HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jknupp

1,116 karma · joined July 17, 2009

email: <my-user-name>@gmail.com

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jeffknupp; my proof: https://keybase.io/jeffknupp/sigs/7Io3CXiZL-UByymj5V_cg4qQ1ZE5OalCTIpHKIhf1oU ]

submissionscomments
jknupp··on Software Optimization: A Systematic Approach
An upcoming part of the series discusses determining what work is necessary, at a very fine level, and working to remove all else. This may seem like a needlesly simplistic exercise, but consider the example you gave: the processes need to communicate with one another. The method by which they do so is an implementation detail. Even if they eventually use the files for another purpose, those are two separate requirements (the first to communicate with other processes and the second to journal that communication). Replacing file based communication with something like a simple TCP based message protocol would likely yield great dividends. For processes on the same machine, an IPC mechanism like domain sockets or shared memory would surely be faster.

Of course, the first thing to do is determine if increased performance is actually required. No sense in making something fast if no one benefits.

jknupp··on Moving the needle
That would be their opportunity cost, which falls under the general umbrella term "cost".
jknupp··on PHP is much better than what you think
No, it's exactly as bad _of a language_ as everyone is saying it is. In addition, it filled a void that is no longer a void (dynamic HTML generation in a programmer-friendly way) and has rightfully been supplanted as the go-to language for new projects by a number of superior languages.
jknupp··on Moving the needle
"take the big tech giants like Google, Microsoft and Apple. To them, if it is not an x $billion opportunity, it isn't worth expending resources on it." ...? Surely it's worth them spending x $billion - $1 (or some similarly small but less pedantic amount).
jknupp··on If Used Software Can Be Sold, Why Not Used eBooks?
Because "everything digital" != "everything else digital". That argument is a very slippery slope, considering it can be applied both beneficially and harmfully (for whatever your definitions of "beneficial" and "harmful" are).
jknupp··on Lookup any software license shortly summarized in plain English
Um, GPL2 helpfully doesn't include mention of including source in summary, although it's there in the blue box (under "must"). Also, for someone unfamiliar, it would be helpful to explain _which_ source: the library you're including or the entire source of your work which includes the GPL'd library.

"You may copy, distribute and modify the software as long as you retain this license, track changes/dates of in source files and keep it GPL."

jknupp··on Founders Never Sleep
I am honestly searching in vain for a point to this post. The title suggests that the fact that "founders never sleep" is a fact. The author went through a phase where that was true but now believes it's a "bad habit," without any advice on how to avoid it or mention that it was driven by his circumstances, which have since changed. It basically amounts to him saying "When I had no money, I had to work long hours to provide income for myself while also trying to run a startup. Now that the latter is profitable I no longer have to do this. This is good because I didn't enjoy my previous situation and don't recommend it."

How is that useful advice to those trying to earn a living and run a startup? What would be a better alternative?

jknupp··on Comcast Wins Protest Against “Shake Down” of BitTorrent Pirates
Even if there is no relevant legal precedent, Comcast's common sense argument that the plaintiff in the case had a clear history of not using the identities of the subscribers the court compelled ISPs to release in any litigation is the kind of argument that, in a perfect world, would become the norm. However, IANAL so I have no idea how likely it is to be successfully used again.
jknupp··on Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static types, too
The author's interpretation of the argument in favor of dynamic languages seems purposefully naive. I don't think that any proponent of dynamic languages or unit testing claimed that the mere presence of unit tests guaranteed bug free code or that it was impossible to have type related errors at run time if you have unit tests. It's a more nuanced argument asserting that the benefit to programmer productivity when using dynamic languages outweighs the cost of potential type related errors not possible in a statically typed language. Whether it has merit or not is the question I hoped this paper would answer.
jknupp··on Ask HN: Which technology\language you find most difficult to learn?
SML.

I remember at CMU, the sophmore level programming language theory course (the name escapes me, it was 15-212) was wildly different than anything I had done before. All programming courses one took up to that point were the normal intro level courses that most passed out of and a data structures/algorithms course. Sitting down the first day and being introduced to SML along with language constructs with no analogue in the programming languages I knew was tough. I struggled for about a month, much like I imagine many do when learning about pointers: you may be able to do some of the work, but you don't have a proper conceptual model to be able to reason about it. All of a sudden, after re-reading the material from the beginning, everything just clicked. It was probably my favorite undergraduate CS course from then on.

jknupp··on Why Silicon Valley Tech Wunderkinds Overestimate Their Own Smarts and Abilities
I would wager it makes far less of a difference than you imagine. The problem here is survivorship bias. We naturally hear far more about consumer startups because we are their target audience (in a general sense). Therefore, we hear about consumer startups that fail more often than about enterprise startups. It then seems that enterprise startups are less likely to fail.

If that were true, the fact that VC money is focuses far more on consumer startups would be ridiculous. Surely if enterprise startups succeed more often VC firms would make investments where they could benefit from this fact, likely by structuring deals around taking a percentage of profits since big exits are rare but long spans of profitability would not be. There would be no point in playing the consumer startup lottery as you would be greatly overpaying for risk.

jknupp··on Harvard + MIT = edX
To say it would be preferable if there were no profitable business model is short-sighted. It would mean that the only entities capable of undertaking something like this would be existing universities (and the wave of private companies offering a wide curriculum of online courses would end). Those universities that attempted something similar would at best be able to merely recoup costs. In short, the higher education revolution would amount to existing universities putting classes online. Why in the world is that preferable?
jknupp··on Harvard + MIT = edX
I'm still unclear what the business model for universities (as opposed to private companies) in this space is. The problem is, they will inevitably be compared to (and in some sense compete against) their non-virtual counterparts. Especially when they've essentially given away all their course materials and lecture videos for free, and considering these classes are not for credit, I just don't see the benefit for the average person over studying what's already freely available. And one can't even make the argument that the free resources aren't meant to be used to learn a subject (as is the case with most free reference material), since these were obviously created with precisely that goal in mind.

When they inevitably move to a tuition based model, the ever present question of "the real MIT or the online one?" may be too much to overcome.

jknupp··on Ask HN: Interest in a new open source, fast, in-memory, data analysis system?
I'm not sure I understand how your design overcomes the issues of either type of database. You'll have unstructured data like a NoSQL database by virtue of your insertion mechanism, and there is no mention of how you plan to optimize for record size the orders of magnitude that would be required to keep all data in memory. As a thought exercise, say my average record takes up 1Kb. After only a few million records, with zero overhead for the database structures themselves (not to mention unrelated processes also runnin on the system) you've already exceeded the amount of memory typically used to run these types of processes.
jknupp··on Is Reading the Internet Convincing Women Not To Study Computer Science?
Thanks to an HN story on the front page a few days ago, I learned the useful fact that any title that ends in a question mark can safely be answered "no". Saved me valuable time that would have been spent trying to decide what "reading the Internet" meant.
jknupp··on Skout Facing Sex-Predator Crisis
This reasoning is flawed. No one said that there weren't teenagers who were the victim of a sex crime and also happened to be Skout users. Rather, the issue is that the platform was being used by sexual predators as a tool to facilitate initial contact with teenagers they otherwise wouldn't have had access to.

Additionally, it's likely that an overwhelming proportion of those represented in the statistic you cited were victimized by someone they knew rather than a stranger over the internet. For a fair comparison, those victims would need to be excluded. Not to mention the question of what portion of those 2 million users are active enough on Skout to even represent a realistic target. Multiple cases being reported (in the US alone) within a span of days is unlikely enough to warrant drastic action.

jknupp··on Skout Facing Sex-Predator Crisis
Perhaps in theory, but realistically this makes no sense. This is not a pornography site, where there is some taboo prize for lying about one's age. It's a social network, only as useful as the number of connections a user has on it. What is the likelyhood that a teen, and enough of their friends, will sign up again under a false name and somehow work out a system for determining the false names of all their friends? The benefit to the staggering minority of teens that would have been receptive to a sexual predator awareness message from an _iPhone app not at all sexual in nature_ is far outweighed by the overt protection of all teens using the service. How popular do you think it will likely be amongst pedophilies without potential victims?
jknupp··on Skout Facing Sex-Predator Crisis
I think you're a bit confused. The issue is not teens posing as adults, but sexual predators posing as teens. Appeals to the sense of honesty of perpetrators of sex crimes are likely misguided.
jknupp··on GCC 4.7.1 released
Helpfully, the changes page for 4.7.1 points at 4.7 changes, which confused me for a minute because I was sure I had read these before...
jknupp··on Linkrdr: The Next Generation Feed Reader
Linked by Dave Winer (www.scripting.com) and startupsea yesterday.

Inspired by an HN Post: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3555923

jknupp··on Linkrdr - Next Gen Feed Reader
Founder here: Added OPML support. Give it a try!
jknupp··on Show HN: my side project inspired by HN post
Sorry for that, looks like my last git commit accidentally turned debug mode on. I fixed the email issue too. Thanks for the heads up.
jknupp··on Show HN: my side project inspired by HN post
Adding feedback as we speak...

'Relevant' is meant to mean 'relevant to your interest', defined by the scoring algorithm.

For example: in a blog post containing 30 links, each link individually is unlinkely to be relevant. However, if one of those 30 links is also linked in a number of other feeds you subscribe to, this is a more 'relevant' link. Also, if you tend to click on links from a certain domain often, future links from this domain are more 'relevant'.

jknupp··on Show HN: my side project inspired by HN post
Fixed. That was embarassing...
jknupp··on Django Production Deployment and Development Using Git
Is there anything from the post you'd like more detail on? Email me at <myusername>@gmail.com and I'd be happy to go over everything I've done so far regarding deployment and source code management via git.
jknupp··on Django Production Deployment and Development Using Git
I've looked at Fabric but decided that, for now, it's a bit heavyweight for my needs since I'm only deploying to one machine. If my deployments get more complicated, I'll definitely take another look.
jknupp··on Django Production Deployment and Development Using Git
Well, like it says in the post, my root directory served by Apache is just a clone of my git master branch. When I've finished making changes and committed them to master, deployment is a simple "git pull" and Apache reload via postinstall hook. Sometimes migrations need to be run, but they're all staged via another postinstall hook.
jknupp··on Advertising: Reddit Versus Facebook
I would agree if IllestRhyme was about reading stuff related to hiphop. Instead, it's about _creating_ stuff related to hiphop. There's much more of a focus on user interaction. A user gets far less out of the site if all they do is read (and this is pretty obvious from the minute you get on the site).
jknupp··on Show HN: My side project. Like SO for rap music writers
My 1 month old side project and first webapp. Just hit 100 users yesterday.
jknupp··on A C++ developer's experience learning web programming
I see where you're coming from. It's not meant to be a Python/Django love-fest. Rather I was trying to say there's really a lot to learn if you're coming to web development from another field. That said, it's definitely learn-able due to the orthogonality and ease of use of many of the tools available.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →