HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jnicholasp

254 karma · joined February 29, 2016

submissionscomments
jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
> Arguing that qualia don't exist because you can't observe them externally is like a blind person arguing that I can't possibly see a broken pencil because they can feel the pencil is solid.

This is what makes me wonder whether some of us are, in fact, p-zombies: only a blind person, someone who doesn't have visual experiences, could argue that visual experience doesn't exist, and similarly it seems that only someone who doesn't have subjective experience could argue that it doesn't exist. And there do appear to be people arguing that subjective experience doesn't exist. Either I'm misunderstanding them, I'm failing to see the third way, or some of us are indeed p-zombies.

jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
> The question is whether we have justification to believe that it actually exists

I understood this to mean that you were doubting whether subjective experience actually exists, and I responded by arguing that it is not possible to doubt that your own subjective experience exists since you (I, at least) experience it directly, which is different than the class of now-refuted inferences that you were comparing it to in. I was not making any argument about where it comes from or what causes it.

jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
I've read that :) And it appears like a plausible world to me, although of course I have no idea if it's the world we happen to live in. It does seem to get as close to an answer of how a good [entity] could have [created|simulated] a world with apparent evil in it, as anything I know of.
jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
Ah, ok. Yeah, sort of similar: only some "chosen" people might have actual experiences attached to their existence, for better or for worse.
jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
It's not clear to me that there would be a meaningful behavioral difference between an entity that feels pain/pleasure from a given behavior, vs. one that "only" registers negative/positive incentive. But, like pretty much everything in this topic, the water is murky and it's hard to tell what is reliable and what isn't.

What do you mean by the Calvinism question? Whether the real existence of human p-zombies would parallel the Calvinist doctrine of predestination and there being only a subset of humans who are the elect chosen for paradise? If so.. yeah, maybe?

jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
Yes, I'm interested in the possible real world situation, which does seem plausible to me. I accept the idea that, in almost every way, an actual human p-zombie would behave indistinguishably from a conscious human, but if we let go of the indistinguishable-by-definition requirement, it does seem possible that the discussion of qualia is one of the very few, perhaps only, places where p-zombies would behave differently than conscious beings.

What other significant differences would you expect?

jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
> Why should I expect this to be any different?

Because you experience it? If you do..

The difference between the idea of qualia and the other properties that we granted special status to and then later refuted, is that in the latter cases we were trying to explain something external that we thought we were observing, whereas with subjective experience we are discussing a phenomenon that we (or at least some of us) directly, infallibly observe. It is not possible for me to be mistaken about whether there is something it is like to be me; it is not possible for me to be mistaken about whether what I experience is what I experience. It is possible for me to be mistaken about whether there is something it is like to be you, because I cannot directly observe your internal experience.

jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
I wonder if that's completely true, though: that p-zombies behave in every observable way the same as non-zombies. What about in this very discussion of inner life and zombie-ness? Will a p-zombie claim to have subjective experience, or will they be confused by the concept (maybe along the lines of this other comment I replied to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856232)
jnicholasp··on A New Theory of How Consciousness Evolved
The idea of subjective experience or qualia can only seem like nonsense if you don't experience it - if you're a p-zombie. If you do experience qualia, if there is "something that it's like" to be you, then the scientific response to that persistent, inexplicable experience, despite not having any sensible or useful way to explain or even question it, is very definitely not to attempt to dismiss it. It is not scientific to deny things that exist merely because they don't fit with the accepted scheme of things, or merely because we don't currently know how to gain further insight into them.
jnicholasp··on Apply HN: Wikipedia for how, and how well, we know what we think we know
You're right about the formatting, oops. There are supposed to be three paragraphs there, but I'm not familiar with HN's formatting, and I didn't think about it after I posted it.

I would say that Wikipedia became popular, and eventually earned itself a high place in search results, because it is easy to use, yes, but mostly because it provided a place/format for useful information that couldn't be accessed anywhere else as easily. It doesn't mean much to say, "Oh, my site will be easy to use too!" - that's just an unsubstantiated claim at this point. But I don't think that's a hard target to hit.

On the other point (providing a place for useful information that can't be easily gotten elsewhere), once you have a clear idea of what the site does, it's immediately apparent that the information it provides is extremely useful, and that there's nowhere else to get it.

I'll try to give a couple more concrete examples: in politics, how often does it appear to be the case that people understand why their opponents believe the things they do? How many people can give a genuinely strong argument for the opposing view, vs. how many people are unable to give a plausible argument for the other side and tend to assume that their opponents think what they do simply because they're stupid/selfish/malicious/etc.? Our political process is highly polarized, and there is almost no reasonable, informed political debate, certainly not anywhere that is prominent and accessible, and this is extremely detrimental to the project of trying to run a well-functioning democracy. Wikipedia made it not possible for reasonable people to be trivially wrong about matters of fact, by making it simple to find out what is right. We need to do the same thing for arguments, by making it simple to look up what is strong and coherent.

In science, suppose you're a biochemistry grad student trying to get a handle on everything we think we know about the biochemistry of dementia. Currently this means reading tons of uncorrelated papers scattered across dozens of journals, and attempting to assemble in your own head a logical structure that ties all of them together, sussing out and keeping track of thousands of relevant bits of data about who knew what when, who references who, how strong each paper's individual arguments are, which points undermine which others, which ones strengthen which other ones (and how much), what are the strongest known approaches, where the open questions are, etc. Every expert in a given topic has in their head their own ad hoc version of this logical structure, and all of them vary from each other. We will gain immensely by combining all of those implicit maps into one explicit map, that will be more complete than any individual's, improvable, allow quantified collective judgments on uncertain points (a la prediction markets), and which will be vastly simpler to acquire for new would-be experts.

Do those examples make the site's function any clearer for you?

jnicholasp··on Apply HN: Wikipedia for how, and how well, we know what we think we know
So apparently I should look at my comments after I post them, so I can edit the bad formatting.

Also, is there a HN formatting guide somewhere that will tell me how to do italics, bold, make links, etc.?

jnicholasp··on Apply HN: Wikipedia for how, and how well, we know what we think we know
This site wants to be Wikipedia for inferential knowledge - where Wikipedia is a general encyclopedia and catalogs knowledge of all kinds (people, places, things, events, ideas, etc.), this site deals only with ideas that are <i>arguments</i> or <i>claims</i>, and that depend for their plausibility and truth on chains of inference stretching back ultimately to some fundamental axiom. This includes essentially all of philosophy, science, religion, and politics, since all of these make debatable claims about what reality is and how it is likely to respond in given circumstances, and since those claims are all based on some chain of prior reasoning every link of which are themselves debatable.

We need a Wikipedia-like central resource that explicitly graphs all of these chains of reasoning, reduces them to their individual links, and lays bare their connections and branchings, so that we can 1) understand the underpinnings of our own ideas, 2) understand the underpinnings of <i>other peoples's</i> ideas (i.e., stop assuming that other people are stupid strawmen), 3) show definitively that genuinely stupid ideas are genuinely stupid, by systematically meeting their bad arguments with clearly stronger counter-arguments, 4) stop having the same arguments constantly all over the internet/tv/congress/world, by having it all out in one place where the argument can be logically organized, permanently recorded, and exhaustively fleshed out, and 5) finally be able to walk through, clearly and completely, exactly what gives us reason to think that something is true.

jnicholasp··on Apply HN: Wikipedia for how, and how well, we know what we think we know
Disclaimer: I'm not really eligible for a YC Fellowship at this point, as I'm not a hacker and don't have a technical co-founder, and therefore can't create the proposed site. This post is mostly for generating discussion, and for the outside chance of finding someone who sees the potential and wants to come on board with me to make it happen.
jnicholasp··on Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of them and they eat it’
I do wish you luck. Can you give more detail about your day job?
jnicholasp··on The Origins of Pattern Theory: Christopher Alexander at OOPSLA (1996)
Seconded. This is a really fascinating book for anyone who is interested in how space and environment affect us, or anyone who wants to build or remodel their own home/office/pub/any other human-used space. Whether or not you agree with any of the particular patterns (and there are hundreds), the authors' discussion of why they think each one is worth considering will make you think more deeply about the way buildings function and influence our behavior, and will prompt better, clearer ideas for how you want the spaces you live in to work for you.
jnicholasp··on Meeting People Is Easy, but Hard
And you usually want to avoid RAPE:

- Religion

- Abortion

- Politics

- Economics

Of course, rape itself is also probably not a conversational winner, generally speaking.

← PreviousPage 6 of 6