HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jkingsbery

2,170 karma · joined January 19, 2010

submissionscomments
jkingsbery··on Debate over 'fake work' and 'lazy management' in tech industry
> We have a good leader, which makes all the difference.

I think this is the trick right here. Our paycheck might come from such-and-such company, but really we work for the people in our management chain. I'm currently at Amazon, and I've been pretty lucky with having good leaders, but part of that is because I've had the luxury of being selective (my first director in my time at Amazon was someone I had worked with previously, and when I switched teams I joined to work with someone I knew).

jkingsbery··on Can a puppetry major survive a flagship’s financial crisis? Should it?
Not everything that we learn has to be learned in college. Not sure if 100% accurate, but a quick google search shows WVU tuition is about $9k for in-state, $25k out of state... does it really make sense for someone to spend $100k (or $36k, for West Virginia residents) to learn puppetry? If that's your thing, great, why not go apprentice yourself somewhere to learn that skill instead?

Or offer a class or two in puppetry, that someone as a theater major can take. Not everything that isn't STEM is "liberal arts" - as this article says, puppetry by itself is pretty niche, and the point of liberal arts is to be more broad.

jkingsbery··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
Jim Geraghty of National Review has written a lot about this, as he pretty early advocated for the possibility of the lab leak. Because he writes for a right-leaning publication though, there are lots of ad hominem attacks thrown his way that are pretty baseless.
jkingsbery··on Notes apps are where ideas go to die (2022)
Is this really how other people operate?

I really on my old notes all the time. People mention "oh, I was going to look into X," and I do a quick search through my notes to send them some links to the investigation I did earlier on X. People ask a question "What are you planning on doing on Y?" and I find in my old notes "subject matter so-and-so says: Y? I wouldn't worry about Y." Especially in engineering, there are lots of things that I think are not important at the time because I lack context to understand it's importance, and I only understand it's importance because I wrote down unimportant seeming things, go back and read through my notes and realize "Oh, 3 different people told me Z is a big deal. I didn't realize, I should go learn more about Z."

jkingsbery··on 'Algebra for none' fails in San Francisco
In the public school I went to up through 7th grade (in the late 90s), the top 10% to 20% took algebra in 8th grade. In the private high school I went to, most of the 9th grade class had algebra the previous year (whether they went to public school or private for middle school). While by no means universal, it's been pretty common for a while.
jkingsbery··on 'Algebra for none' fails in San Francisco
The facetious answer, of course, is that because the people designing these policies learned math in the California public school system.

Less facetiously: A/B tests are great at lots of things. But these results really shouldn't surprise anyone. The idea that you will improve things for one group of students by making things worse for another group is really not only silly, it cost real kids a year of potential progress. An A/B test would cost some percentage of kids that year, which is better than hurting the whole group, but A/B testing on something that obviously would hurt their future does not seem fair to those hurt by the proposed changes.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Is it appropriate to ask a startup to let me see their cap table?
Having worked at a couple startups where my stock options didn't end up meaning much: the percentage of the company is kind of a funny thing. What I would ask them about more specifically is their plans for the employee stock pool. Stock options are (mostly) not liquid until there's been at least a couple rounds of funding, and each round of funding brings dilution to the existing shares.

Another bit of advice I wish I received before negotiating with start-ups: stock options are worth what they're worth now, not what they might be worth later. If you get 10,000 shares at a fair-market value of $0.01 that vests over 4 years, that compensation is worth $25 per year. (10,000 * 0.01 / 4). They will try to sell you on the shares sometimes being worth a lot more. I hope the shares are a lot more some day! But their expected value is their fair market value.

> what % of the company I'd be getting

A large percent of nothing is still nothing. Besides your own stock, ask questions to understand the financial maturity of the company. If it's a consumer product, how many customers have they signed up? If it's an enterprise product, have they signed any deals? If they haven't (which happens, signing enterprise deals can take 12-18 months) understand where the deals they are working on are in the pipeline. If they have 12 months of run-way but most of their deals are in the 18 month out horizon, understand that you are taking a lot of risk in joining that company. Also ask about potential customers that are not doing business with the company yet: why not? What are the blockers?

Don't be satisfied with answers like "our founders know this space, they've been here before." No start-up that has funding has an unimpressive founding team. There's no shortage of Ivy League/Stanford grads with years of experience at <whatever company impresses you these days>. Even with those pedigrees, 70% of those companies aren't going to be successful.

jkingsbery··on The Priest in the Arena
This article is extremely poorly written. The author makes many claims without justifying any of them. To the extent it had a point, the So What of the point gets lost.
jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Why do many CS graduates lack foundational knowledge?
This was a while ago now, but my undergrad requirements consisted of: (1) data structures and algorithms, (2) computer architecture, (3) advanced algorithms, (4) computational theory, (5) programming languages, and (6) a few electives (discrete math was also a requirement). To complete my electives I took a couple classes in AI/ML and a class in compilers. I went to a small liberal arts school for undergrad, so there was no database class offered, and I don't remember a class specifically in networking (although a little bit of networking was covered in an OS elective that was offered). I did get all 3 areas you mentioned in grad school though.

This all is to say: as a matter of curriculum design maybe we can train future software engineers better, but when presented with an individual candidate consider not only what the candidate knows now but also that person's ability to learn.

jkingsbery··on Something Pretty Right: The History and Legacy of Visual Basic
When I started to learn programming in the mid-90s, it was still common to not have home Internet (or, if you did, it was too expensive to spend the whole day online). I learned a lot of programming from the VB helpfiles, a random book on VB from Barnes and Nobles, and recording VB macros in Excel and frankenstein-ing them back together to do different things. In particular, learning from recording macros and seeing the command was a very intuitive way to learn - I didn't have to guess at what the first version of a program would do.
jkingsbery··on Inverted computer culture: A thought experiment
Good speculative fiction at least tries to give some reason why something might come to be the case. This article just says "pretend computers are old; old things are like X today; therefore, computers are going to be just like X," while ignoring all the things that are different.
jkingsbery··on How ‘Diversity’ Policing Fails Science
But it's not about people signing a thing saying they won't be racist. Since I know you read the article, I'm sure you saw the bit about someone penalizing a candidate for saying that "he respects his students and treats them equally." People can now quote the I Have A Dream Speech as part of their application essay and be branded racist for daring to say we should judge people by the content of their character. Whether it's coordinated or not is irrelevant - there is a group of people that push a particular subjective world view on others not just on not being racist but how one should not be racist.

Life doesn't have a liberal bias. If you think so, then either you are surrounding yourself by too many people that think exactly the same way you do (which kind of misses the point on diversity), or you have created an environment in which there are people who think differently than you, but are reluctant to actually speak their mind.

jkingsbery··on Telling your inner critic to chill
> Have you personally overcome imposter syndrome through this advice?

Yes, this is personally what I do.

> I think this could easily be read as meaning that aspiration is a precondition of self love.

I suppose I could have been more clear. Aspirations need not be professional, they could be moral, relationship based, experiential, etc. You're right that if we say "I can only love myself when I'm better" means you never will be happy with yourself, and that's not what I'm trying to say. But one of my favorite definitions of the word "love" is to will and act for the good of someone - and if you aren't doing something to make yourself or your life better in some way, then you are not acting with love to yourself. On the flip side, saying "Yeah, everything is great" is not actually making things better (and at the same time, neither is saying "everything is horrible").

jkingsbery··on Telling your inner critic to chill
Some of this seems like bad advice.

Imposter syndrome is a real thing, and it's certainly possible to be overly self-critical. But plenty of people aren't "in the right place," and aren't "doing the right thing." People only get "stronger, smarter, ... and more productive" through intentional self-development, not by wishful thinking. For most of us, to love ourselves means we should be aspiring to something better, and not content with how we are now. Telling yourself you're worse than you are isn't healthy, but neither is it healthy to tell yourself that you're better than you are.

I would advise someone to overcome imposter syndrome by anchoring in objective facts about reality.

jkingsbery··on A Person Paper on Purity in Language
No, I get that. He even explains that in the post-script at the bottom.

Maybe he's making a good point in an alternate universe.

jkingsbery··on Manage like an engineer
> Need to prepare a deck for a business review? Open an issue. Want to refresh our career ladders? Open an issue. Planning an offsite? You guessed it, open an issue.

As an engineer (not a manager!) who does a lot of non-engineering tasks: this kind of misses the point. Don't get me wrong - if creating a GitHub issue helps you keep track of things, great.

But GitHub (and most other engineering tracking tools) are meant for relatively clearly defined tasks, and the input on those tasks come only from engineers. But a lot of times we deal with amorphous, poorly defined tasks that involve non-engineers. "Put it in GitHub" is solving the easy part of the problem. The hard part is identifying who are all your stakeholders, getting them onboard, and turning that task that is ill-defined into something well-defined.

jkingsbery··on A Person Paper on Purity in Language
I guess. But we're not in that universe, we're in this one, and the dictionaries don't say that. Bad analogies can't lead to good logic by making them longer.
jkingsbery··on Fewer than 40% of New Yorkers earn a living wage
They are quite poor compared to NYC standards, but the idea that 60% of those people are not earning enough to maintain the lifestyle that Americans typically expect is just not credible.
jkingsbery··on Fewer than 40% of New Yorkers earn a living wage
> The living wage model does not allow for what many consider the basic necessities enjoyed by many Americans.

Call it whatever you want... New York being one of the richest states in the United States, saying that the median person in New York cannot afford "what many consider the basic necessities enjoyed by many Americans" is a contradiction. The idea that 60% of New Yorkers are not even at "subsistence" level of wages just makes no sense.

jkingsbery··on Names should be cute, not descriptive
> The world is boring enough as is. Let's add more whimsy and cuteness through our service and project names.

This is a recipe for creating a wholly impenetrable language about your services. Which is easier for an outsider to understand:

"I updated the code for how Batman writes to Goliath in Cair Paravel"

"I updated the code for how the backend services write to the customer database in the billing application."

> I don't want to be the one to advocate for delaying features so we can rename broadcast-service to broadcast-and-new-responsibility-service. That's going to be an unpleasant conversation with your product manager, for good reason: Because this never should have happened, and it's a waste of time to change the name.

What seems to happen more often at the particular Large Company I work for is that not just responsibilities change, but fundamental assumptions underlying the architecture of a system change every few years. So rather than renaming a service, often a new system is put in place that reflects these new assumptions, and this new system will have a new name. The migration then isn't about the new name, it's about the new system, along with the new APIs and model of operation that comes with it. Yes, there are lots of examples of billing systems written 40 years ago in COBOL, but most software systems have a lifecycle on the order of 3-5 years.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Lead developer but I just don't enjoy management
I've worked as a manager of engineers for three different companies, and in 2 of those 3 times it followed the pattern of my manager being stretched too thin and asking me to take on management capabilities.

I figure at some time in the future I'll probably have to do it again, but like you, it's not the thing I enjoy. My current company has a non-management track, allowing me to stay as an individual contributor. Some of what you describe is really about getting sucked into management specifically, but some of what you describe is inherent to increasing in seniority. As a more senior individual contributor, I get to still focus on technical problems, but a lot of these technical problems are more about what is the right system to use for solving a problem, or how to get two systems to talk to each other, rather than writing the code for that myself. Also, as you gain seniority more of what you do is necessarily going to be giving advice and feedback to others - but as a more senior IC, most of the feedback I find myself giving is about how to approach technical problems rather than dealing with HR headache type feedback.

It sounds like the company you work for is relatively new. It might be worth raising the concept of a dedicated IC track with your manager. That being said, it might simply be impractical for the company to move you to that position until it has grown a bit more.

jkingsbery··on A Person Paper on Purity in Language
> He even says as much in the postscript.

Yep, I read the post-script.

From the post-script:

> to develop an extended analogy with something known as shocking and reprehensible

I guess maybe to say a different way - given that's not how English works, then this isn't a shocking analogy, it's a bad one.

jkingsbery··on A Person Paper on Purity in Language
I don't really know what to make of this satire... I find this confusing:

> In most contexts, it is self-evident when "white" is being used in an inclusive sense, in which case it subsumes members of the darker race just as much as fairskins.

That's definitely not how that works. "Black" and "white" are opposite in the dictionary. Looking up the term "man" in the dictionary [1][2], they all contain as one of the definitions of "a human being of either sex; a person" or something like it. It is at worst an unclear-but-possible construal to use the word "man" to imply "person," whereas construing "white" to mean "white or black" is not how any version of English works.

[1]: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/man

[2]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/man

[3]: https://www.google.com/search?q=definition+man

jkingsbery··on How transportation technologies shaped empires
If the hypothesis includes the stipulation "from the capital," it would have been useful to see some commentary on what the author thought about the Roman Empire moving its capital (or having multiple emperors each with a capital).
jkingsbery··on Microsoft workers to form company’s first union in the U.S.
(I'm assuming by football you mean American football)

It's not really a fair comparison. The NFL is a monopoly, so there is no way for athletes to vote with their feet. At various times in the past, in order to negotiate the NFLPA has had to decertify in order to sue the league.

The NFL is also not a good proxy, because the average career for an NFL player is 2-3 years, and it is a physically dangerous job.

jkingsbery··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
But that's what the word in Latin doctus means: being learned or skilled in something: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/doctus.

And in any case, when a word is incorporated from another language, it's meaning is misunderstood all the time. Why is this case somehow morally offensive?

jkingsbery··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
> for various ideological reasons

They are opposed to colonies wherever they might be, even lunar colonies.

jkingsbery··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
But "person" has the word "son" in it, and that's gendered.

Better go with huperchild.

jkingsbery··on The Boring Conservatism of Elon Musk
I was referring of course, to the quote

> Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.

I'm not presenting a strawman - it's what the quote said. The quote makes a claim about the proposition made by conservatives. I suppose though I did make an ad hominem attack - the fact that the quote cited came from a musical composer (and not a political scientist of the same name) speaks in neither direction to its veracity. The quote claims that conservatives want laws to apply to some and not to others. That conservatives don't generally think this way can be seen by reading anything from Thomas Sowell, George Will, or Milton Friedman (for just a few examples). I could pull out particular examples from their books, but their books are dripping with examples - open to a random page in any of the three authors and you'll find one.

The quote in question, however, is presenting a strawman, by not presenting any examples in support of it.

jkingsbery··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
I think they are entirely over used whatever one chooses to call them, but these don't mean the same thing at all. Content note could mean anything. For people with PTSD though, for whom psychological triggering is a real thing (not just something they don't like), a "trigger warning" means something pretty specific (or at least, it did before it became overused).
← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →