HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jl2718

3,462 karma · joined February 17, 2018

submissionscomments
jl2718··on SocioAttractiveness has a bigger impact on men's economic success than women's
Simpson’s paradox. The causal axis is (more strongly) positive for career success, but the informative axis is negative for the choice to pursue economic mobility through a career versus family. In simple terms, more attractive women are more likely to marry rich and neglect career success, while the number of men that pursue this strategy is much lower.

Reminder that statistics are only accurate for exactly the question asked. We have a bad habit of assuming that we correctly asked the question that we are actually interested in.

jl2718··on We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to return to OpenAI as CEO
Are the Microsoft job offers at the same compensation still on the table?
jl2718··on Common pesticides in food reducing sperm count worldwide, study says
The most common form of GMO is for tolerance of extremely high levels of pesticide and herbicide usage. This is mostly because engineering chemical resistance is a vastly simpler process than pest resistance.

Rational people are not generally concerned with the modifications themselves[1], but the results of the practices they allow, which is exactly what this article is about.

And it’s not like the actual pest-resistant strains are actually reducing pesticide usage. What incentive does a farmer have to do that? Likely the pesticide resistance is part of the package.

Perhaps there is an opportunity to flip this around and make a GMO crop that will not grow at all in the presence of pesticide or herbicide.

[1] Yes, there is growing rational concern for GMOs that are not just resistant to chemicals, but actually produce novel compounds that may affect humans.

jl2718··on The Benefits of Walking Backwards
For most people, forward walking/running involves a slight twist of the knee that stresses the illiotibial band against the lateral aspect of the knee joint. This results in a common overuse injury in runners.

When I get this, it is usually because I have just entered a relatively serious training program from relative rest, something like adding 20+ miles a week. I generally cannot walk forward at all.

However, there is usually no limitation at all to my backwards walking or running, so I spend a week or two not just walking backward as necessary, but also in training, I will do backward track intervals with no IT band pain at all, until I forget about it and try turning around. Anecdotally, it improves recovery time for the IT band, but also causes the opposite problem to flare up in the MCL.

Note that present tense is for convenience. It’s been a long time since I’ve run.

jl2718··on Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says
If all their job postings are not actually hiring, then they won’t get any applicants for the jobs that actually are, and then they can use that as evidence that they can’t find in-country candidates.

So basically the only way to find any real job posting is to spam-apply to everything. Is there a service for that?

jl2718··on Ask HN: What are you passionate about at the moment?
This will be important for me when I get there, but I’m still in the first quarter of my 200-year lifespan.
jl2718··on The wealthy parents of "self made" billionaires
Literary context? I thought of: https://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html
jl2718··on 'It's quite soul-destroying': how we fell out of love with dating apps
> Netflix is no substitution for a hobby.

Maybe, but to the brain engaged in the activity, watching movies or playing video games is much better than a hobby. Real life is only exciting about 1% of the time for anybody. Curated entertainment cuts out most of the boring stuff. Consider this: physiologically, the person watching the biography is probably living a more exciting life than the person who it’s about.

jl2718··on Atrocity propaganda
> they can only truly be stopped by force.

It’s been my lifetime hope that there is another way through obsolescence and irrelevance. If a people have a self-sovereign mechanism for self-defense and economic participation, then the cost of conquering them is far greater than the extractable value.

jl2718··on Kidney stone procedure "has the potential to be game changing"
Breakthrough? You could buy these machines on Alibaba years ago marketed for this purpose. I assume this means there was a cottage industry of private kidney stone treatment in Asia.
jl2718··on Heated yoga may reduce depression in adults
So depressed people either went into a hot room tightly packed with fit people stripping down and contorting their sweat-covered bodies, while they followed along and learned a new skill, or they did absolutely nothing.

Groundbreaking research.

Maybe depression isn’t just unexplained chemical imbalance, and there really is something wrong with the way people are living.

jl2718··on I face investigation for terrorism
Back then you could send an email “from” any address without verification, and I’d bet they weren’t sophisticated enough to detect that. There were many open and/or hacked SMTP gateways. I went to a federal military school and showed people how to do this on our own .mil servers. This would be deadly serious today, but email was 95% jokes and flame wars anyway, so it just made things more hilarious. Even Stanford CS’s SMTP in the 2010s allowed unauthenticated “from” addresses, and someone was using it to impersonate the Google founder emails for promoting and funding their startup.
jl2718··on Brisk 22-minute walk could offset harmful effects of sitting, study suggests
I think we should all have recess and play tag.
jl2718··on Canada is considering a guaranteed universal basic income program
Except by your own definition the state does a worse job at benefiting people with your money than you do.
jl2718··on Canada is considering a guaranteed universal basic income program
Reminder that the entire point of UBI is to eliminate needs testing for welfare. Why?

1. Administrative costs 2. Disincentive to work 3. Simplification 4. Equality

The government only does one thing: takes money from people, and gives money to other people. They don’t build roads or systems of defense. The vast majority of the government outlays are somehow concerned with giving out money to people that “need” it, and they do a patently awful job at it. The idea of UBI is just to give that money away efficiently instead of creating a massive poverty pimp administration. Even people that hate the idea of giving away money start to look at it favorably in comparison to the current system. In numbers, the US government spends about $25-30k per adult citizen. Maybe give each adult about $15k per year and eliminate all spending on healthcare, education, social security, welfare, housing, and anything concerned with diversity, equity, or inclusion, because everybody’s getting the exact same thing.

But that’s not going to happen without a huge fight from the poverty pimp lobby, and by fight I mean stuffing the pockets of legislators and judges while calling for riots over perceived injustices. So anything in this direction will just increase the size and inefficiency of the poverty pimp business, and thus achieve the opposite of its intention.

In conclusion: nice thought; bad idea.

jl2718··on Google owes executive $1M after losing gender bias lawsuit
The problem with these lawsuits is that they require a company to prove that their promotion decision is based on competence, which is the exact opposite way that it actually works: to minimize risk to their boss’s job.
jl2718··on 'This will be our last post' – LBRY throws in towel against the SEC
What exactly is it that made this token a security, and why was it targeted versus any of the other tokens that were marketed and sold for common enterprise and future profits? I didn’t follow because I didn’t realize that it was connected to a decentralized YouTube competitor. Now it has the appearance of being motivated not by securities law, but censorship. I’m sure they also violated SEC rules, but I’m wondering exactly how so, and how it could be avoided for a future incentivized P2P video network.
jl2718··on Disc Brakes Took over the Cycling World. Here's Why That Was a Mistake
Yes, very cool. I like the dual piston actuators, but that caliper structure seems like a limiting factor or point of failure. Also, it has to mount somewhere. It would seem natural to integrate it with the fork, so I looked up what they did with TT forks and came up with this single-piston dual-cantilever design as a separate component the P5 [1]. I was thinking of an internal fork mount for the hydraulics, a much larger pad, and a rim specially made with a wider braking surface. Somebody must have tried that in a concept design.

1. https://www.bikeradar.com/news/magura-rt8-tt-first-look/

jl2718··on Disc Brakes Took over the Cycling World. Here's Why That Was a Mistake
I switched to tubeless on rim brakes and had a downhill blowout from pressure cooking the sealant. I also tend to abuse my rims and rarely true them, so my brakes are always loose or rubbing. Both these problems may go away with carbon rims, but pincher brakes with carbon pads don’t have much stopping power. Discs do, but they are heavy and put extra torque and heat stresses on the frame, as well as a twisting moment to the straight spokes on the front, which they obviously weren’t designed for.

Okay, ready for a new idea I just thought of? Hydraulic rim brakes. They are built into either side of the fork and push bigger pads into deep carbon wheel surfaces for as much braking power as you want, with the torques applied to the strongest points of the wheel and frame, and no twisting moment applied to the spokes.

jl2718··on Universal cancer vaccine trial shows significant improvement in overall survival
I don’t know much about this, but I’m not sure “reset” is the right term here. It seems more like “overwhelm” than “reset” to what a newborn might have. Measles can cause autoimmunity, and I’m not sure it’s been shown to abate it.
jl2718··on Universal cancer vaccine trial shows significant improvement in overall survival
If you are truly dying of metastatic cancer, and as you seem extremely well-informed and competent to make your own decisions, I feel obligated to share. Not medical advice, entertainment purposes only:

Checkpoint blockades are great if you are providing a lot of the epitopes to target, but not so great if your immune system isn’t already killing cells to provide that. One way of providing substrate is personalized mRNA. Another much simpler way is tumor ablation. I have done this on myself and my animals with mixed results, mostly positive. I use ascorbic acid to ablate skin tumors, and ethyl-cellulose injection for larger masses.

jl2718··on Universal cancer vaccine trial shows significant improvement in overall survival
“UV1 is a therapeutic cancer vaccine used to generate an immune response against the enzyme human telomerase (hTERT). The enzyme is essential for the ability of cancer cells to proliferate. Telomerase is present in 85-90% of all cancers, across the stages of the disease.”

It’s a protein epitope vaccine against a normal human protein. Not stated here, but it may also target normal stem cells needed for repair and renewal processes. This risk may be reduced by the cessation of checkpoint blockades, but, the immune system can’t forget a target, and autoimmunity is an unsolved problem. HLA binding is also not perfectly specific, and any immune response is likely to generate more immunity from the target cell. This universal targeting of normal peptides may be an acceptable last-line defense, but I would be more comfortable targeting a somatic mutation with some significant differentiation from anything in the human exome.

jl2718··on Expecting return to office will boost worker productivity is 'magical thinking'
Remote work is more productive. Office work is more valuable.

I’ll explain. Remote management is a lot more one-way and top-down tasking. It’s possible, but very hard to do it any other way. In-person teams do not require explicit tasking, and they will find consensus on good and bad directions much faster, but the actual work goes slowly.

“If you want to go fast, go alone. If you want to go far, go together.”

You can’t have both. Measuring productivity of individual in-person employees will fail, and measuring value output of remote teams will also fail.

jl2718··on Mistral releases ‘unmoderated’ chatbot via torrent
A gentlebot never tells.
jl2718··on Diversity Statement Then Dossier
Somebody please explain why every academic department in the western world does this, without assuming any motive other than pure financial self-interest.
jl2718··on Don’t mess with a genius (2010)
We’re talking about clay pots here. How would you get the crown into the narrow opening? If you have two containers, one for displacement, the other for measurement, you would lose far more water in the pouring than the precision required.

Here is an idea: I can imagine a vessel that looks like an elongated tetrahedron upside-down with one of the isosceles faces open and the point below it beveled to enable it to balance in two positions, position 1 with the long end slightly higher than the short end, and position 2 with the long end exactly the same height as the short end. Start in position 1, fill with water, place the crown to overflow it’s volume, then remove the crown, tip the vessel to position 2, mark the extent (rather than the height) of the water on the elongated end, repeat with the gold, compare.

This could be improvised with something like a large urn and a block to lift the long end a little bit. I’m still not sure about the precision of the overflow and dripping off the water.

jl2718··on Don’t mess with a genius (2010)
I assume he used a mechanical balance to measure the equal weight of gold. Couldn’t he then just submerge the balance?

If the method from the story doesn’t work, is it possible that it was just a plausible-sounding cover for the actual method that they wouldn’t have wanted to disclose?

jl2718··on Fat Cells Never Disappear – Making Future Weight Gain More Likely
I don’t like defeatist articles like this, but, there is some legitimacy to it, both in physiology and observation.

I would suggest that the practical solution is to prioritize exercise and food selection rather than calorie restriction.

It may be the case that some people need to eat a lot more to feel normal. Okay, fine, then they also need to exercise a lot more to be healthy. This is inordinately common among world-class athletes by their own admission, and it often shows up in their less-active retirement. So maybe you need to eat 6000 calories a day to feel normal. Okay, fine, do that, and actually put in the work to burn off the excess. Should be about 8 hours, and you’ll be a personal hero of mine at the end of a month of that.

I think most people would be a lot better-off if they would ignore the scale and focus only on performance, but be honest about it. For instance, I don’t care how much you weigh, but if you can’t run a mile in under 10 minutes and pick your own body weight off the floor, you’re going to have problems. Focus on improving a broad range of physical ability, eat as much as you need to keep improving, and you’ll be a lot better off in the long term.

jl2718··on Sucking carbon dioxide out of the sky is moving from science fiction to reality
Please stop. This is the environmental engineering version of “not even wrong”. There are so many problems it’s hard to know where to start.
jl2718··on Tidal energy is not renewable
When the nuclear apocalypse has passed, and the last remaining humans are living underground on mushrooms, somewhere an economist will claim growth using a model updated to include the work done by ants, and somewhere a bureaucrat will update the tax code to collect on it.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →