Pigeonpunk (patent pending)
193 karma · joined December 9, 2015
Pigeonpunk (patent pending)
There are major impediments that are non-technical for those of us in government positions, just take a look at the bidding process for projects that are pretty much required for something the scale of "overhauling" the system backing state or federal programs. Is it necessary? Probably not. Does it happen anyway because it's required? Yes. This isn't the fault of some tenured programmer, hell, they're probably not even consulted as a knowledge worker as part of the bid process. This isn't a failure of culture, this is the failure of a byzantine beauracracy built around protecting itself instead of the people it's meant to serve. You can have all the innovation that comes out of the NIH, the NSF, DARPA and the NSA; but the amount of time even practical papers and systems that are produced by these institutions are put into practice by the government thay funded them is exceedingly slim due to the institutional rust that's in place. Many of these "SV culture" companies are actively building things that were first concepts in a government lab, but by all means, blame the underpaid, overworked technical staff that actually designed them.
There are still very solid use cases for Mongo/Couch/Dynamo/GraphQL/etc. it's just that the hype train of "use NoSQL for everything, even situations that are tailor made for row/column stores" has quieted some (there's still pockets of "OMG MAP-REDUCE ALL THE THINGS").
I think the combination of the drop in hype, along with the ability to see gains with things like PostgreSQL (and others) handling JSON blobs well has made people actually evaluate trade offs a little bit more sanely.
We can't effectively say for certain whether there's a correlation with throwing in a higher power or just group therapy on its own in this circumstance, and I know for a fact there are many that will not join an "* Anonymous" group because of the more religious overtones. This creates a dichotomy that is hard to separate when talking about groups like AA, as it reinforces the thought that their process is important over the comradarie and support of a shared experience.
"It is absurd to use drugs for depression that increase the risk of suicide and homicide when we know that cognitive behavioural therapy can halve the risk of suicide in patients who have been admitted after a suicide attempt and when psychotherapy does not increase the risk of murder."
And I think it really speaks to the need to have professionals that aren't just throwing folks on drugs and sending them off. A whole form approach to mental health is needed, where a combination of various forms of therapy may be the best way to help an individual; since pretty much every study can agree that the efficacy essentially comes down to the individual level.For my ADHD, anxiety, and depression I don't take anything (currently), but I do regularly see a therapist with whom I work through issues I'm having and how to combat them, as well as how to reinforce my successes. This isn't to say that at specific times I haven't tried different pharmacology to combat one or all of these issues; but at this time, the most effective thing __for_me__ has been basic therapy.
This isn't to say that what has worked for me will work for others, but at its most basic, finding a professional that is willing to really dig into what's going on is extremely important, as they will be able to work with the individual to figure out not only what's going on, but even what the goals are and whether they are even achievable goals (elimination of symptoms, management, setting new normal habits, etc. etc. etc).
And that's why I get frustrated with fluff journalism around much deeper studies, they can convince people that an entire system and industry is a bunch of quacks that shouldn't be taken seriously; is the person that's doing self-study going to dig into what it means for a study to show bias or the effect size or the sample size; or whether it's a direct study or a meta-analysis; or what the type of statistical analysis was used (were they using teeming or densification methods for gaps in data, was it a regression analysis, if so was it linear, bilinear, quadratic, etc); I could keep going on... or are they going to just read a couple of journalism pieces and call it a day.
This isn't to say I don't love medium-science (not hard, not soft) journalism; I love Quanta and the pieces they put out about science and math concepts, but if I want to dig deeper I will look up the pub or pre-pub information from the details they're covering; I would hope that someone that's doing self-study would do the same with medium-science medical journalism, but I can't ever guarantee that.
How about:
- "I would love to finally see an article that has tips for a society on how to prevent ADHD..."
- "I would love to finally see an article that has tips for a society on how to prevent Schizophrenia..."
- "I would love to finally see an article that has tips for a society on how to prevent Bipolar Disorder..."
- "I would love to finally see an article that has tips for a society on how to prevent Mania..."
Each and every one of these are somewhat related mental health disorders and can cross over with depression as well. They can exacerbate it or even change how you may respond to various types of therapy (talk, drug, STM, etc).And "real reasons to be depressed", what would those be; or are you mixing up sad or anxious or morose or frustrated or ... with "clinically depressed." Clinical depression, much like the other mental health issues that I used above, doesn't have to have a reason as proscribed socially.
Unfortunately, most "self help BS" is written from two perspectives, those that have never had a bout of clinical depression; and those that have and found a specific way to get __themselves__ through it. If those that used specific things to get through it presented that information in that manner instead of "this is what everyone should do" it may be understood better overall, but that's a failing of being human; not of the writers.
And google swings... and it misses...
There are two somewhat competing studies involved in what you linked.
The original meta-analysis is stating that "[a]ll antidepressants were more efficacious than placebo in adults with major depressive disorder." And if you dig into that study, the level of effectiveness varies, but is consistently above a placebo.
The other, states that the original meta-analysis missed some points within their study; specifically that under the standardized criterion, there is an unknown level of bias in the results (73% showing unknown bias, and 26% showing high risk of bias - essentially confirming that most studies couldn't be done in a full blind or double-blind manner); and that while the sample size was high, the effect size was less known due to drop-out rates of the studies.
This isn't necessarily contrary to the initial meta-analysis, but brings to light that they may need to be taken with a level of caution; it doesn't make the claim that anti-depressants are no better than placebos, but that when doing the meta-analysis Cipriani et. al. needed to make more apparent exigencies with their results.
All this being said, the puff piece draws a more black and white tone with the meta-analysis and the meta-meta-analysis results; which tends to be the problem with these types of pieces. Sure, do your own research, but you'll need to dig into what's actually behind the journalistic fluff to get at the real meat and potatoes of the subject, if you don't you may come away with the idea that anti-depressants have 0 efficacy instead of "some efficacy, with the caveat that studies are somewhat mixed on individual results due to the nature of how the studies are conducted."
Unfortunately, there is no strong consensus that gluten intolerance does or does not exist, and the best most folks without Celiac can do is a nutritional exclusionary screening. The real tell on it is more to do with what grains can or can't be used/tolerated when it comes to wheat sensitivity, gluten intolerance, or fodmap carbs.
Celiac, like Type 1 diabetes, gout, lupus, and many other auto-immune disorders can only be managed, not magically cured.
Gluten intollerances are a different matter entirely, and can stem from over use of gluten enriched flours (think pizza doughs, white bread, anything using bleached flours, and anything that commercially needs more rise than the natural flour can provide).
But, I think the thing that has helped me the most is learning how to bake. Home made breads will consistantly beat the pants off of most commercial ones; the only problem you may find in Lithuania is availability of gluten free "cup for cup" baking flours, but if you can't find them readily, you can substitute most flours by weight into a standard recipe.
Some notes on gf flours, you will never get the rise you would out of bread flours because they're missing the biggest ingredient for rise, gluten. But you can get pretty darn close with your own sourdough mother made out of a mix of other flours. My usual mix includes some combination of:
- white rice flour
- brown rice flour
- tapioca starch
- almond or teff flour
- xanthan gum, guar gum, or amaranth gum as the gluten substitute
- powdered egg whites also as gluten substitute
You're going to need to experiment, but getting a good all purpose mix will make a night and day difference in the gluten free life.As for countries that are "better" for gluten free, I would hazard a guess that many asian countries are going to be better just due to their lack of reliance on gluten heavy grains as dietary staples. And lastly, you're going to have to get used to not eating out as much, and being very deliberate about it no matter where you live.
Subtly guiding the user is like slicing a watermelon with a katana, and this was more of a sledgehammer.
Once you get to the general public it's another matter entirely; for instance, look at how 538 was pilloried for their "30% chance to win the presidency for the current head of state," and how many times they've put out detailed information on how 30% =/= 0%. Your general person running review of the data (not the engineer hiding in the back office tuning the results, who should have access to the information) is going to treat most things above 50% as inherently true and anything below 50% as inherently false (within some margin of error, i.e. 50% +/- 5 points).
It would be better to go the 'dumb' machine route of setting up some standard escalation flags; which looks like it may be what happened with this (albeit in a bad way), "person self filing and < 18 years of age; raise flag." The system being bad at differentiating 1919 & 2019 and then sending out an automated response seems more like a bad UX problem at this juncture, since it's something that could have been avoided with a quiet internal flagging instead of a loud external one.
And in general this type of function overloading kinda breaks the general python philosophy of "Explicit is better than implicit." So again, what's the motivation with this?
Like the post, but it's just seems a weird hill "die on" with no real improved functionality over what would be standard practice in Python.
If I'm making a quick soup for the evening; I'll use store-bought stock, if I'm making it for a huge group of friends, I'll put in the time to make my own.
Home made spaetzle is a great, quick noodle (and since I've got Celiac, it's an easy noodle to make GF) that takes about 5 minutes to actually make, 3 minutes to boil, and 5 minutes to brown on the stove top. Using it for Mac-and-Cheese is almost faster than the Kraft stuff.
And with anything that is a learned skill, cooking is slow at first; but as you get better at the basics it speeds up the process. As an example, it used to take me almost 2 hours to change my oil on my car; now I can do it as fast as a shop (~20-30 minutes).
The biggest thing that it all comes down to is time/money tradeoff, if I can convince myself that something is more worth the time it takes to do than the cost of someone else doing it, I can usually make it happen.
It's been one of my better attempts at trying to circumvent the 'scorched earth' leaving of the task management process.
[0] https://alistapart.com/topics/That being said, I do martial arts, and I would compare intense focus on performing an intermediate to long kata to the generally expressed trance or meditative states; and in those times I would consider it similar to either art or programming flow.
And I think that's where the distinction is, as 'traditional' meditation tends to be a more passive meditation style that doesn't work well with the active needs to essentially distract my brain into a present tense form.
Like for me, depending on where I'm at in existence from day to day my therapist has said the 'H' portion of ADHD is minor for me, other times it's been a major contributor to issues; but I have to have a level of introspection to even catch when certain parts of my diagnosis are sitting at high tide or low tide...
Sometimes I can remember every detail of every interaction and task for weeks at a time, nearing eidedic memory; but most days I'll misplace a knife I was just using for butter.. and yesterday I forgot all the time I spent doing chores because I essentially was on auto-pilot, my wife thanked me, I said "for what?" high tide and low tide...
I'll hyperfocus on creating a task-list for a project I'm super excited about, and __usually__ forget the Trello board exists or misplace the papers or let the notes go through the wash or... high tide and low tide...
Some days I'll be able to fall asleep as soon as I lay down. Most days though I can't get my brain to shut up, taking notes to free up the brain space makes more room for something else to jump in, meditation/breathing exercises are momentary fixes that don't last long enough to allow sleep to come, a glass of water or bathroom break turns into an hour on reddit, etc and then suddenly it's 5am... high tide and low tide...
Most psychologists and psychiatrists worth their salt will tell you that ADHD and Anxiety are kissing-cousins; and will usually look for the other if someone has one of them. Guess what is a great emotional inhibitor to doing things... Anxiety.
More generally, a strong emotional response of any kind could be considered as a chemical imbalance by how you're categorizing ADHD. ADHD isn't as hard and fast assigned a "chemical imbalance" like Depression, and more closely related to Asperger/Autism as an executive function/communication disorder (via DSM 4r9 and all of DSM 5). The reason that some of us are given something like Welbutrin or Proponolol instead of a straight stimulant like Ritalin or Aderall is because ADHD can in many cases be clustered with Depression, Anxiety, or other mood disorders (which are in the "chemical imbalance" group, and knocking out one can help the other).
So, short story long, there's no contradiction; but like with most things, there can be multiple root causes for a single, broadly defined outcome like procrastination.
- In the middle of flow
- Trying to fall asleep
- Trying to go back to sleep
- In the middle of important conversations
- During meetings - even one's you're leading
- When you're getting dressed
- When you're making breakfast (where the hell did I put the 3rd spoon I've pulled from the drawer)
- When you're in intimate moments with a partner (or by yourself - no judgement here)
- When you're making lunch (just burned my second grilled cheese because I can't stay on task for 5 minutes)
- During exercise
- During free-time and hobbies
- Between small tasks
- In the middle of small tasks
- etc
- etc
- etc
The article itself is about the issues surrounding the person's ADHD, not just "procrastination," which for many people is a good thing, because it's a brain break; but for many of us with ADHD it's the norm and a cycle we have to fight instead of embrace.This section spoke to me in the same way, as each time I a new system up (or an old one back up) it works until I have to deal with an emergency day, where even the act of updating the list goes out the window. And then, the next day it's "hey, I made it through yesterday, I don't need that system today." and then it's done... until my emergency is "holy hell, I have no clue what's on my plate for the day/week/month, I need to fix that." where I'll pick up my go to old system (kanban style Trello board) and repeat the cycle anew.