HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jl2718

3,462 karma · joined February 17, 2018

submissionscomments
jl2718··on Reviving Racial Preferences in California
I see a lot of different ideas that fall under the flag of socialism, but I keep seeing good results from one disjoint set of ideas being used to justify another which has objectively terrible results.
jl2718··on How did Stripe come up with its name? (2015)
Hmmm… apparently unrelated, but…

The dominant payments startup at the time was “Square”, which was named because they made a square-shaped device that read a magnetic stripe into a phone audio port.

jl2718··on Reviving Racial Preferences in California
I had a card-carrying communist teacher in high school, and he used to say that representative democracy was obsolete because we now have better mechanisms for Athenian-style direct democracy. These referendums seems to indicate that this would swiftly put an end to his entire ideology. I would also like to point out that every time there is a referendum in California, the people go with the conservative position, but every time there is an election, it goes to a liberal candidate. How is this possible?
jl2718··on Shell abandons its plan to offset CO2 emissions
Study the carbon cycle a bit and then come back and tell me I’m wrong about this:

Offsets do not work. The best application of that funding would be to stop destruction of the ocean habitat. Short explanation: Almost all surface and atmospheric carbon ends up in the ocean by rivers or rainfall. Geological-timescale sequestration is performed by zooplankton et al in the form of CaCO3, but something has to eat them or they will block the light for their own food supply, and the rest of the ecosystem follows from there. And yes, surface habitats also matter, but their destruction is more localized.

jl2718··on Hundreds of thousands trafficked to work as online scammers in SE Asia, says UN
I question the utility of imprisonment to achieve any legitimate social goal. It may not be an effective deterrent of the most heinous crimes. It doesn’t seem to work as rehabilitation. It only works as physical prevention of recidivism in people that lack self-awareness and self-control to prevent it, but unfortunately those are exonerating conditions in our system. It seems to me that prison should be understood and used in the opposite way: not punishment, but a compassionate alternative to remove people from society. Punishment and deterrence are something different from a behaviorist perspective, and there are other things that work better, faster, and cheaper. Physical pain is punishment: pepper spray, bullet ants, microwave cannons, carbon dioxide. Deterrence is mainly the quality of alternatives available, for which there should be a floor established, like an agricultural labor camp at sub-minimum wage.
jl2718··on Ask HN: My mother is slowly losing her eyesight, how to prepare?
Two things:

1. I experienced rapid vision loss during an acute diabetic reaction to starvation re-feeding, and getting insulin sensitivity back might be the best way to protect the eyes. Consider metformin in addition to the obvious diet and exercise.

2. I didn’t actually come here to suggest metformin. I clicked because of the heading typo, which smells to me like a type of auto-correct error that seems to be more common in neural network-based systems. That is, the suggested word is related to the context, but non-sensical. I’m constantly re-correcting bad suggestions now, even when I correctly type exactly what I want, sometimes several times on the same word. I think it’s making autocorrect worse, and mistakes more common and harder to spot versus the models based on closest word neighbors, or smaller contexts.

jl2718··on West Point discovers time capsule from 1828
I thought so too, and I went to one of the three National Service Academies, so I was taught about a lot of these people directly. Many of the modern top generals were some of the lowest-ranked graduates, and generally took the easiest majors, mostly Political Science. The bottom-ranked leader phenomenon starts with the leaders selected by the cadets themselves, and continues to the top of the ranks. So why was it different back then? There was a stronger emphasis on military science, but they also prided themselves on outperforming Harvard in whatever colleges used to compare each other, so it wasn’t the only focus.

The obvious answer is pretty simple: graduation order determined time-in-rank seniority, so they were considered for promotion before anyone else, and this both continues and compounds throughout their career.

Is there an actual correlation to military performance? Probably, and probably slightly more so for the academy than other schools, because of the way that subjects are taught. I later went to several other name-recognizable universities, and there are large differences in the pace and depth of what is taught and tested, with the academy having a much greater pace over much more material at a much lighter depth, so it’s kind of like testing your ability to take in a lot of information very quickly and react to it, rather than master a domain of knowledge and creatively expand upon it.

There is also a social effect of named leaders to gain support among a cohort, especially in ‘minority’ populations, which are formed by commissioning source in the military officer corps. For example, Westmoreland was “first rat” at The Citadel, which has a much lower admission standard than West Point, but it was a brutal program with fierce advocacy among graduates.

jl2718··on Ask HN: Favorite Educational Channels (For Kids)?
Apologies for being unclear about this. I’m not suggesting exploitation like extracting value. I’m saying that they make their videos primarily interesting to children’s existing attention span, whereas book time may teach children to increase their attention span and become interested in something, like printed letters on a page, that otherwise appears quite boring.
jl2718··on Ask HN: Favorite Educational Channels (For Kids)?
This comment is overly-dramatized, but has a point which is perhaps more subtle. There is a difference between training their attention mechanisms and exploiting their attention mechanisms. The vast majority of this ‘educational content’ is on the exploitation side.
jl2718··on Without belief in a god, but never without belief in a devil
When we study ants, we do not begin with a belief that their behavior is wrong or improper. We assume that they act in a way that is required for their survival and proliferation.

It would be ‘nice’ to say that such things are just a social dysfunction that we can safely avoid. They may not be. A lemming that follows the herd may find that it has led them off a cliff, but a lemming that doesn’t will certainly die.

We may now have better options to opt out. I’m mostly speaking to the relatively wealthy, skilled, and able. But I’m not sure. Opting out of one hysteria may also require membership in another such mass movement, complete with an obvious enemy, and a ridiculous but necessary set of rituals to convince others that we are not a threat.

I’ve believed throughout most of my life that communications and especially privacy technology would give us better options. I’m not sure it’s ending up that way. I see great technological developments in that direction, but almost all social developments in their use going the opposite way.

I think what these things come down to is each individual assessing a practical threat to themselves and reacting accordingly. I don’t generally accept explanations that assume entire populations acting wholly irrationally. It can also probably be seen as arising from material conditions such as increased resource scarcity, which is a tautological result of economic cycles, regardless of how the economists may measure their positive effect. This view requires extraordinary sociological imagination, to consider what type of situation that you could find yourself in, which would lead you to switch sides on your most ardent beliefs. That situation is therefore the threat, not the people, but it may be unavoidable. I believe that people are smart and compassionate and empathetic and do realize this, but it doesn’t affect their best option for actions, posturing, and espoused beliefs.

jl2718··on Michael Burry, of Big Short fame, just bet $1.6B on a stock market crash
Simultaneous debt collapse and global de-dollarization: good luck timing this one.

Knowing that the markets are massively distorted and unsustainable gets you nothing. Knowing the next wave of irrational distortion gets you good long-term returns. Good timing is either pure luck, insider information, or outright manipulation.

jl2718··on Driver death rates by make and model – Insurance Institute for Highway Safety
Not very informative without normalization by miles driven.
jl2718··on How much better was DEC Alpha than contemporaneous x86? (2020)
My first computer job was a high school internship at a small software company that was gifted an Alpha for testing, and it was just sort of sitting there in the lab next to where I worked doing basically nothing until it failed to boot into ghost, and I decided that I was going to rewrite the ghost bootloader (drive mirroring over the network).

Well… this was obviously extremely naive and I did not succeed, but, I did a lot of reading through the instruction set manuals on that machine. The most remarkable feature I think was just the number of registers. IIRC there were 64 64-bit registers. I had done some x86 32 assembly, and I hated always having to push onto the stack because all they had was eax ebx ecx. It wasn’t until MMX that you could use more than that on x86, and there weren’t many. I wrote most programs entirely in registers, almost like LLVM today.

jl2718··on Apple already shipped attestation on the web, and we barely noticed
This protocol is private because “trust me”.
jl2718··on Debate over 'fake work' and 'lazy management' in tech industry
> Oftentimes, employees are getting plenty of work done; it's just that the projects are of little to no importance to the company's bottom line.

a.k.a. “Innovation”.

For whatever reason, I’m one of those engineers that big organizations seem to hunt down for their “innovation” agenda. I have much to say about these experiences. In particular, the advice given by innovation gurus like business professors, authors, and management consultants, is terrible.

jl2718··on Cicada: Private on-chain voting using time-lock puzzles
Purple thumbs are a pretty good system, and they were definitely not convinced by voting machines, nor paper ballots. But, it's a physical security nightmare. My job was to keep IEDs out of the polling places. There are many more issues such as multiple voting, cross-district voting, cross-border voting, voter intimidation, retaliation, etc.

And imagine an academic suggesting that it's not practical. The most celebrated academic result of the last 25 years in the field was a crypto system that would take a thousand years to multiply one-bit numbers.

Regardless, you're right. It is a waste of time. There's no funding. Academia is like consulting. You make money by telling people what they want to hear. I've become more aware of this.

jl2718··on Cicada: Private on-chain voting using time-lock puzzles
What do you propose to do with paper? Mostly it just gets fed into a machine. Is it impossible to vote twice with paper? Is it impossible to throw away paper? Is it impossible to miscount paper?

Paper doesn't impart any security property by itself. Can paper be used in a secure system? Maybe. Can a machine be used in a secure system? Maybe. Is all paper secure? No. Is any machine secure? No. Same for blockchain, mobile, internet, satellite, and ouija boards.

jl2718··on Cicada: Private on-chain voting using time-lock puzzles
Until it’s a result you don’t like. Have you ever considered the possibility that there are places where election systems can’t be trusted? I’m sure you’ll be just as supportive of the Russian-led vote in occupied regions of Ukraine.

My proposal was for provable voting systems in conflict regions. It stems from my experience on the ground supporting the 2014 election in Afghanistan. People all over the world risk their lives to vote, and they, normal primitive farmers with no education, demand proof that it was done fairly. The current method is a line of people showing their hands, then one by one, marking a wall and walking out with purple thumbs.

But really, the place and the situation is irrelevant. I find your response both abhorrent and stereotypical.

jl2718··on Cicada: Private on-chain voting using time-lock puzzles
This is an extremely weak straw-man argument. It doesn’t need to be on the blockchain, mobile, or even the internet. You can print out the cryptographic proof on paper if it pleases you.
jl2718··on Cicada: Private on-chain voting using time-lock puzzles
Meanwhile in academia, I’ve proposed research into cryptographically-provable voting systems, and received nothing but hostility and discouragement. The same cryptography professors who started their careers in the topic after the 2000 election, have now changed their research interest to ‘combatting disinformation’ about election integrity.
jl2718··on No One Is Happy About Diversity Efforts at Work
Nobody’s trying to decrease racial bias. It’s compliance training.
jl2718··on Shifting views about psychedelic drugs require a new category for them
Imagine being told that your 50-year-old brain surgeon is returning from to a year-long psychedelic sabbatical just prior to your surgery. LSD, ayahuasca, psilocybin, frogs, everything. They tell you that this has completely changed everything about what they think and know.

There is an inconsistency between the ability to “change your mind”, and the right to hold a lifetime credential, or more broadly, an identity or reputation. In the other direction, a person with a new brain may find themselves trapped by an old identity, reputation, or criminal record. Either way, there’s no good way to assess whether someone’s capabilities or behavior has changed to become inconsistent with past labels. This is also true for the sober passage of time and experience, but massively more so with the use of drugs (including alcohol). The main difference with psychedelics is that they affect a broader range of higher-order brain systems, whereas most other abused substances mainly affect the dopamine system, which is also disastrous, but probably takes longer to affect skill and knowledge.

Imagine all of this research results in wonderful outcomes for happiness and positive affect and sociality etc. Everybody wants the treatment. Then we discover that all we’re doing is making people dumber, and dumb people are happier. And they’re also more confident, extroverted, and relatable, even creative, as they are no longer bound to their former knowledge, reasoning, or expertise, so the perception is that they are even smarter. It’s perfect for the individual, but a potential disaster for society.

And of course, a proper screed today wouldn’t be complete without prognosticating about AI. It’s possible that some form of machine learning could and maybe should replace most forms of crystallized intelligence and skill, such that the only thing left for humans is exactly this type of “dumb genius” that we seem to find so beguiling in the majority of famous people.

https://youtu.be/GtBhclCigH0

jl2718··on US public debt projected to reach 181% of economic activity in 30 years
They talk about tax revenues as if that’s a relevant component of bond market cash flows. It’s not.

I have an easy solution for bringing it down to any number you want: more government spending, the more wasteful the better.

You see, government spending is part of that ‘economic activity’ number. In fact, certain types of especially wasteful spending require purchases that guarantee it will count for double in that number. Of course this creates more debt, so every year you have to create enough money to increase your spending by a huge factor, but it works in the formula used here.

This is not a new idea; it was most recently popularized by an Obama economic plan to introduce stimulus on the same premise. And he’s right; spending does bring down the number temporarily. Is it insanity to believe that this represents an economic benefit? Well, you may recognize this response from Rick Santelli:

“You can’t buy your way into prosperity. And if the multiplier that all of these Washington economists are selling us is over one, then we never have to worry about the economy again. The government should spend a trillion dollars an hour because we’ll get $1.5 trillion back.”

Now as a historical exercise, I would like just one example of a long-term financially-responsible central government that had full control of the issuance of their own legal tender. I’m not suggesting a different system; I’m merely pointing out the possible futility of our expectations.

jl2718··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
If they changed the wording from “corporate profits” to “lack of competition”, then a solution would be apparent. As it is, they’ve crafted the narrative to encourage a push toward even greater monopolism.
jl2718··on People paid to train AI are outsourcing their work to AI
Perhaps we’re starting to see the limits of the machine learning era in AI. We may have nothing more to teach it. There are a number of ways to go from here, none of which is entirely within our control or understanding.
jl2718··on It’s not the chemicals that cause addiction (2017)
Reminds me of this: https://youtu.be/z3kF9S0h_7A

Not even once, kids.

jl2718··on NYC Bailing Out Hotels Paying Premium Rates for Budget Rooms to House Migrants
This feels more financial than political. As in, it really has nothing to do with the migrants, it’s just a way to funnel money into pockets of donors.

Let’s just accept defeat and start paying direct tribute to our overlords. More efficient. Less collateral damage.

jl2718··on Mark Zuckerberg on Apple Vision Pro – Lex Fridman Podcast Clips
The gaming will be awesome, no doubt.

But… you’re not going to have time for that. This is going to take over the ‘virtual workplace’ and thus you will spend most of your life with all of your actions and surroundings monitored to make sure you’re doing some meaningless task and nothing else.

People say it’s a horrible idea. They hate it. Tough. Your company will require it. It’s nothing for them. The future of work is going to make sweat shops look like lollapalooza.

jl2718··on The planning of U.S. physician shortages (2020)
Imagine a world where computer use required a prescription from a limited number of licensed engineers. You have to pay to talk to them about your problem and they’ll set you up with an app to use for a week or two.
jl2718··on ChatGPT took their jobs. Now they walk dogs and fix air conditioners
Thank you for that perspective. From the AI side, I think it’s funny how there can be so much simultaneous interest in both “AI writing”, which is exactly as you say, and “AI summarization”, which is like inverting the AI writing function to retrieve the prompt data.

An absurd, but seemingly likely, end state of this is an arms race between the two technologies, completely transparent to the user, and resulting in roughly the same user experience, which is always set to the limit of their tolerance.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →