57 karma · joined January 12, 2023
Coq is well designed/easy to understand but it is missing a core mathlib like Lean. Moreover, most proofs are designed to "compile" quickly and not to be human readable.
For example, how I'm supposed to use a markdown language that doesn't have a tikz-like library? Sure you can still write commutative diagram but that's not all tikz does.
Moreover, if you feel more comfortable by running examples there are qiskit, pennylane and other libraries which shares a lot of tutorials and notebook (and some can be run on a true quantum computer if you have the money or the time to wait in queue!)
Moreover, it is theoretically viable to produce all electric energy via renewables, albeit impracticle and 100 years away. Thus, I can't see how saying that """EVENTUALLY""" hydrogen might be renewable is good for the environment.
Hydrogen is good for a very niche part of our production system (and spoiler it is not car industry or house heating where better alternatives already exist[1][2]).
[1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/home-heating-with-hydrogen-is-ill-... [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41928-021-00706-6
However, that's just because I decided the right data to test it onto. So, you can't really say much on a model using that definition.
That's not to say that it is unsettling, but I just want to point out that many of the "weird" behaviours are mainly dependent on the subject (person) and not the object (smartphone/internet/socials).
btw, in other languages i guess it is decent although it depends on which language, at least gpt4.
anyway i think your statement that industry is light years away from unis is just misleading. i think the two are trying to answer different questions: 1. how can i achieve a "somewhat" decent chatbot that gets me rich albeit not even knowing what it does [industry in case you wondered] 2. try to understand, quantify and measure how well a model works, is it stable? does it converge if we have small datasets? and so on so forth.
just my two cents, to conclude i think a good analogy to the current climate is the 700-800s with electromagnetism: plenty of people discovered "empirical" laws but didn't understand really the phenomenon.