It makes sense to try to get what benefit you can out of all criticism, but I think Jeff is still right that critics should try to keep it constructive.
The fact that you can buy investments with money makes it a medium of exchange. Money is theoretically supposed to be a store of value as well, but it is not a good store of wealth, due to inflation. With current central bank policy (or at least Fed policy in the US), most interest bearing accounts are not currently a good way to store wealth, because after adjusting for inflation, their low interest rates mean that you are actually losing wealth over time.
"Basic science is currently a socialist enterprise, funded
by the taxpayer, with the results available to society at
large."
One current problem is that this is that the results are not always available to society at large; I've seen a lot of stories on HN about attempts to change that.
"Since the benefits of scientific advances
are consumed by everyone, no individual has a strong financial incentive to invest in basic research."
Related to this point, patent law causes companies to focus more on efforts that lead to patentable inventions, and therefore away from basic science, which is unpatentable.
Well, dismissing her experience based on a "freshness rating" hypothesis wouldn't be justified, but she does say that she had "used [Monster] in the past and...been successful in obtaining jobs through it."
I don't think it's accurate to say that most states require a license just to own a firearm. There are age, mental health, and criminal background restrictions, but that's not quite the same thing. Some states do have gun ownership licenses, but most only require licenses to carry a firearm, and in many of those states, that is technically only required for concealed carry.
That (or any other useful work beyond just finding primes) would be great, and it's mentioned in the article (as something that cryptocurrency "newbies" commonly suggest), but the concern with all of that is efficient verification.
Well, you're right about human labor being a luxury in a world of increasing automation. It seems like people are willing to pay for that, though. Until something really crazy happens, like mind uploading becoming a reality, automation will result in more people being employed for luxury purposes. Many of these will be low-wage jobs, but that won't be so bad if technological progress continues to make things more affordable. But human labor as a luxury does not necessarily mean low-wage work. For example, mechanical watches have essentially been toys for rich people for the past few decades, yet they continue to be produced in significant numbers, and the higher-end watches generally have a significant amount of human labor involved.
Good point. A lot of people assume that college sports programs always generate income for the school, but many of them lose money (though probably not the ones employing these particular coaches). I attended a school that was in the process of adding a football program, and the first effect of that was an extra fee for students (in addition to an existing athletics fee). I think the only way that college sports can be acceptable is if they never take money from other programs or increase the cost of education for students not participating in those sports.
I took your advice. On a related note, does anybody know how organizations promoting certain legislation decide between emphasizing calling and e-mailing? Usually I've been asked to send an email, but sometimes the same organizations that normally use that strategy ask for phone calls specifically.
I don't know what tzaman was saying exactly, but what I noticed was that "today" got down to one or two pixels pretty fast, while the larger and larger time periods were restricted to only another ~1000 pixels or so, so at some point you have to shift back to imagining the relative lengths of time in your head again, instead of seeing e.g. "today" as 1/30 of the month.
Regarding gifts of approximately equal value, I've heard of women giving men "engagement watches". It seems like they're generally worth less than the rings, though.
I don't think that the "animal rights" movement "promotes clean killing as an ethical good". Sometimes these videos are released with the intent of persuading people to stop consuming meat (and perhaps even eggs and dairy). But even if the videos are only intended to change certain abusive practices within the meat industry, I think many people would agree that abuse followed by killing is worse than killing alone.
Some private organizations have very deep pockets, and it's not just industry, as non-profits can also fund research. But if industry is biased toward applied/translational research, perhaps it's not just a focus on short-term profitability or a lack of funds for large projects. One interesting idea is that patent laws are partially responsible for this bias, because they grant a temporary monopoly on inventions/applications, but not on basic science.
I would guess that this is either related to user enthusiasm for more professionally developed games (explaining why Windows users aren't as excited), or a desire to support the creation of cool stuff and be part of a community around it.
That's one of my least favorite things about Apple as well. They have always been able to leverage the fact that they are the only maker of Macs, and now they additionally have these more closed designs with RAM, storage, and batteries that are difficult to impossible for users to replace.
That said, Apple is not the only offender, nor are they the worst; I checked out the Lenovo online store, and they charge $160 extra to go from 4GB to 8GB of RAM on the laptop I looked at. Apple, despite the soldered-in RAM on the new MBP, now charges $200 to go from 8GB to 16GB.
My interpretation of that would be that if we already have one of the world's harshest tax policies in that regard, why would we want to have a reputation for being even worse? Do we want to make productive foreigners even more wary of acquiring US citizenship?
Interestingly, there is an estimate of the size of a sphere containing the water of the world's seas in Twenty Thousand Leagues under the sea:
"THE PART OF THE planet earth that the seas occupy has been assessed at
3,832,558 square myriameters, hence more than 38,000,000,000 hectares.
This liquid mass totals 2,250,000,000 cubic miles and could form
a sphere with a diameter of sixty leagues, whose weight would
be three quintillion metric tons."
According to Google and Frink, 60 leagues is less than 1/4 of the 860 miles estimated here; I'm not sure how much of that is due to the smaller scope of the estimate in Verne's book.
I think it's interesting that this was covered by Reason and that liberty/oppression is apparently part of the theory now. I wondered why it wasn't mentioned when I first encountered Haidt's ideas, because it seemed to me that would leave libertarians valuing the same things as liberals (fairness and (lack of) harm), but different interpretations of those values. That's how I had felt when taking that test, anyway: I felt that my ideals were coherent and well-defined, but it showed up very much like Mangu-Ward's results, as if I were a less-moral liberal.
The usefulness of versioning and other successful models in other fields/contexts is an interesting thing to think about. It could be that some applications of these models are not solving existing problems so much as creating new opportunities. Versioning for art and design could create new opportunities for collaborative creation even if it doesn't solve the problems of existing artists and designers. I don't know how well this can work, though.