HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jl6

19,625 karma · joined August 1, 2010

gemini://lab6.com
submissionscomments
jl6··on Mind-altering drugs played key role in rise of Andean civilization
Context does matter though? There are plenty of substances which are legal for certified professionals to use in controlled settings that would be illegal for untrained amateurs to use for recreational purposes. Plutonium, for example.
jl6··on Google will buy half the electricity from one of Finland's nuclear power plants
Guess it’s a good time to be in the power plant business.
jl6··on On Really Trying (2009)
So where did it all go wrong, to end up with you posting comments like this?
jl6··on My Feed, My Way
I don't think it's at all obvious that a regulation-based approach could produce better outcomes than a prohibition-based approach. No doubt prohibition causes much violence and misery, but prohibition was a response to other great harms, most famously the condition of opium addicts.

Rather than rehash the arguments for and against, I would ask a meta-question: if the matter really were so clear, then why, over the last ~200 years, did every country introduce a prohibition-based stance, and why has no country switched to tax-and-regulate?

jl6··on My Feed, My Way
"tax and regulate" isn't immune from second-order effects either. Set the tax high enough and you'll get smuggling gangs with all the same tendencies.
jl6··on No constitutional right to clean water, federal court finds
At the risk of an analogy, this is like finding that the Linux kernel provides no guarantee that a process won’t contain buffer overflow vulnerabilities. While buffer overflows are bad, and it would be a good idea to try to prevent them, enforcing against them at the kernel level would be a far-reaching prospect with many consequences, intended and unintended.

The judge is opining that other layers of protection are available.

jl6··on The many mysteries and lessons of the Bayeux tapestry
Low stakes conspiracy: the high-security operation to move the tapestry to London was actually cover for the simultaneous movement of gold from European nations as part of their recent hedge against US counterparty risk.
jl6··on Welcome to the Porcelain Insulator Collector's World of Mud
No disrespect to Arnold Rimmer, but that telegraph pole society has got nothing on the insulator folk.
jl6··on Welcome to the Porcelain Insulator Collector's World of Mud
Well I can’t say I understand the appeal of collecting insulators, but I’m completely in love with the idea that there are people who enjoy such a niche hobby with such intensity, and apparently have been enjoying it for decades, and have societies and conventions and everything. Unbelievable. This is what the internet is for.
jl6··on .name Termination
I can only assume somebody was asleep on the job when this scheme was approved, because the outcome is in direct contradiction to ICANN’s mission statement:

> Its enduring mission is to ensure the stable, secure operation of the Internet's unique identifier systems.

https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/about-icann

Arbitrary termination of service is not stability.

Enabling name hijacking is not security.

The answer cannot be a rival name scheme based on decentralization or crypto or whatever. Those are never going to help normal non-wizard users. The answer has to be to make the regulators do their job.

jl6··on Forgotten History of Small Nuclear Reactors (2015)
I think “medium” is a key enabler for being able to sustain a regular schedule of reactor building. It’s way easier to raise $3bn every 3 years than $30bn every 30 years.
jl6··on Forgotten History of Small Nuclear Reactors (2015)
Feels like there is a "too small" range where fixed costs make a reactor design uneconomic, and perhaps a "too big" range where they cost so much that they are rare strategic investments without the benefit of a production line.

Is there a happy medium? Some of the modern SMR proposals aren't all that small. There's a 470MW Rolls Royce unit, for example.

jl6··on Firefox intent to ship: JPEG XL
Great outcome, and I hope the weight of mainstream browser support will spur camera and phone manufacturers to emit native JXLs from their devices.
jl6··on Beware Management Consultants
Not sure about high espionage, but information laundering is the right phrase for how it usually works: consultants cut across organizational boundaries, gathering useful information from the people who know what's actually going on (the rank-and-file employees) and packaging it for CxOs in a way that allows them to present an opportunity as their own idea, or a risk as not their fault. Nice, safe, clean information.
jl6··on Deus Ex creator Warren Spector is retiring from game development
It’s just gone past the halfway point between the date Deus Ex was released, and the date it was set. That puts it on target, because it feels like about half the plot has come true. It was a prototype for a much larger system.
jl6··on Crime Pays but Botany Doesn't
Can I get this, but for geology?
jl6··on IMAX vs. IMAX 70mm: The difference between these two cinema formats
Passionate hobbyists are often a great source of technical information, and usually more objective than industry sources. The thing to watch out for is people who have become so absorbed by their hobby, they start to put great subjective weight on distinctions that would be without difference to a "normal" person. Audio gear, gourmet food, fine wine, running shoes... It's XKCD 915 all the way down. I also recommend Penn & Teller: Bullshit! S03E12 ("The Best") on this subject.

Good for the hobbyists, if it enhances their enjoyment, but if you're a casual, microscopic variations are going to be dwarfed by other factors.

jl6··on UEFA and its national associations will not participate in FIFA competitions
Infantino’s justification has been to “grow the game”, but I cannot imagine how football could possibly get any bigger, except maybe in the US.
jl6··on Europe's fires are just the start
> the loss of the Amazon (it's pretty much lost already, isn't it?)

No, it’s not lost already. We should attempt to preserve what remains, not assume failure is inevitable.

jl6··on Humans haven't stopped evolving
Good question, with a couple of possible answers:

1) maybe those species aren’t as unchanged as we think, because our evidence of the past is limited to things like skeletons, and maybe the skeletal structure of the shark didn’t change much, but other aspects did.

But more likely…

2) maybe unchanging requires a stable environment with stable selection pressures - but humans have had a rollercoaster of change in selection pressures, possibly more than any other species.

jl6··on Programming language file extensions that match ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 country code
We must prepare for the possibility of a malicious secession of Exeter City, likely with Chris Martin as president.
jl6··on John C. Dvorak has died
Is that from the San Francisco Examiner? Do you have sources for the family information you mention?
jl6··on Worse on Purpose – How Corporate Greed Killed Product Quality
Yeah. Nobody is innocent here.

Someone linked to The Market for Lemons below. This is exactly right. We now live in the World of Lemons. Everything is lemons, because we can only properly judge quality for the tiny number of things we truly care about. For everything else, we just buy the cheapest thing, because by definition we don’t care enough to do otherwise.

The only possible solution is to buy less stuff, to the point where you have the capacity to care more about each thing, and enough money to pay for these things, which will inevitably cost more.

But then that means making peace with the idea that not having a thing can be better than having a crappy thing. It’s a tough sell to the consumption mindset.

jl6··on John C. Dvorak has died
Wikipedia sources the claim to an article by Jerry Pournelle in BYTE magazine, from 1985.
jl6··on Sealed tomb filled with paintings and inscriptions discovered in Egypt
I don’t think anyone can lay claim to a plot of land in perpetuity. Reverence should and does fade over time. Maybe when you are initially buried, that plot of earth belongs to you for a while, but after hundreds of years, it’s the other way round: you belong to the earth.

By the way, I don’t think you deserve downvotes for expressing your opinion.

jl6··on What AI did to stackoverflow in a graph
Here’s one:

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/79981854/how-to-run-mode...

-5 points, closed as not related to software development. It’s not a particularly great question, but clearly a bunch of people were more interested in keeping their garden tidy than in helping someone learn.

jl6··on First atmosphere found on Earth-like planet in habitable zone of distant star
If you have a billion year long civilization, it would probably be easier to genetically/medically engineer humans to live forever, so that a 75,000 year space voyage doesn’t seem so long. Easier than near-lightspeed space travel at any rate.
jl6··on 'Likweli': A new monkey species discovered in the Congo Basin
A definition that is debatable at the edges doesn’t have to be debatable at the center, so I don’t think it follows that we need to completely throw out the concept. Nature doesn’t provide neat categories, but speciation is nonetheless a real natural phenomenon that isn’t perturbed by having fuzzy boundaries.
jl6··on 45% of Enthusiasts 'Seriously Considering' Leaving Sony for PC
All forms of entertainment are entering crisis, because there is so much of it competing for attention, and so many years of back catalog that are still entertaining and available for free-or-nearly-free. Premium gaming and premium content of any kind seems unsustainable.
jl6··on Postgres rewritten in Rust, now passing 100% of the Postgres regression tests
"Is 50% faster than Postgres on transaction workloads" - That is a very big claim! 50% faster on everything? Is it a strict improvement across the board or are there tradeoffs that make some workloads slower?
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →