HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jmcdonald-ut

120 karma · joined September 15, 2012

submissionscomments
jmcdonald-ut··on My takeaways from "Clean Code"
As someone who is just diving into Ruby, I'm curious what specifically you think is bad advice for Ruby?
jmcdonald-ut··on My takeaways from "Clean Code"
> Comments are fails

As the article mentions, I agree that it's good to make sure that you're naming conventions and code itself is expressive. Furthermore, if you approach coding with this philosophy you will most likely write much better code the first time around. Still some comments, written in plain (INSERT YOUR NATIVE LANGUAGE HERE), which give an executive summary of the class or method can be useful.

> Avoid output arguments / Have No Side Effects

This can be difficult to do in a language like C. It is convention to pass pointers to arrays, structs, etc and allow the method to change it or operate on it. Also it is normal for a method to adjust a pointer's position. With all the grief this caused me though, I do think that this is great advice for a language like Java, Ruby, etc.

jmcdonald-ut··on “Why are you using Node.js rather than PHP?”
A bit off topic: I agree that a lot of newbies tend to gravitate towards PHP. When I was 14 I wanted to program, and PHP had such a low barrier to entry that I was able to get coding without any configuration. No working in the shell, just writing a file and uploading it to a shared host.

To be honest, starting with PHP and just going was a really effective way to get me hooked to programming. Eight years later, and I've worked with C++, Ruby, Java, and C# to solve various problems. After seeing what else is out there, and understanding that different languages solve different problem sets, I don't think I'll ever gravitate back towards using PHP if I can help it. Occasionally it's fun to look at some of my old code and cringe. I'm sure if I could find some of my old questions on various forums they would look a lot like the question that user asked.

jmcdonald-ut··on Show HN: Introducing CircleUp - group photo sharing made simple
What's your differentiator? I mean for competitors you have instagram, facebook, google+, drop box, imgur, photobucket, and flickr to name a few. This is a space with a lot of noise, so I think you really need something special if you're going to enter it.
jmcdonald-ut··on Student Hackers: DO NOT Intern...BUILD.
Nothing has helped me get better at what I do than the knowledge/fear that a senior developer would be integrating my work.
jmcdonald-ut··on Interns: Everything you need to know about a summer in the Bay Area in one place
As a student in school right now I disagree with your third point. I have to pay for my schooling and don't have the money to live without a job so I don't have the choice. Working various internships has given me more experience at solving problems without the hand holding that school provides, and in turn makes homework generally easier.

Before I was lucky enough to land my first internship I worked for eBay as a customer service representative. While they had tuition reimbursement the job was so stressful that I felt it was a major detriment to my education. Jobs like this also don't care about your schooling or life outside of work.

Finally getting to program on the job and solve real world problems has been a change of pace. Your co-workers and management actually give you space, a chance to breathe, and respect that you have full time school outside of work. Working during school hasn't been half bad.

So, respectfully I disagree with your third point. I agree on the other points though.

jmcdonald-ut··on Life After PHP
I became interested in computer science initially with PHP. It had a low barrier to entry and worked rather well for solving the problems at hand. Now that I've worked with C#, Java, C++, and Ruby I can say that PHP still very much exists in my toolkit (and is used), but has become a tool that I rarely reach for. The bashing that PHP gets, it often deserves. However, I've come to accept that all languages have their pros and cons.
jmcdonald-ut··on He Has Millions and a New Job at Yahoo. Soon, He’ll Be 18
It seems that he came from money and privilege? He attracted a very peculiar crowd of investors to say the least, and I wonder what role (if any) his background played. Good on him though, and congratulations. He certainly seems brilliant.
jmcdonald-ut··on Web Development: A Crazy World
As a computer science major this doesn't worry me at all. Learning the fundamentals, the theory, and the overall science leads me to believe we will be just fine on the market.

As an intern I use PHP on a day to day basis. At school classes have been fairly language agnostic, switching from C++, C#, Java, PHP, and others. I have classes that force you to do all your work in the terminal, and some that allow you to use powerful IDEs. Furthermore, I have classes that you rarely even touch a computer (Algorithms, which should be more aptly named Algorithms II since Algorithms & Data Structures is a pre-req).

In my experience, switching tools/languages/frameworks isn't as hindering as lacking core engineering skills.

jmcdonald-ut··on The Mobile Train Has Left The Windows 8 Platform Behind
To say Microsoft isn't offering anything new or compelling is a matter of opinion. They are going to be the first company to offer the most consistent experience across phone, tablet, and computer.

I'm not concluding whether or not they will be successful, just saying that Microsoft may indeed be offering something compelling and new to consumers with tech devices (consistency).

jmcdonald-ut··on The Evening Walk
Before I was studying CS I worked in a call center for customer support (I now have an internship, thank God). People are relentless thanks to the anonymous nature of the phone. I learned pretty quickly that if I took a walk on my breaks* that my mood would always improve.

To this day I now walk to school and work, and I like to think it's helped make me more creative and introspective. As always, I know that it helps keep my mood up. I really urge people to try to get outside and walk around a bit daily, it works wonders!

jmcdonald-ut··on New MySpace done with Node + Express
That's how I feel. Design wise it's a great website, but I don't like the feel of horizontal scrolling.
jmcdonald-ut··on ChilledLime - A new way to ask decidable questions and crowdsource opinions
I think it looks cool, but also seems like it has potential for conversations to quickly degrade to nothing useful.

- What are the plans to maintain relevant, and insightful conversations?

- I may be missing something, but how is this different than something like Quora?

I do like the striped colors at the top representing what items have been voted for. Overall this looks cool. Good work!

jmcdonald-ut··on Google Maps never supported IE on Windows Phone 8, and likely never will
I wonder the same thing. It seems like Google is trying to make Windows attempt to enter the market as painful, and played out, as possible. (I'm talking about Windows Phone 8, obviously they've been players for a while).
jmcdonald-ut··on Inception Explained – HTML + CSS Experiment
This didn't work with my scroll wheel very well. Once I just grabbed the scroll bar, I had some better luck. It looks neat though, I just suggest making it so the scroll wheel is more graceful.
jmcdonald-ut··on Don't Drop Out to Do a Startup
I couldn't agree more. As a current student, dropping out doesn't appeal to me. I enjoy the structure presented by my classes and the college social life outside of classes. This has been the right choice for me, but for others it most certainly would not be.

Do what you feel is right. When it comes to a big choice like this I feel like subconsciously you just know what is right for you.

jmcdonald-ut··on Web Developer Admits: Objective-C Beats HTML5
I do agree that it comes down to a few people and their personal taste, but I still contend that those few people are often some of the brightest in the industry.

That being said, the example such as Microsoft does ring true, and perhaps Facebook didn't give HTML5 a fair try. I still think that overall evidence has been pretty clear that native can still provide better performance.

jmcdonald-ut··on Web Developer Admits: Objective-C Beats HTML5
Given the considerable resources that Facebook has, and the amount of effort they put into an HTML5 application at first, it seems reasonable that native still gives a much superior experience. Sencha has done some great things, but one must consider the bias Sencha has for HTML5 to be great. It is in Facebook's best interest to deliver the best experience possible, but it is in Sencha's interest to deliver promising HTML5 results.

I'm not sure we can mark this as a win for HTML5, but what Sencha did is impressive. HTML5 will certainly continue to grow, and this is a fantastic step forward.

You are also correct that HTML5 is cross platform, and Sencha has proven that HTML5 can be taken into serious consideration when starting a new project.

jmcdonald-ut··on Apple - Think Twice
I used to work phone support for a large auction site (your first thought is probably correct). I can confirm this notion or idea. We were given generic things that the customer could try to fix the problem. You know "Clear cache and cookies", etc.

If the issue persisted and we could not reproduce the problems on our own machine we weren't allowed to push trouble tickets to our QA team. For a lot of the lower tech users, I suspect issues were on their end. However I often got users who obviously knew what they were doing, and it was frustrating that there wasn't more we could do.

jmcdonald-ut··on Living in a Van
Not that it matters much, and this is only anecdotal but I had friends who would smoke pretty frequently. A lot of call centers, and retail spots would drug test. My friends would still get the job if they got past the initial interview. It seems like most companies are more interested in harder drugs, which I can understand.

On topic: I think that if you're looking for a cost effective way to live, do what someone said earlier and move to a less prominent neighborhood. This seems like it would be more along the lines of "fun to do for a couple weeks".

jmcdonald-ut··on State of the Lambda
If this helps replace functors I'm all for it.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2