HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jjk166

8,522 karma · joined April 26, 2017

submissionscomments
jjk166··on Why are there no flow batteries with symmetric ferrocyanide electrolytes?
Yeah, just like no one would ever buy a lead-acid battery.

I don't think many people are concerned about their batteries being safe for ingestion.

jjk166··on Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
The purpose of a teacher is not to be a challenging conversational partner.
jjk166··on Mamdani Bans AI in NYC Schools
If the kids don't want to learn, and the schools aren't looking for anything beyond their ability to produce an answer, that's not an AI problem.
jjk166··on German industry pushes to restore 40-hour working week without extra pay
> No manager/CEO would say “hey, due to AI my workers get the same work done in 30h for which they needed 40h before - let’s cut their working hours down to 30h with same salary”.

Why not? The moment anyone offers this option, they get their pick of employees who will both churn less and be better rested for their work time, increasing productivity, whereas their greedy competitors get the people with no better options and burn them out. Despite people's despair, the current situation is extremely unstable.

jjk166··on German industry pushes to restore 40-hour working week without extra pay
Productivity per capita has already 5Xed since the 40 hour workweek was implemented. The resources required to comfortably raise a family in a suburban home can be generated with only a few hundred hours of labor per year. Everything they had then is easier to produce now, and the things we've gained since like consumer electronics require barely any human labor at all to produce.
jjk166··on This Fence Has No Farmer (Chesterton's Fence and AI-Generated Code)
> There's an assumption buried in Chesterton's Fence: somebody built the fence. It didn't grow there by itself, so whoever put it there presumably had a reason. Code has traditionally worked much the same way. Even if the reasoning was bad, there was at least some reasoning to uncover.

That assumption is not in Chesterton's Fence. Plenty of things happen by accident, even without invoking AI. The point of Chesterton's Fence is simply that you should not assume by default that there's no good reason for something to exist. If you live in an area where a tornado might deposit a fence in a random location, it still behooves you to investigate any fence you come across before removing it.

Note that even if something was done without purpose, it can still potentially be providing some benefit that you'd rather not give up, or someone else may have since taken advantage of it existing and built upon it. If you don't understand the system, then you can't predict the consequences of changing it. There is no escaping the need to develop understanding.

jjk166··on Aging brains blend memories together instead of just forgetting them
> "A computer" in the first statement is IMO obviously intended in the common usage sense of the term, i.e. the brain is not a desktop computer

No one has ever thought that a brain is a desktop computer, and that is not the common usage sense of the term in this context.

jjk166··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
> Nobody is banning legal immigration. It's being restricted.

No it has been banned. There is no legal way to do it. Even if it is a temporary ban, it is a ban. If you support indefinitely pausing legal immigration, you are anti-legal immigration.

> Yes, and if that program is being abused (just ask people here on HN about H1Bs to see how they feel), then you pause it until you figure out how to solve it.

That is an absurd strategy. Would you "indefinitely pause" schooling children until you can figure out a way to solve the problem of students cheating on tests? Would you "indefinitely pause" funding police forces until you can figure out how to prevent police abuses? Would you "indefinitely pause" money transfers until you can figure out how to solve tax fraud? Pausing any of these would create massive problems while doing nothing to speed up improvements, and it doesn't help that "solving" those problems may not even be possible. We can immediately switch to a better system after someone figures out that better system; until then we make do with what we have.

jjk166··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
It most certainly is hypocritical. You can not be simultaneously pro-legal immigration and support banning legal immigration. If you support banning legal immigration, you are by definition anti-legal immigration.

> Being anti-illegal immigration and pro-legal immigration doesn't mean you want to flood the country with legal immigrants.

If only there were something between 0 and unrestricted immigration, some sort of program where people apply for permission and the government issues approvals for individuals to enter its borders after meeting legal criteria.

jjk166··on Actinide is first startup to produce high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU)
> it is hard to hide the scale of building and power usage from international watchdogs. Because nothing consumes tons of energy and doesn't output tons of product to sell except for nuclear material refinement for weapons.

Until datacenters

jjk166··on Actinide is first startup to produce high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU)
If the bad actor has centrifuge technology and access to low enriched uranium, they are already weeks away from achieving weapons grade material. If a country with Iran's enrichment capabilities had a sufficient LEU stockpile swapped for an equivalent amount of HALEU, it would shave about 7 days off the time necessary to produce a bomb's worth of weapons grade uranium.

For nations with enrichment capabilities, enrichment is not a major contributor to overall breakout time. Enrichment doesn't take much time, it's building enrichment facilities that takes a while, especially clandestinely.

jjk166··on Actinide is first startup to produce high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU)
> What has changed here to make them competitive again?

Nothing. This is a company that specializes in making medical isotopes, which is something Calutrons are good for - you need high levels of enrichment in a single step, you don't need to process large quantities, and the energy consumption doesn't matter. Any talk of using it for reactor fuel production is pure PR spin.

jjk166··on Actinide is first startup to produce high-assay low-enriched uranium (HALEU)
It's actually the opposite. Centrifuges are a cheaper and easier enrichment method. A single uranium centrifuge is on the order of $10,000 to $20,000. It's economical to run lots of centrifuges, but you could in theory get up to high enrichment just using the same centrifuge again and again.

Lot's of non-nuclear weapons states do have access, the Netherlands for example enriches more uranium annually than the UK. It's the components of centrifuges that are tightly controlled. Building enrichment facilities is well within the capabilities of pretty much any nation state, it's doing it secretly which is the hard part.

This alternative technique only makes sense at extremely small quantities. For their primary market of making medical isotopes, it makes a lot of sense. For nuclear reactor fuel it's incredibly impractical.

jjk166··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
"We're not anti-immigration, we're only anti-illegal immigration!"

* indefinitely pauses legal immigration *

jjk166··on U.S. gov't moves to suppress pushback on data centers
For context, a US coal plant on average causes 3 deaths per year due to air quality. If we're not calling a coal plant a major source, wtf would we refer to as a major source?

It doesn't matter that the aggregate air pollution of the entire country far exceeds any individual source, the point of the major/minor distinction is to compare individual sources.

jjk166··on Octopus intelligence may be related to never-before-seen mutation
I'm talking about the intelligence claim. There is nothing surprising about a gene having a molecular effect.
jjk166··on Octopus intelligence may be related to never-before-seen mutation
I'm referring to the link with intelligence. The e coli experiments has nothing to do with that.

> that doesn't mean they're correlated to each other, let alone causal, of course, in either direction.

Which was my point.

jjk166··on Octopus intelligence may be related to never-before-seen mutation
I was referring to the correlation (or lack thereof) with intelligence. The e coli work is a non-sequitor.
jjk166··on FDA authorizes first wearable device that monitors ketone and blood sugar levels
It depends on intended use. If it is to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent a medical condition then it is a medical device that may need approval. If it's not intended for anything medical, it doesn't need FDA approval. For example, clinical thermometers are class II medical devices, lab thermometers aren't medical devices at all. If the device were genuinely only marketed for general wellness, it would be exempt.
jjk166··on FDA authorizes first wearable device that monitors ketone and blood sugar levels
Blood glucose levels affect lots of health functions. Diabetes represents an extreme end of the spectrum where the body's ability to regulate these fluctuations fails, but just because your body can get your levels in control eventually doesn't mean you won't suffer from the negative effects of it needing to do so.

Maintaining consistent glucose levels improves mental health, weight management, sleep quality, muscle recovery, systemic inflammation, cardiovascular health, and may even slow aging. There isn't much clinical data at the moment on how to use blood glucose measurements to control glucose levels outside of people with diabetes (there are lots of things that impact it besides just sugar intake), but there are definitely major theoretical benefits if it can be worked out.

Also, just reducing the incidence of diabetes would be no small accomplishment. About 3.5% of global disability adjusted life-years (DALYs) are due to diabetes. As of 2021 it was the 7th largest contributor of global DALYs.

jjk166··on Anthropic expected to tell investors it sees over $30T in potential revenue
A world where investors have grown accustomed to absurd levels of growth.
jjk166··on Octopus intelligence may be related to never-before-seen mutation
The default assumption is non-correlation. No firm evidence was presented demonstrating correlation. Hence "not even clear it qualifies as correlation."

This is a one time event that happened sometime after incirrates and cirrates split. This is like claiming there is a correlation between the Carrington Event of 1859 and the outbreak of the US civil war in 1860. One happened before the other. One could plausibly construct some narrative that causally links the two. But does it qualify as correlation?

jjk166··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
All software is going to have edge cases, no matter how good the contractor is. The decision to not have contingencies to manually handle reasonable edge cases is entirely on the government.
jjk166··on Octopus intelligence may be related to never-before-seen mutation
Correlation does not imply causation and it's not even clear this qualifies as correlation.
jjk166··on Characterizing Agentic Flooding of Government Services
LLMs are just revealing how many systems rely on making applications artificially difficult, either to understand or to generate, to reduce volume. These systems have been failing silently for years, unmuting the alarm is the first step to fixing them.
jjk166··on A faster way to calculate the day of the week
That would be 10.9 million years. Could probably get away with a slightly smaller look up table.
jjk166··on Risk Engineering
Knowledge of how to fix the system comes from understanding how the system works, which does not necessarily require experience fixing it. Every problem ever fixed was at some point fixed without prior experience - if we can fix problems that have never happened before we can fix problems that haven't happened in a while.
jjk166··on AI didn't erase the junior engineer's value, it increased it it
That makes sense from an engineering perspective, but from a business perspective you don't want the understanding to live in the heads of a small team of people. Companies own the codebase, they don't own their employees. If losing a single employee means losing the understanding for a significant chunk of the codebase, that's a serious risk. With the senior/junior model where you have a senior engineer architecting the system and a small team implementing that architecture, the understanding lives in the senior engineer's head, but it also lives in the head of the person who implemented it, and their teammates who implemented the parts that interact with it and were present for the discussions probably have enough knowledge to figure it out pretty quickly, so as long as the company doesn't lose the whole team all at once they're okay. If you make the team more productive with AI tools you can have the team do more, which still cuts down the total headcount, if to a lesser degree, but preserves the redundant understanding.
jjk166··on Moderna reports first positive Phase 3 for mRNA neoantigen therapy in melanoma
The criticism was both impolite and against HN rules.

The reply was reiterating HN rules, as well as adding data supporting the original statement.

jjk166··on Moderna reports first positive Phase 3 for mRNA neoantigen therapy in melanoma
They were no dumber then than in 2026, but they fundamentally had much less access to information. How much do you trust the medical advice of an uneducated person in 2026?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →