HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jlgbecom

318 karma · joined August 11, 2010

submissionscomments
jlgbecom··on Scalable ACID
From a development standpoint, I don't quite understand the advantages of NoSQL over SQL. I get that you don't have to have a rigidly defined table structure, and that your data structure can change when your application changes, but I guess I'm one of those curmudgeons that prefers rigidity over permissiveness. I like that I have to think hard about my table structure and models before and as I code. I also rarely feel bogged down by SQL, although I've been using it for over a decade, so that helps.

As for scalability, as this post shows, I think the best thing to come out of NoSQL is the race for greater scalability it has and will continue to inspire in SQL solutions.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook
Something is going to topple Facebook, but I very much doubt it will be Diaspora.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
I don't think it's fully implemented yet, but here's the protocol Appleseed is using:

http://svn.appleseedproject.org/trunk/_documentation/quickso...

From the source, it looks like they're building abstracted PHP libraries, too. And it's an event/hook architecture, so you can pop this protocol out and put another one in, theoretically.

I don't know if this is a placeholder protocol while they build the software, or if this is what they plan on using and evolving.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
That has to be the most ridiculous criticism I've ever heard of any project ever.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Exactly. I'm amazed that people think that Diaspora can accomplish in a few months what Elgg, Appleseed, Onesocialweb, etc. etc. have all been working on for YEARS.

Especially when considering that these are being developed by professionals with industry experience, and Diaspora is four college kids.

We all want to hear the story of the intrepid engineers working in their parents garage and changing the world, but let's be realistic here.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Which project are you most interested in, then? Because of all the projects, none really have codified protocols for social networking.

Except possibly OneSocialWeb, which extends XMPP. Is that the project you find most intriguing?

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
I'd be interested to hear why you're more interested in hosting Diaspora instead of Appleseed?
jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Appleseed uses an MVC+Hooks framework, so it can support whatever anyone wants to build a set of hooks for.

I'm sure you'll see a lot of different protocol support in the future.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
A lot of the biggest sites on the web are coded in PHP, including Facebook, Wikipedia, and Digg.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Yeah, it's federated server software. It's meant to be run by people who provide a hosted environment for users.

In other words, it's software for anyone who wants to run their own facebook-like site. Except that all the sites running it connect to each other.

Once it's out of beta, most users will just go to a sign up page of any number of nodes out there (I think there's like 50 out there already? I'm not sure)

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Appleseed is already open to the public for whoever wants to download the source and install it (it took me about 2 min on a shared host, really easy). You can then disable invites on your node by going into the administrator and setting on "use invites" to "no".

But in any case, they give out invites like water, you just have to email invite@appleseedproject.org. Since that's the beta testing site, they're looking for beta testers, not casual users.

Diaspora does have publicity on it's side, I'll give it that. We'll see how user-friendly it's first release is in September.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora: An Overdue Update
Appleseed is a lot farther along, and has been releasing steadily this whole summer. It's years ahead of Diaspora, they've been putting out a new release every month, and they already have a bunch of nodes already running their software.

http://opensource.appleseedproject.org

I think by the time Sep 15th rolls around, Appleseed will be on it's fourth release this summer.

jlgbecom··on Ask HN: Diaspora hasn't updated their blog in a month.
They sure are operating more like a dot-com vaporware startup than an open source project. I understand not releasing code right away, there's reasons for that, but why no specifics about their approach? Why is everything about this project a guessing game?
jlgbecom··on Ask HN: Diaspora hasn't updated their blog in a month.
Meanwhile, the Appleseed Project has been posting regular updates all summer. Their roadmap, SVN, and documentation is available to everyone, and they've been building the software since 2004.

http://opensource.appleseedproject.org

← PreviousPage 3 of 3