HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jkingsbery

2,170 karma · joined January 19, 2010

submissionscomments
jkingsbery··on Enterprise UX Design: Make me think
The problem with this article is that there are lots of different kinds of enterprise software.

If you are building a piece of software that is The Software that your user will be using most of the day, I think this is good advice. But there is tons of enterprise software that this doesn't apply to:

* When the primary users of enterprise software are in high turn over jobs, they are unlikely to develop expertise in your tool.

* When users need to use once a month or once every six months, they won't be able to develop expertise in your software. Think about HR systems for updating contact information (which only happens at major life events) or updating benefits (which happens during open enrollment once a year, or during major events). Or maybe a portal you log in once per month to pay a bill.

* When your software is used often, but it is one of many tools that your users context switch between, they are unlikely to develop expertise in your software. The switching between different pieces of software means that there isn't enough time for things like muscle memory for keyboard shortcuts to develop.

Enterprise UX design, like all UX design, should start with understanding the customers and their needs.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: How to get rid of impostor syndrome?
To add to bonoboTP's useful comments:

> When I do mimic accomplishing various things, this mostly comes from taking various portions of online example code, reformulating it, and doing some basic data plumbing to make it work the way I want it to.

What you've described is common. It's the basis for the punchline to https://xkcd.com/1988/ .

> I have in fact built tons of projects and worked on large codebases, but I'm not certain that makes me an engineer or that any of this is a genuine accomplishment.

I don't know your background, you'll need to figure out some yourself.

I've heard in my career two conflicting opinions. Opinion A: "You can't be a real engineer unless you built something from scratch." Opinion B: "You can't be a real engineer unless you've worked on a large scale project." The number of engineers that have worked continuously on one project from inception to millions of customers is pretty small. Most of us either take a project from inception to some small scale over the course of a couple years, or we are dropped into an existing project that has scaled to one size and we keep it up and running (and maybe growing) for a couple years. There are different challenges with both taking a project from inception to a small scale and with managing something at a large scale, and they are both valuable.

> I should already know all this at this point in my career.

I don't know how far along you are in your career, but programming exercises are valuable whether you've been programming for a couple years or several decades.

There's always more to learn. Not knowing something about software engineering doesn't disqualify you from being a software engineer.

One other thing I do I forgot to mention: ask others for specific feedback. If you're not sure about how you did on something, hearing from someone who you trust to be honest can be helpful relieve your concerns, or help you to at least make your gaps more concrete.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: How to get rid of impostor syndrome?
A few things I do:

1. I recall to myself that the stuff I do is hard. If I feel like I'm in over my head, it's because most people would find what I do challenging.

2. I also look back on things accomplished. Imposters, by definition, haven't accomplished the things they say they have. Engineers with imposter syndrome worry that their accomplishments are somehow insufficient, but they have accomplishments to point to. There is a big difference.

3. Something I learned from a math professor of mine: ask simple questions about a new topic to check your understanding. The act of asking a simple question can help you validate that you actually understand what you're learning.

4. I tell people "I don't know" when I don't know. I've found that almost always, when you say you don't know something, the person will acknowledge that's reasonable. (That person might still want you to come back with an answer later though :-) ). The education system serves us poorly in training us that saying "I don't know" is somehow a bad thing.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: What is the best money you have spent on professional development?
As many others have said, books are the best things I've spent money on, but let me say more:

Do books sometimes say things that are obvious? Yes. For example, when I first read Martin Fowler's book Refactoring, I had been renaming variables and moving methods from one class to another for years. But he gave a new framework for thinking about something that obvious. I've found the idea of separating out my coding flow between adding functionality and improving code really helpful.

Can you get the material for free? Almost always, yes. But it takes time to find the right material, and our time is valuable. A typical industry book is $40-$50, and a typical text book is $100-$150. The authors of these books have spent time organizing the material in a helpful way that you would otherwise need to spend.

For some topics though, it's not just a matter of time savings. I'm working on a topic now that doesn't really have many useful books, so I'm having to read technical specifications produced by industry groups, which lack context and are pretty opaque. I'm missing having a book that explains these ideas in a coherent fashion.

I have tried a few MOOCs for professional development. I've found they can be helpful for a superficial understanding, but they don't encourage the deep understanding I get from reading through a book.

jkingsbery··on Hemingway Editor
Well done.
jkingsbery··on Hemingway Editor
90% of the time when I give feedback reviewing other people's work that they use passive, it's not using about active for the sake of active. It's that in choosing to use the passive, the writer leaves ambiguous who is performing an action.
jkingsbery··on Optimizing Things in the USSR (2016)
Computational complexity was one of 6 reasons the author listed at why the optimization problem was infeasible. I read the article in its entirety, and I saw a claim that the number of calculations scaled in polynomial time, but I didn't see any claims of problems that are verifiable in polynomial time with no known polynomial time solutions.

Then there's the other 5 criteria, which show that this is not a computer science problem. Coming up with an objective function is entirely a subjective matter. It depends entirely on what the ruling party wants. Communist countries don't act to the benefit of all, they act to the benefit of the chosen few, just those few are chosen differently.

jkingsbery··on How to revert HP printer’s ban on 3rd-party ink cartridges
For whatever it's worth:

I just switched from a Brother printer to Lexmark. Not sure if it's Brother itself or just the model, but my particular printer only could connect over WiFi (no ethernet option), and it kept getting confused about it's IP address and dropping from our network. I bought a different printer after losing several hours of needing to use my limited network engineering skills to diagnose so I could print out worksheets for my kids. I haven't had issues since.

jkingsbery··on Why Leaders Need to Learn the Skill of Writing
It doesn't make forming them any easier, it's just a forcing function to spend longer on the task. While it certainly is possible to have a topic that just cannot be handled in 6 pages, my experience is that after removing weasel words, filler, non-essential details, adverbs and the like, 6 pages is enough to base a conversation on most topics when the group has basic familiarity with the subject matter.
jkingsbery··on Why Leaders Need to Learn the Skill of Writing
The large tech company I work for puts a lot of emphasis on writing. Here are a few suggestions:

1. If you want people to read what you wrote and give you feedback, conciseness is important. We have a general rule of thumb that it takes people 30 minutes to read 4-6 pages of terse material, and it takes roughly an hour to then discuss it. As a result, pretty much all our docs are 6 pages (in the main body; appendixes might be added but are written in a way so that the doc stands on its own without them).

2. For many forms of (non-fiction) communication, the inverted pyramid is a helpful way to structure your thoughts. People are most likely to read the beginning of something, When we read the whole thing, we're more likely to pay more attention to the beginning. It's important then to get the most important information in the beginning, with supporting details as you go.

3. Know the audience, and focus on why the audience should care. If it's not clear why the audience would care, try rephrasing or restructuring to focus on the part they actually would care about.

4. Do lots of iterations. Get feedback from others. You can also iterate on your writing yourself: I find that when I write something and come back to it later, I'm better at finding issues. In order to do a lot of iterations, that means you need to plan out your time. In my company, we often kick-off the doc writing process with a "working backwards" schedule: we're presenting to such-and-such VP on Day X, so we have to have a rough draft of the whole doc on Day Y, so we have to have drafts of individual pieces by Day Z.

5. Be aware of what kind of thing your writing. I'd say 75% of my writing, my audience is myself: I'm writing in order to work through thoughts. I approach that differently when I'm writing something for review by teammates, which I again approach differently from a doc written for other groups.

6. Maybe a bit controversial in some circles, but: Strunk and White (https://www.amazon.com/Elements-Style-Fourth-William-Strunk/...). It's a short book, and even if you don't do everything in it, the focus on clarity and succinctness is still useful.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Jack-of-all-trades of HN, how do you approach job search?
>Startups want generalists. Larger companies want specialists

This is sometimes true. I've worked at startups though that only wanted to hire people that had familiarity in their chosen stack, since they have short runway and don't have time to invest in people's ramp up. In the current large company I work for we generally favor "fungible" software engineers (but, in one's day to day work, maybe a particular engineer will wear fewer hats at a large company).

When you interview at a company, you should interview your interviewers to find out whether this is true in the particular situation you find yourself in.

jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Jack-of-all-trades of HN, how do you approach job search?
It's been a few years, but prior to that I went through a period where I worked I did a job search 3 times in a little more than 2.5 years. Here's the process:

1. I start by reaching out to people I know - bosses or teammates I've enjoyed working with, recruiters that have proved trustworthy and so on. People who now me and who have worked with me before know the value I bring, even though I don't really excel in any one area. (Early on in my career, this wasn't literally "people I know," this would be more connections through my school.)

2. Since a lot of interview technical questions skew towards Stuff We Learn in University, I usually skim over my college and grad school text books. That way, if someone throws something at me that I haven't really dealt with in 12 years, I can at least have enough freshness in my mind that I can problem solve through it.

3. I practice problems from a "programming challenges" book like the one by Skiena. I do some of these at a computer. However, since many companies do coding challenges on a whiteboard and these are timed, I try to recreate this by doing some coding problems with pencil and paper while timing myself. Whether or not it is a good idea for companies to do coding problems on a whiteboard is an interesting question, but in the course of a job search, but this is the world we live in. Writing programs while timed is particularly stressful, but by practicing beforehand I find I'm able to adapt to the stress better.

4. A lot of the value we provide (both as experienced engineers and as jack-of-all-trades) is best demonstrated through historical examples, and many companies ask about historical examples. So I make sure that I've gone through the important projects I've worked on in my career, and can talk about the situation I was in for the project, what I did, and what the result of the project was.

5. It's hard to know who looks at what in an application submission, but for any company I apply to I write a cover letter explaining why my unique set of skills makes me a good fit for the particular role I'm applying for. As a hiring manager, I saw people clearly copy and paste other cover letters (e.g., I was in advertising and I'd get cover letters ending "... and that's why I want to work in finance"). As an applicant, I write each of these from scratch, going through each item in the job description and saying something very brief about how that's a thing I've done before. (Earlier in my career, I would use examples from undergrad and grad school.) I've generally had pretty good response rates with this strategy.

6. Across all steps, I work in as much as I comfortably can that as a jack of all trades the value I provide is not that I can implement solutions in the area I'm hired for soon after being hired (although, I can), it's that I can handle the uncertainty that comes in many environments, and I can talk about examples where I've done this in the past. Some companies appreciate the value this brings, but some do not. The ones that don't will probably under value you.

I hope it helps!

jkingsbery··on That company whose name used to contain HTML script tags Ltd
Convince the powers-that-be in your company to invest in contracting with a marketing/SEO person or team to help come up with a new name. You want someone with marketing chops so that it's a good name, but you also want someone who knows about SEO so you don't end up on the second page for your own name search.
jkingsbery··on The No-Code Generation is arriving
I don't read the skepticism as "I don't like this trend," but rather "this trend is not new." And I agree with you that the relationship that people have with computers is fascinating. But as others have pointed out when you tell people "You can do all this stuff without coding," but when what you're really doing is making it easier for people to code while calling it "not code," you're forcing them to reinvent this history of computing, but now they don't have the language to connect what they're doing to what the industry has been doing since 1959.

But the article is just very self contradictory. It doesn't make sense to say "The No-Code Generation is arriving," while also saying that "Lua has never been more popular," or that we just had "the largest increase among all of the [Advanced Placement] organization’s dozens of tests" or "Meanwhile at top universities, computer science has emerged as the top or among the top majors, pulling in hundreds of new students per campus per year." Quite clearly, besides "no-code" platforms, there quite clearly is a growth in interest in traditional coding tools as well.

jkingsbery··on Twitter still hasn't unlocked the New York Post's account
As someone who reads the NYPost regularly, I find that it's an interesting outlet. It publishes a lot of "tabloid" stuff that's worth skipping - celebrity sitings, silly videos that went virals about cats or people trying to escape the police by doing cartwheels, and outlandish headlines. But if you read certain sections (Sports, Business, Metro), the articles are written as they would be in any other outlet (with the exception that maybe the Opinion & Editorial section is more conservative leaning than other NY newspapers).
jkingsbery··on ‘Culture wars’ are fought by tiny minority – UK study
The comparison to religious rituals is interesting. As someone who is Catholic, this looks to me sort of like an attempt at a group confession, but at least in the Catholic tradition we perform examinations of conscience [1] and go to confession [2] and we are told to come to terms with what we actually did wrong. You don't get away with some vague acknowledgement of being a sinner. As the Catechism says, "Through such an admission [a person] looks squarely at the sins he [or she] is guilty of, [and] takes responsibility for them."

Whether one agrees with Catholics on any number of things (and many reasonable people do not), there is a certain logic to the idea that before you can be better, you have to actually say what's wrong. Forcing a group of people to self label as racist in the way described above is unmoored from reality: even if one had done things that were racist in the past, there is no looking squarely at one's short comings, and there is no taking responsibility for anything. And for someone who hadn't done anything racist, or for someone who claims to have never done anything racist, it's just a show, and things won't actually get better in a meaningful way.

[1] https://www.usccb.org/prayer-and-worship/sacraments-and-sacr...

[2] https://www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p2s...

jkingsbery··on ‘Culture wars’ are fought by tiny minority – UK study
What you say might be the case - that some people are trying to take a word with certain connotations and change it's definition. If they had read more, they would see the self-parody that creates.

> 'When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.'

jkingsbery··on Better Than JSON?
> "XML is like violence. If it doesn't work, you're not using enough of it."

That same saying would also work replacing XML for soap (but not SOAP).

jkingsbery··on Be prolific
Maybe the author, rather than writing 1 good article describing it, is planning on writing several articles on the same topic in the hopes of getting better at writing about it over time?
jkingsbery··on Workforce Foundation
There was a post recently on the 1st page about helping those leaving prison with finding employment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24652182). A co-worker of mine mentioned some work he does outside of his normal job with a similar organization, I thought others might be interested.
jkingsbery··on I miss Microsoft Encarta (2019)
I spent a lot of time playing the maze game that came with Encarta, and like the author when I think of the "I Have a Dream" speech, I usually think about the version I watched on Encarta (as well as JFKs speech about going to the moon).

Just this morning at breakfast, my daughter said to me "Did you know about goliath birdeating spiders?" I told her that I did not, but I looked it up on wikipedia. I started telling them how wikipedia is a digital version of encyclopedias, which many of us used to have in our home, came in ~20 book sets and had articles about almost everything you could want to know about. My younger daughter's response to the idea of having a 20 book set about all sorts of different topics was "Why would you do that?" Not only are things like Encarta and Encyclopedias foreign to kids growing up, the logic on why one would need something like that is lost on them. It's not necessarily a bad thing (wikipedia is awesome in its own right), but it is interesting.

jkingsbery··on Justice Department sues Yale for illegal practices in admissions
I don't have data either way. Do you have a citation?
jkingsbery··on The Vikings Were More Complicated Than You Might Think
So, for example: what I learned in school is "the time between 500-1500 (roughly) did not have a lot of written records" and that was the end of story. Since reading on my own, I've found:

* Really, the time where there weren't any written records were mostly concentrated to 500-750 or so. Even though I had learned about Charlegmagne in school, I hadn't really learned much about all he did to encourage reading and writing (obviously, to the extent that it was possible given the cost of vellum at the time). The amount of written records were also not uniform geographically. As the original article says, Scandinavians wrote less than people in souther Europe.

* There actually are decent-for-pre-modern records of England from the time around the Vikings. The story in school was mostly "Things were great under the Roman empire, then things fell off a cliff and stayed that way for 1000 years." In reality though, there are the Domesday Book or the writings of Venerable Bede (just to mention two examples) that record events of the time.

Of course, there wasn't the printing press so it is technically true that things were less documented, I think this is just less so than commonly believed.

jkingsbery··on The Vikings Were More Complicated Than You Might Think
The more I read about the Middle Ages now that I'm an adult, the more I learn that the whole time period from 500-1500 is more complicated than I was taught in school. It makes sense that the Vikings would be more complicated too.
jkingsbery··on Show HN: I made a site where you practice typing by retyping entire novels
I have the same issue in Chrome (85.0.4183.121). It doesn't happen if you type the wrong key, it happens if you accidentally miss or add a key press.

Really awesome site though!

jkingsbery··on Looking at the experience of black Britons through an American lens
Like all metaphors, "the melting pot" has its limits. I've always thought it's for the best that, even though I'm mostly of English and Irish descent that I enjoy Indian, Italian and middle eastern food, and while maintaining my Catholic faith I have Jewish and Muslim coworkers whom I admire and look to examples.

While my identity is still "Irish Catholic," I've been enriched (and yes, changed) through exposure to others.

jkingsbery··on Looking at the experience of black Britons through an American lens
> Americans seem to have this weird view

Some Americans, anyway. Growing up in the US, I was always taught the US was "the great melting pot." But I agree, it doesn't seem like it lately.

jkingsbery··on Show HN: Building a project based on universal income concept
Leaving aside grammar/spelling/weird choice, it's not clear what this is for or why someone would want to sign up. Landing Pages usually a landing page for a thing - it's not clear what the thing is here (other than something having to do with liking UBI, I guess?).
jkingsbery··on DigitalOcean's Hacktoberfest Is Hurting Open Source
It's kind of like that episode of Pinky and the Brain where they finally are able to take over the Earth by convincing everyone who moves to a paper mache copy of the Earth a free t-shirt. People love free t-shirts.
jkingsbery··on Ask HN: Teaching kids how to think?
First, find something that excites them. If it doesn't excite them, they won't engage with it and they won't take any lessons from it.

Physical learning seems to be important. Legos, science experiments, flying kites, etc., are all great ways for kids to learn about things in a concrete way. One science experiment I did with my oldest daughter was a "Will it sink or float?" experiment that is easy to do - just get a tub of water and random house hold items (coins; cereal; piece of bread; piece of paper; etc.).

Reading to them, and stopping to ask them questions about the book. What's happening on this page? How do you think that character feels? What do you think is going to happen next?

Show your kids that they can write stories. It doesn't have to be something fancy, just a bunch of pictures on regular printer paper, each with a sentence describing what's happening. If your kids are too young to write the words themselves, you can ask them what the page should say and write it for them.

Let them be bored sometimes. When given nothing to do, kids are forced to figure something to do by themselves.

← PreviousPage 10 of 21Next →