostly vegetarian food supply

From agricultural point of view, it is nonsense. There are places that generate more human edible calories by having animals. For example Mongolia, or nordic regions.

> Humanity hasn't had such a high meat consumption ever before, it's an aberration of the last century that is unsustainable. We changed the dietary habits of a lot of people over the last century. There's no reason we couldn't change them back.

If people will decide to eat less meat then be so. Forcing them would be disgusting.

jiriknesl··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
Vegetarians eat eggs, drink milk, eat cheese and use leather (and other materials sourced from animals) so the scale of animal production could be lower but cannot be eliminated.

Vegan alternatives in materials depend on oil production.

So in some way, I think, animal production and animal industry is inevitable for us.

As somebody, who has been half half vegetarian (16 years), I would be strongly against making meat even 1 % more expensive. What people eat is their decision, not mine.

jiriknesl··on When McDonalds Came to Denmark
He does and you should too.
jiriknesl··on Bank of England to crack down on 'secretive' cloud computing services
Well, I guess you are speaking about companies who don't know what they do. But this article speaks about banks, who have hundreds of servers, ability to recover anything, full-time employed ops teams, monitoring & automation in place for 20 years already. Moving to cloud provides very little advantage (definitely not financially) to such companies. They are not SaaS who might need to double their infrastructure overnight. Lots of advantages provided by cloud has been in place years before clouds because of VMWare. Another thing is existing bank apps are often monoliths (when you are happy, in Java with Spring, C# .NET, when not, in Visual Basic, Cobol, PowerBuilder, SAP) or huge interconnected services, huge databases with thousands of stored procedures, SOAP APIs in place. This is not a place where you would leverage ElasticBeanstalk or AWS Lambda.
jiriknesl··on The potential Orwellian horror of central bank digital currencies
I don't think there's causation even when there's correlation. But your comment has led me to a thought.

Yes, it's true animal in cages live longer than animal in the wild.

Would I prefer to live in the ZOO or in the wild?

jiriknesl··on The potential Orwellian horror of central bank digital currencies
When I have studied economics, our professor went into long lengths in explanation what makes one an economist.

And the main thing is. To be economist, you have to act in discourse of economics. And discourse of economics is defined by economs.

You don't need any particular profession or education to be economist, just participation in the discourse makes you one. When you are paid to participate, you are professional.

A question is, whether you must participate in research. If yes, you could say that for example economics teacher is not an economist even when they have studied it, they understand it and they teach it. And you could ask the same for 'company economists', CFOs, accountants. They have studied it, they understand it and their main discourse's within of what economists study.

One more thing is. I have met lots of economics grads who had almost no understanding of economics. They learned for tests, then they forgot. A few years after graduation, they remember maybe 5-10%. And I have met lots of amateurs who study, read, think and discuss actively. They might not have a degree and their understanding of economics is superior to a huge percentage of econ grads.

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
Supply, demand. People don't have better use for electricity than miners. If they did, they would buy it out. So your implication is false.

The fact you don't see value in cryptocurrencies doesn't equal for others it's the same.

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
I think your points prove the motivation lots of cryptocurrency authors have.

They don't want politicians and bankers to set the rules. They want developers to set the rules. So they build systems enabling ideas they stand behind.

Just like with open source. I guess if there were no open source, all operating systems would have backdoors, strong cryptography would be banned, we would have very strict software patents, etc. Everyone would be in a cage built by politicians & closed source devs. As we're now in the financial system.

Cryptocurrencies, in ideal situation, should serve as open source counterpart to closed source world.

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
PoW is now done more with renewable energy than most of other sectors. Bitcoin is one of the most clean markets out there.

In fact, Bitcoin is way better traceable than remittance systems used by terrorists. They smuggle cash, they use hawala, they use trade-based instruments (over and under invoicing), they use bank accounts on anonymous companies in tax havens. All these things are way more difficult to trace than Bitcoin (or 99% of all cryptocurrencies).

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
For sure. Cryptocurrency community has so many fanatics it's not healthy either.

The thing is, some clown shouting diamond hands, HODL, to the moon, won't make it to #10 on HN I guess.

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
Western Union doesn't have business accounts in most of countries. Normal transaction doesn't allow Business -> Business payments. They cannot send money to Iran (where we also have partners).

But you are right. Their fees are way cheaper than bank & Payoneer.

Ad on-ramp&off-ramp - sure. This is a temporary situation in which it adds some expense. Hopefully, people will have a chance to have cards refilled directly with cryptocurrencies worldwide (they already exist for major countries).

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
I wouldn't name it quite, from all contents I have read from him, he is fanatically negative towards crypto.
jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
It depends on exchange. Each has different fees.

Also, as Bitcoin is deflationary, in those 5 years, I usually got more than $2000.

But this is I guess just temporary. And if Bitcoin will grow, it will stabilize (probably) and interfacing with the world will get cheaper (both exchange to fiat or buying directly for cryptocurrencies or cryptocurrency-backed payment card).

jiriknesl··on The Non-Innovation of Cryptocurrency
> The notion that these technologies can transform financial services in any way is laughable, because there is no mechanism or specific problem they aim to address that is not currently better done with a simpler solution.

Well, he hasn't obviously tried to send money from Europe to Latin America.

On $2000 transaction. $25-40 bank transfer (takes up to 5 days). $80 Payoneer (can be fast, but can also take 2 days) $1 Bitcoin (4 hours)

jiriknesl··on Tell HN: Don't root for WFH, it might destroy well-paying jobs
They do it a lot. The whole India outsourcing story is about exactly this.
jiriknesl··on Tell HN: Don't root for WFH, it might destroy well-paying jobs
He/she doesn't. SW developers are not poor anywhere in the World. And what he says is not "don't enable jobs for non-US citizens, because I hate them", he says "..., because we will earn less money". It's a completely different motivation.

So the right question would be:

"Why do you oppose hiring devs (who are upper-middle everywhere in the world) elsewhere?"

And the answer is obviously: "Because it will push salaries down."

Personally, I think it's normal. SW development will be done remotely more and more in the future. Those, who want to build a moat, should probably focus on HW or firmware development.

jiriknesl··on On Ransomware and Cryptocurrency
It depends on how you define ethics. I am for example deongological rational egoist. I can decide for myself if my acts of sending money to Iran are ethical. In my case, I send them to people who are aginst the regime, don't torture anyone and are secular. So I exchange good work of good people for value they otherwise couldn't get. This is what matters. Voters', politicians' ideas and opinions, etc. does not.
jiriknesl··on On Ransomware and Cryptocurrency
If a developer in Iran wants to work with a company in the US and they are prevented in doing so, it might be illegal, but it is ethical to bypass such a regulation.
jiriknesl··on On Ransomware and Cryptocurrency
When you put in KYC/AML in place, you lose ability to employ people in restricted countries easily. How do you employ someone in Iran if the US government or Iranian government is against? Bypassing regulations is a great perk.
jiriknesl··on Uber used 50 Dutch shell companies to dodge taxes
Paying lower taxes is nothing like kill or rape. There are lots of internet-only companies for which the government did absolutely nothing.
jiriknesl··on Tesla no longer accepts Bitcoin due to climate impact
So it depends. For example in Argentina, they AFAIK have two conversion rates. When you use a normal bank account, you have to use government conversion rate that's 50% of black market rate between Argentinian pesos and USDs. With Bitcoin, you could try black market straight away and even if you pay 2-5%, you might end up better.

For transaction rate, Trezor says at 22sat/B., you will have your transaction confirmed in 4 hours 10 minutes for $1.85.

Even if BTC price was stable, I would still use it. But my experience is that having some BTC is usually better than just having cash.

jiriknesl··on Tesla no longer accepts Bitcoin due to climate impact
I use crypto (and mainly Bitcoin) to pay for three years every month now. Average fee over those years is more like $1. In comparison with $20 transaction fees my bank asks when I transact for example from EU to SouthAm, zero hassle and no paperwork when sending to countries with trade embargo, I must say, Bitcoin is golden.
jiriknesl··on Has UML died without anyone noticing?
I think, the biggest issue with UML is that it helps with things that doesn't need such a ceremony and doesn't help in things where you would need it.

Modeling database structures, class diagrams, interactions between components is usually something, any senior developer can do on a napkin without all the hassle, certifications, $500+ per seat tools and unique terminology.

The trickiest things are designed much better, when you just open REPL and start playing with the design until you get it down. It's highly creative, speculative and flexible. So exactly the opposite of UML.

In programming, the most exciting parts are things you couldn't productively solve with UML.

And calling diagrams Masala is a huge misunderstanding why people mix contexts, views and representations. This is that creative, speculative and flexible part you exactly need.

jiriknesl··on Java Is Underhyped
I think, there are three things in this one. JVM, Java itself and how it is used.

JVM is great. I think it gets a lot of love (in comparison with .NET Core which is IMHO as good as JVM). In this one, you see JVM everywhere except desktop apps.

Then, there's Java itself. As a language, it really isn't as modern and doesn't provide much what isn't already available in C#, Scala, Kotlin, or even PHP or TypeScript. And it doesn't provide some things that other languages have. So on this scale, once you know Java, you can be productive, but I doubt you will be more productive than someone who knows C#, Scala, etc.

And then, there's Java culture. Plenty of Java devs (mainly in J2EE, Spring world) don't develop in classes, they develop in design patterns. AbstractFactoryStrategy, complete abstracting out databases, five layer data models, classes for things that should be enums. It's a matter of taste, you don't have to do it (Android devs don't do this that much even when they use Java). And I think all the coolness of modelling, UML, etc. is over.

I think, you can be productive in Java (if you use it a bit like PHP). I think JVM is fantastic. For me, I am 8 years in Clojure world and I wouldn't go back to design patterns, writing (in Java often generating) dozens of lines of code just to insert something to the database (entity, mapping, repository, business logic layer, etc.) when in Clojure, this would be three lines (defn, schema check, insert).

jiriknesl··on Just Be Rich
When you are building wealth, you are likely to be young (so often healthy) and there is so much information online, libraries cost nothing. So I don't think this is a valid argument.
jiriknesl··on A campaign to make environmental destruction an international crime
Any cutoff between use and overuse is artificial. It is still use. If it is use, and if it is with billions of people, one day, some resources will be consumed. Maybe sooner, maybe later, but on million-years-scale, it doesn't make any sense anyway.

Overheating, oversheltering, both seems very artificial to me. Ok, you can have a wood cabin in forests, but what's next? Are antibiotics use or overuse? Is internet use or overuse? And who is supposed to decide? Using nonrenevables/using renevables is nice in a thing it is black/white, it has no value component in it.

I don't know how removing interest could help except making some operations nonviable. Without interest, all ventures would have to use different sources of financing. I think a demand for risky lending (where risk is compensated in a form of interest) is natural and would exist in some way anyway.

jiriknesl··on A campaign to make environmental destruction an international crime
Humankind itself is the reason. Since bronze age, we mine, use the nature and lower diversity of species. There is nothing you can do about it. People cannot live without using scarce resources, if they aren't in "stone age" stage. People don't want back to stone age. It is nice we have drugs, energy, cars, etc. But it consumes things. There is no possible economic system that can fix it. We need either downgrade to the point of not even using tools made from metals, or we need to scale up and get other planets as a resources.
jiriknesl··on A campaign to make environmental destruction an international crime
My problem is that human activity for thousands of years is focused on using resources and basically consuming the planet. We take for example iron ore in a places rich with iron, we turn them into the product and spread them across the world, so it is harder to reuse them. We take crude oil and transform some part to plastic, which is harder to reuse and we burn another part, which is irreversible.

And we do it on a huge scale, we need to do it to have drugs, houses, cars, energy, whatever. You can't make a solar panel without mining. You cannot feed 7 bln of people without tractors, etc.

So humankind somehow consumes the Earth. In 1 million of years, we may no longer have any crude oil left. But we are supposed to be here for much longer than 1 million of years.

As I know this, it seems to me, that these things are artificial cutoff. This is bad and that is ok, even when both things consume nature and are unsustainable for millions of years.

A problem is, as long as we are bound to the Earth, there are only two options. Either some form of primitivism, return back to the stone age (not to bronze age, it is mining) and reduce a population to <1% of today. Or to colonize space and "use" Earth (pollution, mining, reduction of diversity is all consumation) and everything so little we will be able to improve enough to colonize space and then start this consumation on much wider scale, that is unlimited (humankind isn't probably able to spread over the whole universe).

A problem with the second is that we are just in the beginning and we don't even have a smallest experience in things like making planets habitable, changing their trajectories, etc. To get there, we need highly speculative science. To get there, we need funds to support it. To have funds, we need profits. To have profits, we need efficient markets. To have efficient markets, we need freedom. And you probably know, anything starting with "The global campaign..." of any kind is definitely going to lower freedom.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →