HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jltsiren

6,349 karma · joined May 14, 2017

submissionscomments
jltsiren··on The Escalation of War in Ethiopia
Its cultural and scholarly centers were Timbuktu and Djenne. They were effectively inaccessible to Europeans during their golden age, but they had established connections to Morocco and Egypt. Hundreds of thousands of historical manuscripts were preserved in Timbuktu. The manuscripts are still largely unstudied, though I guess the digitization efforts should have finished by now.
jltsiren··on On social reality in China
I would focus more on current realities when seeking explanations, because the mentality can shift a lot in a single generation.

I'm from Finland. My grandparents were of a generation that knew poverty and hunger and fought in wars. They raised their families when the country was still poor, and food security was always at the back of their minds. My parents grew up in a country that was rapidly getting wealthier. Their generation took food for granted, but owning things was important to them, as it was something they could not have in their youth. For my generation, the country has always been wealthy, and we have always been able to take basic necessities for granted. Our focus has been in choosing what we want to do with our lives, as the world is open and there are many options to choose from.

jltsiren··on ArXiv's Updated Rate Limit Policy
In my experience (in CS, bioinformatics, and genomics), the first round of reviews often improves the paper substantially. You are getting feedback from people outside your usual peer group, and they tend to notice things people closer to you don't.

And writing is thinking. Because you are forced to iterate on the text over a long period of time, your understanding of the topic improves and you learn to express the ideas better. Your job as a scientist is creating new knowledge, and the initial publication of new results is only the first step towards that.

jltsiren··on The Legend of von Neumann (1973) [pdf]
Usually that's because the engineer is not a very good engineer, at least outside their specialty. If they had studied engineering more, they would have probably learned that other engineers are already doing the thing they proposed.

"Using methodology from a field known for its focus on methodology in another field" was still a novel idea in von Neumann's time. But because von Neumann and others did it, and because millions of people entered science after them, most combinations like that have already been tried. Breakthroughs from combining ideas from unrelated fields require something little less obvious these days.

jltsiren··on ArXiv's Updated Rate Limit Policy
It's not been my experience that papers published in CS conferences get outdated quickly. Maybe AI/ML is different, but it's a weird edge case that should not dominate the discussion. Even CS as a whole is an outlier, because most fields that use arXiv don't have conference papers. If the expectations of AI/ML or even the wider CS are too different, maybe they could start a preprint repository of their own.

One of weird aspects of CS research is the tendency to publish small papers. In more experimental fields, a paper may represent years of work for the first author. But CS students often finish multiple projects every year. Maybe it's because of the focus on conferences. You want to attend conferences (to build your networks, and because it's interesting and valuable), but you often don't get reimbursed if you don't have anything to present. Students from other fields can just present their work in progress, but CS students have to come up with publishable results.

Maybe CS should also strive towards bigger projects. Instead of publishing individual results (which someone often improves a year or two later), the papers could focus on the outcomes of entire research directions. That way you are more likely to produce something of lasting value. Something that is worth writing up and rewriting and polishing, until you understand the ideas much better than after the initial write-up.

jltsiren··on ArXiv's Updated Rate Limit Policy
If your result is not worth publishing in a journal a year or two from now, it't not worth submitting to arXiv today. Just write a blog post about it and move on. And maybe write a paper once you have discovered something of more lasting value.
jltsiren··on ArXiv's Updated Rate Limit Policy
The situation is pretty crazy, but it just means the bar for publishable results will go up. Theoretical computer science is a field built around conferences. The number of papers that can be published in reputable conferences ultimately depends on the size of the community and the willingness and ability of its members to attend those conferences.
jltsiren··on Responsible Release of AI-Generated Mathematics
I was talking about the value created by mathematics. Which largely comes from training people to think about technical details. Which typically manifests as new ideas based on deep technical understanding of earlier ideas.
jltsiren··on Responsible Release of AI-Generated Mathematics
When I was a postdoc in genomics, one of my supervisors had a background in mathematics. Current bioinformatics training pipeline didn't exist yet, so most PhD students and postdocs had a background in something like CS, mathematics, statistics, or physics.

From the supervisor's perspective, people coming from pure mathematics were good at thinking about definitions. Coming up with useful definitions was the primary value they created, while theorems and proofs were just technical stuff they did to evaluate the value of proposed definitions.

My own background was in theoretical computer science, specifically algorithms. When you do algorithms without any qualifiers, you are studing them as mathematical objects in a simplified model of computation. The process often starts with a promising algorithmic idea. But if it looks like you can't prove anything nontrivial about the idea, you often stop studying it, regardless of the actual value of the idea. And if you manage to prove something, you start optimizing the algorithm for your theoretical model in order to prove better results. That usually makes it worse in practice.

The end result is that algorithms papers, both good and bad, typically contain theorems and proofs about algorithms nobody cares about. If you are a practicioner, you need to dig through all that noise to find the core algorithmic ideas, so that you can evaluate them in a more realistic setting. And if you are a theoretician, you are probably more interested in the techniques used in the proofs (which may also inspire future algorithmic ideas) than in the actual results.

You can find plenty of other similar situations. The value mathematicians create is rarely in the theorems and the proofs.

jltsiren··on U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve Falls to Lowest Level Since 1982
The Finnish situation was complicated.

Finland and the USSR had a defensive treaty that, among other things, obligated Finland to fight against NATO if it tried to use Finnish territory or airspace to attack the USSR. There was also a Soviet military base near Helsinki that was supposed to be there until 1994. But after Khrushchev rose to power, the Soviets decided to return it for a number of reasons.

After the USSR fell, Finland deliberately stayed out of NATO in order to maintain a good relationship with Russia. Because the popular support for NATO membership was very low, Russia apparently believed Finnish intentions. Even in late 2021, only ~25% of Finns supported joining NATO. (Six months later, that number was ~75%.)

jltsiren··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
As scientists, we need to have effective filters to quickly ignore things that are probably not relevant to us. But we also need to acknowledge that those filters are necessarily noisy, and they don't tell much of the value of the work they reject.

If you want to determine reliably whether something is irrelevant and incorrect noise, determining whether there is anything of value is a necessary first step.

I've seen many reproduction attempts in bioinformatics fail, because they person trying to reproduce the work didn't have the conceptual background to do it correctly. Instead of spending enough time studying the theory, they rushed directly to action.

jltsiren··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
It depends on what you see as a fatal flaw, and if you count mathematics and theoretical fields or just actual science. In mathematics and theoretical computer science, it's pretty common that major results are initially wrong, and fixing the errors can take a long time. Wiles's proof of Fermat's Last Theorem is the best-known example.

In any case, my point was that rejecting results due to technical flaws is intellectually lazy. As a scientist, your job is more about trying to find value in other people's work than finding excuses to reject it.

jltsiren··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
That's the administrative aspect of the question. But as a scientist, I'm more interested in knowing if the result is real. Sometimes even fatally flawed papers make valuable contributions, because the proposed approach will lead to the claimed result, once done properly.
jltsiren··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
Reputation is a factor, because most processes involve a subjective evaluation by other experts in the field. And non-experts use service activities such as peer review as a proxy for reputation. If reputable entities use your services as an expert, you are probably a reputable expert in the field.
jltsiren··on Nicholas Polson has authored 258 academic papers in 2026 so far
How do you determine that a mistake is serious enough that it actually invalidates the paper? How do you know that it's not possible to correct it and reach a similar conclusion with fundamentally the same approach? Especially when the fix would be complex enough to justify a follow-up paper.
jltsiren··on U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve Falls to Lowest Level Since 1982
Russian security thinking is largely shaped by the invasions of Napoleon and Hitler, which caused terrible destruction. The biggest thing they are afraid of is an invasion from the west. That led to a doctrine, where Russia tries to surround itself with allies and puppets. When the next invasion comes, they can then start fighting against it well outside Russian territory, which should limit the damage to Russia itself.

Under that doctrine, if you are a European country bordering Russia, your duty is to help defending Russia. You can choose whether you do that as an ally or a puppet, but you are not allowed to make any other choices.

That's not reasonable fear, given what Europe became after WW2, but it's what Russian leaders expect. Especially those of Putin's generation, who spent their early lives preparing for a possible NATO invasion that could start WW3.

jltsiren··on 12,000-year-old Göbeklitepe burials explain scattered bones
The population bottleneck was far less dramatic, as it happened over centuries.

When population growth is effectively 0, the size of the male lineage of the average man is approximately 1 in each generation. But random variation means that the male lineages of most men don't survive that many generations.

Now imagine a stratified society, where elite men have more children than commoners and social status is largely hereditary from father to son. The average elite man will have >1 sons surviving into adulthood, while the average commoner will have fewer than one adult son. Repeat that over many generations, and lineages that started from an elite man will likely spread, while lineages starting from a commoner will likely go extinct.

jltsiren··on SpaceX's Starship launching to orbit for first time ever today
Falcon 1 had a few failures, but Falcon 9 was successful from the beginning. Early SpaceX played it safe, because they couldn't afford to lose big expensive rockets. The only explosion after launch happened on flight 19.

There were many explosions when SpaceX was trying to figure out how to land the booster safely. But those were after the booster had already completed the actual paid mission.

jltsiren··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
> Yep. You have to ask - why did OpenAI allow these bots unrestricted access to government sites? Why is security being done in seemingly such a haphazard way?

The basic premise of OpenAI is that experience and expertise don't matter, because general intelligence can figure those out from data. If you start from that assumption, the rest follows. The same people could do things in a different way in a different company, but as long as they are working for OpenAI, they are going to do things in the OpenAI way.

jltsiren··on An airport cooled by natural ventilation
I live in a place with very little need for heating and air conditioning. If I don't do anything, indoor temperatures vary between 17°C and 27°C around the year. I've noticed that I prefer 24–25°C during the day in the summer and 21–22°C in the winter, and a bit less when I'm sleeping.

When I travel around the US, most places are too cold for my taste. Conference rooms are the worst, as I can't adjust the temperature myself and I often spend hours in them without much physical activity. I guess many Americans don't acclimatize to warmer temperatures, because their summers are uncomfortably hot.

And when I return from long hikes high up in the mountains, even that 17°C feels too hot for sleeping for a few days.

jltsiren··on Zelensky says Russia has widened attacks to hit Ukraine's data centres
Nobody is hoping for a peace deal. The goals of Russia and Ukraine are too incompatible for any peace deal European leaders could support. Everyone has resigned to the fact that the war will go on, until the internal politics in either country make it impossible to continue. Or until something completely unexpected happens.

And the $100 billion/year military aid can go on indefinitely, because it's only a fraction of the increased military spending due to the war. If the war ends too soon with the terms favoring Russia, Europe would have to spend even more to increase the pace of its remilitarization.

jltsiren··on Every U.S. State Ranks Above Every Foreign Economy in Household Consumption
Assume that providing a service costs $1000/person/year in countries A and B. In country A, the average individual pays $200/year for the service and their taxes are $800/year higher, which the government uses for subsidizing the service. In country B, the individual pays the entire $1000/year. As a consequence, household spending is $800/year higher in country B.

International comparisons are tricky, because each country does things in its own way. While there are some high-quality data sources for such comparisons, you will almost certainly interpret them wrong, unless you spend a lot of time thinking about their data definitions, methodologies, limitations, and so on.

jltsiren··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Heat pumps already became popular a long time ago. Electricity is so widely used for heating, that the difference in electricity consumption between the coldest winter days and July nights is almost 2.5x. While there are some old legends of Finnish (or maybe Sami) wind wizards, we still haven't figured out how to generate wind power on demand.

In any case, it's up to the market. If you believe it's possible to make money with wind / solar / nuclear power in Finland, you should be able to get permits in a reasonable time. Right now, those building solar are investing more than the others.

jltsiren··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Most of Finnish wind capacity was built without subsidies. The demand was saturated at ~25% of total generation, after which the market started building solar. Wind power is more cost-effective at these latitudes, but solar generation is currently more valuable, as it correlates less with existing renewables.
jltsiren··on Every U.S. State Ranks Above Every Foreign Economy in Household Consumption
This seems to be about actual consumption that has not been adjusted for government subsidies. If country A subsidizes services such as education, childcare, and healthcare more than country B, household spending is going to be lower there. A better comparison would either ignore spending in commonly subsidized categories or include government subsidies in household spending.

A quick reality check: Norway would be one of the wealthiest US states, both by nominal figures and after adjusting for purchasing power. If your comparison says something else, you are probably doing something wrong.

jltsiren··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
It doesn't work that way in Italy. A popular referendum can only abolish an existing law, partially or fully. The general public cannot vote to adopt new legislation.
jltsiren··on Transit rewards
Do you mean that nobody wants property values go up? The government gets more property taxes, because properties near transit stations are more valuable than in other places.
jltsiren··on Transit rewards
The usual rule of thumb is that fixed costs of public transit are covered by increased property values. It could mean a private transit company developing the areas around stations (as it often works in Japan), or it could mean the government getting more money from property taxes. Or it could even mean more money from income taxes, if the transit project stimulates economic activity.

If a transit project doesn't increase property values enough to justify the investment, or if the entity funding the project cannot extract that value, the project rarely makes sense.

jltsiren··on NASA’s Mars Sample Return mission is dead
Maybe if we launched 30 Starships carrying 30 rovers each. With only 30 units, the prices would likely be similar to current commercial satellites, which are already built on standardized platforms.
jltsiren··on Seattle Bans Rental Junk Fees
And market-rate rental complexes replace condos. I can see legitimate reasons for subsidized rental complexes, and there is always some need for market-rate units, but I don't see any justification for dedicated market-rate complexes. People who can afford paying the market rate should be able to buy if they stay in the area long enough, but American cities have a shortage of smaller units you can buy. For some reason, maybe due to regulatory and market failures, developers prefer rental complexes over condos.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →