HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jjk166

8,522 karma · joined April 26, 2017

submissionscomments
jjk166··on One Oakland police officer made $490k in overtime
> but embezzlement and fraud at large scale can easily cause the company to die (problem solved)

The legitimate societal good that those corporations produced (useful products, valuable services, large scale employment, etc) are gone. The people responsible may lose their jobs, but if they get new jobs they are likely to just infect another corporation. Further, those responsible may have left long before the the institution buckled under the weight of their actions, and in the process convinced others to engage in the same practices. I reject the claim that the problem is solved by company death.

jjk166··on One Oakland police officer made $490k in overtime
Excluding of course corporate bailouts.
jjk166··on Babies born under sugar rationing grew into adults with lower cancer risk
While I want to believe the result, it seems like the method is far too susceptible to confounding cohort effects. I'd be curious if a similar trend is seen in other countries that ended rationing at different times, and if any such change is seen in countries that didn't ration. The cancer rates may not be directly comparable due to other differences, but if the rate change is consistently centered around whenever sugar consumption changed, that would be much more compelling evidence; whereas if post-1953 children have higher cancer rates across the board it's probably something else.
jjk166··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
The high threshold is only for public figures, which must show actual malice. For everyone else (e.g. your typical student falsely accused of plagiarism), they only need to show the statement was false, published, targeted the plaintiff, and caused damage - it's still defamation even if they were simply negligent in checking the facts. The company might be able to cover themselves if they are very clear they are just giving a statistical probability and not saying their model was definitely used, but if they imply they have hidden information that points to their conclusion (which is kind of the whole point of their algorithm) then that's not a valid defense. I can't say they would lose in practice, but in theory they ought to lose.
jjk166··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
Seems like exactly the sort of problem the threat of defamation lawsuits are meant to solve.
jjk166··on The case for overhauling American science
Between American science and American government, I know which one I want to see overhauled.
jjk166··on FDA Admitted in Print That Nothing It Knows of Will Wash Cyclospora Off Lettuce
TFA could really benefit from a concise thesis statement. It jumps around randomly and repeats facts that don't appear to be building a strong case for anything specific. Reading between the lines, it seems like the author believes the guidance document should include more on supply chain water testing, but I don't have enough context to know what reason they think it was not included or why they consider that reasoning to be flawed.
jjk166··on Compression is prediction
The article is using probability where it really means proportion and prediction where it means evaluation. The mathematical equivalency is both much less surprising and less revealing once reframed.

If we consider the first example with the arithmetic code, the initial presupposition that only the characters A, B, and C appear in the string already reduces the entropy from 56 ascii bits to 14 bits (A vs Not A and B vs Not B for each character). If you further consider that you only need to distinguish B vs Not B if it's not A, then you can just represent As with a single zero bit and only represent the non-As as two bits (the first of which will necessarily always be a 1 bit). This gets you to 10 bits without even having the proportions of the string. Of course this would be a poor convention if there were say only a single A; in that worst case scenario you would need 13 bits, but simply knowing which character appears the most, without knowing by how much, 11 bits is the worst case scenario for a length 7 string with 3 potential characters. The last bit can be made implicit if you further choose the second conditional appropriately - i.e. if instead of B vs Not B we chose C vs Not C, our last bit would be zero and could simply be dropped meaning both 10 and a single 1 bit encode C - allowing you to encode the example string in just 9 bits and an arbitrary string of that length in 10, again regardless of proportions. That improvement over the arithmetic encoding result in the example is just a case of us cramming a little extra information into the encoding algorithm.

Arithmetic encoding is more clean and more easily extensible, it makes more sense to use than this custom encoding of 7 trits to binary but the point is the "probability" the article mentions is a superficial quality of life feature, not the secret sauce that is the actual key to compression.

jjk166··on Why is everyone trying to build a solid-state battery?
It's not a reference to solid-state electronics, it's a reference to solid state chemical reactions. These are reactions where the reagents are all in the solid state (hence the name).

A steam engine isn't a solid-state motor.

jjk166··on Increasing the lifespan of a bulb makes it worse in every other way
5700 is the temperature at which the peak is in the visible spectrum. It has nothing to do with lighting quality.
jjk166··on Increasing the lifespan of a bulb makes it worse in every other way
Are you going to buy a new house that you can't get lightbulbs for?
jjk166··on Why is everyone trying to build a solid-state battery?
All of which are symptoms of burning, not explosion.
jjk166··on Why is everyone trying to build a solid-state battery?
To stoichiometrically burn 1 gram of gasoline requires 3.5 grams of oxygen, so an energy density of 9.5 MJ/g, still more than double TNT. The state of the oxygen doesn't impact its mass.
jjk166··on Why is everyone trying to build a solid-state battery?
> Most usage of the term 'battery' is independent of technology, outside of usually wanting electricity as the interface. The fact that most batteries people talk about happen to be electrochemical cells is incidental -- it's irrelevant to whatever they are actually talking about. So yes, a lot of the time 'battery' happens to refer to electrochemical cells, but it also refers to energy storage devices in general, which wood obviously is.

Wood isn't an energy storage device. You can't have a piece of wood where the energy has been depleted. There is no device. Wood is the stored energy - it's a fuel. You consume it in some device, like a furnace, to generate energy.

jjk166··on Why is everyone trying to build a solid-state battery?
Heat pumps are best for small thermal gradients. If you want your room to be a nice 70F while it's 50F outside, a heat pump is a very efficient way of heating your room. If you want a blow torch that's hundreds of degrees above ambient, a heat pump is terribly inefficient. The exact cutoff where gas heating becomes more efficient is variable, but it's typically a temperature differential between 40 and 60F.
jjk166··on First atmosphere found on Earth-like planet in habitable zone of distant star
Considering we started our search for extra terrestrial intelligence 67 years ago, and we likely didn't go extinct in 2009, 50 years seems a rather pessimistic estimate.
jjk166··on First atmosphere found on Earth-like planet in habitable zone of distant star
This is false. Earth's magnetic field does not significantly impact atmospheric loss. For comparison, Venus is closer to the sun and has no magnetic field, but has a substantially thicker atmosphere than earth.
jjk166··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
There is an important subtlety which is that engineers are not responsible for which technical challenges get solved, they are responsible for how those technical challenges are solved. An engineer's ethical obligation is not to avoid working on something that could be used in a harmful way, it is to prevent incidental harm from its deliberate usage. There's nothing unethical about working on a fuel additive to prevent engine knock; knowingly using a poisonous compound which is going to create immense public health problems to solve the problem was the sin.
jjk166··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
They are not different phrases. "Annoy to no end" is the American English version while "annoy no end" is the British. Both are acceptable and mean the same thing.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
Except the paramedics are actually making mcdonalds wages.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
Replying to myself as a followup:

https://digitechcomputer.com/costs-of-ems-readiness/

Looks like of the $1954 they estimate for a transport (already quite a bit below TFAs $2673), $1582 is salary. Given that we established the crew in the ambulance are taking home about $140 per transport between them, this seems bonkers. Capital, medical supplies, and fleet maintenance are a whopping 6% of the "cost".

jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
Which would increase the cost to $325, though I was deliberately excluding overhead.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
Insurance is included.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
Medical supply costs for transport are very small. The labor overhead costs are overhead. Insurance is included in the estimate.

A plumber charges you $200 to come to your house, it costs the plumber $20 to come to your house. The latter value is what we're discussing here.

jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
The 12k per year includes medical liability insurance.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
I didn't forget the cost of insurance.
jjk166··on Why American ambulance rides are so expensive
> The average ambulance transport costs $2,673 to provide

I think this ignores the 400 pound gorilla in the room. Why does an ambulance transport cost thousands for the operator? This is a short trip in an automobile, essentially a fancy uber ride. At first one might say that's flippant - obviously ambulances are specialized vehicles, and you have paramedics, and they need to get to locations quickly, and so forth, but let's consider those costs.

A new, fully equipped ambulance is about $150k. Of course this is more than a regular car, but by a factor of 5, not 50. Let's be generous and presume the ambulance fully depreciates in 2 years. Typically an ems crew will be two paramedics. Average paramedic wage is about $23/hr. Again, not orders of magnitude more expensive. Then you have liability, both for the vehicle and for the medical treatment; that's about $12k per year. Throw in money for gas and wear and tear, which should be quite comparable to other automobiles, and it costs about $1600 to own and operate an ambulance for 24 hours.

Now the other side of the equation is utilization. Taking the arbitrary example of Philadelphia Fire Department, they have 60 ambulances that handle on average 700 ems calls per day, and approximately 70% of ems calls lead to transport, so that's about 8 transports per ambulance per day. So distributing this all out, the actual cost to the ambulance operator, ignoring overhead, ought to be somewhere around $200.

I'm sure there are some additional costs I haven't included in this back of the envelope calculation, and maybe some of the numbers I pulled off google are off a bit, this should be taken as a very rough estimate. But even if you significantly increase the cost, the medicare payment amount seems quite reasonable to cover the expenses with a healthy profit margin. Unless you want to claim that operating an ambulance is less than 10% of the cost of ambulance transport, and that the estimators with Medicare are absurdly out of touch with reality, whence cometh $2,673?

jjk166··on GAO: DOE Is Prematurely Excluding Less Expensive Options for Nuclear Cleanup
It is not the Auditor's job to determine that the rules are optimal, it is only to determine whether they are being followed. Presumably when the rule was instated someone had good reason to believe it would be beneficial; and if someone makes a compelling argument that following the rule is not beneficial, it should be repealed, not ignored.
jjk166··on GAO: DOE Is Prematurely Excluding Less Expensive Options for Nuclear Cleanup
I don't see how it undercuts their argument. At best it means the DOE was following the spirit of their standards and the mission need statement was simply created later in the process than it should have been. It's still questionable though whether that prior planning actually considered and evaluated options as open-mindedly as if it had been done by the appropriate process.
jjk166··on It seems that the age of reading might be a short anomaly in human history
When was the last time you broke up a single instance of sex into a dozen or so blocks over the course of a week? It doesn't matter that they don't need to be consecutive hours, it still takes hours, which means it can't be done nearly as frequently as something that takes seconds.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →