HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jjk166

8,522 karma · joined April 26, 2017

submissionscomments
jjk166··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
Higher demand incentivizes more production, increasing supply which drives prices down. Demand increases only drive up prices if supply is constrained.

Very likely wine demand was not going up, and price increases were instead due to increasing costs and inflation.

jjk166··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
> It's a nice claim to say

kinda implies the claim was said

jjk166··on Supreme Court permits states to use SAVE database for citizenship checks
Since 2001 the US has spent 29.7 Trillion on entitlements excluding social security vs 18 Trillion of military spending.

Of course the entitlements are useful spending - these are things people need and benefit from. Had these dollars not been spent by the US government, they would have been spent directly by the taxpayers for the same goods and services. While some money may have been saved if this spending were private, it probably wouldn't change the total economic impact by much.

On the other hand we have nothing to show for the $18 trillion burned on wars that went horrifically. If we'd put that money into useful investments such that it paid interest and stopped our defense spending, we would be running a $300 billion per year surplus right now with no cuts to any other government services, to say nothing of the potential economic advantages if the wars had just never happened.

And don't get me started on the $10 trillion lost to the Bush tax cuts and their extensions.

jjk166··on Supreme Court permits states to use SAVE database for citizenship checks
Because the social security surplus was used to fund the treasury instead of being put towards social security. The 1990s budget surplus that became the Bush tax cuts? Yeah that was the money that was supposed to pay for social security.
jjk166··on Supreme Court permits states to use SAVE database for citizenship checks
But certain groups are probably more likely than others to need to worry about having to prove their citizenship. You don't need to make it impossible for people to vote, you just need to create enough friction that some of them won't who otherwise would.
jjk166··on Astronomer watches Starlink satellites sinking to build a 'planetary barometer'
> Ok, but a significant bulge on one side of the planet will slow all sats, giving the false impression of a homegenous trend.

A bulge would not homogenously slow all satellites, each one would be slowed by a different amount depending on its particular path through the bulge. Those that pass through more of the bulge will be slowed to a greater extent than those passing briefly through. Satellites in different orbits tell you where the bulge is, satellites in the same orbit tell you how the bulge is moving.

jjk166··on The Mafia may be keeping fentanyl out of Italy
Which is even further from murder
jjk166··on The Mafia may be keeping fentanyl out of Italy
It's not sudden to the person planning the hit
jjk166··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
> The incident was a typhoon that caused 60 dam failures in a densely populated area prone to flooding.

So we're not counting natural disasters that cause power infrastructure failure? I take it you don't consider the events of the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami to be a nuclear accident then.

> With nuclear, people in Scotland are in danger from a plant in the Ukraine, can't do anything to protect themselves from it, and have to live with the consequences for 30+ years. That's much worse by any metric.

And people in Scotland are in substantially greater danger from the emissions of coal plants in China, and will be until the world stops burning coal.

> Deepwater horizon was bad, but nowhere near as bad as Chernobyl or Fukushima.

It was much worse in terms of environmental impact, particularly the area impacted.

> Also it wasn't a power plant

I don't see any reason to limit the discussion to electrical power plants.

> Risk is often defined as consequence x likelihood

I was being generous in only looking at consequences without considering likelihood. The consequences are no worse than the dominant alternatives, but the likelihood has been astronomically less, hence Nuclear has been the safest power source ever utilized by mankind. So yes, in a way nuclear's risk is unique - uniquely low. I fully agree this should be accepted and considered in any discussion.

jjk166··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
> Also of course each nuclear plant carries a nonzero chance of a trillion dollar incident (we've had two so far) as well as a nonzero chance of millions of casualties. Both these cons are entirely unique to nuclear power plants. No hydro plant, solar plant, wind farm, coal, oil or gas plant can cause as much damage as a nuclear plant.

The Banqiao dam failure killed 250,000 people in a single incident. Pollution from coal plants running normally causes 1 million premature deaths per year. The deepwater horizon spill was a $100 billion disaster with an environmental impact greater than any nuclear incident. The Centralia fires in PA are still burning after over 60 years and lead to a town being abandoned. Nuclear is not uniquely risky by any rational metric.

jjk166··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Canadian reactors don't use enriched uranium. Also many countries have centrifuges - Germany, Netherlands, Japan, Brazil, and of course all the nuclear armed states. Further, enrichment plants can be built anywhere.
jjk166··on Claude discovers a novel enzyme system with CRISPR-like repeats
In the way that breathing is unavoidable. Like yeah technically there is a way to avoid doing it, but not a way that you want to seriously consider.
jjk166··on North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes
The issue is the mechanism of "lowering" it. You're not giving it more slack.
jjk166··on North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes
If you have an ~~anvil hanging over your head~~ ton of compressed rock under you, the potential energy that would kill you already exists. Slowly lowering the ~~anvil~~ potential energy of the rock makes sense. Damaging the ~~rope holding the anvil~~ rock containing the energy doesn't.
jjk166··on North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes
If you have an anvil hanging over your head, the potential energy that would kill you already exists. Slowly lowering the anvil makes sense. Damaging the rope holding the anvil doesn't.
jjk166··on Doing Everyone Else's Job
It can take years for the damn thing to fail even after the key support stops entirely. In that time you and your colleagues will suffer, and the people responsible will jump ship long before the full impact has been felt, learning nothing from the experience and likely blaming it on the person they leave holding the bag. You can try to get a job elsewhere but things which aren't appreciated at one company often times aren't appreciated at most. Doing a good job is often in your personal best interest regardless of what an out of touch middle manager thinks is more important.
jjk166··on Pion, an agent designed to run any company autonomously
But for a lot of companies, all the connections in the world won't mean shit if someone else can offer a lower cost with a better lead time.
jjk166··on People who can't picture anything are rewriting the science of imagination
The difference is when you imagine things normally you are aware that you are imagining them and you have full control over them. I can picture an elephant in the room with me, I can change its size or color, I can give it a top hat, and critically I can make it go away at will. If you're hallucinating, it's just there, however it happens to be, and while you might be able to reason that it's more likely a hallucination than reality, that doesn't make it feel any less real, nor give you control over it.
jjk166··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
I say "doing a lot of heavy lifting" all the time. I have heard people use load-bearing though it's less common. Other than habit I don't see any real advantage to the version I use over load-bearing.
jjk166··on Navier-Stokes Announcement
Admittedly, peer review originally referred to the fact that the journal being published was read ("reviewed") by your peers, and thus there would be the opportunity for them to provide rebuttals after publication. The process the term now refers to in academia only emerged in the 50's and 60's (Nature for example wasn't "peer reviewed" until 1967). It was literally a marketing ploy to make journals sound more prestigious which got legitimized when certain grant agencies and regulatory bodies started including it in their requirements. All the best science is published in journals that describe themselves as peer reviewed, the government says science not published in such journals isn't up to snuff, and taken literally it seems useful. It's no wonder the public thinks it's an important and long established part of the scientific process.
jjk166··on Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic
No it isn't.

> The term “destructive device” shall not include any device which is neither designed nor redesigned for use as a weapon

Adding a guidance system to a rocket does not mean it is explicitly designed as a ground-to-ground weapon. For the exact same reason it's legal to design and possess drones with guidance systems, it's legal to do so for rockets.

jjk166··on Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic
No it isn't. Guidance systems are perfectly legal. The FAA has some common sense restrictions like "you can't fly it at an airplane" or "you can't fly it over a crowd" or "you can't attach an explosive charge" but the only point to point flight profile that is illegal is that you can't launch into another country's territory. And of course these restrictions are on the flights themselves, not on the capabilities of the rocket.

Selling rocket guidance systems internationally is going to get you in trouble with ITAR, but that's a whole different can of worms.

jjk166··on Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic
Did those dumb bombs tossed out of biplanes lack software because the software was difficult to write or because there was no hardware in the world capable of running software? Given that missile guidance systems predate the very notion of software, and the moment better hardware exists there is software ready to take advantage of it, methinks software was not the hard part.
jjk166··on 'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swallowed a planet
Well if we found current or fossil life with a common ancestor on other bodies it would certainly demonstrate that it arrived via debris; whereas if we find life with no common ancestor or find no evidence of life at all that would reject the hypothesis. It wouldn't necessarily answer which body was the original birthplace, but for the purposes of modelling, whether life happened to start here is a much less impactful question than whether life had to start here. If all life here started here, then life had to develop quickly; if we could potentially descend from stuff in the pre-solar system debris field that could add billions of years to the clock, and makes interstellar panspermia highly plausible.
jjk166··on DHS 'Predictive Policing' Unit Is Analyzing Americans' Financial Habits
That's not what KYC being illegal means. It means it should be illegal to impose KYC laws. Just like state religion or warrantless searches are illegal.
jjk166··on DHS 'Predictive Policing' Unit Is Analyzing Americans' Financial Habits
> I think the intellectual position "it should be illegal for institutions transmitting money between two parties to identify either of those parties" might require some kind of logical argument behind it.

This is both a straw man position and begs the question. KYC laws aren't the option to identify either party, it's the requirement to identify both. The default throughout pretty much the whole of human history across cultures has been not having KYC laws. A logical and compelling argument must be made for implementing and unholding such laws.

> Are you saying all financial transactions should be anonmyous by law?

The anti-KYC position is that it should be possible for some financial transactions to be anonymous by law.

> How would banks function if they were required to be blind to their customers?

While they would not be required to be blind, most have been and by default would like to be. Maintaining identity records reliably tying people to transactions is a significant burden for banks for exactly the same reason it would be an incredible burden on you to keep track of which atm/cashier/couch cushion every dollar in your wallet came from.

Some banks may nevertheless consider the option a net positive, and require their customers to provide identification. People would be able to choose if they want to use those banks or not. If the benefits get passed along to the consumer, many likely would choose to.

> How would the government prosecute money laundering if all cash-trails went cold after the first time they passed a bank?

Presumably by going after the criminal infrastructure handling the money before it passed a bank. Giving up privacy rights tends to make law enforcement easier, but it is a common and reasonable opinion that we should not be trying to maximize the ease of law enforcement at the expense of privacy.

jjk166··on DHS 'Predictive Policing' Unit Is Analyzing Americans' Financial Habits
Did you know they can just beat you with a wrench anyways?

The "maybe if we do what they say and don't make a fuss they'll be appeased and stop" strategy fails when matched up against those who will never be appeased and stop.

jjk166··on LLMs as a Cognitive Virus
"If men learn this [writing], it will implant forgetfulness in their souls; they will cease to exercise memory because they rely on that which is written, calling things to remembrance no longer from within themselves, but by means of external marks."

-Socrates

jjk166··on 'Starwashing': The new space race has an environmental problem
> All the emphasis these companies place on technological progress is a distraction from dealing with the climate crisis, said Gregers Andersen, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Southern Denmark who has written a forthcoming book about Silicon Valley overpromising tech solutions to climate change. “The problem is, of course, that it takes attention away from actually solving the problems that are here on Earth,” he said. “And I think that’s also what’s meant by the term of ‘starwashing.’”

This is an example of the fallacy of relative privation[0]. Private space ventures have essentially zero impact on climate change. They do not utilize the same resources that combatting climate change involves. Changing anything about space ventures will have no impact on the effectiveness or timing of climate change solutions. The global space industry is roughly the same size as the global cosmetics industry - it is exactly as ridiculous to say space is distracting us from the climate crisis as it is to say we should stop producing cosmetics until the climate crisis is solved. Environmental protection is important, but so are other things, and we neither will nor should stop everything to focus on one problem at a time.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies#Fallacy_of_r...

jjk166··on The browser's main thread is expensive
A user's hardware represents the worst case scenario they want to be able to handle, not their preferred nominal settings. Most people aren't changing their screen refresh rate when they switch between playing a game and reading wikipedia.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →