HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jmbwell

2,050 karma · joined February 16, 2015

submissionscomments
jmbwell··on Why senior developers fail to communicate their expertise
Indeed. Understand the principles, you can work with just about any tool
jmbwell··on For thirty years I programmed with Phish on, every day
I’ve been finding it difficult to hand things over to an LLM completely, and I wonder if this is part of it. I’ll let it help me organize at the beginning, and then I’ll have it come through and refactor or review, but the crafting part is where I want to spend my time. I love hitting tab but it seems like every time I do, I get this sensation like I’ve sort of time-warped into the future by a few seconds, and I wonder what I’d have written if the LLM hadn’t done it for me. At which point I’ll never know.

Great for generating volumes of output. Less great for going into a flow state and coming out with something that looks like I made it, something that I see my hand in

And yeah, maybe it’s because I never quite get into a flow state when I do it this way. Hmm

jmbwell··on Granite 4.1: IBM's 8B Model Matching 32B MoE
The language of drama and import without meaningful substance. Words statistically likely to be used in a segue, regardless of the preceding or subsequent point. Particularly effective when it seems like you’re getting let in on a secret. Really fatiguing to read

A writing teacher once excoriated me for saying that something was important. “Don’t tell me it’s important, show me, and let me decide, and if you do your job I’ll agree”

I don’t know how a completion can tell when it needs to do this. Mostly so far it doesn’t seem capable

jmbwell··on GTFOBins
It does seem like an LLM’s ability to see a constraint and just say “I’ll write a quick helper to work around it” kinda wrecks some older-world assumptions. We know how to deal with remote human attackers, remote bot attackers, and to some extent local human attackers, but local self-coding bot attackers lately needs more attention than it used to. It’s not even the same category as malware

I’ve been guilty myself of building containers where everything runs as root on the assumption that the container was the relevant domain

If LLMs are involved, I can’t tell whether OS level security is suddenly more relevant, or suddenly utterly obsolete

jmbwell··on An update on GitHub availability
I understood it to mean, GitHub is being crushed by LLM/AI/Agentic code review and submission, not GitHub’s code itself

What I’m not seeing here but I am seeing with the Linux kernel is, most of the automatically submitted code is irrelevant or not useful

(Maybe that’s what you were getting at, apologies)

jmbwell··on Talkie: a 13B vintage language model from 1930
These days, I’ll take Mad magazine
jmbwell··on Another Day Has Come
I struggle not to have a cynical take these days. Of course he cared about the ROI. The ROI is access to an underserved market, a halo effect, a new community of adherents, a new reason for customers to cross the moat into the ecosystem… a modest investment with a durable long term return in multiple categories.

I appreciate that it’s a win-win for Apple and for its customers, and I firmly believe that accessibility features serve everyone eventually. I’m glad that there are some billionaires who also see it that way.

I guess I just wish we didn’t have to rely on rare cases of billionaires finding it in their own best interest to happen to serve the rest of us. Especially when the actual accessibility work and everything else is actually done by a whole class of people that never make headlines just for leaving their jobs and being replaced.

jmbwell··on Bring Back Idiomatic Design (2023)
“Brand” and “branding” is arguably the most important thing -not- mentioned in the article. The commercial incentives to differentiate are powerful enough to kick a lot of UX out of the way.

Now that all we do is “experience” a “journey,” it’s more about the user doing what the app wants instead of the other way around

jmbwell··on Bring Back Idiomatic Design (2023)
macOS is slightly more consistent among apps that use system controls, but the more custom the app, or the more React Native or Electron it is, the less predictable it is

Infuriatingly, some apps try to be smart — only one line, return submits; more than one line, return is a new line, and command-return submits; but command-return on just one line beeps an error.

Years of muscle memory are useless, so now I’m reaching for the mouse when I need to be clear about my intent

So much is solved when developers just use the provided UI controls, so much well-studied and carefully implemented behavior comes for free

jmbwell··on Bored of eating your own dogfood? Try smelling your own farts
I get it. I also know customer service is a pretty low paying job for something that involves being yelled at all day

I get as frustrated as anyone, but it’s not the fault of the person whose job it is to take my call.

I remember once on the phone with Comcast I just explained the situation and jokingly said look, if it helps, feel free to tell ‘em I’m yelling and screaming. The guy laughed. An engineer called me an hour later with a firmware update for my modem.

Sometimes there’s no winning. But sometimes it helps if you can put people on your team

jmbwell··on Most-read tech publications have lost over half their Google traffic since 2024
Yes, and this has been the case for years. Cnet, ZDnet, PCmag have been user-hostile since long before AI summaries. Pop-ups, “before you go,” back jacking, all the worst.

The Verge is a surprise because it is relatively new and was relatively free of this crap for a long time.

They’re all just empty brands now. They totally caved to advertisers, and now only advertisers care about them.

I dare say AI’s popularity is a symptom of all this more than a cause.

jmbwell··on Ars Technica fires reporter after AI controversy involving fabricated quotes
This. The truth is still putting on its shoes and all that
jmbwell··on Ars Technica fires reporter after AI controversy involving fabricated quotes
I note that Ken Fisher did post an editor’s note, Benj did publicly own up to it, and all of this was mentioned in the article.
jmbwell··on AI Made Writing Code Easier. It Made Being an Engineer Harder
In writing code, as in writing poetry, the mechanical labor is 5% writing, 45% editing, and 50% reading. But the only thing that makes it yours is you.
jmbwell··on Terminals should generate the 256-color palette
Color schemes voluntarily added by the user to an app like vim, great.

All the more reason for developers to keep the app itself responsive to the user’s environment by default.

Don’t bake in elaborate visual choices. It’s a usability thing first and a style thing somewhere much farther down the list.

Keep it simple from the factory. Don’t get in the way of customization. Let the user’s environment do the work of adapting it to the user.

jmbwell··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me – more things have happened
I think fantastical isn’t totally inaccurate, and I’m not being snarky (for once). The personal observations and sometimes colorful language has been something I like about Ars. Benj in particular, with his warm tributes to BBSes. Or Jim Salter’s very human networking articles. The best stuff on Ars is both technically sound and rich with human experience. “Fantastical” taken to mean something like, capturing the thrills and aspirations that emerge from our contact with technology, seems fair I think.

I’ll be interested in finding out more about just what the hell happened here. I hardly think of Benj or Kyle as AI cowboy hacks, something doesn’t add up

jmbwell··on Internet's biggest annoyance: Cookie laws should target browsers, not websites
And then a handful of companies can offer a service to let advertisers punch through the plugins. And then another plugin could block that!

Thing is you’re probably right. The modern web is made of middlemen inserting themselves into user experiences to divert and extract revenue from the primary stream between consumer and producer. There’s always room for another layer.

jmbwell··on Internet's biggest annoyance: Cookie laws should target browsers, not websites
I think targeting web sites was the right move because it was the web sites who were doing all the tracking.

Of course now we also have browsers to worry about as well, being products of the same ad companies that were clogging up the web sites in the first place.

But if cookie laws pushed data collecting web sites to malicious compliance, surely similar laws would do the same to (also data collecting!) browser providers. I’d prefer to avoid inviting browsers to add another layer of bullshit. And there’s no reason it would make web sites behave differently… if I’m a web site bound to comply with laws, I’m probably going to cover my own ass and keep doing what I’m doing without assuming the browser will handle it. Rendering the browser controls redundant and ineffective.

If we want to look for core flaws, look at allowing a handful of giant companies to control the market for personal data — or to traffic in personal data at all.

Ad companies have convinced the whole economic system of the Internet that they are inevitable and essential. They are neither. But we won’t fix that either.

The solution is to get off the damn internet, but short of doing that, I’ll prefer to keep my options open to disable telemetry on my own terms.

Here’s something I would like, though: total sandboxing per web site. Let every domain be alone in its own room of cookies and telemetry. Let it think I only ever visit that site, and optionally always for the first time. I shouldn’t have to blow away all my cookies all the time just to keep Facebook from following me all over the web.

jmbwell··on When ChatGPT turns informant
I tried the same questions with my own account. I was surprised at how much it was able to synthesize that wasn't completely off-base.

With these sample questions, there wasn't much to learn, and it gave me relatively thoughtful-seeming responses. Nothing alarming -- I would expect it to recall things I've discussed with it, and it's very good at organizing things, so it's not a surprise that it did a good job at organizing a profile of me based on my interactions.

I would be curious how crafting the questions could yield unexpected or misleading results, though. I can imagine asking the same questions in different ways that might be designed to generate an answer in support of taking particular action. If I wanted to arrest me at the border, for example, I could probably ask questions in such a way that the answers would make me look arrest-able easily.

So this is my concern with ChatGPT -- not that it will reveal some unseen truth about me, but rather that it is trivial to manipulate it into "revealing" something false, especially as people consider it to be more capable and faithful than an elaborate sorting algorithm could ever be.

jmbwell··on Structured Procrastination (1995)
- Meds are just one of the tools available, just one part of a holistic approach that includes other accommodations, practices, and support from the people around you

- Not everyone experiences these things in the same way

- Your goals are for you to set; if incorporating meds into your plans doesn’t help you reach your goals, fine. But if meds help you unlock goals you might not be able to access otherwise, maybe they’re worth considering.

- The vast majority of professionals really do want to help you reach your goals; most psychiatrists (for the meds) and psychologists (for your cognitive health) are going to be more valuable in terms of perspective than an Internet thread :D

jmbwell··on Retiring Test-Ipv6.com
I definitely owe this guy a beer or coffee and hope to have a chance to make good on it.
jmbwell··on Helium Browser
My daily driver on macOS now for almost a year. Very happy with it.
jmbwell··on Microsoft BASIC for 6502 Microprocessor – Version 1.1
Used to be, with a scope, you could watch it working
jmbwell··on What is it like to be a bat?
It’s about the change from endeavoring to produce a product people want regardless of profit, to making profit regardless of what people want.
jmbwell··on Who does your assistant serve?
Anyone interested in better understanding a complex system can benefit from a qualified professional’s collaboration, often and especially when an outside perspective can help find different approaches than what appear to be available from inside the system.
jmbwell··on Who does your assistant serve?
Any field has hacks. Telling someone what they want to hear and helping get someone where they want to be are different things. Quality professionals help people reach their goals without judgment or presumption. That goes for mental health professionals as well as any professional field.
jmbwell··on Try and
The point I was waiting for them to get to was saved for last: entails completion.

Try to do something, you might or might not do it. “I’m going to try to persuade them to decide in my favor.”

Try and do something, you expect to get it done one way or another. “I’m goin down there to try and straighten them out.”

I don’t have a long history of research in this going back to the 1500s, but I grew up in southeast Texas, and this is how I’ve always understood it to be used around here, when it is used with any intention at least.

jmbwell··on Writing a good design document
All of this, plus, writing the documentation before building the app. I remember a Dilbert cartoon making fun of this being about the time I started realizing Dilbert wasn’t as smart as I had thought.

If you can’t write the documentation before you’ve written the code, you don’t understand well enough what you’re building the code for.

It’s one thing to jump into code because it’s fun to write code. But writing code is not designing software, and vice versa.

Same goes for APIs. Writing docs for an API that doesn’t yet exist can help create a much more complete and coherent API.

This is why I’m often trying to help stakeholders understand that the vast majority of software development has very little to do with actually writing code.

Herein also lies a concern I have about AI assisted development. It can be a powerful aid to the design stages, and it can be a powerful aid to writing code, but I’m not sure it enables skipping the design aspects altogether and somehow coming up with a complete, coherent product.

jmbwell··on Hyatt Hotels are using algorithmic Rest “smoking detectors”
I once had hotel staff show up right after I checked in saying they needed to check on my fridge. They spent a weird amount of time going over it. I hadn’t even looked at it, but it turned out to be one of these. Later I began to suspect they suspected me of messing with it. Now I kinda wish I had been
jmbwell··on Ask HN: Any active COBOL devs here? What are you working on?
I’ve run through a bunch of ZXplore and it’s more fun than I expected.

They have it hooked in to VS Code now. It’s weirdly modern. And you get to play on a real z machine.

Recommendable summer/holiday tinkering project. It’s amazing how much and yet how little has changed in computing and transaction processing.

← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →