HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jkingsbery

2,170 karma · joined January 19, 2010

submissionscomments
jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Literature on crisis response?
This week's EconTalk talked about the general problem of responding to crises, and I found the guest's (and host's) take interesting (https://www.econtalk.org/megan-mcardle-on-catastrophes-and-t...). They talked about how often we respond to infrequent crises by trying to prevent them from happening again, but then that investment goes to waste because that crises doesn't happen again (or doesn't happen for a long time, after which the investment has depreciated). They both advocated for focusing on being more responsive to crises, since adaptability can help more generally across many types of crises.
jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Do you read books regularly? Fiction or nonfiction?
I've gone through phases where I'm more or less organized.

Since the start of COVID and not needing to commute, I found myself with time to exercise for the first time in many years. In order to use that time efficiently and avoid injuries that would inevitably come from someone in his late 30's pretending he's in his early 20's, I read a bunch of books around running, biking, strength training and nutrition over the summer.

I try to make myself read some fiction, but I don't feel compelled too often enough, so it doesn't happen much. I end up re-reading Lord of the Rings and Chronicles of Narnia every 2-3 years.

I've been listening to a few Audible books lately about Roman History. A finished a biography of Caesar and a book offering (yet another) set of theories on the fall of the Roman Empire. I'm currently listening to a book about Cicero's life.

For sorta-related-to-work I have a few really niche books I'm reading on Telecom OSS/BSS, network planning and telecom regulation.

I think my favorite author remains GK Chesterton, he has a couple books I try to re-read every so often. It's fascinating how he was writing around 100 years ago, and how around 25% is super old-timey cultural references or things that no one would think today, but how much of it is still pretty relevant. Also, I haven't read anyone better at turning a phrase.

jkingsbery··on Technical interview methods pale in comparison to playing Factorio with someone
Dyson Sphere Program is so good. I haven't played Factorio yet, but I think it has all the same sorts of things that this article described.

When I started playing DSP at first, I was just putting stuff anywhere. Then I realized that there are advantages in trying to make things modular in a way roughly analogous with code. At the same time though, it is very different than code, as the design is spacial, not as abstract as coding. Refactoring code is very different as a result.

jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
Again, your summary is a simplistic half truth. There are lots of prominent examples of intra-party checks.

Trump recently was opposed in political processes by his own Vice President and Supreme Court nominees, as well as some members of Congress.

Within the Democratic party, there are also examples of these checks happening within the party. DeBlasio (mayor of NY) and Cuomo (governor of the state of NY) have been fighting against each other for years.

More generally though, not everything in the US is a political decision. There are other practical checks on the political process itself, like the freedom of speech Many Americans either don't like either party, or at least don't like the leadership if either party right now. We don't have songs like "Without the Communist Party, There Would Be No New China" (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Without_the_Communist_Party,...). While unlikely, in the US parties can go, and have gone, extinct through the normal political process. And every four years (depending on who wins the Presidential election) there are opinion pieces considering one party or the other's demise. If people disappear for comparing the CCP's leader to Winnie the Pooh, I can't imagine it's very safe to write about the CCP's demise within China.

jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
The US is designed with the idea of checks and balances. It is a half-truth that the Supreme Court can make up whatever interpretations it wants. It can only consider cases that come before it, and it can only take so many cases in a year. With the cases before it, in practice, there are a whole host of things limiting what interpretations are possible, such as precedent, the desire to reach consensus on a more limited ruling, the possibility of setting a precedent that could later be used against the justice's goal, and the fact that justices have to work together even though they strongly disagree with each other. These are in addition to the other checks and balances spelled out in the Constitution, such as the possibility of impeachment of justices.
jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
I didn't know anything about Fred Hampton, so I looked him up (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton). I suppose his example highlights the difference between the US and China, as his family was paid $1.85 million for his death, which is probably still not what they have wanted, but an acknowledgement of government wrongdoing. When is the last time CCP acknowledged wrongdoing?

McCarthyism offers another interesting contrast. Read https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism. There was lots of opposition to McCarthy. Even a noted anti-communism person such as President Truman criticized McCarthy. Most if McCarthy's victims got their day in court, and ultimately the scale (affecting hundreds of people) is dwarfed by the scale of CCP persecution of pro-democracy or those who wish to practice a religion not endorsed by the CCP, which has damaged the lives of millions.

jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
No. The items I linked to all criticise the entirety of the events they describe, not just how to be a better imperialist. Please point out where in the linked to items you get your interpretation.
jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
> The fragility of American imperialism and its fear in being portrayed in any negative light knows no limits.

This is 100% unarguably, demonstrably false. Americans write books critical about American imperialism (https://www.amazon.com/Imperial-Cruise-Secret-History-Empire...), we make (and fund with public broadcasting money!) documentaries that criticize both the effectiveness and wisdom of our own military efforts (https://www.pbs.org/kenburns/the-vietnam-war/). Most US media has been very critical of recent military efforts. These are just a few examples.

Is the US perfect? No. Are there examples of it the US behaving in a way that makes its citizens less than proud? Yes. But there is a wide gulf between the US and the CCP and what one can get away with saying and doing in the US vs. what one can say or do under CCP control.

jkingsbery··on 'Do Not Split': A Hong Kong protest film [video]
I read this similarly. In the US, there are lots of things that the government doesn't control, and even for things the government does control the federal, state and local governments can be controlled by different parties that have conflicting priorities. Also, the way that the political parties are structured in the US is very different, where there are national party organizations, but also local party organizations that do as much influencing over the national parties as vice versa.

To reduce the difference between China's political situation and the US's to be the difference between 2 parties and 1 is not accurate.

jkingsbery··on The dispassionate developer
I had a similar reaction when comparing software engineering to other professions. My brother is a lawyer, and he has to do continuing legal education (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuing_legal_education). I have friends who are doctors that go to (and sometimes speak at) conferences. I'm not sure that we software engineers need to spend all our free time on leetcode and answering StackOverflow questions, but reading a book about something outside of normal work hours seems like pretty tame stakes.
jkingsbery··on EU agency says AstraZeneca vaccine is 'safe and effective'
I'm in the US (New Jersey specifically, which has done terribly with the roll out), so maybe it's different in the EU, but at least here we don't have an over-abundance of vaccine doses. Eliminating one of the vaccines currently limits vaccine supply in most places.
jkingsbery··on EU agency says AstraZeneca vaccine is 'safe and effective'
If it is up to each nation, that's too bad. We should be treating adults as adults, telling them "here's the information: about 30 people had bloodclots out of 5,000,000 having received the vaccine (source: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-56397592). We're not sure if any of those 30 are linked to the vaccine. If those risks seem acceptable to you, here's the vaccine."
jkingsbery··on Right to Repair Gaining Momentum
I'm pretty in favor of right-to-repair, but I came here to see if any one had good reasons for not having right-to-repair (or limiting it). Thanks for providing this alternative view point!

It probably doesn't apply to phones, but the liability is an interesting question, especially for equipment with a lifetime of decades.

jkingsbery··on The Sovietization of the American Press
Both parties destroy their own.

There are a number of anti-Trump Republican politicians. For standing up to Trump, they face primary challenges and other career-affecting blow-back.

The left also destroys its own sometimes. An interesting recent case is Governor Andrew Cuomo of New York, who after (1) making a decision that we now understand is poor which lead to thousands of unnecessary deaths, (2) forced a government health organization to change a report solely for political reasons, (3) has bullied pretty much everyone in New York state politics, AND (4) now has 6 credible (i.e., not necessarily true, but believable) accusations of impropriety from women that worked for him, Democrats are suggesting that maybe he be investigated.

The comparison to the Soviets should always be careful. The original article does a good job showing actual examples of the parallels, so we can see that the comparison goes only as far as media treatment.

jkingsbery··on The Miseducation of America’s Elites
Agreed, but citations needed:

http://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiii/en/encyclicals/docume...

http://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documen...

http://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/en/encyclicals/docu...

http://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/en/encyclicals/docu...

http://www.vatican.va/content/paul-vi/en/encyclicals/documen...

http://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/do...

http://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/do...

http://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/do...

http://www.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/en/encyclicals/do...

http://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/docum...

http://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_exhortation...

These are just a few examples. Besides that, there is all the work that Catholic, Christian and other religious organizations due in charity work and providing the only functioning schools in a community.

There is also a more libertarian-leaning (i.e., people who don't like being called "conservative") approach that points out (1) capitalism has done more to lift people from poverty than any other human invention, and (2) too often, government regulations actually get in the way of social justice (see, e.g., housing regulations).

It strikes me as stunningly ignorant that someone can believe that there is no "conservative position on social justice."

jkingsbery··on Passion Not Required: It's OK to Only Program for a Paycheck
Agreed, that's what I mean. A lot of people still check email on vacation. I set an example by not doing that. I also (gently, half-jokingly) give people grief when they check email when they are supposed to not do that.
jkingsbery··on The Uyghur Genocide: An examination of breaches of the 1948 Genocide Convention
I haven't read it all yet, but are there any (1) incorrect statements of fact or (2) specific opinions that seem unjustified leaps?
jkingsbery··on Rent controls have split housing in Berlin into two distinct markets
In practice, this almost never happens. There isn't a fixed supply of bread. When the price of bread goes up, the following all happen:

- Bakers will bake more bread - People from an area with cheaper bread will travel farther to sell bread where it's more expensive - Individuals will decide to bake bread for themselves - Companies that don't bake bread but that have the capability of baking bread (either directly, or with minor changes) will start baking bread.

All these activities happen in proportion to the price increase, increasing volume and putting pressure on prices to go back down. And this article describes the data showing that this happens.

jkingsbery··on Passion Not Required: It's OK to Only Program for a Paycheck
I appreciate the point of this article, but I think it oversimplifies both the thing it's criticizing and the solution.

Maybe others have heard "you must be willing to put your work family first" or "you can use your vacation time, but do you really need to?" I have not heard either of these in my career. No where (large company, small company, private company, publicly trade company, company founded the previous year or a company founded 125 years previously) had anyone said or implied expectations other than my actual family should come first. Every where I worked, ensuring that we took sufficient vacation time was encouraged (although I have worked with people that misunderstand that vacation time means that you don't work, and that checking email is working).

More subtly, However, is how companies handle "crunch time," (again, this has been a thing in pretty much every company I've worked at regardless of size, age, or industry). No one is saying "this is more important than your family," but they will say "we need to get this done by X date." The managers I have respected understand that there are sacrifices to do this and do something to make it up (e.g., give bonus vacation days). But on our end, we have a paycheck because our company takes in revenue - our job is to do the things that ensure we continue to ensure revenue, we can't just say "I wrote the program, I'm out."

However, there is something to keeping your management accountable that this is a career for us, not a charity. If you want us to stick around, you have to pay us. If you want to build a team that people want to work on, we need passionate people but we also need people representing a diversity of skills, interests, race, gender, ways of thinking, etc. Many of the people I've enjoyed working with are certainly passionate about programming, but they had passions outside of work and coding. They have hobbies that include reading fiction, running, building stuff with Arduinos, or doing community service. They spend time with their families and friends.

I also agree with the article as it rejects the "this is how to be a real programmer" mentality. It's easy for that to introduce bias about who a group hires, promotes and works to retain (or the people we as a software engineering community tend to attract). There are lots of ways to be a "real" programmer (whatever that's supposed to mean).

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Are you on a technical specialist career path, what does it look like?
I'm a Principal Engineer at a big tech company, so I think I fit your description. But I don't think the phrase "technical specialist" applies to me. From being at a big tech company, I know of some technical specialists, that have an amazing depth of knowledge in one area. For me though, I got to where I am focusing more on knowing a little about a lot of things and being able to tie things together.

In our company, Principal Engineers (PE's) have varying responsibilities, but they usually revolve around (1) reducing ambiguity in projects and (2) proactively looking out for technical challenges that can bite the team in the long run. That can mean a lot of different things. For me, it's mostly involved writing design documents to come up with strategies for solving problems (and all that's needed to do that, such as getting iterative feedback, doing deeper dives in particular areas, reading industry or academic research, talking to people who have knowledge in more specific areas) and writing code to tackle more challenging areas. These problems are usually ones that would span multiple development teams.

The question of "transferability" that someone else brought up is interesting. At least in my career, I've jumped in to some pretty niche things that have proved in the end to be transferrable. The fact that I had experience managing a data science team before helped me get my 3rd job. A major factor in getting my 4th job came from the fact that in my 3rd job I had worked with Erlang. And my current role I got at least in part because of my experience at a telco startup. What I've found is that in any job, some stuff is completely dead-end knowledge (my domain knowledge about number porting will probably never be used again), some niche knowledge that might come up again (knowing how to do Bayesian probability analysis or write Erlang code), and some things that you'll apply over and over again (how to learn a new domain; how to work in an area where you are not an expert; how to understand customer needs; how to effectively communicate your ideas).

In any case, even if you aren't managing people, as you advance as an individual contributor, mentoring and helping other people grow will still be a large part of your responsibilities. In our company, the senior individual contributors often advise managers on how to think about the performance of individuals.

jkingsbery··on Making Games on Your Own as an Engineer
Good article - it's a useful distinction whether you're building something to sell or something for fun.

One resource worth mentioning is: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228884866_MDA_A_For.... Working backwards from the desired kind of game you want to make based on the 8 categories this paper talks about (sensation, fantasy, narrative, challenge, fellowship, discovery, expression, submission/abnegation) can give you a clearer way of measuring success than whether you did a good job implementing whatever mechanic you thought of.

Another thing the article doesn't mention that I think can be valuable for software engineers is doing paper prototypes. As engineers, we often think about producing code as the only way to build prototypes, but sometimes you can get mileage from testing a game mechanic through much cheaper to produce paper prototypes of the game (or a part of the game).

jkingsbery··on Twitter locks out Irish Bishop after he criticized euthanasia
It's a half-joke in Catholic media circles that making comments like this is likely to receive some kind of punishment on social media... I say "half-joke" because it happens extremely frequently and those writers in that world all know it happens and try to laugh about it.

As someone in the tech world, I spend most of my time interacting with more "liberal" people. I don't hear about this happening with any frequency, accidentally or otherwise, to those on the left. At the same time "diversity of thought" is something I only read about in right-leaning circles. Events like the one shown in this article are why diversity of thought matters. This is clearly an important debate, and Twitter, willfully or systematically, is shutting down a legitimate, notable voice in the debate, and Twitter is ill-equipped to even understand that the point made by the bishop is reasonable (if not universally shared).

jkingsbery··on Twitter locks out Irish Bishop after he criticized euthanasia
The offending tweet was arguing against all forms of suicide, assisted or otherwise. I'm trying to understand your point charitably, but it escapes me how arguing against suicide could be interpreted as arguing for suicide. I understand that there's a consequentialist argument ("it is going to happen anyway"), but that seems to accept something as inevitable which is not.
jkingsbery··on John McWhorter: The Neoracists
The "or in deciding how we express ourselves" is what gets me in that passage. The social contract we had was described by Voltaire in Letters on England #6 ("as there are such a multitude, they all live happy and in peace", https://www.gutenberg.org/files/2445/2445-h/2445-h.htm). My religion should affect how I express myself; my religion should not affect how you express yourself (or vice versa).
jkingsbery··on John McWhorter: The Neoracists
> Of a hundred fundamentalist Christians, how many do you suppose could be convinced via argument to become atheists?

The word "fundamentalist" is unhelpful here, but if you ask adult Christians why they are Christian, I would be willing to bet most would give you a reasonably rational, well-articulated answer (that you may happen to disagree with). The same is true for adults of other religions.

The other problem with this particular statement is that statistics show that lots of Christians stop being Christians. Some were devout Christians who become devout Atheists. Some were lukewarm Christians who stopped going to church. Some never really went to Church, so just stopped calling themselves Christian. On the other hand, there are plenty of biographies of atheists who became Christian.

jkingsbery··on Stop defacing quotes with brackets
The root behind most (meaningful) objections to bad grammar comes back to clarity - by using poor grammar, the writer obfuscates the meaning of a sentence. In this case, the meaning is perfectly clear, and it is pretty obvious what the original quote is. Writing a whole article nit-picking something like this is obnoxious and silly.
jkingsbery··on Losing bonds sports fans
Reading through the actual study, there were 752 fans surveyed, but 290 were fans of one team, and 27 were for teams other than the 10 teams they were focusing on, so really the analysis was a survey of 435 people. Also, the measure of affinity was answering a hypothetical question (a version of the Trolley Dilemma, except the person being asked would have to sacrifice himself/herself). So I'm a bit skeptical it's as simple as the study makes it out to be.

Anecdotally, it seems like it should be more complicated too. As a New York Yankees fan who was in Massachusetts when the Boston Red Sox won their first World Series (Major League Baseball) in 80+ years, it seems winning was a pretty big bonding moment for Red Sox fans.

I think affinity must also be different depending on the region. If you go to Boston, there are signs everywhere for the Red Sox and Patriots. In Seattle, everything is all about the Seahawks. In the New York area, we have multiple teams in the major pro sports, so sport-team-affinity and location-affinity are necessarily more loosely coupled here.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: What is the oldest image online in which the link is not broken?
> "Never on the Internet have so few worked so hard to bring you so much in so little time."

Gotta love the editorializing right there.

jkingsbery··on It’s time for a new, progressive supply-side economics
All good ideas for things to go fix!

I don't understand why this is "progressive," in the way that term is usually used. I have been reading various different conservatives arguing for supply-side changes in these different industries my entire adult life. Sometimes, a thing is just a thing that people can agree on independent of world view. For example, the author could have instead written "People who care about affordable housing must continue to unite against excessive zoning and NIMBYism."

jkingsbery··on Why do we assume extraterrestrials might want to visit us?
No, the claim "early in the development of trains people were sure it would be physically impossible for humans to travel over 30 mph or so" cannot be correct, because people had been traveling faster than 30 mph on horse back for at least centuries. There's no way anyone can think was true given that they had many counterexamples.

The article you sited says that some people thought there might be issues at 50 mph. Evidently there were some people who thought this, but that doesn't say anything about how wide-spread that thinking was.

← PreviousPage 8 of 21Next →